Compare And Contrast Billy Budd Versus Bartleby

2073 words - 8 pages

A Comparison/Contrast Analysis of "Billy Budd" and Bartleby"

Several comparisons and contrasts can be made concerning the two stories, Billy Budd and Bartleby, written by Herman Melville. The setting of the two stories reveals an interesting comparison and contrast between the British Navy on the open sea, and the famous Wall Street of New York. The comparison and contrast of characters, Billy Budd, Captain Vere, and Claggart in Billy Budd, and the `narrator' and Bartleby in Bartleby, at times are very much alike, and also very different. The conflict, climax and resolution of the two Melville stories contain similarities and differences. These two stories, on the exterior, appear to be very different, and on the interior are alike, especially if trying to analyze the stories by interpreting the symbolism that Melville may be trying to reveal in his writing. This essay will analyze the similarities and differences in Billy Budd and Bartleby.

The first analysis of these stories will be comparing and contrasting the setting. To compare the setting of the two stories, much like the decline of the British naval supremacy in the world due to over-expansion, and especially mutinies, which were taking place throughout the Navy, mostly because of over worked conditions, extended enlistments, and impressments of non-volunteers, on Wall Street, there was a conflict between wage laborers and capitalists in the form of strikes and violence in the street. The conflict leads to the forming of trade unions to resist the methods of factory production and wage labor. The setting can also be compared because of the limited mention of the surroundings, until the very end when Billy Budd, after being hanged, has his body set out to sea, and Bartleby, in the end, during his death, is sent away to a prison, known as `the Tombs.' A final comparison can be made, that both settings are confined to a relatively small space; Billy Budd on a ship, and Bartleby to an office building.

The setting for Billy Budd is on a British naval ship, sailing on the sea during the late 1700s. This was a critical period for the British Navy. Great Britain was at that time an imperial presence all around the world. This included the Americas, Africa, Australia, India, and the Far East. All these territories had stretched British Naval forces beyond its capacity to govern and control such a huge empire. These complications eventually led to its decline. In contrast, the setting for Bartleby was New York City's Wall Street. During the early to mid 1800s, Wall Street was the center of America's financial and business life. The banking and credit institutions, insurance companies, and the growing stock exchange were all revolutionizing the American economy.

The comparison and contrast of the characters will begin with who the main characters are. In the story of Bartleby, the main characters are the unnamed `narrator,' who is...

Find Another Essay On Compare and Contrast Billy Budd versus Bartleby

Compare and Contrast High School versus College

698 words - 3 pages      After going to high school for four years, college is definitely a step up. There are similarities, but at the same time more differences. There is still some required classes and homework, but they are different at the same time. Classes in college are bigger as well as the campus, class times vary a lot more, homework takes more time, and the teacher/student communication is a 180 degree change from high school. ...

Compare and Contrast High School versus College

1238 words - 5 pages Every student typically has a great high school career. Classes are not very difficult; AP courses are an exception. Student workload is minimal, obtaining good grades is not much of a struggle, and exams are typically easy to pass. Course load outside the class is no more then a few hours of homework each week. Teachers and faculty help facilitate a moderately laid back culture to learning. The school system supports students to make...

Compare and Contrast High School versus College

957 words - 4 pages All throughout high school I’ve sat and listened to a countless number of teachers throw information in my face. Whether it be a new concept in math or a description of how to properly play kickball in gym. With all the years of hearing lecture after lecture, I cannot believe why I decided to come to college. I have signed and paid to have trained professionals throw more material in my face. One of the biggest difference between high school and...

Billy Budd - Thoreau and Melville

1167 words - 5 pages Billy Budd - Thoreau and Melville   The story of Billy Budd provides an excellent scenario in which to compare and contrast Thoreau and Melville. The topics of government-inspired injustice and man's own injustice to man can be explored through the story. Thoreau's position is one of lessened government and enhanced individualism, while Melville's is one of group unity and government's role to preserve order. The opinions of...

Comparing Billy Budd and Christ

3108 words - 12 pages Comparing Billy and Christ in Billy Budd Herman Melville's Billy Budd provides us with a summation and conclusive commentary on the ambiguities of moral righteousness and social necessity. The conflict that arises pitting natural justice in opposition to military justice essentially deliberates over whether the sacrifice of the individual is required for the continuum and conservation of social order. The deep allegorical theme of the...

Good and Evil in Billy Budd

1189 words - 5 pages Good and evil exist in all things. In Herman Melville's novel Billy Budd, good is represented by Billy Budd and evil, by John Claggart.  Together, they embody Melville's portrayal of opposing forces that run throughout all aspects of human experience.  In addition, Melville provides for the possibility of a balance between good and evil through the character of Captain Vere.  In Freudian terminology, I might view Claggart as...

Billy, Bartleby, and Edna: American Transcendentalists

1107 words - 4 pages In "The transcendentalist" and "The Divinity School Address" Ralph W. Emerson clearly expresses his view the world, which is quite different from the one most people are used to and perceive as acceptable. Emerson said that when he is observing the nature around, he starts feeling a connection between him, God, and nature overall, which proves that Emerson was experiencing the divine consciousness connection (a transcendental point of view)....

Billy, Bartleby, and Edna: American Transcendental

1149 words - 5 pages In "The transcendentalist" and "The Divinity School Address" Ralph W. Emerson clearly expresses his view the world, which is quite different from the one most people are used to and perceive as acceptable. Emerson said that when he is observing the nature...

Billy Budd, Sailor, by Harrison Hayford and Merton M. Seaths

696 words - 3 pages Can a man kill another man; yet, be a passive hero? In Harrison Hayford and Merton M. Seaths short story, “Billy Budd, Sailor (An inside Narrative)”, Billy Budd is characterized as a passive hero. Unexpectedly, Billy Budd is singled out and forced into the King’s service. Even so, Billy Budd has a positive influence with nearly all of his ship mates and officers. However, Billy’s affect with the new master-at-arms proves Billy does not have a...

Comparing Billy Budd and the Life of Melville

1508 words - 6 pages Parallels Between Billy Budd and the Life of Melville  As with many great works of literature, it is important to become familiar with the author's life and time period in which he or she lived. This understanding helps to clarify the significance and meaning of his or her work. In many ways, Billy Budd depicts issues of importance to Herman Melville with both direct and indirect parallels to the time of the Civil War and to particular...

Billy Budd Essay: Themes of Good and Evil

1910 words - 8 pages Themes of Good and Evil in Billy Budd   Many themes relating to the conflict between Good and Evil can be found in Herman Melville's novella Billy Budd.  Perhaps one of the most widely recognized themes in Billy Budd is the corruption of innocence by society (Gilmore 18).              Society in Billy Budd is represented by an eighteenth century English man-of-war, the H.M.S. Bellipotent.  Billy, who represents innocence, is a young...

Similar Essays

Comparing Religious Archetypes in Moby Dick, Billy Budd, and Bartleby the Scrivener

2293 words - 9 pages Religious Archetypes in Moby Dick, Billy Budd, and Bartleby the Scrivener       Herman Melville's use of Biblical overtones gives extra dimensions to his works.  Themes in his stories parallel those in the Bible to teach about good and evil.  Melville emphasizes his characters' qualities by drawing allusions, and in doing so makes them appear larger than life.  In the same way that the Bible teaches lessons about life, Herman Melville's...

Billy Budd by Herman Melville Examine the theme of institutional conscience versus private conscience in Billy Budd.

793 words - 3 pages Institutional Conscience v. Private Conscience"When the woman saw that the fruit of the tree was...desirable for gaining wisdom, she took some and ate it. She also gave some to her husband...then the eyes of both of them were opened." This well-known Bible verse from Genesis 3:6 was known as The Fall of Man. Symbolically, when the first humans ate from the forbidden tree of the knowledge of good and evil, civilization was conceived. Its...

Compare and Contrast Brick-and-Mortar Versus Virtual Organizations

1793 words - 7 pages The Information Age has ushered in a whole new competitive virtual marketplace for traditional brick-and-mortar organizations to compete with in the tough competitive global markets of the 21st century economy. The ability of virtual organizations to easily advertise and market their products through the internet and social medias have created a potentially limitless clientele through the utilization of a mass mediated approach that has...

Compare and contrast the conductive versus the conductive versus the contractile cardiac muscle fibers.

564 words - 2 pages Compare and contrast the conductive versus the conductive versus the contractile cardiac muscle fibers. Describe their arrangement in the heart and explain the roles each play in the contraction of the heart.Contractile· Striated· Has intercalated discs - gap junctions· 1-2 nuclei· Branching· Aerobic ONLY (highly enriched with mitochondria)· T-tubules,...