This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Compare And Contrast Parmenides' And Plato's Different Views Of Reality. Which Theory Do You Find The Most Convincing?

733 words - 3 pages

Parmenides and Plato were both concerned with ontology (from the Greek 'onta' or being) and questioned the nature of the "real". They both concluded that the world around is a dream or an illusion and that the senses, as opposed to reason, cannot aid us in our quest for truth.Parmenides was the first of the ancient philosophers to make use of deductive argument and he did this in order to underline the dichotomy between what was commonly believed to be true (i.e. change, motion and growth etc) and what the reason illuminates as real. In Parmenides' own words:'But the decision about these matters lies in this: it is or it is not.'What 'is not' cannot be for "is not" is simply a privation of "is"; it is not a piece of Being with matter and form. That which "is" is necessarily corporeal, as J Burnet explains: 'There is no real doubt that this is what we call a body. It is certainly regarded as being spatially extended for it is quite seriously spoken of as a sphere'.For Parmenides this perfect sphere of 'being' is eternal, unchanging and immovable. There is no more of it in one part than another, it is perfectly equal and hence there can be no room for movement or growth. Melissus and Zeno developed such arguments, Zeno famously postulating the paradox of motion; if a tortoise were given a head start in a race with Achilles, Achilles would not logically be able to overtake the tortoise, despite being faster, because by the time he reaches the point where the tortoise was the tortoise will have moved ahead of that point. As long as the tortoise keeps moving it will always stay ahead, no matter how small the lead.By the same principle Zeno argued that a man could not run from one end of a stadium to the other because he must first reach the halfway point, yet before he reaches the halfway point he must first reach the point that lies halfway between the new points and so on.Plato, when formulating his theories, was aware of those of Parmenides and of the problems they implied. His concept of the Forms was designed partly to challenge Parmenides'...

Find Another Essay On Compare and contrast Parmenides' and Plato's different views of reality. Which theory do you find the most convincing?

Identify two theorists of consciousness who write from either a 1st, 2nd or 3rd person perspective, summarize their positions and choose which one you feel is most convincing

1608 words - 6 pages David Chalmers and Daniel Dennett are both atheists and philosophers (1)(2). However, this is pretty much where the similarities end. David Chalmers is an Australian philosopher and self-proclaimed 'dualist' (3) who firmly believes that "the heart of the science of consciousness is trying to understand the first person perspective" (4). He rejects more materialistic views which he sees as reductionist and argues that when the third person

Compare and Contrast Two Views of Gay Marriage

892 words - 4 pages refine, support, encourage and complete one another” (27). The battle of marriage between gay couples is one of the most intense and relentless arguments in today’s society. Sullivan tries to express his ideas on how same-sex marriage is only the righteous thing to do for all gay men and women in America by establishing a sense of equality among U.S. citizens. Bennett responds by arguing that if same-sex marriage is allowed

Compare and contrast the Psycoanalitic Theory with the Behaviorist Theory

1722 words - 7 pages Compare and contrast two psychological approachesBy Rory SimmonsMy intention in this essay, is to compare and contrast the following psychological approaches Behaviourism and Psychoanalysis, in doing this I will unpack the key points of these two approaches, highlighting the differences and explaining them.The first approach I will look at is Psychoanalysis; the most famous psychologist linked to this is Sigmund Freud an Austrian psychologist

The Old Nurse's Story (E. Gaskell) and The Axe (P. Fitzgerald): Of the two stories you have read, which do you think is the most effective ghost story? Which story do you prefer and why?

2139 words - 9 pages particularly exciting scene taking place we find that the author uses long paragraphs and little punctuation so as not to break the tension by making the reader stop and start. It is an effective way to write and makes the reader subconsciously read faster, making the heart race.The Axe is made increasingly ambiguous by the fact that we do not know whether the ghost is a real ghost or a figment of the narrator's imagination. I would lean towards

Compare and contrast two social science views about the ordering of social life.

1611 words - 7 pages specifically, how social order is made and remade. While the two theories aim to understand a broad picture of understanding society, they do so in very different ways. They both split the big questions down into smaller ones, Goffman looks at how an individual creates order, and Foucault looks at how discourse does. The two theories are both very different yet similar in many ways. This makes them interesting to compare and contrast, something

Compare and contrast two social science views about the ordering of social life

2015 words - 9 pages interaction according to Goffman. The social self, in Goffman’s framework has no substance beyond expected behaviours, on different occasions and in different contexts. . Goffman sees social institutions as non-existent, as structures themselves. Instead, he views them as products of people’s interactions and social situations they reproduce each day. However, by concentrating on micro levels of social interaction Goffman shows little regard for the

compare and contrast the customs between two different country

906 words - 4 pages Vietnam is a country, which has long history. Chinese dominated Vietnam for 1,000 years. The French also dominated the country for 61 years. However, Vietnam gets most influence from China, which is one of the most powerful countries in the world after America. However, Viet Nam culture and Chinese culture have First of all, Chinese culture came into Vietnam long time ago when the feudal came from China and made the most effect to Vietnamese

Compare and contrast two of the set texts from two different periods "Everyman" and "Doctor Faustus"

1081 words - 4 pages ElizabethanRomantic Tragedy. However Christopher Marlowe used the structure of an olderMedieval form of English Drama, the morality play as a model. Morality plays tended toshow the moral struggle of mans soul and the conflict of good and evil. This is evident inthe play of Doctor Faustus who is embroiled in a battle between the temptation of thedevil and God. You could argue that Doctor Faustus is not classed as amorality play. Because in the tradition of a

Compare The Birthing Scene In Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, Directed By Kenneth Branagh (1994) With The Original Version Directed By James Whale (1931). Which Do You Think Is Most Effective And Why?

1361 words - 5 pages communicates Victor's feelings and work as well as showing the darker side of one human artificially creating life "“ in effect taking on the role of what some people would believe to be the work of god.As the scene progresses, Victor begins to connect up all the wires. This is shown in a very long shot which allows the viewer to see the entire room, as well as the attic roof. Towards the end of the birthing scene, the creature is up in chains

Compare and contrast the representation of charities in two different television adverts

1371 words - 5 pages more to prove and rather than just tell a story. It shows us close ups of the cigarettes and the "fatty stuff" that would put us off. All the settings in the NSPCC advert are where you would normally find a child, at school, in the park, on the bus and at home. It's trying to show you how the child's abuser is always there with them no matter where they are. In the British Heart Foundation advert it is set in the pub, where you're most likely to

Compare and contrast two beliefs about life after death. Assess which of these two views may provide a stronger philosophical basis for belief in life after death?

1402 words - 6 pages “surviving” death exactly means. There are two main theories developed for the meaningful survival after death: materialism and dualism.Materialism is the theory that our minds are inseparable from our bodies. Materialism is the view that only that which we can come to knowledge of empirically and do not accept the existence of a separate soul as it cannot be verified. It is based on and understanding of the universe that has one

Similar Essays

Compare The Play "Pygmalion" By George Bernard Shaw With Its Film Version "My Fair Lady". Which Do You Find More Effective Work Of Art And Why. Use Quotes

1908 words - 8 pages and play such as the character interactions or how both of them portray social status, especially in the conclusion, the musical displays several contradictions in comparison to the movie.Bernard Shaw wrote the play during an important moment in history, which was when women were starting to gain independence in the beginning of the 20th century. It is produced in 1914 which is when WW1 broke out and war time made it easier for women to find

Aristotle And Plato's Views On Reality

1030 words - 4 pages Aristotle and Plato were both great thinkers but their views on realty were different. Plato viewed realty as taking place in the mind but Aristotle viewed realty is tangible. Even though Aristotle termed reality as concrete, he stated that reality does not make sense or exist until the mind process it. Therefore truth is dependent upon a person’s mind and external factors. According to Aristotle, things are seen as taking course and will

Compare And Contrast The Views Of Durkhiem And Karl Marx

1240 words - 5 pages This essay will explore Emile Durkheim and Karl Marx's views on religion, it will attemptto compare and contrast some of these views held by each of the thinkers. This essay willalso argue which thinkers point of view is most appropriate in today's modern times andthe reasons for this.The four main topics for discussions, which are presented in this essay, will firstly startwith Durkheim's famous book "The elementary forms of the religious life

(Educating Rita Willy Russell) Russell Uses The Contrast Between Frank And Rita's Cultural Backgrounds To Make Both Comic And Serious Points. Which Of These Do You Find More Effective?

1293 words - 5 pages cultural differences between Frank and Rita are illustrated.Frank asks Rita her name in a manner which is natural for a Middle Class man,"You are?"Rita doesn't understand and returns,"What am I?"Even after Frank repeats the question Rita still doesn't understand,"I'm a what?"Presently, Rita shows us again how different her background is from Frank's. No respectable member of Middle Class Society would describe a religious nude painting as "erotic". Rita