Compare And Contrast The Ideologies Of Nationalism And Unionism In Northern Ireland Politics.

2574 words - 10 pages

The ideologies of Nationalism and Unionism in Northern Irish politics have generated almost all of the conflict and violence that has risen out of the troubled nation over the last century. The ideas advocated by the two ideologies find themselves at great conflict with one another; Unionists support the inclusion of Northern Ireland as part of the UK while Nationalists argue for an independent unified Ireland. The fact that the two ideologies coincide with opposing religious thought greatly exacerbates the conflict. Rather than concentrating on a specific time period, this essay will give a general overview of the ideologies in order to demonstrate the way in which they have evolved since their emergence, as well as a discussion of the ideologies of the political parties and organisations involved with both Nationalism and Unionism.Irish Nationalists oppose the division of Ireland and want to see Northern Ireland become part of the Irish Republic. An overwhelmingly Catholic movement, Nationalists are the minority in Northern Ireland. They often feel disadvantaged and believe themselves to be the subjects of political, psychological and economic discrimination (Connolly 2004:online). Nationalists have often resorted to violence as a means of achieving their ambitions through such groups as the Irish Republican Army (IRA) and the Irish Volunteers, although other Nationalist groups such as the Social Democratic and Labour Party (SDLP) are very much against this approach, opting for politics as a means of change. Irish Nationalism has been interpreted both as a resistance to the British and as an 'ideological cover for Catholic supremacism and anti-Protestantism' (Ruane & Todd 1998:55).In the 1880's Ireland saw the emergence of the movement for Catholic emancipation; if viewed from within its religious context, the movement could be interpreted as first stirrings of Nationalism. The Nationalist movement prior to this was not based so much on religion; it was only after the time of O'Connell in the mid 19th century that Nationalist ideology adopted a religious outlook (Archer 2004:Tape 160). The real emergence of Nationalism as a potent force was the Easter Rising of 1916. This event saw an angry rebellion from the Nationalists in an attempt to claim Ireland from the British as an independent nation. Soon afterwards, however, Northern Ireland was partitioned and only the South could call itself a republic; Northern Ireland fell under British jurisdiction. Irish Nationalists in both the North and South refused to accept this and Nationalism became about reunification.Nationalism called for an ideological change after the violent insurrections achieved nothing but to martyrise the 1916 leaders and create an aggressive agenda of armed struggle in the years to come. Many still wanted violent revolution, while the more moderate leaders such as Arthur Griffith contemplated the idea of monarchy (Archer 2004:Tape 162). Nationalist leader John Redmond was...

Find Another Essay On Compare and contrast the ideologies of Nationalism and Unionism in Northern Ireland politics.

The Short and Long Term Effects of the Hunger-Strikes in Northern Ireland

3149 words - 13 pages The Short and Long Term Effects of the Hunger-Strikes in Northern Ireland The hunger-strikes of 1980 and 1981 had highly significant consequences for Northern Ireland nationally and internationally. While at first they polarised the community, they eventually led to the beginnings of peace in Northern Ireland. Soon after Direct Rule was introduced in Northern Ireland in March 1972 Westminster created a new department

Community Care of the Elderly in Northern Ireland and Great Britain

2311 words - 9 pages the identified barriers and then propose a solution towards the improvement of them.The first barrier to be discussed is not a common one it will more than likely only be identified through clients that it has affected. It is the barrier concerning older people who wish to move location in and out of Northern Ireland. For example if an older service user wishes to move to Great Britain to be nearer relatives, or indeed back to Northern Ireland to

Northern Ireland and Peace Process

1482 words - 6 pages Northern Ireland & Peace Process The origins of the Northern Ireland peace process can be traced back to the agreement generally known as the Anglo-Irish Agreement, which was signed in 1985 between the British and Irish governments. According to this agreement, the United Kingdom accepted the condition that the constitutional status of Northern Ireland in the United Kingdom will not be changed without the approval of the majority of Irish

The Conflict in Northern Ireland

4472 words - 18 pages The Conflict in Northern Ireland The conflict in Northern Ireland is in many ways a paradox. The region has adequate resources and, although it has been a rather marginal area of the British Isles, is nonetheless quite affluent compared to most of the rest of the world. The people are invariably described as friendly and hospitable and to outsiders they seem to form a homogeneous community. The United Kingdom, of which Northern Ireland

The Conflict of Northern Ireland

1976 words - 8 pages unionists with the exception of the Dup (who are led by Ian Paisley and are strongly opposed to any form of compromise.) were in favour of the agreement. The Good Friday Agreement was a watershed in the politics of Northern Ireland an agreement that many doubted would ever be possible but even though the agreement has been agreed and signed implementation has proved to be an altogether different task and has been met

The Problems of Northern Ireland

2867 words - 11 pages The Problems of Northern Ireland Northern Ireland is part of Ireland which is the most western part in Europe. It is a small place with a population of 1.5 million and is no larger than Yorkshire. It has been the centre of media attention because of a conflict between the people of the province. Many people have been killed there and in the years 1968-1994 over three thousand died. Northern Ireland is ruled by the

The History of Northern Ireland

2712 words - 11 pages The History of Northern Ireland Northern Ireland has had a volatile and tortured history. In 1969 began the conflict, which today is known as "The Troubles", but Northern Ireland's troubled history roots back to a much earlier period of time. The seeds of partition were really sown in the mid 19th century when the notion of two separate nations took root in Ireland. The Young Ireland movement of the 1840's

Nationalism in Quebec and Canadian Politics

2341 words - 9 pages During the twentieth century, Canada as a nation witnessed and endured several historical events that have had a deep and profound influence on Canadian politics. The most influential and constant force in twentieth century Canadian politics has been the increasing power and command of Quebec nationalism and the influence it has had on Canadian politics today. Quebec nationalism has shaped the structure and dynamics of Canadian federalism from

In the Time of the Butterflies compare and contrast essay

818 words - 3 pages PAGE In the Time of the Butterflies EssayPolitical oppression can destroy not only a family's sense of independence and success but also a country's sense of independence and success. Unique strengths can be developed and can bring out the best and the worst of an individual amongst difficult and challenging times. Alvarez's organization and development of the historical fiction helps us better understand the Mirabel family's involvement in

Economy, Finance, Industry and Trade in Northern Ireland

966 words - 4 pages Northern Economy, Finance, Industry and Trade*Ireland is currently enjoying a period of economic growth, with output and employment rising and unemployment falling.*Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is defined as the sum of all incomes earned from productive activity. GDP per head is taken to be a good indication of a region's relative prosperity and since 1989, GDP per head in Northern Ireland increased almost by 58%. This compares with a 49.9

The Northern Ireland Troubles: Background, Development and Peace Process

936 words - 4 pages The United Kingdom of today, as know, encompasses the main and biggest British isle located in the Atlantic Ocean, comprised by the countries of Wales, England and Scotland. However, there is one more country that’s currently being counted as being a part of the United Kingdom as a whole – Northern Ireland, occupying a part of the north on the island Ireland. When an invasion from the United Kingdom resulted in the latter seizing control of

Similar Essays

Politics In Northern Ireland Essay

1074 words - 4 pages walked through the Catholic town I was staying in with marching bands playing offensive songs to the people of the town.With this experience, it has made me look at politics from more of a pessimist~{!/~}s perspective. Although, I do think that all problems in the world rather it is political, economic, or social, can be managed. This particular case in Northern Ireland widely reflects some of the theories and ideas discussed in class.Ireland can

"The Ulster Unionist Party Was Primarily Responsible For The Development Of Sectarian Politics In Northern Ireland Between 1921 And 1972". Do You Agree?

2857 words - 11 pages "The Ulster Unionist Party was primarily responsible for the development of sectarian politics in Northern Ireland between 1921 and 1972". Do you agree?The Government of Ireland Act 1920 paved way for the partition of Ireland. Partition of Ireland would in view of the Westminster government prevent civil war between Catholic Nationalists and Protestant Unionists. The Nationalists made it clear they sought independence from Britain having lobbied

Compare And Contrast Northern Colonies With Southern Colonies

904 words - 4 pages homage to Edgar Allan Poe, leaving behind a half-filled bottle of cognac and three red roses at the writer's grave. FindingDulcinea remembers the short, tragic life and many works of this doyen of the macabre.Edgar Allen Poe's Early Days Edgar Poe was born in Boston on January 19, 1809, and led a life defined by poverty, illness and addiction. Following the death of his parents, Poe was raised as a foster child in Virginia by John Allan, a

Ancient Ireland Through Different Eyes: Review The Book "How The Irish Saved Civilization" By Thomas Cahill And The Film "In Search Of Ancient Ireland" And Compare And Contrast The Two.

1519 words - 6 pages The film "In Search of Ancient Ireland" and the book by Thomas Cahill titled "How the Irish Saved Civilization" are two fascinating sources of information on early Irish history. They each discuss the role of religion in ancient Ireland, as well as the invasions of the Vikings. Although each examine the same issues, both sources present slightly different views, one being somewhat more biased, and the other a more objective portrayal, on