This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Compare And Contrast The View That ‘An Arrest’ Is A Tale Of Nature

1422 words - 6 pages

Compare and contrast the view that An Arrest is a tale of nature
rejecting a human villain with the view that it is concerned only with
a vengeful superego

‘An Arrest’ is an ambiguous story. You can look at it in different
ways. One way to see it is as a tale of nature rejecting a human
villain. This view is put forward right from the beginning. When the
narrator uses words such as “confined” and “fugitive” to describe the
state of Orrin Brower, he creates the image of an animal isolated from
human society. This is because ‘confined’ is usually a word to do with
animals or mad people who are not allowed to be in contact with humans
Further evidence to support the argument of Orrin Brower being
portrayed as a savage beast comes when the author writes that he had,
“recovered liberty,” which is like an animal being released into the
wild. Orrin Brower does not feel guilty for beating Burton Duff or
think of the consequences of his actions, as a human would; he only
feels and acknowledges his freedom which is an animal-like thing to
do. When he is on the run he decides to escape to the forest which may
be as he is treated like an animal he starts to believe that he is
one. The fact that the narrator states ‘he had the folly to enter a
forest’ suggests that even though he thinks of himself as an animal,
Brower is not and therefore does not belong in the forest- this proves
that nature will inevitably try to discard him. As he enters the
forest, we are told that ‘the night was pretty dark with neither moon
nor stars visible’ which could be seen as a nature trying to confuse
Brower. We begin to doubt Brower’s animal-like image when Bierce
writes, “Brower had never dwelt thereabout, and knew nothing of the
lay of the land” as, being portrayed an animal, he should be home in
the wild. This idea builds up as he is, “naturally, not long in losing
himself,” which shows that he is a human as he gets lost naturally as
any human would in a forest where they do not belong. This shows that
despite how he has been treated and what he believes, Brower is still
human.

The reader is pulled up short by the adverb ‘suddenly’; we become
aware that the ‘road’ represents man’s intrusion into nature; it is a
turning point in the story. Here, Brower meets a strange figure;
‘there before him saw, indistinctly the figure of a man, in the gloom’
which, because of the description Bierce uses, makes it hard for the
reader to picture him- suggesting that the figure is less than a real
person. The narrator says that “the two stood there like trees,” which
is ironic as they are the complete opposite; they are not things which
blend in with the forest, such as trees, they stand out as they do not
belong there. This also suggests that the figure is more a part of
nature than Brower as it is ‘indistinct’- it blends in with the trees
rather than standing out. We know that the stranger is possibly not
human as Bierce writes “The emotions...

Find Another Essay On Compare and contrast the view that ‘An Arrest’ is a tale of nature

Introduction to Philosophy: This essay is about my philosophy of human nature and a comparison and contrast with Karl Marx's view of human nature. Essay includes resources

1650 words - 7 pages us, he loves us and judges whether we are condemned to hell or resurrected to heaven considering what sins we have committed.The philosopher I will compare and contrast with is Karl Marx, because he has many different as well as some of the same thoughts of human nature as I do. Marx was an atheist, and in the general trend of his thought was materialist and determinist. As a would-be social scientist, he proposed to explain all human phenomenon

A compare and contrast of Ibsen and Strindberg and their view on women

843 words - 3 pages more rights.In a look from the future to the past, most people tend to believe that Ibsen was correct and Strindberg was wrong in their feelings about women but not all people. It could be that most people are simply biased on behalf of Ibsen because of the way society is transformed to today. The liberation of women has changed the way society reacts towards the issues regarding the treatment of women. Today society appears to still be undecided the same issues of whether women are being treated fairly. This may be an ongoing controversy until the end of time.

Compare and Contrast the way nature is represented in Percy Bysshe Shelley's Mont Blanc and lines 452-542 from Book six of The Prelude by William Wordsworth

1666 words - 7 pages ) that credit a greater design with its creation.The beginning of the fourth stanza from lines 84 to 95 are concerned not with Mont Blanc itself but the cyclic nature of life and death. This whole section is one long sentence, filled with lists 'the fields, the lakes, the forests and the streams' (l84), uses of the words 'and' 'that, and an ever increasing intensity caused by the language. We move from 'forests' to 'rain' then 'fiery flood and

Compare and Contrast of "The Goose Girl" by the Grimm Brothers and "The Tell-Tale Heart" by Edgar Allan Poe

1860 words - 8 pages Tell-Tale Heart” short story is about the narrator taking care of an old man who can no longer take care of himself. He became obsessed with the old mans eye and would sneak into his room at night to watch his eye and watch the old man sleep. He had nothing against the old man; he was always nice and friendly. The only thing that bothered him was his eye and how it was “a dull blue, with a hideous veil over it that chilled the very marrow in [his

Compare and contrast the presentation of oppressionin I Am Not That

1217 words - 5 pages South America but she has overcome this and thinks of herself as superior to the white racists. I will begin by discussing 'I Am Not That Woman'. The main theme to the poem is set in the Asian society, Eastern culture. Although there is a new theme introduced in every verse, they all add to the main theme of oppression. The woman is in the situation of being forced into having an arranged marriage and not having any freedom because of it

COMPARE AND CONTRAST BOURDIEU'S APPROACH TO THE AGENCY/STRUCTURE DICHOTOMY WITH THAT OF GIDDENS

2876 words - 12 pages COMPARE AND CONTRAST BOURDIEU'S APPROACHTO THE AGENCY/STRUCTURE DICHOTOMYWITH THAT OF GIDDENSIn recent years, several authors have attempted to deal with the problem of the relationship between agency and social structure. This has manifested itself in the theory of structuration. Anthony Giddens' structuration theory is one of the best-known and most articulated efforts to integrate agency and structure. His theory proposes a duality of

Knights Tale, Compare And Contrast Movie And Book

413 words - 2 pages that is almost similar to sword fighting, which is called ¡§Fencing.¡¨ This is where the rules are almost similar but you fight in different motions. We also have games that use guns also, but they also hurt a lot, this game is called ¡§paint ball.¡¨ Where you try to hunt down your opponent and shoot him before he shoots you with his paint balls.The time periods are different, since the book and the movie

compare and contrast the relationship between man and nature in Emerson and Thoreau

1280 words - 5 pages realities only, and not allow themselves to be deluded, life, to compare it with such things as we know, would be a fairy tale.” Through these lines, he emphasizes on reality in being more essential in exposing the truth and meaning of life. Possibly the most important contrast between the ideologies of Thoreau and Emerson are their arguments and the basis of their arguments. Both of the excerpts are evidently encouraging the people to return to a nature

Compare and contrast the relationship between Man and nature in Emerson and Thoreau

907 words - 4 pages Man and Nature were always linked together right from the beginning of time. Men depend for their livelihood on nature and this is why people give a lot of importance to nature ultimately leading to the protection of nature by men. The common understanding of men is that they protect nature but on the other hand nature also shapes the life of man so man and nature stands at an equal position. Ralph Waldo Emerson born on 25th May, 1803 and died

Compare and Contrast the Relationship between Man and Nature in Emerson and Thoreau

1568 words - 6 pages The relationship between man and nature is immeasurable because man and nature are interdependent on each other. Nature is everything that supports life on earth and man enjoys the beauty of nature. Ralph Waldo Emerson was born in 1803 in Boston and he was teacher by profession and also a naturalist (Semihatopal, n.d). Henry David Thoreau was born in Concord in July 12th 1817 and he was an ecological prophet and also naturalist who was the

Compare and contrast the relationship between man and nature in Emerson and Thoreau?

709 words - 3 pages , artist, as it offer a unified vision and inspired the man towards his work for such as the poet, artist musician, architect, and so on. And it conveys a sense of well-being and of communion with the universe by its natural beauty. Emerson further states that “The nature and the spiritual element in man works together to provide human a noble character and behavior of moral and heroic human deeds. There is a particular resemblance between the

Similar Essays

Describe The Nature Of A Totalitarian Regime, And Compare And Contrast Hitler's Nazi Regime With That Of Stalin In Communist Russia

3998 words - 16 pages In order to accurately compare and contrast Hitler and Nazi Germany with that of Stalinist Russia it is important that we first discuss and fully understand the nature of the totalitarian regime. This will be achieved through an illustration of each separate entity of the totalitarianism system of state bureaucracy; economy management; legislature and the executive. The restriction placed upon civil society achieved through established social

Compare And Contrast The Ways In Which The Domination Of Women Characters Is Presented By The Writers Of 'a View From The Bridge' And 'a Streetcar

679 words - 3 pages a daily life of the characters. Unlike Alfieri in A View from the Bridge, A Streetcar Named Desire has no narrator and mostly focuses on the characters to establish Williams’ point of view. Perhaps, the most iconic aspect of Williams is that he creates the minor characters in such a way that they all have an effect on Blanche in some shape or form. For instance, the Vendor says: ‘Red hots! Red hots!’ Blanche then ‘utters a sharp, frightened cry

A Compare And Contrast Essay Between Anthen & A Handmaids Tale

776 words - 3 pages in school as easy and boring, and he said that he understood more that the teachers. In Handmaid's Tale the main character is a woman of who seems to be mildly attractive since she acquires the interest of several men in the story. She also seems to be fairly intelligent because she said that she had taken several college courses. Although both characters are both apparently in good health and both are intelligent, but they have very different

Compare And Contrast Of Two Stories "Latifa" And "The Crazy Dervish And The Pomegranate Tree: A Mystic Tale"

704 words - 3 pages servant of Abraham goes to the land of Abram to find his son, Issac a wife the servant gets a sign from God that when Rebecca draws water from the well and gives drink to him and his camels, she then is the one chosen by God for Issac.Farnoosh Moshiri's story "The Crazy Dervish and the Pomegranate Tree: A Mystic Tale" can also be looked upon as a Sufi - mysticism. Naroo in the Sufi reading can be translated as God. Naroo or God is what the