Compare And Contrast Marx And Weber

4185 words - 17 pages

During the nineteenth century, Karl Marx and Max Weber were two of the most influential sociologist. Both their views on the rise of capitalism have various similarities and differences. They believe that capitalism is relatively new to the modern world. Their views differ on the rise of capitalism. Regardless of Marx and Weber's differences, both theorists agree that capitalism is a system of highly impersonal relations.Karl Marx was born on May 5, 1818 to the father of a Jewish lawyer. As a young student Marx often read works written by Hegel. From school, Marx wrote to his father of his feelings on Hegel. He had found a disliking for those Hegelians who sought to "draw atheistic and revolutionary conclusions from Hegel's philosophy" (Granat Encyclopedia, pg.153) In order to better understand the views of Marx we must look at the philosophy of Hegel.German philosophy in the nineteenth century was dominated by the ideas of Hegel. Hegel's philosophy was based on the concept of idealism. By looking at prior philosophers one will see that Hegel's philosophy was similar to that of Immanuel Kant. Kant was interested in the study of knowledge. Kant had argued, that ideas or concepts are apriori. Apriori ideas are one which exist before one's knowledge of the world, that is ideas are not empirical.Hegel's philosophy was an expansion on the philosophy of Kant. Hegel believed that apriori knowledge came from "geist" or the holy spirit. History, according to Hegel, consisted of a set of ideas or a thesis. For every thesis there was an opposite set of ideas or an antithesis. It is through this contradiction that a new set of ideas or a synthesis are born. The synthesis of the thesis and the antithesis forms Hegel's theory of the dialectic. History was a set of arguments or a "dialectic" which would then define a new era in history.Between Hegel and Marx came Ludwig Feuerbach who believed that Hegel was upside-down. Ideas, he contended, should be thought of more in the material and less in the non-physical. Ideas do not come from "geist" but rather from other humans. Feuerbach had seen language as a shared phenomenon. It is with this ability for humans to speak the same language that ideas are developed. Since ideas can only come from other ideas they are dependent on the language of society. Hence, ideas can only come from society. Feuerbach viewed history as consisting of an "epoch" of ideas. An "epoch" was a set of ideas that that defined a period in history.The nineteenth century was also the era of Darwin who tried to answer questions using scientific reason. Darwin had also exposed his theory of evolution during this era. Looking at the philosophy of Marx one sees that he takes into account the philosophy Darwin, Hegel and Feuerbach. Marx felt that Feuerbach had focused to little on Hegel, and had lost the dialectic. Marx had seen history as consisting of both the dialectic and materialism. He called this "Dialectic Materialism." History, in the view...

Find Another Essay On Compare and contrast Marx and Weber

Durkheim, Weber and Marx Essay

1228 words - 5 pages Three men, each with their own views of society and each called Fathers of Sociology and Modern Sociology by the people that continue to study their theories as it relates to society. In order to compare and contrast them, each must be given a short synopsis (if that is ever possible) of a key point in their theory and interpretation of society. Durkheim introduces us to the concept of “anomie”. Anomie, as explained by Durkheim’s theory, is

Marx and Weber Essay

632 words - 3 pages Two great socialogists Karl Marx Max Weber had different view about stratification in the society.Weber's point of view has some differences and simmilarities to Marx's. Marx arques that any human society devided into of two combination of people or two classes that constantly oppose each. One class tend to be take dominant position over the other class. Marx said that these two classes have different relation to the industry that rule economy

Marx, Weber and Religion

2924 words - 12 pages motivations, Weber posits that human conduct is governed by innumerable factors (Ekstrand 2000:30-2; Lowith 1993:63; Turner 1993:27). These factors cannot be clearly distinguished as sacred or profane as Durkheim proposed (Turner 1993:27), but are derived from both emotional and cultural experiences (Van Krieken et al. 2010:359). Both Durkheim and Marx regarded human behaviour as a direct response to structural influence, whereas Weber accounts for

The Three Sociologists: Marx, Durheim, and Weber

1188 words - 5 pages without drawing on some kind of theoretical ideas.” Per-ceptions of Karl Marx, Emile Durkheim and Max Weber (who can also be known as the ‘holy trinity’ of the three founding fathers) theories have been interpreted for hundreds of years, leading to them having a remarkable impact in history and to-day’s society. However the relevance of these theories in contemporary sociology raises a magnitude of different questions and opinions on how the theories

Social Stratification According to Marx and Weber

1548 words - 6 pages ]. Factors?, C. 2014. Compare and contrast the marxist and weberian theories of social class. why do you think marx emphasises relations of production in the formation of. [online] Available at: http://www.studymode.com/essays/Compare-And-Contrast-The-Marxist-And-672845.html [Accessed: 2 Apr 2014]. Giddens, A. and Birdsall, K. 2001. Sociology. Cambridge [England]: Polity Press. Kirby, M. 1997. Sociology in perspective. Oxford: Heinemann

Similarites Between the Theories of Max Weber and Karl Marx

1029 words - 4 pages Max Weber and Karl Marx has often been regarded as influential theorists who both analyzed in how the society is constructed in relationship to its economic conditions, more specifically on the division of labour. Both the labour and economics create a force on how societies are shaped and because of that Weber and Marx each developed a unique theory on how individuals react and how societies are formed. Many individuals say that, Marx and

Marx, Weber and their Critique of Global Capitalism

1739 words - 7 pages While Marx and Weber had divergent analyses of capitalism, their evaluations of modern global capitalism have a common thread of thought. They both view the implementation of global capitalism, where subordinating individual needs and desires to achieve the end goal of accumulating wealth for wealth’s sake, as irrational and unreasonable. Because of that commonality, it is feasible to draw from both analyses to explain global capitalization

Social Theories of Karl Marx and Maw Weber

945 words - 4 pages There are many sociological issues in the world today that can relate back to the concept theories that Karl Marx and Max Weber formed many years ago. Although there are too many for us to go further in depth on, I chose to primarily focus on Racism and Classism. With the perspectives of these theorists in mind I can explain how Racism, Classism, in conjunction with Feminism are among the largest social problems human beings face in the world

Compare and contrast dystopian

3699 words - 15 pages . Outsiders to this world include Bernard Marx, Helmhotz Watson and John the Savage. All feel different due to individual circumstance and rebel against their Brave New World.The descriptions of futuristic London are rendered in plain style creating a drab, lack of beauty mirrored in the words used. "A squat grey building of only thirty-four stories. Over the main entrance the words, CENTRAL LONDON HATCHERY AND CONDITIONING CENTRE, and in a shield

Compare and Contrast Essay

823 words - 4 pages very different. Their appearances, personalities and how they are involved with Louis can both be compared and contrasted. Appearance can always be used to compare and contrast two characters in a movie. Penelope is a brunette with medium length hair. She also wears makeup that makes her look sophisticated and important. The makeup she wears does not make her look anything less than a rich woman. Her clothes are also of the rich fashion. She

Compare and Contrast Essay

964 words - 4 pages Compare and Contrast Essay The setting of a story is the time and place in which the story takes place. The author may include a specific date or time period, or leave it up to the reader to determine a time period by suggesting certain events. The author may choose to give specific examples and clues as to where the story takes place or may suggest certain things to clue the reader to where the story is taking place. The theme of a

Similar Essays

Compare And Contrast The Views Of Durkhiem And Karl Marx

1240 words - 5 pages This essay will explore Emile Durkheim and Karl Marx's views on religion, it will attemptto compare and contrast some of these views held by each of the thinkers. This essay willalso argue which thinkers point of view is most appropriate in today's modern times andthe reasons for this.The four main topics for discussions, which are presented in this essay, will firstly startwith Durkheim's famous book "The elementary forms of the religious life

Eric Schlosser's Fast Food Nation Attempts To Explain Chapter Material And Compare And Contrast Using Marxist And Weber Concepts

793 words - 3 pages Karl Marx believed in the theory of Dialectical Materialism. The "commodities" such as the machines, technology and workers are the capitalism's mean of production. Each piece has a place in the structure. The workers do not generally own the machines that he or she works on nor does he/she create the technology. He/she are merely parts or cogs in the great workings of the structure.This concept is very instantly recognizable in Chapter 8 of

Compare And Contrast The Communist Manifesto By Marx And What Is To Be Done By Lenin

1372 words - 5 pages The Communist Manifesto was written by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels in 1848. During this time, many intellectuals were examining Europe's capitalist system and the effect that industrialization had on the working class. Marx was not the creator of the socialist movement. While attending the University of Berlin, Marx studied the works of Saint-Simon, Fourier, and Cabet and he found their principles too idealistic. Marx began using history

Compare And Contrast The Philosophies Of John Locke, Thomas Hobbes, And Karl Marx

772 words - 3 pages In the idea of human nature; origin of state, the nature of government, the rights of regulation can be drawn as the reflection of insightful philosophies of John Locke, Thomas Hobbes and Karl Marx. By understanding this within the context of human nature, we can see their ideas play to how they perceive a modern philosophy. Karl Marx's Communist Manifesto illustrates the desire to build "a society without economic classes". John Locke's