Compare Attitudes Towards The Nude And Discuss, With Reference To Cabanel's 'venus' And Manet's 'olympia', Whether Or Not They Offer An Adequate Response.

2407 words - 10 pages

In this essay I aim to compare three writers' opinions and attitudes towards the nude, these writers being Castagnary , Zola and Clark . I will also discuss whether or not I think their comments offer an adequate response to the nude, while referencing two works from the Salon of 1863- Alexandre Cabanel's "Venus" (fig. 1) and Edouard Manet's "Olympia" (fig. 2).The nude in art has been a consistent theme and subject for artists throughout the history of art, be it religious art or portraiture, the human form has always fascinated mankind . However attitudes and opinions about the 'right' and 'wrong' kind of nudes differ hugely, as I will discuss. In the controversial salon of 1863 crowds were dismayed and outraged by Manet's Olympia, with her direct gaze and 'unacceptable' standards of modelling and composition, but were delighted with Cabanel's Venus (which subsequently was purchased by emperor Napoleon III ), that possessed all the 'refined eroticism' that was expected of salon goers of the time. Castagnary epitomises this idealised view of the nude in his account of 1863 when he uses the words 'dazzling, immaculate and naked beauty' to describe the nude form of the goddess Venus.Castagnary also comments on Venus's 'harmonious pose' and 'pure, well arranged contours'. Cabanel's Venus is perfectly, technically drawn- idealised, devoid of any blemish or body hair. She is sexually passive, characterless and more perfect than is humanly possible- which fitted with the accepted style of the time. According to Frances Borzello, Cabanel adheres to a strict set of conventions when he paints his Venus as 'historically, the reclining nude is painted in the guise of a classical goddess and tends to lie with her eyes turned from the spectator, half closed, or even closed (as in Cabanel's piece), offering no obstacle to his free-ranging glances over her body... she often stretches out in a landscape whose hummocks and valleys metaphorically echo her curves (hence the significance of the swelling sea Venus floats atop)' .Camille Lemonnier states that 'in order for a nude to stay pure in art she must be made impersonal ' and this is what Cabanel does by draping the arm across Venus's face, obscuring it and allowing her just to 'peek' out through half-closed eyelids and by ridding her body of 'imperfections' (which explains the absence of pubic hair) that make her personalised, and therefore flawed. The view that comes across very strongly in Castagnary's account is that all artists that paint nudes should strive to create perfection. This is a very different view compared to both Zola and Clark.Cabanel also includes the group of flying cupids that accompany Venus on her journey ('to finally stand erect and reveal herself to men' as Castagnary puts it). They play the part of the necessary 'allegorical trappings' that must be included in a 'traditional' reclining nude, as the aim of the painter is to elevate his model to 'goddess' status and present her...

Find Another Essay On Compare attitudes towards the nude and discuss, with reference to Cabanel's 'Venus' and Manet's 'Olympia', whether or not they offer an adequate response.

Essay on UFO's and whether or not they are real; includes works cited.

1867 words - 7 pages UFOs: Are They Real?UFOs have been one of the greatest mysteries of all times. From the beginning of time humans have seen UFOs. The real mystery is whether or not a UFO is a ship from another planet. There have been numerous reports of flying saucers. Many of them have been able to be explained and some were even elaborate hoaxes. But still, there are a few out there that are unexplainable and could quiet possibly be visitors from somewhere

With reference to relevant literature, discuss the notion that a career in the international hospitality and tourism industry is not a good idea.

2738 words - 11 pages With reference to relevant literature, discuss the notion that a career in the international hospitality and tourism industry is not a good idea.The hospitality and tourism industry is one of the largest employers in the United Kingdom and many other developed and less developed countries. Tourism is one of the fastest growing sectors within the global economy with a growing presence in virtually every country. The World Tourism Organization

Discuss whether Facebook is an effective medium for product promotion or not.

1131 words - 5 pages their stand on the effectiveness of advertising in Facebook. Protesters emphasize the safety of the internet advertisement as traps exist and virus will invade into the computers through click-through advertisements. This shortcoming, however, has be minimized Facebook where company promote their goods through profile pages. Trust can also be gained through a safe promotion page with an immediate response to the consumers. The sameness of the

"Women and Judaism" is about women's place in Orthodox society, and whether or not they are treated as inferiors

2224 words - 9 pages sleeves at least to the elbow, blouses or dresses with necklines that do not expose any cleavage and skirts that cover the knees when seated. This is not because a woman's body is sinful but rather that men are weak, and if they see too much of a woman's skin it would arouse desires and distract them. It is also considered immodest for a married woman to have uncovered hair in front of men other than her husband, not because women's hair is

Should Bicycle Riders Be Able To Choose Whether Or Not They Wear A Helmet? (Australia)

1053 words - 4 pages ground with forward momentum; or the windshield of a motor vehicle. Tests are not carried out for these, however. Such an impact is likely to impart some degree of rotational force on the head and brain. The effect of helmets on rotational forces to the brain is not entirely clear. Rotational forces may be reduced by the same crushing effect of the helmet that reduces linear forces; but they may be increased due to the increased size and mass of

Discuss Crane's treatment of nature in The Red Badge of Courage and Henry's shifting attitudes towards it

798 words - 3 pages "[keeps] from intercourse with his companions as much as circumstances [allow] him", even though "a sympathetic comparison of mental notes would have been a joy to him." However, when battle arrives, "he [becomes] not a man but a member", a part of a "subtle battle brotherhood, [...] a mysterious fraternity". A sence of belonging fills him with strength and disperses his fear. However, the following battle proves to be too much for an inexperienced

"Cultural identity is shaped by the values, way of life and the aspirations of the community that they live in." Discuss this statement, with close reference to 'The Shipping News' by E Annie Proulx.

1222 words - 5 pages middle aged man, rather impersonally referred to as Quoyle. Finds a clear sense of cultural identity though the recovery of his ancestral home.The cultural identity of an individual is shaped by a range of factors, including the values, way of life and aspirations of the community in which they live. The Shipping News, by E Annie Proulx, provides an outstanding analysis of the way that cultural identity is shaped by such elements. Newfoundland

Discuss whether or not Chaucer's the miller's tale is accurately described as a fabilau.

1016 words - 4 pages be revised for the miller's tale to be considered a fabliau. The miller's tale is a metrical tale in the sense it has an alternate number of stressed and unstressed syllables in each of its lines. For example, "He ne hade for his labour but a scorn".This means that at least half of the requirements of the oxford dictionary meaning of fabliau have been met. Thus meaning the only other part left to fulfil is whether or not the miller's tale is a

Do UFO's really exist??? This essay is an arguement over whether UFO's exist or not. I sided on the, "yes, they do exist" side. I hope this is helpful to you!

1366 words - 5 pages for some reason or another, theplot fascinates you. You keep watching for about twenty more minutes,but then soon start to loose interest in the movie. But then, all of asudden, you yourself are swept away from the couch which you weresitting on, and taken into the stars by what scientists call an UnidentifiedFlying Object, or UFO. Well, some people have claimed that they havebeen in the situation which I have just stated.The most popular and

Discuss the different attitudes towards Love and Marriage presented in Act 3 scenes 4 and 5 of Shakespeare's "Romeo and Juliet"

1694 words - 7 pages regards love as a temporary and physical relationship, and she sees Juliet's marriage to Paris entirely acceptable.To conclude, in the two scenes the attitudes of Capulet, Lady Capulet, Paris and the nurse towards love and marriage were normal for the time. They believed that marriage was a business deal and love was not a priority when it comes to power and authority. It seems as if passionate love is outside their experience ands they fail to

Rights and Freedoms guaranteed in the Charter should be limited. They should not be absolute. Discuss.

636 words - 3 pages , not just by the government but also by individuals and society. Due to the limits on our rights and freedoms and the limit on government's power, this can not happen in today's world. We are protected by our own limits.I think we should never argue about the limits on our rights and freedoms in the Charter. So you see, compared to the past, I believe our rights and freedoms are eternal and absolute. Just remember the limits work in our favor and that whether it is absolute power, rights and/or freedoms, they will corrupt absolutely.

Similar Essays

Discuss Thomas Mann's "A Death In Venice". Also, Find An Interpretation Of The Story And Write Whether You Agree Or Not With What It Says.

1967 words - 8 pages readers' imagination. I consider these characters not evil or devils, but as unfortunate coincidences (planned by Mann to be that way) that predict his death. I cannot agree with Tadzio's relation to death. Tadzio is full of life, even for a sickly boy. He plays on the beach all day, dresses in colorful clothes, and grows his hair like a carefree individual. The connection with Tadzio to death is in Aschenbach's mind, not in real life. It is not even

Audiences Are Not Only Entertained They Are Made To Engage With The Social Concerns Explored In Plays. Discuss This View With Reference To Your Study And Experience Of Two Of The Texts Set For Study.

1133 words - 5 pages Audiences are not only entertained they are made to engage with the social concerns explored in plays. Discuss this view with reference to your study and experience of two of the texts set for study.For centuries, drama has acted as a mirror for culture and society. Through the power of dramatic form, we have been invited to be entertained yet also engaged in the social concerns, which can both be provocative and surprising. Both 'Stolen' by

Should An Athlete's Gender Determine Whether Or Not They Will Be Allowed To Participate In Any Sport They Choose?

1295 words - 5 pages Should an athlete's gender determine whether or not they will be allowed to participate in any sport they choose?Whenever the topic of letting women play sports with men comes up, there are always people who have their own distinct opinions of what should happen. It is almost like bringing up the topics of religion or politics within a large group. People's ideas on the subject might agree with a main view, but each person sees minor respects of

Discuss Whether Or Not Globalisation Is The Death Of Culture.

2174 words - 9 pages often for wealth and trading purposes, and can at times come at the expense of culture. Culture is an expression, rather than a simple definition. It links us to places and peoples through mediums such as religion, clothing, food, or the media. The media in particular is continuously advertising different cultures across the globe.Globalisation also presents us with the dissolution of national state boundaries, representing the magnitude and