This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Compare And Contrast Of‘‘Binsey Poplars’’ By Gerard Manley Hopkins And ‘‘The Trees’’ By Philip Larkin

2136 words - 9 pages

Choose two of the poems given in the handout . Compare and contrast these two poems (‘‘Binsey Poplars’’ by Gerard Manley Hopkins and ‘‘The Trees’’ by Philip Larkin), paying close attention to their language and form.

In a recent article in The Guardian, Billy Mills writes, ‘Trees have been putting down roots in poetry for centuries’, and indeed there are as many poems about trees as there are species of trees themselves. As someone who grew up surrounded by trees and as a lover of poetry, it was a natural choice for me to use this assignment to explore two poems that are ostensibly about trees; Philip Larkin’s ‘The Trees’ and G.M. Hopkins’ ‘Binsey Poplars’. Of course, to say that the ...view middle of the document...

Its third person narrative gives a distance to the poem’s message and renders it less personal, but by no means powerful, than ‘Binsey Poplars’. Larkin’s poem is unsophisticated in its form and metre. The words are simple and easily understood. Its unpretentious rhyming scheme of ABBA, CDDC, EFFE and simple three stanza four line structure should not present the reader with too many concerns with regards to comprehension and meaning. However, this apparent simplicity is deceptive and I believe a misrepresentation of Larkin’s intent. Simplicity in form and structure does not result in a simple poem. In fact it is its simplicity that I find underlines its creativity and its power.
Larkin opens the poem with an almost banal and childish quality, ‘‘The Trees’ are coming into leaf’; the kind of poem opening we have all written at school. It is also quite an optimistic opening talking about new life and rebirth. As a reader we do not feel at this point that we are going to be challenged by the poet. However, this optimism is almost immediately undermined in the second line and a pattern of optimism contrasted with ambiguity begins. The use of words such as ‘almost’ and ‘kind of’ and ‘seem to’ throughout the poem add an uncertainty that is beguiling and unusual given that the subject matter we are dealing with is a certain one. Leaves die and are renewed. People die and new life is born in a continuing cycle. Why the uncertainty? I don’t believe Larkin is questioning the phenomenon as such but asking the reader instead to ponder on it, think about it and reflect on how the human experience is mirrored in nature. We are asked to consider if death really is death if we know new life is to come. Leaves falling are like a kind of dying but not quite because they also represent the new life force about to come into being.
There are some clever similes and metaphors throughout that engage the reader and provoke meditation on the theme. The leaves are words ‘almost said’ their greenness is a ‘kind of grief’. The alliteration in line four is a beautiful sound when we listen to the poem but it is an unusual choice to juxtapose greenness, which we usually link to life, with grief, which is usually denoted with the colour black. But Larkin himself seems to be saying that this is all one of nature’s tricks, the leaves are not dying just simply making way for new life, the bark renewed hides the rings of truth inside which tells us the many years the tree has stood. He strikes a pensive and meditative tone in the second stanza,
Is it that they are born again
And they grow old? No, they die too,
Their yearly look of looking new
Is written down in rings of grain.
The poem is questioning itself, musing on this seeming trick of nature. The enjambment from line one to two echoes the continuing of the life cycle. The superficial veneer of the renewed bark hides the real age of the tree just like our outward ageing appearance hides all our life’s experiences which...

Find Another Essay On Compare and Contrast of‘‘Binsey Poplars’’ by Gerard Manley Hopkins and ‘‘The Trees’’ by Philip Larkin

Carrion Comfort by Gerard Manley Hopkins

3542 words - 14 pages Carrion Comfort by Gerard Manley Hopkins Gerard Manley Hopkins was a talented poet, and he was also extremely devoted to his faith. He used his poetry as an avenue in which to express his love and praise to his Creator, and many of his poems are beautiful hymns of adoration. “Carrion Comfort,” however, is one of his “terrible sonnets.” Hopkins not only wrote about the beautiful part of faith, but also the questioning and suffering that

Poetry Explication of "Spring & Fall", by Gerard Manley Hopkins

911 words - 4 pages The poem "Spring and Fall" by Gerard Manley Hopkins is a poem focusing on the brevity of life, and the grief that is felt in the hearts of all mankind throughout our lives. It is also about the sadness felt by humans as we see ourselves aging, and ultimately about the fact that sin and separation from God bring sorrow and sadness that can never be fully explained by man.The poet is seemingly speaking to a young child, Margaret, who in her

Analysis of the Poem The Wreck of Deutschland by Gerard Manley Hopkins

2349 words - 9 pages will for England. Gerard Manley Hopkins, himself, is the speaker of the poem, “The Wreck of the Deutschland.” In this poem, Hopkins is horrified by the news of the five Franciscan nuns who tragically drowned in the shipwreck of the steamship, Deutschland, trying to escape from the anti-Catholic Falk Laws, seeking refuge in New York in America. Hopkins is horrified because he couldn’t understand why God would cast their deaths in the shipwreck

Attitude and Appreciation of the Natural World in Gerard Manley Hopkins and Henry Wadsworth Longfellow's Poetry

1822 words - 7 pages the world around us. Such findings are present in the work of many poets - namely Gerard Manley Hopkins (1844 - 1889)and Henry Wadsworth Longfellow (1808 - 1882). Hopkins and Longfellow were two contemporary poets from the nineteenth century from different cultures, English and American respectively who relished in the gift of nature with all her attributes. Both of their work is characterised by a deep and personal

Gerard Manley Hopkins

737 words - 3 pages Gerard Manley Hopkins Gerard Manley Hopkins is a reflection of his time period because his work represents realism, his work was different from what was expected, and his work had to do with religion. Although Hopkins is considered as one of the great poets of the past, he was not that appreciated during his time period. The only reason that we have his work today is because his friends held on to his work after his death and decided to

Rhythm and Dictions in Gerard Manley Hopkins' "Spring and Fall"

1538 words - 6 pages leaves whirling in the strong gusts of wind. By depicting the sound of the wind and the rustling leaves, Hopkins puts the readers in the scene, which further integrate the poem's effect on the readers.In "Spring and Fall", Gerard Manley Hopkins uses rhythm, word choice, and alliteration to make his poem come alive to his readers. He uses his innovation of sprung rhythm in contrast to the straightforward, sing-song rhythm to demonstrate the phase of

Lesson Plan: Students work in large and small groups to analyze and discuss the poem "Spring and Fall:To a Young Child," by Gerard Manley Hopkins

1117 words - 4 pages RationaleStudents will be able to explain the terms figurative language, neologism, simile, and metaphor. After understanding the terms in isolation, students will be encouraged to locate these literary concepts within the context of the poem "Spring and Fall: To a Young Child," by Gerard Manley Hopkins. The instructor will then gently guide students through the poem using Socratic questioning so that they may imbue the poem with inter

Allusions to God in the Poetry of Gerard Manley Hopkins

1765 words - 7 pages bird, the blooming of a flower, the birth of a human, all emit energy. They all take their toll on this planet, but each and every one was planned for and built for a purpose by our Heavenly Father. Gerard Manley Hopkins’ message is that all things are meaningless less without God. (Chevigny) He frequently utilized symbols to demonstrate how God is evident in all living things. He coined the term instress, to explain the experience that comes

Compare/contrast the ways Philip Sidney's Astrophil and Stella and Milton's Comus explore gender and sexuality

1185 words - 5 pages the society. Both Sidney's and Milton's heroines are no longer passive feminine receivers of affections. They determine what happens to them by using reason rather than emotions. Hence, Sidney and Milton exemplify progressive views of their periods, attempting to see gender and sexuality in a new light. Sexuality and desire Philip Sidney: Astrophil and Stella (c. 1591) Sidney's Astrophil and Stella, a compilation of 108 sonnets and 11 songs

Comparing two poems - Binsey Poplar by Hopkins and I wandered lonely

849 words - 3 pages Comparing two poems - Binsey Poplar by Hopkins and I wandered lonely as a cloud' by Wordsworth. Compare the two poems and comment on: - The overall feelings of the poem - How they use language effectively - What the poems suggest about the characters of the authors. The two poems 'Binsey Poplars' by Hopkins and 'I wandered lonely as a cloud' by Wordsworth both contain very strong, emotive feelings. However, the feelings that

Grigson and Ward on the Poetry of Gerald Manley Hopkins

2956 words - 12 pages is symbolic and is trying to say how out of touch man is with the world. Grigson said: "nature and glory in nature must be grasped by reaching to natures qualities and selfhoods. The God of Gerard Manley Hopkins is not inside nature - he is the worlds splendour and wonder - but one thing he does: through the nature he has made passes the voltage of the current of his love, his grandeur." From this, I understand that Hopkins not only conveys

Similar Essays

A Comparison Of The Poplar Field By William Cowper And Binsey Poplars Felled 1879 By Gerard Manley Hopkins

1439 words - 6 pages A Comparison of The Poplar Field by William Cowper and Binsey Poplars Felled 1879 by Gerard Manley Hopkins The first thing that is noticeable is that both the poems are about a group of trees alongside a river. The other general similarity between the poems is that they are then later cut down and so the writers are now deprived of their enjoyment in the "cool colonnade". However there are many differences between the

"The Way Through The Woods" By Gerald Manley Hopkins And "Binsey Poplars" By Rudyard Kipling

1757 words - 7 pages Compare the two poets' representations of and attitudes to nature in 'The Way Through the Woods' and 'Binsey Poplars'.-----------------------------------------------------------These two poems, by Gerald Manley Hopkins and Rudyard Kipling respectively, are both concerned with how humans and how their presence among nature can have a negative effect. Both of these poems seem to agree that humans do have an influence on the natural evolution of

Faith And Doubt In The Poetry Of Gerard Manley Hopkins

1621 words - 6 pages Gerard Manley Hopkins had eight siblings and was born of Manley and Catherine Smith Hopkins. His parents were Anglicans that followed the Catholic tradition in sacraments and papacy. By instilling the theological values, faith and morals into Gerard, he became heavily influenced by his family. His parents taught him, as well as their other children to love God. Gerard guaranteed his mother that he would strengthen his connection with God and

"Henry Purcell" By Gerard Manley Hopkins

1290 words - 5 pages 'Henry Purcell' by Gerard Manley Hopkins is a sonnet. This is so, as it begins with two quatrains, which describe the musician from whom the poem takes its name, followed by a sestet that takes a closer look at the music that he (Henry Purcell) created. However, a sonnet is usually defined as fourteen lines written in iambic pentameter, and the poem 'Henry Purcell' has six iambic feet per line, and as a result it is a sonnet in Alexandrines. A