This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Compare And Contrast The Human Relations School Of Thought With Taylorism.

2172 words - 9 pages

IntroductionSince the end of the 19th century, when factory manufacturing became widespread and the size of organisations increased, people have been looking for ways to motivate employees and improve productivity. This essay will focus on two of the earliest management approaches of Taylorism and the Human Relations School. First the central tenets of both models are outlined giving examples of how they are still applied in contemporary society. This is followed by a comparison of the two theories, which seem to be opposed at first glance, but are in fact similar in their basic approach. Finally, the relevance of both approaches for today's managers is evaluated by identifying the option to bring them together as a basis for an overall Human Resource strategy.TaylorismTaylorism is a management approach initiated by Frederick W. Taylor (1856-1915), an American engineer. Taylor was concerned with inefficiency in manufacturing operations, in particular with the phenomena of "loafing" and "systematic soldiering", i. e. the collusion of workers to restrict their output. He believed that the way to achieve higher efficiency would follow from detailed control of the work process by management and the decomposition of work into routine and predictable tasks .Taylor introduced some basic principles to serve managers as a guideline. Firstly, the use of scientific methods to determine the one best way of doing a particular task . This is also known as the school of Scientific Management which argues that business decisions should be taken on the basis of fact and scientific principles, e. g. time and task study, instead of guesswork. Secondly, the systematic selection of the person with the most appropriate qualities to do the specified job and continuous training of the worker in the most efficient techniques . Thirdly, a clear functional division between management, which plans and organises the work, and workers, who execute the tasks following detailed instructions . Hence, there is a "purely instrumental and low-involvement employment relationship" with the absence of mutual obligations between the two parties other than the exchange of pay for performance . Finally, the provision of financial incentives, usually in the form of piece-rate plans, which reflects Taylor's theory of the economic man, a concept that assumes that workers are motivated solely through monetary rewards. Consequently, the basic motivational assumption of Taylorism was that work is inherently distasteful to most people, but they would tolerate it if pay was decent .The application of Taylorism has been criticized for degrading individuals to become machinelike and discouraging innovation. Nevertheless, Taylor's ideas are still widely applied in contemporary society as they caused enormous increases in productivity. Even though often termed differently, many current management tools and techniques are only modernized versions of Taylorism applying the same basic principles....

Find Another Essay On Compare and contrast the Human Relations School of thought with Taylorism.

Compare and contrast essay using "The Sanctuary of School," by Lynda Barry and "'I Just Wanna Be Average,'" by Mike Rose

1056 words - 4 pages Reaching OutThe two essays, "The Sanctuary of School," by Lynda Barry and "'I Just Wanna Be Average,'" by Mike Rose, are two essays concerned with children and the way a school system affects a child's life. Barry and Rose use situations in their own life to help readers understand their point of view. The responsibility of parents, the assertiveness of their teachers, and the way they used their unique situations to help solve problems in our

Compare and contrast two of the following and examine what they reveal about the nature of human existence: Plato's "Allegory of the Cave" and "The World of the Matrix"

1642 words - 7 pages highest stage of cognition “understanding”. The experience of this prisoner is a metaphor for the process by which rare human beings free themselves from the world of appearances and, with the help of philosophy, perceive the world truly. Fully aware of true reality, he must return to the cave and try to teach others what he knows.In the World of the Matrix, the main character is Thomas Anderson, an employee of a respectable software

Compare and Contrast Human nature in Prelude and Don Juan. Woodsworth and Byron

1214 words - 5 pages Compare and contrast William Wordsworth's and Lord Byron's views of human nature revealed in their poetry. In what sense can these views be considered 'Romantic'? Support your analysis with illustrations from The Prelude and Don Juan.INTROThe 19th Century, it is well known as the Romantic period in English Literature. ciety. This unbridled passion in Romantic poets led to literature that depicted emotional matter in an imaginative form, with

Compare and Contrast the structure of "Waiting for Godot" with the structure of any traditional play

962 words - 4 pages universe is void - nothing to believe in but nothingness. There is no moral ethical code. There are just people existing, being only for themselves, and sometimes by themselves. (Gordon, 2002)"Waiting for Godot", is part of the Theatre of the Absurd. This implies that it is meant to be irrational. Absurd theatre does away with the concepts of drama, chronological plot, logical language, themes, and recognizable settings. There is also a split

Compare and Contrast the Poetry of James Berry and John Betjeman, with

1295 words - 5 pages Compare and Contrast the Poetry of James Berry and John Betjeman, with particular reference to the Cultural Differences. Refer to at Least two Poems by each Poet James Berry's poems are written from the perspective of a lady named Lucy. Lucy moved to England because she had heard the streets were practically paved with gold there. She writes letters to her friend Leela in the form of poems. Lucy regrets her move to England in a lot of

Compare and contrast Roman Catholics and Protestants with brief history of the two

647 words - 3 pages more fights between the similar fish than the very different fish, and what are those two inparticularly?" All I do is smirk and hand you an essay that sounds allot like the following.Since christianity was born, there have been two main sects, the roman catholic church and the protestant church. These two have a long history with each other going back to the time of Abraham. What's odd is that even though they have so much in common, it was

Compare and contrast the Psycoanalitic Theory with the Behaviorist Theory

1722 words - 7 pages Compare and contrast two psychological approachesBy Rory SimmonsMy intention in this essay, is to compare and contrast the following psychological approaches Behaviourism and Psychoanalysis, in doing this I will unpack the key points of these two approaches, highlighting the differences and explaining them.The first approach I will look at is Psychoanalysis; the most famous psychologist linked to this is Sigmund Freud an Austrian psychologist

Compare and contrast Steinbeck's novel "The Grapes of Wrath" with the Exodus story

1265 words - 5 pages aspects of the two stories coincide with one another. There are five main ones that can be found throughout the story: a child's float down a river, slavery, the reason for leaving, the length of the journey, and the destination.The origin of Moses is probably one of the most well known stories from the Old Testament, besides that of Adam and Eve. Moses was born a poor Hebrew slave, but shortly after his birth Pharaoh orders all male Hebrew children

COMPARE AND CONTRAST BOURDIEU'S APPROACH TO THE AGENCY/STRUCTURE DICHOTOMY WITH THAT OF GIDDENS

2876 words - 12 pages COMPARE AND CONTRAST BOURDIEU'S APPROACHTO THE AGENCY/STRUCTURE DICHOTOMYWITH THAT OF GIDDENSIn recent years, several authors have attempted to deal with the problem of the relationship between agency and social structure. This has manifested itself in the theory of structuration. Anthony Giddens' structuration theory is one of the best-known and most articulated efforts to integrate agency and structure. His theory proposes a duality of

Compare and Contrast of the Od

1187 words - 5 pages , instead of coming on his own, and that Tiresias attempted to hide the truth from Oedipus, shows that Tiresias was trying to protect Oedipus. He knew it would cause Oedipus harm in the end. Tiresias' differing attitudes in the works serves as a parallel to how the truth told in general. Truth that brings hope to people is normally easily given, but truth that brings sadness or despair is generally told with caution and reluctance. The

Compare and contrast of the od

1187 words - 5 pages , instead of coming on his own, and that Tiresias attempted to hide the truth from Oedipus, shows that Tiresias was trying to protect Oedipus. He knew it would cause Oedipus harm in the end. Tiresias' differing attitudes in the works serves as a parallel to how the truth told in general. Truth that brings hope to people is normally easily given, but truth that brings sadness or despair is generally told with caution and reluctance. The

Similar Essays

Taylorism And Human Relations School Of Thought

2202 words - 9 pages relations school of thought. In this stage, theory built up with the diffusing of labour movement in capitalism countries.This essay will focus on two of the earliest management approaches of Taylorism (scientific management ) and the Human Relations School of thought. First the writer would like to compare and contrast of the two theories. This is followed by the central tenets of both models and finally giving examples of how they are still applied

Compare And Contrast High School Versus College

698 words - 3 pages silent crowd.      With so many students and so many faces in each class, college professors don’t personally get to know their students. A professor wouldn’t even notice if a student didn’t attend class one day, or if that person was taking that class at all. In big classes, the professor won’t even know a students’ name by the last day of class. In high school, teachers get to know their students on a first and last

Compare And Contrast High School Versus College

957 words - 4 pages All throughout high school I’ve sat and listened to a countless number of teachers throw information in my face. Whether it be a new concept in math or a description of how to properly play kickball in gym. With all the years of hearing lecture after lecture, I cannot believe why I decided to come to college. I have signed and paid to have trained professionals throw more material in my face. One of the biggest difference between high school and

Compare And Contrast High School Versus College

1238 words - 5 pages with the process of studying material and applying it, a mundane process enforced throughout each grade. Finally, class instruction amongst most teachers involves, “Instructor Annoyance.” These are small student actions, which irritate teachers and professors. Ironically, the same agents in high school are seemingly the same in college. Some students choose to get up and leave class to socialize with friends or stop in the bathroom to take an