This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparative Essay

1914 words - 8 pages

Alec Steinhorn - English - Ms. Spiegel - 11/24/13
The Individual Versus His Environment in The Stranger and Grendel
Due to the multifaceted nature of literature, analysis thereof is prone to generalization. One of the most grievous generalizations oft encountered involves failing to distinguish between a character and the novel it inhabits. Take John Gardener’s Grendel and Albert Camus’s The Stranger, for instance. It’s far too easy, when analyzing for dominant ideologies, to slap them both with the label of existentialism and be done with it. However, closer scrutiny indicates that whilst both Meursault and Grendel are existential heroes, Grendel, unlike Meursault, exists in a solipsistic universe that runs contrary to his ideology and thusly never experiences the catharsis that Meursault does.
As put by Jean-Paul Sartre in his essay Existentialism is a Humanism, “The other is indispensable to my existence, and equally so to any knowledge I can have of myself,” meaning that one’s existence is utterly dependent on the existence of others. We see the idea that the perceptions of others shape one’s self very clearly in The Stranger. Meursault requires “that there be a large crowd of spectators the day of [his] execution and that they greet [him] with cries of hate,” signifying that others’ physical expression of hatred (and thus separation) are necessary for Meursault to become truly alienated. Just as he is nothing before he defines himself, he is nothing without being defined by others. Thus, the existential crisis he experiences supports the ideology of existentialism throughout the novel.
Another important existentialist concept is that everyone is completely accountable for his or her actions. “We have neither behind us, nor before us in a luminous realm of values, any means of justification or excuse,” writes Satre; “man is condemned to be free.” Camus uses the metaphor of the trial to represent humanistic culpability; that any action you take, you must also take complete responsibility for is an idea integral to existentialism and expressed through Meursault’s trial. Though it, Mersault is punished for every last social faux-pas he makes on or about the time of his mother’s funeral (the coffee he drinks, the cigarette he smokes, his refusal to see her corpse before she’s lowered down, to name a few), his refusal to cede to society as represented through acceptance of Christ, his tactless liaison with Marie just after Maman’s death, and of course his killing the Arab on that “sun-drenched Algerian beach.” The spectators laughed at Mersault’s feeble excuse for killing the Arab, that “it was because of the sun,” to show that all excuses are absurd under existentialism. The metaphor of the trial, and within it the strict cause/effect plot points and use of absurdity, promote existentialism in The Stranger as they force Meursault to face the responsibility of true freedom, as must any man with every decision he makes.
At a climactic...

Find Another Essay On Comparative Essay

Julius Caesar and The Odyssey Comparative Essay

884 words - 4 pages Julius Caesar and The Odyssey Comparative Essay Throughout William Shakespeare’s play Julius Caesar and Homer’s epic poem The Odyssey, loyalty is strongly presented as a major motif. In both texts, loyalty is highly valued as one of the most important traits to a person’s character. Not only do the loyal characters receive better fates, but those who are not loyal are punished for the actions, usually through revenge. In Julius Caesar, the

Macbeth and Lady Macbeth Comparative Essay

1154 words - 5 pages Christina Anton E. Bilan ENG 3U1 12 May 2014 Macbeth and Lady Macbeth Comparative Essay In the play Macbeth by William Shakespeare, Macbeth and his wife; Lady Macbeth become greedy for power after being given a prophecy from three witches. In the end, however their greediness just gets them killed. In the play Macbeth and Lady Macbeth are different in terms of their reaction to prophecy, gender identity, and sense of guilt. Their opposing views

Comparative essay

1363 words - 5 pages There are some qualities of dreams which help to separate them from real life occurrences. It is important, then, when writing about dreams, that these qualities are present to help the reader to make the distinction. There is a difference, however, in writing about a dream as the main focus of a literary work, and using a dream in a larger piece as a literary device to further the story as a whole. In each case there needs to be a suspension of

Comparative Essay

1218 words - 5 pages In Chris Cleave’s Little Bee and Incendiary, the characters Little Bee and the unnamed narrator respectively, undergo a traumatic experience in the early stages of the books. Little Bee is confined in an immigration detention center upon her arrival in England for not having legal documents to prove her age. Meanwhile, the unnamed narrator has her life blown apart by a terrorist attack that kills her husband and four year old son. Both characters

Comparative Essay

815 words - 4 pages The books The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain and The Future of Us by Jay Asher are able to show that friendship is powerful enough to be stronger than the outside forces, such as society. Friendship enables people to accomplish many things such as, escaping from an uncivilized society, or helping each other to get rid of the greed they have, through hardship and fun. Even when people run into trouble, the authors suggest that when

Comparative Essay

963 words - 4 pages Within one’s lifetime, the mark to finding oneself is being able to overcome hardships and difficulties in order to unravel the full potential concealed within them. From being manipulated and deceived, this manages to bring about an ability hidden within oneself that can only be triggered by experiencing what it is like to be a victim of deception. In A Doll’s House by Henrik Ibsen and As You Like It by William Shakespeare, each author entraps

Comparative Essay

1508 words - 7 pages Durkheim and DuBois are both Non rational, Collective thinkers whose actions are motivated by morals and ethics, principles, practices, beliefs, habits, or passion, and the lives of the past are patterns, which are the result of the futures’ fundamental formation. Both theorists have concepts, and studies which overlap with one another, and both theorists can be combined in their ideas through W.E.B. Du Bois’ classical work The Souls of Black

Comparative Essay - 749 words

749 words - 3 pages Modernist literature makes the statement of non-traditionalism in its content and style. The modernist movement began in Europe and moved to the United States in the early twentieth century. The voices of modern idealism speak out against the conformity of the nineteenth century, and oppose class distinctions and lifestyles considered politically correct during this time. Religion and what it represents, no longer explicitly drive the content of

Comparative Essay - 942 words

942 words - 4 pages Books written in the Gilded Age are most usually an accurate representation of the lives led by those characters represented in them. They give us an in depth and up close and more personal look at the difficult and fast-changing times back then. Although Maggie and O Pioneers! differ in geographical terms, they both make me feel like I actually understand what it was like to live back then. When you compare them side by side you can see that

Comparative Essay - 657 words

657 words - 3 pages Spencer BeaudryIB English 1AJanuary 15, 2014The Downfall of Life in Hamlet and The Grapes of WrathThe emptiness of the red country fills doubt in many; a false king whom rules on a throne of lies brings the downfall of many once trusted. The Grapes of Wrath by John Steinbeck is an iconic American novel and Hamlet written by William Shakespeare is a well-known tragedy. The Grapes of Wrath illustrates the typical family hardships during America's

Comparative Essay - 1314 words

1314 words - 6 pages Vladek and Guido use their skills and intelligence to endure a genocide that killed over 6 million Jews and 11 million people in total. Although sadly Guido did not make it through the Holocaust, his wife Dora and Son Giosué survived, thanks to the help of Guido. Vladek survived by using his many talents in the prison camps whereas Guido survived by his cunning intelligence and positive attitude. In the Books Maus I and II by Art Spiegelman, the

Similar Essays

Comparative Essay Of David

1620 words - 6 pages Running head: COMPARATIVE ESSAY ON DAVID PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1 COMPARATIVE ESSAY ON DAVID PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 7 Comparative Essay on DavidThe biblical story of David and Goliath served as a great source of inspiration for many artists during the renaissance and Baroque era. The story of David embodied inner strength, power, a will to survive, a sense of triumph. Donatello, Verrocchio, Michelangelo and Bernini are artist who sought to bring to

Othello Comparative Essay

1536 words - 6 pages ]" Shakespeare's Othello thus mirrors the concerns of its Jacobean context. It reflects the fear of white society towards persons of another culture and it's also displays the expectations on women during that time. Othello Year 11 Comparative Essay

Comparative Essay A Bird In

874 words - 3 pages Comparative Essay - A Bird in the House and A Jest of God One of the harsh realities of life is death. In A Bird in the House and A Jest of God, Margaret Laurence realizes the death of a loved one, the 'death of a dream', and the death of a relationship through the eyes of women. Laurence uses similar themes and ironic situations in both novels to paint a grim picture of life and death. In both novels, the author writes of the

Comparative Essay: Mothers With A Divided Heart

894 words - 4 pages Comparative Essay: Mothers With A Divided Heart Kathy O'Reilly April 3, 1997 Comparative Essay The importance of raising children to be productive members of a rapidly evolving, achievement oriented society, is paramount to the success of the family and the global economy. At the same time, the stresses of every day individual economic and personal fulfillment needs are a significant counter force. This force works against the available time