This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Compare Any One Documentary Film With Any One Cinema Dramatization Of Real Events. (Both Films Must Have Similar Themes, E.G. Love, War, Sport, Etc).

2885 words - 12 pages

In this essay, I will aim to discuss and analyse my chosen documentary ‘The Short Life of Anne Frank’ by Gerrit Netten, with cinema dramatization of real events ‘The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas’ by Mark Herman. I will be focusing on how each director uses techniques to show true aspects of real life, and how this persuades the audience into believing that they are witnessing something accurate, and true to the directors intention.

Gerrit Netten’s 2001 documentary ‘The Short Life of Anne Frank’ and Mark Herman’s 2008 historical drama based film ‘The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas’, are both based on the innocence perceived through the vision of two children’s eyes and thoughts, surrounding the abhorred events that took place in German-occupied-Europe between 1941 and 1945. Though both motions follow the destructive situation that happened during those years of devastation, it is also apparent that both films are impressive yet contrasting pieces of work that show the personal cost of tragedy through innocence, and also through the director’s control of sound and image.
‘The Short life of Anne Frank’ is a twenty-eight-minute long look motion, which introduces the audience with a concise observation about the young German-Jewish girl’s life, and her own personal development through growing up, ambitions and desires, orderly documented in her diary; the dearest thing she held closest to her. We see in Netten’s documentary a brief overview of her productivity within German life with her family as she grew up, followed shortly by a very abrupt preface about the Anti-Semitic political party gaining power. The emphatic male commentary by Jeremy Irons alongside of this is profoundly informative yet powerful throughout the entire documentary, and creates an empathetic story with facile narration contributing to the impact of it. We see comments introduced such as:
“He (Hitler) wants Germans to be proud of their country. As he sees it, they need to unite under a strong leader because they are being threatened by enemies. According to the Nazis, the Jews are Germany’s greatest enemy, they portray Jews as dangerous.” (The Short Life of Anne Frank, 2001)
As an opening statement, the honesty of revealing the horrific truth of people’s views on such developments in such a simple way, emphasizes the brutality in a matter of minutes and examines the horrors of the lives that many were forced to lead under Nazi power, as well as gripping the audience’s attention with subjectivity. The voice of documentary is quite a vital part to convincing an audience that what they are endorsing is the truth, and with the stated comment from Irons as an example, it is easy to trust in what is being said as there is a durable ground in the way in which he communicates it. John Corner states that,
“Unless it is explicitly indicated otherwise in the film or programme, audiences will hold to a firm and comprehensive trust in the ‘truth’ of what they see. They will become the...

Find Another Essay On Compare any one documentary film with any one cinema dramatization of real events. (Both films must have similar themes, e.g. love, war, sport, etc).

Love-in-idleness: Topic assigned was describe one idea that Shakespeare used on more than one level in any one of his plays

1029 words - 4 pages propagate.Love-in-idleness can mean an idle love, one that is fanciful and without depth like the medieval view of love as a sickness or disease. It also presents love as fickle and erratic when it pairs and re-pairs the lovers. This sort of love doesn't really have any deep emotional value and it doesn't last very long. Also it isn't the sort of love that helps bring about a new fertile society where "jack has jill, and naught goes ill." In a A

Is Police Brutality Focused on Any One Group?

2215 words - 9 pages real question however is do police tend to focus on any one group in particular or does external factors only make it appear that way? Do officers that are sworn to protect the public actually want to use excessive force against any specific group other than criminals? Or is it just the imagination, creating a vision of police brutality on a specific group due to circumstances outside of police control? Fitzgerald, S (2007) “Police Brutality

The Difference Between Medieval And Early Modern Is One Of Degree Rather Than Strict Demarcation." Discuss This Idea In The Context Of Any Two Writers You Have Read

1733 words - 7 pages groundwater is contaminated, people will be harmed by drinking this water, eating produce and meat grown with the contaminated water (http://www.nirs.org/factsheets/yucca.pdf). Thirty-five thousand gallons of milk per day from the Armargosa Valley in Nevada are sold in Los Angeles, California. Cows that have been exposed to the contamination through their feed and drink. Therefore, if radioactive waste leaks and contaminates the groundwater

Discuss the use of psychoanalytic concepts of identification, fetishism, voyeurism and narcissism to cinema with detailed reference to at lease one film. Film: Basic Instinct

3124 words - 12 pages Psychoanalysis and film have long encountered each other since both were born around the same time. It was in 1896 that Freud first used the term psychoanalysis only a year after the first screening of the Lumiere films in the Grande Café. A number of people have greatly influenced film theory using psychoanalysis including Mulvey and Lacan whose theories shall be explored in this essay. There are a number of basic Freudian ideas that

Compare and Contrast the structure of "Waiting for Godot" with the structure of any traditional play

962 words - 4 pages play, like Oedipus, there's a clear casual sequence of events, a plot, as in any well-made play. Because "A" happens, "B" happens, which causes "C" to happen. (Johnson, 2006). For example: The consequences of Oedipus's learning of his identity as the man who killed his farther and slept with his mother, are the falling action. This discovery drives Jocasta to hang herself, Oedipus to poke out his own eyes, and Creon to banish Oedipus from Thebes

Was any one of these reasons more important than the others in Hitler's rise to power?

1178 words - 5 pages abolish the treaty and all of it terms. Consequently the Treaty of Versailles helped to cause the Economic depression, in Germany. Meaning that the treaty and the economic depression were both linked together strongly, because the treaty told Germany to pay reparation bills, around ?6600 million to the countries they damaged during World War 1. Which meant that Germany did not have much money left for it. This caused the start of the economic downfall

Discuss some of the ways in which one European cinema has sought to deal with the themes of nationality and national history.

2251 words - 10 pages Spanish cinema has gained much recognition since the end of the countries dictatorship in 1975. One of the main reasons behind this recognition is due to creative control now being in the hands of film makers, such as Pedro Almodóvar, Fernando Trueba and Guillermo Del Toro in the late 20th century and early 21st century. These directors have created films which dealt with themes of nationality and national history, such as Todo sobre mi

Analysis of Andrew Rossi´s Documentary Film Page One: Inside the New York Times

645 words - 3 pages Andrew Rossi’s documentary film, Page One: Inside the New York Times fits into the finger categories of news media/entertainment and social relationships. The most relevant category is news media/entertainment. The New York Times is the nation’s oldest continually publishing major newspaper. A newspaper is a type of news media, and its goal is to inform the public. The documentary also fits into the category of social relationships. The

To what extent do any two texts, one drama one prose, mirror their society

4767 words - 19 pages that the protagonist must be dominated by a tragic flaw which leads to his downfall. All tragedies have a hero with a flaw, and in the play Othello, the hero becomes transformed by his tragic flaws of jealousy and gullibility. Othello's central flaw is jealousy. His flaw is exploited by Iago and manipulated through many incidental events. Othello's boundlesslove for Desdemona makes it unbearable for him to think of another man looking at her. His

With reference to any one dimension of social inequality, show what interests, structures and agents are involved in its construction and maintenance?

1441 words - 6 pages With reference to any one dimension of social inequality, show what interests, structures and agents are involved in its construction and maintenance?The aim of this essay is to discuss the Irish Travellers as an ethnic minority group. It will highlight the interests of this disadvantaged group and focus on the inequalities they encounter. It will conclude with knowledge based on references on what structures and agents are involved it its

Spellbound Documentary {list 5 themes that were seen in the film and which one you felt was the most important and why}

644 words - 3 pages In the film Spellbound, there are many themes that are may seem evident, and then there are those which are underlying, but just as significant. One palpable premise is the levels of intensity in terms of support, studying, and the general environment from the parents. For example, Neil had a very concentrated father who was constantly involved in preparing his son for the spelling bee by being his tutor and providing him with heartening words

Similar Essays

Analyse Any One Film Or Group Of Films In Relation To Its Social And Ideological Context: "The Cabinet Of Dr. Caligari" Along With "The Student Of Prague"

2611 words - 10 pages the strange vision that haunted him through the one medium he thought could make them real; film.Stellan started his affair with cinema under the wing of Paul Wagner and the German national cinema, the UFA, when he produced Der Student Von Prag ( The student of Prague) in 1913, depicting a poor student signing a contract with a strange sorcerer, Scapinelli. Who himself is an incarnation of the devil.The narrative of the film develops and the

Career Theories. Choose One Career Of Your Choice And Compare It With Any Two Career Theories

2438 words - 10 pages , thus providing a context for identity formation (Altman J.H, 1997: 231). Because career development is a lifelong process, "family of origin continues to have an influence through the life span" (http://career.ucsd.edu/parents/PACD.shtml).In terms of social classes, sociologists held that in all societies, the development of social classes was a natural phenomenon. For any society to exist, its members must adhere to both the implicit and

Objectivity Of Documentary Film: Cinema Vérité

1825 words - 7 pages with scripting an idea is that the script writer(s) have a subjective view of the documentary. The vastness of documenting a situation is restricted by the script making it impossible for a documentary film to capture objective realism in their work. To understand the subjective ideation of film scripting, one has to consider the various possibilities of changing a section of a scene. There are innumerable possibilities for documentaries to be

How Do Any Of The Film Makers That You Have Seen, During The Course Of This Module, Make The Cinema Itself, Their Primary Subject Of Investigation

1420 words - 6 pages field of grass to a baby unaware of 'Green'? How rainbows can light create for the untortured eye?... Imagine a world before 'the beginning was the word.'" Stan Brakhage 1963.With inspirational words like these, most of the experimental film-makers were trying to ask exactly the same questions in their films, film-makers such as Michael Snow. Why should he have to conform to normal cinema standards for his films, if people didn't understand them