Compare And Contrast The 1990 Gulf War To The 2003 Iraq Invasion. Did The Position Of Arab Regimes Differ?

2892 words - 12 pages

Compare and contrast the 1990 Gulf War to the 2003 Iraq invasion. Did the position of Arab regimes differ?The Gulf War in 1990 and the invasion of Iraq in 2003 both had a profound impact not just on the countries directly involved - primarily Iraq and the United States (US) - but also on the geo-politics of the world. Arguably, the War ended in a stalemate because the Iraqi regime that had started the War by invading Kuwait remained in power. Perhaps inevitably then, in March 2003 the US and its allies invaded Iraq with the stated aim of overthrowing the regime of Saddam Hussein and destroying that regime's Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMD). Some similarities between both Wars are immediately obvious: for example, the same country, the US, led both wars against the same country, Iraq. There are, however, significant differences between the Wars. Accordingly, this essay compares and contrasts some key aspects of the wars: their military aspects, the use and abuse of intelligence services, causes and outcomes, differences in media coverage, and the changing views of different Arab regimes. It argues that the military outcomes were very much the same and that western intelligence essentially continued to offer wrong advice and analyses; in contrast, the roles of the media diverged significantly between both wars as did the political outcomes and the views of Arab regimes. Overall, comparing and contrasting both Wars highlights their major impact on world politics and power, with their consequences playing a significant role in shaping today's contemporary world.MilitaryMilitarily, the Gulf War and the Iraq War have much in common. Both wars were fought by predominantly the same nations, with similar outcomes achieved. What distinguished these wars at was the acute asymmetry in fatalities with many thousands slaughter edon the Iraqi side, as opposed to minor death toll on the side of the coalition. The Persian Gulf War was undoubtedly one of the most swift and successful military operations in history. Coalition troops effortlessly crushed Saddam Hussein's armed forces. In the Gulf Conflict, "Iraqi troops numbered approximately 545,000 to 600,000." While this figure closely approximated the number of US military personnel, many of the Iraqi troops were young, under-resourced, and poorly trained conscripts. The one-sided nature of the conflict is best summarised in estimates of casualties: US Department of Defence reported that "U.S. forces suffered 148 battle-related deaths. Some estimate that Iraq sustained between 20,000 and 35,000 fatalities." In addition, "civilian fatalities were estimated at about 3,500 from bombings and some 100,000 from other effects of the war." Casualty figures on the US side in the Iraq war were very similar to those of the Gulf war: according to CNN, the US government reported "that 139 American military personnel were killed."For the US, the Iraq War was equally as effective as the first war in achieving its military...

Find Another Essay On Compare and contrast the 1990 Gulf War to the 2003 Iraq invasion. Did the position of Arab regimes differ?

How important was the emergence of civil society in Central and Eastern Europe in the early 1980s for the collapse of communist regimes in 1989? Compare and contrast the Polish and Romanian cases.

2967 words - 12 pages the strength of 'civil society' in these states and have used the notion as an interpretative tool in attempt to measure the democratic health of former communist states (Briton 2005: p. 1 ).However, not all states of the Soviet bloc had strong civil society and not everywhere democratization did go such peacefully as in Poland, Czechoslovakia and Hungary where situation was much more simple. On the other hand in countries such as Romania, Bulgaria

Compare and contrast the role that women played in both world war one and world war two. To what extent did women expand their role in society between the wars?

1299 words - 5 pages effort. Many of these feminists hoped that patriotic support of the war would enhance the prospects for women's suffrage after the war, and this came true in a number of countries.The more than 25,000 US women who served in Europe in World War I did so on an entrepreneurial basis, especially before 1917. They helped nurse the wounded, provide food and other supplies to the military, serve as telephone operators (the "Hello Girls"), entertain troops

Compare and contrast the style of commands of Ghengis Kahn and Napoleon. Incl. Strategy and Operations, and army organization. In what areas did they succeed over their contemporaries?

1175 words - 5 pages THIS WAS LIMITED TO A 1-2 PAGE ESSAY ANSWER (TIMED) FOR A MIDTERM EXAMQuestion:From your readings thus far compare and contrast the style of commands of Ghengis Kahn and Napoleon with specific reference to Strategy and Operations, and army organization. In what areas did they succeed over their contemporaries?My Answer:Almost 600 years separated the rise of Genghis Khan and Napoleon Bonaparte--The former finalizing his claim to power at the

Saddam, Iraq, And The Gulf War

2896 words - 12 pages . Saddam felt that linking the Israelis with his invasion of Kuwait would win the support of the Arabs. Most Arab nations, like Saudi Arabia and Egypt, dismissed this announcement.      On August 17, 1990, the Iraqis acted on their plans against the nation of Kuwait. US, British, and other foreign citizens were not allowed to leave Iraq or Kuwait. An Iraqi spokesperson said that they would “stay as long as Iraq remains

Compare, Contrast Systems: Windows XP, Windows 2000 Advance Sever, and Windows Server 2003

1538 words - 6 pages . Windows XP and windows 2003 are the effect of windows 2000 Advance Sever evolution. Furthermore, Windows 2000 Advanced Server evolved from windows Network Server 4. To list some improvements, Windows 2000 provides numerous added characteristics for corporations that needed more scalability and consistency. Windows 2000 Advanced Server is a network operating system program specially designed for ecommerce and is capable of handling the most

The Arab Gulf States

1042 words - 4 pages Arabian Gulf or the Persian Gulf: is the arm of the Arabian Sea, extending from Gulf of Oman in the south to along the Shatt-AL Arab in the north. Its length around 965 km from Shatt-Al Arab to the Hormuz fjord, which links it in the Gulf of Oman. The area of the Arabian Gulf approximately 233 100 km², and varies in width between a maximum of about 370 km to a minimum of 55 km in the Hormuz fjord. A maximum depth of the Arabian Gulf is 90 m. The

Was the 2003 war in Iraq justified and necessary?

11254 words - 45 pages agreed additional shipping, transportation and storage costs incurred as a result of diverting and delaying shipmentsThe 2003 Gulf war. After the Afghanistan war, president Bush made it clear that he had plans to attack Iraq. This led to a divide in the world. In the end it was at the centre of the debate, and probably gave Bush and Blair a lot of extra-unwanted pressure. After much debating and talking on 20th March 2003 at 02:34

The Iran-Iraq War: The Original Gulf War

1490 words - 6 pages Iraq has a long history of conflicts with its neighboring countries but none more notably than Iran. Iraq and Iran have had boarder disputes dating back to 1501 during the rule of the Persian Empire. More presently a standing feud has been raging over a 127 mile patch of land known as the Shatt al Arab River, a key point of real-estate due to its important oil shipping ports and access to the Persian Gulf. A treaty was signed in 1937 to settle

Media Coverage in the Vietnam War and the War on Iraq (2003)

890 words - 4 pages . In this essay, I shall compare the media coverage between the Vietnam War and Gulf War II. There are four areas to cover, which are the freedom of correspondents, embedding, the reliability and quality of the coverage. In the Vietnam War, the U.S. government gave war correspondents great freedom to move freely in combat zones, to report whatever they wanted and they didn't require any military vetting (Evans 2003). This freedom resulted a vast

The Bush Administration¹s Relation With Iraq Prior to Iraq¹s Invasion of Kuwait

4282 words - 17 pages the accumulation of close to 100,000 Iraqi troops onto Iraq¹s southern border with Kuwait.Summoned before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee to clarify her role in the Administration¹s relations with Iraq prior to August 2, 1990, Ambassador Glaspie offered her version of the events that led to the invasion. She recalled that Iraq had first and foremost just finished a long, drawn out war with its neighbor and nemesis, Iran. Hussein

Why Did The United States Go To War With Iraq?

1678 words - 7 pages In the recent war with Iraq Americans wants to really know why did the United States go to war with Iraq? There are several conclusions that people have come to. Some of the main reasons that the United States went to war with Iraq was because of the belief that Saddam Hussein was harboring terrorists in Iraq and that he had in his possession weapons of mass destruction whether they were nuclear or gas bombs the United States had no idea. When

Similar Essays

Why Did George.W Bush Win The War In Iraq In 2003

1514 words - 6 pages Aylin Kaplan 4272407 Why did George W. Bush decide to invade Iraq in 2003? Explain your answer.When we are asked the question of why did George W. Bush invade Iraq, we can think of multiple reason's. Some of the claim's for the invasion of Iraq were oil, to stop the war of terror, revenge for the event's of September 11 and Saddam Hussein generating weapon's of mass destruction (WMD). Of all of these claims, one main reason can be seen to why

Compare And Contrast International Attempts To Regulate Spam With The Spam Act 2003 (Cth)

1474 words - 6 pages Email, Australia) defines spam very broadly as any electronic mail message that is:a. transmitted to a large number of recipients; andb. not explicitly and knowingly requested by some or all of those recipients.6Despite the use in its title the Spam Act 2003 (Cth) (the Act), the term 'spam' is not defined. Instead the Act regulates 'unsolicited commercial electronic messages'.Spam Act 2003 (Cth)OverviewAs set out in the second reading speech, the

Compare And Contrast The Economic, Political, And Social Structures Of Ancient Athens To Modern Day Iraq To See If Democracy Can Work In Iraq

1152 words - 5 pages gone through many involuntary changes. From 1538 to 1914 Iraq was controlled by the Ottoman Empire. In 1914, the British took Iraq from the Ottoman Empire in World War I. During the war, the British had told the Iraqi people that they would have independence. Instead the League of Nations gave Iraq the status of a "mandate" territory. This enthralled the Iraqi people and a rebellion broke out in 1920. The British stopped the rebellion quickly. To

Compare And Contrast Two Theories Of Motivation Explaining How The Two Approaches May Differ And How They May Be Similar

1353 words - 5 pages The subject of motivation can be approached from a number of perspectives. Some theories approach motivation as coming from within a person (Drive Theory), whereas other theories approach motivation as coming from within the person (Incentive Theory). Compare and contrast two theories of motivation explaining how the two approaches may differ and how they may be similar. Does one theory seem to explain motivation better than the other? Support