Comparative Theory Essay: Ethnohistory And The Postcolonial Perspective

1421 words - 6 pages

In The Houses of History, selected and introduced by Anna Green and Kathleen Troup, the different theories of the twentieth century are broken down and specifics are introduced about each theory. Historians use these theories to study certain aspects of history and to be able to compare two theories to each other and the problems each theory addresses must be identified. With all aspects of history having some sort of connection, it would be better to take a holistic approach to the history of different eras. As we first read in Arnold earlier in the semester, "History is above all else an argument (Arnold 13)." Therefore, to compare two theories of history, the argument must begin with the facts of the theory and what that theory is used for, and then argue where it might have flaws or not connect history together.
Beginning with ethnohistory, which includes anthropology, the beginnings of the different studies of mankind are introduced, when the book then jumps to a postcolonial perspective the views of the future are pointed to the mistakes of the past. Each theory has a purpose to explaining the views and studies of different historians around the world. This essay will compare my views on ethnohistory combined with anthropology versus the views of postcolonial history. To start with anthropology, and outlining the timelines of mankind, one can start cumulating the facts around how humans have evolved throughout hundreds and thousands of years. Using anthropology as a theory of history is the ability to understand the social and cultural behaviors that connect the concept of human culture. As historians there are many benefits from using anthropology, studying the behaviors of human kind and all of its variations is a true example of evolution through time. These examples are socially relative and also culturally relative, helping to create a picture of the affects of human behavior caused by social and cultural societies. As more historians used the theory of anthropology, the theory itself began to have offspring ideas. British historians Emile Durkheim and Keith Thomas led the way in the twentieth century as historian who developed more influences based on anthropology. " For Durkheim, study of the social group or community took precedence over the individual. He believed that human behavior is fundamentally shaped by the moral, religious and social society in which the individual lives (Green, Troup 173)." In other words, the way Durkheim viewed anthropology in the twentieth century was society as a whole. His study was based on large groups of people rather than just a single person. Keith Thomas drew a different view with anthropology; he wanted to lead anthropologist into an untapped resource within the studies of the development of mankind. Thomas ideas for anthropology were to lead historians into more in depth findings about people's everyday lives. Thomas idea was, "...anthropology was to become immensely influential in...

Find Another Essay On Comparative Theory Essay: Ethnohistory and The Postcolonial Perspective

The Dialectical Model in Comparative Perspective

2373 words - 9 pages , Michael, and Graham Woodgate, ed. ìSociology and the Environment. Social Theory and the Global Environment. London: Routledge, 1995. Ross, Carolyn, ed. Writing Nature. New York: St. Martinís Press, 1995. Emerson, Ralph Waldo. ìNature.î Ross 421-423. Oates, Joyce Carol. ìAgainst Nature.î Ross 458-463. Handouts: Bibliographical Information Unavailable Martin, Emily. ìBody Narratives, Body Boundaries.î Merchant, Carolyn. ìNature as Female.î Nash, Roderick. ìWilderness and the American Mind.î Representations: Maxim. Feb. 2001. 16 Feb. 2001 16 Feb. 2001 <>

Improvement. Comparative essay on Leaving by M.G.Vassanji and The Cage

890 words - 4 pages Improvement.Comparative essay on Leaving by M.G.Vassanji and The Cage by Neil Bissoondath By Michael Rosario 821-685-773 Displacement is a theme that deals with leaving home. being able to better yourself through change. "The Cage" by Neil Bissoondath and "Leaving" by M.G.Vassanji both play on this theme. In these two stories characterization is used to convey the topic. Characterization is a process by which we are given an in-depth look at the


1082 words - 4 pages ROMEO AND JULIET COMPARATIVE ESSAY'The difference between Franco Zeffirelli's Romeo & Juliet (1968) and Baz Luhrmann's version of Romeo & Juliet (1996) is simply a modernisation created by Luhrmann to attract a teenage audience.'To what extent do you agree with this statement?Romeo and Juliet, written by William Shakespeare, is a tragic love story about two young lovers who are forced to be estranged as a result of their feuding families

The Colonies of Culture:The Postcolonial Self in Latin America and Africa

2446 words - 10 pages The Colonies of Culture:The Postcolonial Self in Latin America and Africa The colony is not only a possibility in the geographical; it is a mental dominance that can imperialize the entire self. Entire continents have be domineered, resources completely dried, and at colonialism’s usual worst, the mental devastation of the indigenous culture has left a people hollow. Indigenous culture is no longer that. In the globalized world, no culture

Macbeth and Lady Macbeth Comparative Essay

1154 words - 5 pages Christina Anton E. Bilan ENG 3U1 12 May 2014 Macbeth and Lady Macbeth Comparative Essay In the play Macbeth by William Shakespeare, Macbeth and his wife; Lady Macbeth become greedy for power after being given a prophecy from three witches. In the end, however their greediness just gets them killed. In the play Macbeth and Lady Macbeth are different in terms of their reaction to prophecy, gender identity, and sense of guilt. Their opposing views

Isolation: A Comparative Essay. Hamlet And Gertrude

1720 words - 7 pages Isolation: a Comparative Essay.In William Shakespeare's play Hamlet, the concept of identity is explored through Hamlet's isolation which is created by the conflict between his duty to his father, and his duties to the monarchy and his peers. Gertrude suffers the same identity questions through her isolation and also that of her sons. The isolation they experience not only is caused by some sort of tragic event, but also provokes many dilemmas

Arctic Wolf and Dingo comparative essay

643 words - 3 pages The Arctic Wolf and the Dingo have many similarities because of the fact that they are both from the canine species. Although they do have these similarities, this essay will be focusing on their differences - specifically the way that the each of these species has adapted to their environment. The particular adaptations that will be examined in this comparison are their fur, their pack sizes and hunting techniques, and the ears of these two

Donne's Poetry and Great Gatsby Comparative essay

1238 words - 5 pages destructive nature of love, explored by the behaviour of shallow and conceited characters. Both texts utilise a diversity of structural and literary techniques to communicate to the audience their perspective on love.In A valediction forbidding mourning Donne uses his profound metaphysical knowledge to explore and compare the relationship between death and parting from a lover. In the first stanza of A valediction forbidding mourning, Donne's

Comparative Essay: The Frog Prince Vs The Princess and The Frog

2103 words - 8 pages “Monster” (Prince, 2001). This essay will examine the evolution of the original Grimm Brothers’ fairytale, the messages both main characters represent, and how the adaptation to fit a modern child readership diminishes a classic fairytale. Through discussing these arguments, this paper will prove that Disney’s adaptation into The Princess and The Frog is counter-productive in representing the original story’s messages, morals, and values

The Churches of Christ: A Comparative Essay

824 words - 3 pages The Churches of Christ: A Comparative EssayOver the past ten years there has been much controversy in the Christian and secular media about the International Churches of Christ (ICC), and the United (or mainline) Church of Christ (CoC). This controversy has stemmed from the ICC's misuse of funds, doctrinal problems, member abuse, and mind-control. The differences between the CoC and the ICC are important for Christians know and understand.The

Robert Frost Poems Comparative Essay - The Sound of the Trees and Tree at my Window

2844 words - 11 pages humans are genuinely lost forever. Secondly, the entire phrase can suggest from the narrator's perspective that the tree is never "lost". In the last section of the poem, Frost utilizes an extended metaphor of "inner" and "outer" (15-16) weather to show a contrast between how humans experience weather in a different way than trees. The word "weather" in the last line ties the whole poem together

Similar Essays

Mohan Rakesh, Modernism, And The Postcolonial Present

9589 words - 38 pages humanism, nationalism, and cosmopolitanism, center and periphery, village and city. Approaching him as a paradigmatic figure, the essay first considers the concepts of modernity and modernism as they emerge at the levels of taxonomy, theory, and practice in Indian literature and culture after the mid-nineteenth century, providing a conceptual framework for successive generations of pre- and post-independence writers. It then examines the modernist

Comparative Essay: The Church And The Caliphate

2491 words - 10 pages the Islamic fundamentals on which they were founded. Concluding the matter, Arnold argues, "the theory of the Caliphate is still cherished by theological students who shut their eyes to the altered circumstances of the political world, and expound the doctrine of the Caliphate as though they were still living in the ninth century"(19). Theoretically (or in the circumstances in which it was created), the true, original form of the Caliphate would be

Julius Caesar And The Odyssey Comparative Essay

884 words - 4 pages Julius Caesar and The Odyssey Comparative Essay Throughout William Shakespeare’s play Julius Caesar and Homer’s epic poem The Odyssey, loyalty is strongly presented as a major motif. In both texts, loyalty is highly valued as one of the most important traits to a person’s character. Not only do the loyal characters receive better fates, but those who are not loyal are punished for the actions, usually through revenge. In Julius Caesar, the

The Theory Of Comparative Advantage Essay

749 words - 3 pages Buy American. In recent years, and especially since the recession, this has been the mantra of ‘patriots’ across the nation. The recent jobs bill that went through Congress may even have subsidies to encourage it. But what effect would buying products made in the United States really have? Would it create jobs for Americans? Would it save the flailing auto industry? Or would it ultimately hurt our economy? According to the Theory of Comparative