This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Compare And Contrast The Psycoanalitic Theory With The Behaviorist Theory

1722 words - 7 pages

Compare and contrast two psychological approachesBy Rory SimmonsMy intention in this essay, is to compare and contrast the following psychological approaches Behaviourism and Psychoanalysis, in doing this I will unpack the key points of these two approaches, highlighting the differences and explaining them.The first approach I will look at is Psychoanalysis; the most famous psychologist linked to this is Sigmund Freud an Austrian psychologist who first proposed his Psychodynamic approach. These perspectives states, that there are three main sections to the human psyche. The first is the "ID" this is the natural drive, which seeks gratification constantly, the second is the "EGO" this is our personal set of values developed as children, and finally the "SUPEREGO" a set of learned values, taken from society and our parents rules and values. Also he believed that as children we all go through five stages oral, anal, phallic, genital, and latency. If the child is either under or over gratified in any one of the stages then they will have problems in adulthood.Another element of Freud's theories was his studies of dreams; Freud believed that dreams acted as a form of fantasy, a defence mechanism against the unacceptable urges of the id. Fantasy allows the individual to act out events in the imagination, which can satiate the urges of the id, which are repressed. Freud theorized that dreams were a subconscious manifestation of these repressed urges, and that they served mainly to satisfy sexual and aggressive tendenciesThe other theory I will refer to is Behaviourism; this is an approach, which states that all psychology must be directly measurable and recordable, if it is to be regarded as scientific. In his 1924 book Behaviourism, Watson made the notorious claim that, given a dozen healthy infants; he could determine the adult personalities of each one, "regardless of his talents, penchants, tendencies, abilities, vocations and the race of his ancestors." While making such a claim seems ridiculous today, at the time Watson was reacting to emerging Freudian psychoanalytical theories of development, which many people found threatening. Watson's scheme rejected the entire hidden, unconscious, and suppressed longings that Freudians attributed to behaviours and posited that humans respond to punishments and rewards. Behaviour that creates positive responses is reinforced and continued, while behaviour that creates negative responses is eliminated.After both of these psychologists came other expanding on their theories, psychologists like Pavlov and Skinner expanded Watson's theories and Psychologists like Jung and Adler expanded Freud's.An important component of many psychological theories in the late nineteenth century, including psychoanalysis was "introspection", the study of the mind by analysis of one's own thought processes. It was in reaction to this trend that behaviourism arose, claiming that the causes of behaviour were not founded in the mind,...

Find Another Essay On Compare and contrast the Psycoanalitic Theory with the Behaviorist Theory

Compare and contrast these theories: SMCR, Inoculation Theory, The Boomerang effect, and Rank’s Model of Persuasion. Identify the strengths and

737 words - 3 pages Research studies suggest theories such as the SMCR model, Ranks theory and inoculation theory are effective models of persuasion. In addition, they determined the boomerang effect to be a unique theory of persuasion in which the communication efforts result in goal opposites (Woodard et al., 2013, p. 144). In comparison, the communication outcomes of the SMCR and Ranks theories goal oriented. The SMCR model consists of four uncomplicated key

Compare and contrast Parmenides' and Plato's different views of reality. Which theory do you find the most convincing?

733 words - 3 pages Parmenides and Plato were both concerned with ontology (from the Greek 'onta' or being) and questioned the nature of the "real". They both concluded that the world around is a dream or an illusion and that the senses, as opposed to reason, cannot aid us in our quest for truth.Parmenides was the first of the ancient philosophers to make use of deductive argument and he did this in order to underline the dichotomy between what was commonly

Social Contrast Theory

1844 words - 7 pages whereby, according to differing versions of the Social Contract theory, individuals were either happy or oppressed within it. Thus, individuals by using their natural reason ultimately sought refuge under a “unitary authority” to rule them, while consenting/surrendering to it some of their liberties with the objective of protecting their remaining rights/liberties; by doing so societies were to be formed with “political/social” order. However, despite

Compare and contrast knowing a friend to knowing how to swim, knowing a scientific theory and knowing a historical period. What conclusions about the nature of knowledge can you reach?

1423 words - 6 pages We can compare many things and people only by each quality. Contrasting them with their qualities will be at the same time easy and hard. Comparing a friend with something that is not alive, like knowing how to swim are two different things. A friend for example is a human being as everybody, who will help you anytime you want, give you support, understand and love you. According to Jane Sequichie Hifler, "In every man there is something wherein

Comparison and Contrast on Theory XY and Z

882 words - 4 pages Comparison and Contrast on Theory XY and ZDouglas McGregor suggested that there are two different ways in which we can look at workers attitudes toward work. Each of these views, which McGregor called Theory X and Theory Y, has implications for management.Theory X ('authoritarian management' style)-People do not really like to work and will avoid it if at all possible so they must be coerced, controlled, directed, threatened with punishment to

Motivation at Hitachi Automotive Products - MGT 331: Organizational Behavior - discuss motivational processes organization and compare with Alderfer's ERG Theory

1658 words - 7 pages opportunity to learn and provide input into projects that affect the actual motivation process at Hitachi. Team members come away from the committee meetings with a feeling of having accomplished a goal that benefits the company as a whole.GrowthThrough the various employee development programs at Hitachi, the growth portion of the ERG theory is fulfilled. The tuition assistance program allows team members to attend classes outside of work with the

Compare Darwin's Theory of Evolution to Lamarck's Theory of Evolution

614 words - 2 pages to having longer legs and a longer neck. According to Lamarck's theory, during a bad season when all the vegetation in lower areas (easily reachable by the giraffe with the shorter neck and legs) had gone, the giraffes were forced to stretch their necks, to reach for food on a higher level. These giraffes would then have longer necks and would pass this trait of having a longer neck to their offspring. Lamarck's theory then states that over time

The Behaviorist and Cognitive Approaches to Psychology

1422 words - 6 pages The Behaviorist and Cognitive Approaches to Psychology In this essay I am going to explore two of the major approaches to Psychology, Cognitive theories and Behaviorist theories. I will discuss in some detail the two approaches, state how they compare and illustrate the similarities and the differences between them. John Watson, one of the founders of Behaviorism, based his theories on the principles of learning

Compare and Contrast "Frankenstein" and "The Dead"

1122 words - 4 pages Compare and Contrast "Frankenstein" and "The Dead"Reading contemporary novels and stories has been one of my passions since childhood. Throughout the years, I have changed the genre considerably, yet never ventured into classical authors until this semester. Unlike the contemporary books I've read, these classical works demand much more reader participation and involvement. Two examples of such demands of their readers can be found in Mary

Compare and Contrast: China and The USA

1145 words - 5 pages There are many different pros and cons in life. Regardless of what someone is trying to compare. It is very interest when doing research on new country that an individual does not know much about that particular topic. What are the most important qualities in a country that help us function as a society. They are economic growth, strong structural system with government so the people can have a leader to follow in the right path. The very first

Compare and contrast Steinbeck's novel "The Grapes of Wrath" with the Exodus story

1265 words - 5 pages aspects of the two stories coincide with one another. There are five main ones that can be found throughout the story: a child's float down a river, slavery, the reason for leaving, the length of the journey, and the destination.The origin of Moses is probably one of the most well known stories from the Old Testament, besides that of Adam and Eve. Moses was born a poor Hebrew slave, but shortly after his birth Pharaoh orders all male Hebrew children

Similar Essays

Behaviorist Theory Essay

1213 words - 5 pages students to success in their education. Lesson Plan Teacher: Mrs. Parfinski Title: Behaviorist Theory in First Grade Subject: Psychology Grade Level: 8th Objectives: To find if operant conditioning, in the way of positive reinforcement, works on first grade students. Materials Needed: First grade student, paper, pencil, and rewards. Brief Description: Come up with an unpleasant behavior most first grade students have. Then come up with

Behaviorist Theory Essay

1293 words - 6 pages volunteer to complete bell work problems on the whiteboard. Sometimes he gets the answers right, and when he gets them wrong he just shrugs it off. His talking in class is disruptive and sometimes he misses vital lesson material and prevents others from hearing the message as well. Review of Theory Theodore’s behavior problems could best be explained by reviewing two behaviorist theories; those of Guthrie and Skinner. Guthrie would see Theodore’s

Compare And Contrast One Process Theory Of Motivation With One Content Theory. Include In Your Answer A Brief Explanation Why One Is A Process And The Other A Content Theory

1965 words - 8 pages BH1107 731676 Compare and contrast one process theory of motivation with one content theory. Include in your answer a brief explanation why one is a process and the other a content theory.Motivation is great part of today's management. However, "most organizations don't give it much thought until something starts to go wrong. Pain gets people's attention." (Sanjeev Sharma) Therefore it is important to motivate because motivation is force behind

Biological Theory Vs. Behaviorist Theory In Aggression

1371 words - 5 pages Biological Theory vs. Behaviorist Theory in Aggression Aggression is a problem that affects all members of society. There is no doubt that aggression pays off for some. Parents who yell and threaten punishment get results. The child who hits the hardest gets the toy. The brother who is willing to be the most vicious in a fight wins. The teacher who gives the hardest test and threatens to flunk