Comparative Study Of Innocence In Two Women And Mr. Pip

1362 words - 5 pages


English Comparative Study of TextsThrough the impacts of conflict an individual's innocence may be lost as they become corrupted by the external world, and shed their naïve attitude toward life and come to terms with reality. The context of war facilitates the necessity for sacrifice of one's innocence in order to provide a means for physical survival, despite becoming psychologically compromised. Times of distress or corruption by external forces often dictates a person's need to escape, whether physically removing themselves from a place or danger, or escaping from themselves and an internal conflict. Both of the comparative texts look at a loss of innocence during times of conflict; the novel 'Mr Pip' is set on a small island during the Bougainville War, whereas the film 'Two Women' explores the loss of innocence during the bombings of Rome and the war in Italy during the Second World War.Innocence is state of being, dictated by a person's ignorance of the world and an unwillingness to learn, being content with the life they have, however a person may lose their innocence as they become corrupted by their attainment of different experiences around the world. Children have had less time to experience the world and depend on their parents or adults to shape their opinions of the world, making children ignorant and therefore becoming symbols of innocence. Illustrative of this is Mr Pip by Lloyd Jones, which explores the state of a child's innocence through the external corruption and impacts of war. Using a child character, Matilda, to provide the naïve narration within the novel, allows the concept of innocence, both how it deteriorates as a person becomes more corrupted and how it is maintained, to be explored more effectively, as innocence is most often associated with children, whom have no experience of the world or of the corruption that comes with it. Innocence is established within the first chapter of Mr Pip through this naïve narrative voice "we loved that word- parasol", showing that she has not been corrupted by external forces and that she is ignorant of the world around her, as she is consumed with simple thoughts such as the love of a word instead of thinking about the problems of others or questioning the world around her. The use of "we" also suggests that Matilda is not alone in this innocent way of thinking, but instead shows that everyone she has been exposed to is also just as ignorant of the outside world and that they all live in a tight-knit community, held together by this shared innocence. The geographical isolation of the island they live in from the rest of the world further emphasises this ignorance of the outside world that is shared by this community. However, Matilda begins to become more distant from this community the more she becomes acquainted with Mr Watts, a man who is excluded from this community because he is different, both in skin colour and background, and in his way of thinking that...

Find Another Essay On Comparative Study of Innocence in Two Women and Mr. Pip

A Comparative Study of Japanese and English

2661 words - 11 pages ) explains how vowels in Japanese can be manipulated to offer semantic variation. It is shown that vowel length can change a word such as hodo ‘degree’ to hodo: ‘sidewalk’ (Okada 1991:95). Accenting vowel sounds can also convey different meanings. For example hasi means ‘end’ but hasÍ means ‘bridge’ and hási means ‘chopsticks’. Japanese proves complicated to an English learner by use of two distinctive suprasegmental units, the syllable and the mora

The Symbolism of Innocence and Nature in

1147 words - 5 pages ornithologist sleep and running toward a great pine she often longed to climb (Jewett 4). The great pine is symbolic of Sylvia’s sexual awakening and loss of innocence. The pine is clearly a phallic object that Sylvia must “mount” (Jewett 5). Sylvia climbs the tree and it seems to “lengthen itself” as she goes up, and when she reaches the top she stands “trembling and tired but wholly triumphant” (Jewett 5). This is the moment in which Sylvia has left her

Comparative Analysis Of The Ghost In Two Hamlet Movies

1094 words - 4 pages Comparative Analysis Of The Ghost In Two Hamlet Movies The play “Hamlet, Prince of Denmark”, by William Shakespeare being of such a complicated variety of themes, contains many different story lines as well as being very extensive in nature makes it quite a challenge to be produced and acted. On paper, the reader can translate things, as they like. Since Shakespeare is not around to tell us the meaning of every theme or the truth about

A detailed study of William Blake's 'Songs of Innocence and Experience' in relation to the principles of the pastoral convention

1642 words - 7 pages Literature CourseworkKara-kaye D'Aguilar HoilettQuestions:(a)What does the Pastoral Convention refer to?(b)By detailed reference to Blake's poems, show how they highlight features of the pastoral.(c)What is the underlying significance of Blake's usage of the Pastoral? (What message is he conveying by using it?In the poetic anthology, Songs of Innocence and Experience by ardent romanticist William Blake, the reader is exposed to a kinship of

Women and Industry: The Role of Women During World War Two in Ontario, Canada, 1939-45

1629 words - 7 pages While the men are away the women do not play. As men left to serve in World War Two, women were left to occupy the frontlines of the working force. They had to take over the industrial production for the war effort and the daily jobs that were not nearly as relevant to the war. In the essay I will be writing about the empty job positions left behind while men when to war across seas and the demand that was put on women to fill the positions

Magwitch's Manipulations of Pip in Great Expectations

2732 words - 11 pages elaborate, but lowly production. Pip views the formal confirmation of his apprenticeship to Joe as a torturous performance in which he is participating but over which he has no control. Of this event Pip says, "My . . . other remembrances of the great festival are that [Mr. Wopsle and Pumblechook] wouldn't let me go to sleep, but whenever they saw me dropping off, woke me up and told me to enjoy myself" (113; ch. 13). Pip wants to withdraw

Dickens' Depiction Of Pip and Magwitch

1658 words - 7 pages alone and he is upset about something. But in their first meeting Pip was in a graveyard, but in their second Pip is sitting inside with a nice cosy fire. This could be indicating the effect that Magwitch has had on Pip. Dickens has made the two chapters very alike so that he can bring back the same feeling from when the reader saw Magwitch the first time. Also when the reader first sees Magwitch in chapter one they immediately think badly of

A Reflective and Comparative Study of the Oppression and Persecutions Toward Roma in History

1069 words - 5 pages forced to live appear all the more lamentable. Whether they be living in the ghettoes or in communal shacks outside the city limits, the Roma are, in the majority of cases, not even privileged to basic amenities such as electricity or sewerage. In this destitute state, Roma children are denied the right to even a basic education, while adult men and women are often not given the opportunity to work and thus are forced into criminal activity to

The Relationship of Pip and Magwitch

1441 words - 6 pages The Relationship of Pip and Magwitch Write an essay about Pip and Magwitch's relationship, concentrating mainly on the section when Magwitch returns from Botany Bayonwards, though you should briefly touch on the opening of the novel respond to Orwell's assertion in his essay (Charles Dickens) that Pip maintains an abhorrence for the convict. Magwitch is introduced to Pip as a shock, at first he come across as

A comparative study of market efficiency in emerging markets: performance of passively and actively managed funds

1942 words - 8 pages managed funds shifts the burden of capital gains from trading to their shareholders. Their study also shows that investment in US equities of mutual funds and passively managed funds (Exchange traded funds) generated similar returns when adjusted for tax notwithstanding the lower fees of the passively managed fund. Gardner et al (2005) also confirms this with emphasis on the tax advantage of passively managed funds over actively managed funds. The

Comparative Study of Religions

1570 words - 7 pages represents God’s continuing presence in the world” (Brodd et al., 412). This belief is not recognized within Muslim or Jewish beliefs because it goes against the emphasis of the oneness of God between the two religions. The importance of prayer is highly recognized for the communication with God but offers different meanings. Jewish people view types of prayers as “… [P]rayers of praise, confession, petition, and thanksgiving”(Brodd et al., 392). God is

Similar Essays

Comparative Essay On Two Texts: 'travelling Shoes' By Lenore Horowitz And 'mr. Curly Transports Wayfaring Pilgrims Away' By Michael Leunig

1009 words - 4 pages Horowitz. The text is in the form of a poem and describes the positive effects and individual growth brought about by physical journeys. The poem is broken into two stanzas; the first describes the journey while the second stanza highlights the reflective phase of the journey.In the first stanza, the composer writes of the obstacles that were faced. The title is a metaphor, which is used to explore her achievements and development. Horowitz uses

A Comparative Study Of Sydney A Comparative Study Of Sydney Carton In Dickens' Novel, A Tale Of Two Cities, And Romeo Montague And Juliet Capulet In Shakespeare's Play

1257 words - 5 pages A comparative study of Sydney Carton in Dickens' novel, A Tale of Two Cities, and Romeo Montague and Juliet Capulet in Shakespeare's play, Romeo and Juliet, requires the reader to analyze various aspects that the transforming effect love can have on a personality. As we study each character, it is relatively easy to see that no matter how painful love can be, it is usually to one's betterment to have experienced it. Love affects each person

Comparative Study Between Two Texts Sister Kate And The True History Of The Kelly Gang

2246 words - 9 pages Analyse two works of historical fiction from the same period of history and compare the strengths and weaknesses of these two works for our understanding of that historical period Analyse two works of historical fiction from the same period of history and compare the strengths and weaknesses of these two works for our understanding of that historical period. - What are the sources of conflict between different groups in society

A Comparative Study Of Oedipus And Chinatown

825 words - 4 pages There are many common ties between the ancient story, Oedipus the King, and the 1974 film, Chinatown. Many of the similarities between these stories are easily understood, while some require deeper study. Oedipus, who is the lead character in Oedipus the King, and Jake Gittes, who is the main character in Chinatown, are both men who are living in corrupt cities, and are determined to seek out the truth, at any cost. As John Fawell states