Comparative Study Of Oration On The Dignity Of Man And King Lear Essay

1176 words - 5 pages

How does a comparative study of texts enhance your understanding of issues that are common to both texts?
A comparative study of two texts allows one to shape a more profound understanding of the complex, tacit notions presented within each text that is driven by the contextual backgrounds of each composer. Giovanni Pico’s ‘Oration on the Dignity of Man’ and William Shakespeare’s ‘King Lear’ both delve into key concepts: the nature of reason and the divine order of things. Despite the common ideas within these texts, their style and perspectives have been influenced by their socio-cultural and religious context. While Pico’s text was influenced by ancient Greek philosophy which privileged mankind’s place in the world, Shakespeare’s play was driven by the secular nature of his times.
The capability to think, understand and form judgments logically can have a significant impact on one’s well-being and status. Throughout the Renaissance period, there was a momentous outbreak of philosophical perspectives which championed the abilities of man, including the power and nature of reason. At the time, Pico was beginning to expand his scope on the nature of reason and the value of it to human beings. Pico exemplifies his approach towards reason when he writes, “If, however, you see a philosopher, judging and distinguishing all things according to the rule of reason, him shall you hold in veneration, for he is a creature of heaven and not of earth…” His consideration of man as metaphorically a ‘creature of heaven’ demonstrates his belief that one who seeks to reason and rationalise things is enlightened. Here, we also see an allusion and influence of the Greek philosophy of Plato and Aristotle, appropriating their belief that the ultimate exemplar for man was a philosopher or a contemplative man. In his exaltation of reason, Pico also writes that to use reason well is to “imitate the life of the cherubim”, and that individuals should do so “by refraining the impulses of our passions through moral science, by dissipating the darkness of reason by dialectic—thus washing away, so to speak, the filth of ignorance and vice…” The alliterative use of the hard consonant ‘d’ sound here emphasises the “darkness” that man can emerge from by eschewing the impulsive nature of the passions and pursuing rationality and intellectuality instead. The cleansing nature of intellectual pursuit is moreover supported by the light/ dark or heaven/ hell imagery (also, imagery of baptism and rebirth) when he writes that reason can “wash… away, so to speak, the filth of ignorance and vice…” Ultimately, Pico concludes that one who reasons and contemplates is angelic and the perfect exemplar for man.
In King Lear, Shakespeare also reflects upon the nature of reason but absorbed Pico’s ideas through a secular lens, outlining the liberating times of the later Renaissance period. Unlike Pico, Shakespeare delved deeper into nature of reason, exploring how the ability of reasoning...

Find Another Essay On Comparative Study of Oration on the Dignity of Man and King Lear - Essay

King Lear and the Theme of Tragedy

1175 words - 5 pages A tragedy is a genre typically defined as a play that deals with a series of events that lead to the downfall of the hero. Written between 1604 and 1606, ‘King Lear’ falls into this genre of tragedy, depicting the destruction and demise of the main character (Abrams). The play centres on Lear, an aging king who, in his retirement, decides to divide his kingdom between his three daughters while retaining the title and privileges of being king

Essay on King Lear, by Shakespeare. A discussion of three characters and their roles in the play

693 words - 3 pages rather, though the fork invadeThe region of my heart: be Kent unmannerly,When Lear is mad. What wilt thou do, old man?Think'st thou that duty shall have dread to speak,When power to flattery bows? To plainness honour's bound,When majesty stoops to folly. Reverse thy doom;And, in thy best consideration, chequeThis hideous rashness: answer my life my judgment,Thy youngest daughter does not love thee least;Nor are those empty-hearted whose low

Oedipus the King and The Tragedy of King Lear

1190 words - 5 pages further heightened, by the fact that Teiresias is physically blind and Oedipus is seeing. For an audience these two images would provide an immediate physical difference among the two, that they could easily identify. In The Tragedy of King Lear blindness is an appropriate metaphor, since Lear’s behavior is just like that of a blind man’s. Lear is just as blind to the possible consequences of his rash decisions, as a blind man is to the

King Lear Speach Assessment on a Director speach showing the various interpretations of King Lear

557 words - 2 pages Good afternoon and welcome cast and crew to the Globe's latest production of King Lear. What is tragedy? The Greek philosopher Aristotle summarised tragedy as a fatal flaw causing an important person to fall from happiness and prosperity in to catastrophe resulting in the hero moving from ignorance to knowledge and rousing a spectrum of emotions from spectators.In this production of King Lear I wish to underscore this movement from ignorance to

The Nature of King Lear

1071 words - 4 pages to see the true nature of his children and also invokes the language of nature in blind ways. After wrongly condemning Edgar he calls Edmund a "loyal and natural boy" (II. i. 85). In speaking of Edmund in his critical essay on King Lear, W.H. Auden writes, "The natural son behaves unnaturally and ends up as an outlaw whose hand is against every man" (Auden, p.226). In describing Edgar, Auden states, "Edgar wants to go on being a secure

The Tragedy of King Lear

1029 words - 5 pages homeless. After Gonorill and her husband received their portion of King Lear’s kingdom, things began to spin out of control and go downhill from there. Another selfish act that Gonorill committed during this play was poisoning Regan out of spite. Despite both being married, the two sisters were competing against one another for the same man. That man was Edmund. Gonorill initiated an affair with Edmund and began cheating on her husband. She

The Reinvention of King Lear

2118 words - 8 pages The Reinvention of King Lear         On any given night within the global theatre community, chances are good that somewhere upon a stage there is at least one production of a Shakespearean play being performed, and whether it is Hamlet set in Nazi Germany (Eine Klein Hamlet) or The Tempest reworked as children's theatre (The Island of Anyplace), this production is, more often than not, a new interpretation of the ancient text. While the


1803 words - 7 pages experience. Justice can only be achieved by a deep understanding of human nature. This understanding can only be attained through experiences and self discipline and not through the extensive study on treatises. According to Aristotle, a good ruler is a man with practical wisdom. Plato is an idealist while Aristotle is a realist. Plato believed in the employment of men in the common life of the society. Aristotle’s theories have a large scope that

King Lear - Disruption Of Order In King Lear And The Causes

881 words - 4 pages Shakespeare's King Lear is a play which shows the consequences of one man's decisions. The audience follows the main character, Lear, as he makes decisions that disrupt order in his Kingdom. When Lear surrenders all his power and land to his daughters as a reward for their demonstration of love towards him, the breakdown on order in evident. Lear's first mistake is to divide his Kingdom into three parts. A Kingdom is run best under one ruler

A Comparison of the Outcomes of Othello and King Lear

558 words - 2 pages The Tragic Outcome of Othello and King Lear   Two Sources        In Othello and Lear, Shakespeare contrasts two endings that tragedy can bring.  As Lear is thrown from kingship, he begins to see through his previous misconceptions about love, justice, and the nature of authority.  Othello, on the other hand, held no real misconceptions about the world.  He begins the tragedy nearly

Insanity and the Necessity of Madness in King Lear

1841 words - 7 pages The Necessity of Madness in King Lear At the beginning of “King Lear,” an authoritative and willful protagonist dominates his court, making a fateful decision by rewarding his two treacherous daughters and banishing his faithful one in an effort to preserve his own pride. However, it becomes evident during the course of the tragedy that this protagonist, Lear, uses his power only as a means of projecting a persona, which he hides behind as

Similar Essays

Giovanni Pico Della Mirandola Oration On The Dignity Of Man, 1496

718 words - 3 pages man is unique and can or has accomplished great things. As Mirandola similarly states, man has a ton of worth and use so we need to go out and celebrate. Celebrate was makes man so great; his achievements. These ideas are supported by Humanism. Mirandola also makes a connection between the Dignity of Man and the Pater Familia. The Pater Familia stated that the oldest male of the house was in charge and took on all responsibilities. They soon

King Lear And A Thousand Acres Comparative Literary Analysis

1819 words - 8 pages minor details have been changed to provide an intriguing new take on the same story. One such change is the fact the story goes from a third person view in King Lear, mostly following King Lear, to a first person narrative from the perspective of Ginny in A Thousand Acres. Ginny is the modern day version for Goneril’s character. King Lear and A Thousand Acres may take place in two different time periods; they both offer comments on the status of

Humanistic Ideas: Pica Della Mirandola's "Oration On The Digity Of Man" And Baldassare Castiglione, "The Book Of The Courtier."

988 words - 4 pages education. To humanists moral and ethical issues were related more to secular society than to spiritual concerns, and it was a shift in the focus of values to man and his affairs. Finally, the humanistic period set values on behaviors, creative thinking and helped develop the morals that were necessary for society in the Renaissance times.The humanists believed in Pico Della "Oration on the Dignity of Man", and of his dignity of boundless freedom

King Lear And The Genre Of Tragedy

1299 words - 6 pages A tragedy is a genre typically defined as a play that deals with a series of events that lead to the downfall of the hero. Written between 1604 and 1606, ‘King Lear’ falls into the genre of tragedy, depicting the destruction and downfall of the main character (Abrams). The play centres on Lear, an aging king who, in his retirement, decides to divide his kingdom between his three daughters while retaining the title and privileges of being king