Comparative Analysis Of The Ghost In Two Hamlet Movies

1094 words - 4 pages

Comparative Analysis Of The Ghost In Two Hamlet Movies

The play “Hamlet, Prince of Denmark”, by William Shakespeare being of such a complicated variety of themes, contains many different story lines as well as being very extensive in nature makes it quite a challenge to be produced and acted. On paper, the reader can translate things, as they like. Since Shakespeare is not around to tell us the meaning of every theme or the truth about every nook and cranny about his works. It is up to the reader to decide what the importance of everything is. Thus when a producer decides to create a film based on “Hamlet” it is most certain that his creation will vary from any others. Each will create their own version of the story, stressing some issues more than others as well as completely leaving sections out. In this essay I will compare Kenneth Branagh’s presentation of the ghost with Franco Zeffirelli’s.

In Kenneth Branagh’s version, the ghost is introduced at the very beginning of the film. We are unclear as to the purpose of the ghost’s visit through this vague first impression we are presented. Is he a good or evil spirit? He most certainly does not seem to be friendly and is reluctant to speak. One might question the whole purpose of the visit in the first place. It does not state the nature of its appearance and seems to almost attack the guards. However, Zeffirelli skips this first interlude completely and we are aware of the encounter with the ghost through a conversation Horatio and the guards have with Hamlet. In both film versions, as is presented in the play, Hamlet seems to believe what he is told without question.

     The second visit from the ghost is certainly the most important in analyzing the intentions as well as the actual character of the ghost. In Brannagh’s version the second appearance of the ghost is similar to a scene from a horror movie. The way Hamlet is portrayed running through the woods, with thick fog rising from the earth and a fast paced rhythm following his actions all resemble elements of a cliched horror movie. This first gives us the impression that we are to meet some evil stuff. Why else would he create this whole sci-fi image that totally does not fit in with the rest of the movie. Then the very instant we see the ghost’s pale blue eyes we get the sense that this thing has seen the darkest corners of the fires of hell. Right here is where his identity takes shape. (Even though when we cut to the flashback of the King’s murder he has the very same eyes. In the Ghost, the eyes are terrifying evidence of his supernatural ordeals; on a live character, they look artificial and take away from the ghost’s individuality as a supernatural being.) When we hear the ghost speak it is clear that this Ghost is angry. It is also clear that he is a supernatural being and wants things to get done. But what disturbs me is that there is very little, if any emotion being displayed here. The most immediate response is...

Find Another Essay On Comparative Analysis Of The Ghost In Two Hamlet Movies

Shakespeare's Hamlet - The Importance of the Ghost

2858 words - 11 pages Story Told in Hamlet” describes the ghost’s activity prior to the opening scene of Shakespeare’s tragedy:   The story opens in the cold and dark of a winter night in Denmark, while the guard is being changed on the battlements of the royal castle of Elsinore. For two nights in succession, just as the bell strikes the hour of one, a ghost has appeared on the battlements, a figure dressed in complete armor and with a face like that of the

Shakespeare's Hamlet - The Ghost Of Hamlet’s Father

2486 words - 10 pages the royal castle of Elsinore. For two nights in succession, just as the bell strikes the hour of one, a ghost has appeared on the battlements, a figure dressed in complete armor and with a face like that of the dead king of Denmark, Hamlet’s father. A young man named Horatio, who is a school friend of Hamlet, has been told of the apparition and cannot believe it, and one of the officers has brought him there in the night so that he can see it for

Title: The Ghost in Hamlet: Messenger of Earthly Justice Author: Shakespeare

1247 words - 5 pages The Ghost in Hamlet: Messenger of Earthly JusticeThe Ghost in Hamlet is no messenger of Divine Justice but rather a messenger determined to convince Hamlet to pursue its personal justice. The Ghost's appearance is persuasive, but Hamlet is right to avoid jumping to conclusions about its demand. It is important for Hamlet to distinguish between its urgent request and what may lie beneath it. The Ghost's speeches emphasize human sins and mirror

Faustus and Hamlet´s Belief in the Ghost

1677 words - 7 pages . However it has been said that Marlowe made this protestant connection to cease all accusations of him being a practicing catholic. A ghost appears before Hamlet claiming to be “his father’s” spirit and states that he is currently in purgatory. Question start to rise on the reliability of the ghost, (648 words) because besides being in purgatory this quote insinuates that the ghost is Catholic, which makes him very suspicious

Significance of the Ghost to William Shakespeare's Hamlet

1872 words - 7 pages their sins. This is an act of ultimate cruelty to two men who were his friends. Because of Hamlet's apparent madness, they were perhaps justified in their treatment of Hamlet. The nature of the ghost also affects any opinion that may be held of Gertrude. She may be seen as evil, but she may also be seen as a weak and stupid woman. The ghost may appear to show mercy to Gertrude, but he envisions her ,"pricked and stung

Shakespeare's Hamlet - Hamlet and the Ghost

2594 words - 10 pages the battlements of the royal castle of Elsinore. For two nights in succession, just as the bell strikes the hour of one, a ghost has appeared on the battlements, a figure dressed in complete armor and with a face like that of the dead king of Denmark, Hamlet’s father. A young man named Horatio, who is a school friend of Hamlet, has been told of the apparition and cannot believe it, and one of the officers has brought him there in the night so that

An Analysis of the Characters in Hamlet

2517 words - 10 pages , Laertes, Ophelia, Fortinbras, Rosencratz and Guildernsten, Horatio and Hamlet. 1. The Ghost – The Ghost is the ghost of the late king Hamlet, the present Hamlet’s father. It is a very important character and is mentioned in the beginning itself. It sets the basis of the whole story. This ghost makes a majestic appearance in Denmark which is noticed by two soldiers. This is how the story begins. They then report it to

Comparison Of Two Horror movies: The Exorcist and The Shining

834 words - 3 pages The two film posters I am studying are "The Exorcist" and "The Shining" both of which are part of the Horror genre.In both posters many visual and written codes are being used. Firstly in The Exorcist poster the visual codes used includes the dark silhouetted house with the bright angelic light shining down on the man a very typical horror film set up with symbols of good (the light shining down on the man) and symbols of evil (the dark and

Dissertation Proposal of An Analysis of the Strategies and Effort of Product Placement in Movies

2115 words - 8 pages Analysis of the Strategies and Effort of Product Placement in MoviesObject of analysisThe term of "product placement" is not a new concept, it has occurred in the 1920s and early 1930s(Balasubramanian, Karrh, and Patwardhan, 2006, pp115,116). According to Gupta and Gould(in Wenner, 2004, p103), product placement involves use of the certain brand or item's name, packaging, signage or other trademark in television or movies, with which to promote

Character Analysis of Ophelia and how she conects the two plots of the play Hamlet. The two plots are the Hamlet Plot and the Polonius plot.

1254 words - 5 pages Ophelia in Hamlet is generally considered a very simple character who exemplifies the perfect young, innocent woman. However, her importance to the play shows that there is more to her than most people think Ophelia is a substantial character in the play whose flaw is her vulnerability to being manipulated by others. With this flaw, Ophelia becomes a tool that allows Shakespeare to connect the two parallel plots of the play, Hamlet's and

Two Types of Madness in Shakespeare's Hamlet

1873 words - 7 pages beliefs (Hart 78-9). Many times this conflict leads to the disintegration of the mind, as is true in Hamlet's case. Hamlet develops a revenge complex which eventually leads to his downfall. When his father's ghost tells him to "Revenge this foul and most unnatural murder" (1.5.25), Hamlet replies that the ghost's demand of revenge, "...alone shall live/ Within the book and volume of [his] brain" (1.5.102-103). From this point on, Hamlet lives

Similar Essays

The Importance Of The Ghost In Hamlet

1568 words - 6 pages Words are like leaves; and where they most abound, Much fruit of Sense beneath is rarely found. (Essay on Criticism, ll.309-310)   Any investigation of Shakespeare's Hamlet that wishes to harvest "fruit of sense" must begin with the ghost. Dover Wilson is right in terming Hamlet's visitor the "linchpin," but the history of critical opinion regarding its origin has been diverse and conflicting. Generally, critics have

Importance Of The Ghost In Shakespeare's Hamlet

1202 words - 5 pages The Importance of the Ghost in Hamlet            The stage presence of a ghost would have been familiar to an Elizabethan audience and so the appearance of the Ghost in 'Hamlet' carries some messages which are general - almost as though the ghost was a familiar symbol which evoked certain thoughts merely by being present. The Ghost in 'Hamlet' has a more specific role than that given to ghosts in general, however; it has a crucial part to

The Meaning Of The Ghost In Hamlet By Shakespeare

798 words - 3 pages In traditional and modern, ghost reflects death and fear, and it never change. In Hamlet, the ghost is a symbol of Hamlet’s father who is killed by Claudius. Its propose is to demand Hamlet to avenge its death. Although the ghost only appears three times in front of Hamlet, it is a specify role to develop the whole story and plot. Through Hamlet, the ghost is the motive to make Hamlet kill Claudius, and the ghost plays a critical role to

It The Ghost In Hamlet Pure Of Evil?

1652 words - 7 pages The Ghost in Hamlet is a widely controversial topic with arguments determining whether the Ghost is a “goblin damn’d” or a “spirit of health.” (1.4.40) “‘A spirit of health’ is one, which comes from heaven with charitable intentions, and ‘a goblin damn’d’ is one, which comes from Hell with wicked intentions.” The Ghost only has two appearances in the play and is a symbol for uncertainty, yet it is important as it catalyses the play into