Compare And Contrast The Style Of Commands Of Ghengis Kahn And Napoleon. Incl. Strategy And Operations, And Army Organization. In What Areas Did They Succeed Over Their Contemporaries?

1175 words - 5 pages

THIS WAS LIMITED TO A 1-2 PAGE ESSAY ANSWER (TIMED) FOR A MIDTERM EXAMQuestion:From your readings thus far compare and contrast the style of commands of Ghengis Kahn and Napoleon with specific reference to Strategy and Operations, and army organization. In what areas did they succeed over their contemporaries?My Answer:Almost 600 years separated the rise of Genghis Khan and Napoleon Bonaparte--The former finalizing his claim to power at the demise of the Kereit in 1203, and the latter excepting the lead role in the coup d'etat in 1799. When general, simplified principles are observed, one can already distinguish a common thread that linked the two great warriors. Amazingly, their common strategies were implied despite army organizations were anything but similar. The Mongolian Army was cavalry "pure," that is, the Mongolians fought from horseback and were masters at horsemanship and archery, and relied very little on (and not until after Genghis' successes) the augmentation of infantry forces from the subjugated territories. Napoleon, as was one of his many claims to fame, especially as his rise to power paralleled the rise in gunpowder-related panoplies of Europe, relied heavily on his own mastery of artillery (no less than nine of his maxims relate to the artillery or artillery officer roles). This is not meant to imply Genghis was ignorant of the siege and siege-weaponry of his era, but like, Napoleon, he chose to abstain from siege warfare whenever possible, and therefore, the reliance on a cavalry-pure army was upheld.Before discussing the strategic similarities of the two generals, the similarities in the army organization must be realized. As was mentioned above, the actual organization of the two armies was as different as two armies could possibly be: Mongolia's "Cav-Pure" and Napoleon's well organized combined-arms army with heavy reliance on the impact of artillery. However, there was one similarity that formed many of the strategies (and stratagems as they often were) their leaders would employ to ensure their successes: that is, both men were blessed with an infinite amount of drive, but with the minimum amount of manpower. Compared to his fellow European countries (save Britain) Napoleon's France was extremely outnumbered in actual field army strength, especially that of Russia, and the combined powers of Austria, Germany, and Belgium--and even more so in 1813 when the Allied countries massed their efforts to finally dethrone the King of Battle. Likewise, 600 years earlier, Genghis Khan, in blatant defiance of the Chin Dynasty, set out on a warpath that subjugated the peoples of Northern and Southwest Asia and Russia through the Urals and up to the Volga River--and he did so with an army of no more than 70-80,000 Mongolian Cavalrymen and an additional 40,000 (at most) auxiliary foot soldiers (Hartog 53). Given the great odds that both men faced during their pursuit of greatness, it is without wonder that both men relied heavily on...

Find Another Essay On Compare and contrast the style of commands of Ghengis Kahn and Napoleon. Incl. Strategy and Operations, and army organization. In what areas did they succeed over their contemporaries?

Compare and contrast Toyota and Volkswagen in terms of their international business strategies

1281 words - 5 pages always appeared that gaps remain between local employees and senior managers. And to be a local employee or a small junior & middle-manager, it is sometimes very hard to understand why the top management of the corporation would make such a decision, and they have to implement even they do not willing to do so. While, this kind of lack of understanding of management behavior, and even the displeasure is what impacts the executive function in

Compare the roles of the army, the church and the syndicates (or unions) in Spain and Portugal during their respective dictatorships

713 words - 3 pages solve their many problems. Not only they had no food and clothing, but also they had no benefits such as pensions. Although the aim of the trade unions is primaly to protect the workers, what they could actually do was very little because of the fear of the secret police.It was in the 60s and 70s that the trade unions did finally manage to react against the dictatorship without fear.In those years, 20,000 Astuarian miners went on strike, as the

Buddhism vs Catholicism. Describe the roles of Lama and Priests within their religions. Compare and contrast. Compare and contrast Buddhist and Catholic nuns.

716 words - 3 pages people within these two religions different are what their job actually requires them to do. Priests and Catholic nuns have a lot more freedom about where they can work & in what areas such as education or health. Buddhist nuns and Lamas have a strict timetable which they have to follow. Priests & Catholic nuns also have more possessions than Buddhist nuns and Lamas. The most important thing which can be learnt is that all these people have given up so much to help everyone else learn about God/Buddha and their dedication is what they share in common.

Compare and contrast the writing styles of William Byrd to William Bradford based on style, tone, and purpose.

872 words - 3 pages Writers are characterized by three factors. These factors are style, tone, and purpose. William Byrd and William Bradford were two colonial writers however they took completely opposite approaches toward writing. During these times, journals, diaries, and sermons made up the literature. Byrd and Bradford were no exceptions with their works of A History of the Dividing Line and Of Plymouth Plantation respectively. Whether it was the difference in

Compare and Contrast the natural and social sciences in their philosophy and approach to research

1072 words - 5 pages statements, following an objective , value-free observation of facts and through deduction , formulation of hypotheses and testing the scientific validity of the same, to measure and quantify evidence. In contrast , the social sciences such as sociology, history , anthropology seek to explain and interpret human behaviour , its actions and meanings attributed to these in the social world in order to produce normative statements, that translate

A compare and contrast of Ibsen and Strindberg and their view on women

843 words - 3 pages did Julie's mother to Julie's father. Jean knows that all women are conniving and are attempting to trap men into supporting them. Therefore, Ibsen and Strindberg concur that women are viewed not as people but as property. The conflict in opinion happens not in what these authors believe women are but what they think women should become Also they differ in how Ibsen and Strindberg believe society should reach to women.Strindberg believes that

Compare and contrast the role that women played in both world war one and world war two. To what extent did women expand their role in society between the wars?

1299 words - 5 pages effort. Many of these feminists hoped that patriotic support of the war would enhance the prospects for women's suffrage after the war, and this came true in a number of countries.The more than 25,000 US women who served in Europe in World War I did so on an entrepreneurial basis, especially before 1917. They helped nurse the wounded, provide food and other supplies to the military, serve as telephone operators (the "Hello Girls"), entertain troops

Compare and contrast the concepts of eudaimonia and happiness, and their respective roles in the ethical philosophies of Aristotle and Mill

2188 words - 9 pages In the Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle attempts to determine what the best life consists in, and demonstrate that all human action aims at eudaimonia. Mill's ethical philosophy is that actions are right if they promote the general amount of happiness, wrong if they decrease it. Their respective concepts, eudaimonia and happiness are similar in many ways, for example, they both embrace the idea of quality of happiness as well as quantity. There is

Compare And Contrast Britian And France Over Educational Practices

1281 words - 5 pages Compare and contrast Britain and France over educational practices The existence of mass education is a common feature of industrial societies. It is agreed by sociologists that the education system accepts some responsibility in preparing young people for the world of work. It is viewed as an institution where socialisation takes place, involving acquisition of knowledge and skills. It with or without intent also helps to shape beliefs and

Compare and contrast two theories of motivation explaining how the two approaches may differ and how they may be similar

1353 words - 5 pages The subject of motivation can be approached from a number of perspectives. Some theories approach motivation as coming from within a person (Drive Theory), whereas other theories approach motivation as coming from within the person (Incentive Theory). Compare and contrast two theories of motivation explaining how the two approaches may differ and how they may be similar. Does one theory seem to explain motivation better than the other? Support

Compare and contrast two of the following and examine what they reveal about the nature of human existence: Plato's "Allegory of the Cave" and "The World of the Matrix"

1642 words - 7 pages Firstly, we must understand what it means by human existence. It is what it means to be or become a human, to exist and emerge in this world. It consists of many things, like choice, freedom or maybe what defines us as humans.In the allegory of the cave, a group of people have lived in a deep cave since birth, and they have never seen sunlight or the outside world in their lifetime. They are bounded and could only see the shadows cast on the

Similar Essays

What Was The Grand Strategy Of The Roman Empire Before The 3rd Century Collapse? What Reforms Began And How Did They Change Roman Grand Strategy, Tactics, And Military Organization?

1006 words - 4 pages , in which supplies could be made available to the Roman army while they were denied to an attacking force, and they were invaluable to intelligence operations and emergency protection. However, as time passes, this new strategy of reliance on the mobile force took its toll upon the standard Roman militia: the infantryman. Because the majority of funding and training and recruitment efforts focused on the "elite" forces, and the traditional Roman

Compare And Contrast The Characters Of Malcolm And Banquo. To What Extent And In What Ways Are They Associated With Natural Order ?

863 words - 3 pages , intelligent and confident about what he has to do. We detect his political intelligence when he manipulates Macduff, testing his loyalty until Macduff declares that he (Malcolm) is not fit to be King at all. When they both receive the news of the massacre of Macduff's family, Malcolm encourages Macduff to allow his grief convert into anger against Macbeth, and in the end, Malcolm wins a loyal comrade in battle.Like most brave and generous-minded

Animal Farm By George Orwell, A Compare And Contrast Of Napoleon And Snowball.

1135 words - 5 pages careful thinking and use of time. Napoleon, however, had used his knowledge to write a fake letter said to be written by Snowball to have agreed to be a secret agent to the Foxwood Farm. Napoleon knew that the other animals could not read very well and so by making his letter, no one could prove the letter was false except for the pigs that knew very well what Napoleon did. In addition, both Napoleon and Snowball were the most active in the speeches

Why Did Contemporaries Engage In Such Fierce Debate Over The Impact Of Eighteenth Century Enclosure?

3383 words - 14 pages Why did contemporaries engage in such fierce debate over the impact of enclosure in eighteenth century England?The eighteenth century carried a number of problems including inflation, the effects of the French wars, the growth of industry and the demand for more food and this compelled farmers to use all available land in a more productive manor. The main obstacle to improvements in agriculture was thought to be the open field system of farming