This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing A Aboriginal And Australian Justice Systems

1486 words - 6 pages

Interrelationship : Aboriginal & Australian justice system :
The recognition of aboriginal customary laws under the Australian Criminal justice system is just confined to acknowledgement of just the traditional physical punishments at the stage of sentencing. It all depends upon the interpretation and readings of individuals who play a role in the Criminal justice system in the capacity of judicial officers, officers of the court, lawyers and police officers etc. (Aboriginal Law& criminal justice,Law Reform Commission,W.Australia)
Comparison between Aboriginal & Australian justice system :
There are certain areas of conflict between the Aboriginal Justice system and the Australian Law. Persons following the aboriginal customary laws if give out traditional bodily punishments prevalent under the customary law may be regarded as an offender under the australian law. Similarly there are several initiation practices under the the customary law that constitute criminal offence. Some scholars have proposed to make the traditional punishments of the aboriginal people as lawful under the Australian legal system but there are an equal number of critics for the proposal as well. They say that it should be on case to case basis rather making every provision of customary law legal. (Aboriginal Law& criminal justice,Law Reform Commission,W.Australia)
There are several inconsistencies between the aboriginal law and the australian law, for e.g. if a person commits a crime governed under the australian law then in that case he will be liable to punishment but if an aboriginal person violates both the customary law and australian law then in that case he will be liable to be punished under both laws or in effect getting double punishment for a single offence or double jeopardy. (Aboriginal Law& criminal justice,Law Reform Commission,W.Australia)
There are considerable differences between the methods of dispute resolution under the aboriginal law and the Australian law. Aboriginal dispute resolution methods actively involve members of the family and community whereas, under the Australian system complete strangers to the dispute adjudicate and hand out punishments. (Aboriginal Law& criminal justice,Law Reform Commission,W.Australia)
The parties to a dispute take an active part in the dispute resolution under the aboriginal law whereas, under the Australian legal system litigants are represented by advocates.
Decision making under the aboriginal law is a collective effort while under the australian law it can be termed as hierarchal. (Aboriginal Law& criminal justice,Law Reform Commission,W.Australia)
If we take facts and figures in to consideration then we will find that there is over-representation of aboriginal people within the criminal justice system as offenders in comparison to other people governed under the australian law. It can be said in broad terms that the over-representation could be due to the fact of offending acts, their social and economic...

Find Another Essay On Comparing a Aboriginal and Australian Justice Systems

Comparing Australian and Chinese Identities Essay

1430 words - 6 pages between Chinese identity and Australian identity. Oxford Dictionary (2014) defines “national identity” as “a sense of a nation as a cohesive whole, as represented by distinctive traditions, culture, and language.” Therefore, this essay analyses the national identity of Australia and China from the aspects of their unique histories and political systems, meanwhile focuses on how these features influence their national identities. Australia is

A Balance Between Rehabilitation and Punitive Justice Systems

3005 words - 13 pages Restorative Justice is a system centred on reparative aspects rather than only punitive ones. Indeed, the crime should be fixed, not just punished. It has become progressively more popular over the years and its apparition can be explained from the failures of the traditional models of criminal justice. The actual criminal justice system has more than proved the problems it raises and its inefficiency in a number of matters: “We have never

Post World War Two Racism, in Aboriginal and Non-Aboriginal Australian Communities

1677 words - 7 pages Post World War Two Racism, in Aboriginal and Non-Aboriginal Communities. Over the years Australia has had many different problems with racism and racism affecting peoples’ lives. Many racial groups have been affected, most significantly the Aboriginals. The end of world war two in 1945 marked a huge change in types of racism. Australia went from the ‘superior’ white Australians dominating over immigrants and aboriginals. To a relatively

Justice Systems and Citizens Security

1767 words - 8 pages The Justice system comprises of entities which serve to prevent, detect, prosecute, adjudicate and discipline criminal activities. Globally, Justice systems aim to ensure citizen security simultaneously without infringement on the citizen’s rights. The Due Process model is a model which recognizes that the state must respect all the legal rights of a person when carrying out justice. The Due process model questions the criminal justice system as

Court Systems and Criminal Justice

1429 words - 6 pages The two types branches of our court systems is the duel court system (Bohm & Haley, 2010, p 288). Each system in the Federal or State side contains numerous possibilities in their jurisdiction with their authority to of the court to hear and decide cases (Bohm & Haley, 2010, p 288). However, the two courts described are: Trial Courts of Limited Jurisdiction and Trial courts of General Jurisdiction. Trial Courts of Limited Jurisdiction is a

French and American Criminal Justice Systems

1168 words - 5 pages French and American Criminal Justice Systems There many different criminal justice systems in the world today. Some that consists of many of the same policies and some that are considerably different. In the case of France and the U.S. there are a lot of similarities, but I will be focusing on the differences between each of their systems. The aspects that I will be comparing are police, courts, the legal profession, legal education

Balance of Man and Nature in Japanese and Australian Aboriginal Art

1171 words - 5 pages Balance of Man and Nature in Japanese and Australian Aboriginal ArtMany cultures use art as a means of expression of their spiritual beliefs. Religion has been a common theme seen in several art medians. This influence can be seen in architecture, painting, sculptures, and decorative arts. The two different art styles that I will discuss are the Japanese and contemporary Aboriginal. While both show a connection to ancestors and balance with the

Review of the Racial Discrimination Act (Australian) and It's Influences on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders

852 words - 3 pages Definition: Direct Racial discrimination is the act of treating a person unfairly (compared to the rest of society) based on their race, color, descent, national origin or ethnic origin. Indirect racial discrimination is when a policy, legislation or rule has an unfair effect on certain groups of people, more than that of others, based on their race, color, descent or national or ethnic origin. However these policies, legislations and rules can

Comparing and Contrasting Economic Systems Essay

683 words - 3 pages Throughout all of the 1900's the world's developed countries slowly began to practice three main types of economic systems, those of which fell under three categories, communism, socialism and, capitalism. A great example of a communist country was China. This meant that government had total control of production and how it was produced. In this system everyone works for the common good of the people. Socialism consisted of a system where

Comparative law analysis between Australian, Germany and China Legal Systems

4297 words - 17 pages faith.Finally, if it can be proven there was a 'serious misunderstanding' between Moe and KKCO, a court can set aside or vary the contract.5.0 Governing Law Using Australian Choice of LawIn the given situation, it is not possible to identify a particular Country or State Law as the law that should govern because they are not stated.In cases of Tort, for example when a negligent act occurs, most recent High Court decisions indicate that the law to be applied

Aboriginal deaths in custody - history of colonization in Australia, Australian society, statistics, western society. Includes extensive bibliography - A- mark

2635 words - 11 pages Haralambos et al, 1999) introduced the concept of 'Fourth World Peoples', which has been applied to Aboriginal people of Australia. They are seen as an indigenous group, rather than a migrant group; they are politically powerless and struggle for justice in many aspects. Australian history has been written by the western societies, who have attempted to erase the culture of Indigenous Australians.The statistics and details indicate that the high

Similar Essays

The Australian Legal System, Differences In Civil Law And Criminal Justice, How Can Both Systems Be Improved? Justify

1097 words - 4 pages In Nsw, courts provide a resolution between individuals, corporations, government agencies etc... Courts are the place where the validity and application of law are determined and enforced. In courts there are two systems, Criminal justice and Civil law. Generally Criminal cases involves the person being persecuted by the police or Director of public persecutions for an offence against the law, while civil cases are disputes between people

Similarities Between Australian Aboriginal And Native Americans

573 words - 2 pages The term 'Indigenous' brings a lot to the table. It is used to describe such a diverse group of people that differ ethnically, culturally, and economically but are supposed to be looked upon as 'one'. But are we really 'one'?Australian Aboriginals and Native Americans have all seemed to make great strides toward equality in the past 200 years. After 200 years one would think that the people of Australia and America would be able to set aside

A Report On The Australian Aboriginal And Torres Straight Islander Sexual Health Program

2357 words - 9 pages : Australian Institute of Health & WelfareCommonwealth Department of Health, 2000 The Management of HIV/AIDS. A resource guide for Indigenous primary health care organisations, Canberra: Public Health Media UnitCommonwealth Department of Health, 2001 Better Health Care. Studies in the Successful Delivery of Primary Health Care Services for Aboriginal and Torres Straight Islander Australians, Canberra: Public Health Media UnitHealey, K., Aboriginal

Aboriginal Women And The Canadian Justice Sysem

2597 words - 11 pages (LaPrairie 1987). For a number of years it has been apparent that ?the Canadian criminal justice system has failed Aboriginal people and, more specifically, Aboriginal women?(Sparling 1999). Should the concept of women?s history within the judicial system be one of disregard and negligence, ?it should come as no surprise that the history of Aboriginal women?s imprisonment is an exaggeration of the same? (Sparling 1999).Compared to other offenders