This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Compare Foucault’s Treatment Of The Insane With That Of Goffman’s On Asylums

1654 words - 7 pages

When reading the works of both Michel Foucault and Erving Goffman, together they give a delineation of the discourse of madness. This essay delves into both of these renowned sociologists, in an attempt to explore both Michel Foucault’s finding on the treatment of the insane and Erving Goffman’s work on asylums.
It begins with a very deep and archival aspect on Foucault’s part; where close attention was paid to the evolution of language, words and the view of the mad. Foucault studied and researched in a more genealogical and archeological perspective, as he looked at the mad from inception. He focused on society as a whole and saw madness at the macro level, thereby researching society’s changing views and the interactions and treatments the patients received from the administration of these mental hospitals.
Foucault as a post structuralist was very interested and invested in studying society, more specifically the constant changing of knowledge and how society as a whole viewed other individuals within that society. This was done by grouping these individuals into unsavory categories; these categories were developed based on the acts or ideas of these individuals which were seen as being against the “norm”. Within the sixteenth and eighteenth centuries, these categories of people were comprised of the prostitutes, vagabonds, beggars, criminals and the mad; they were confined to institutions all across Europe.
With this “Great Confinement,” Foucault looked closely at the distinctions which were developed to distinguish between madness and sanity within the Age of Reason. He debunked these distinctions in more detail in his paper “Madness and Unreason: History of Madness in the Classical Age” (Foucault, 1961) After acquiring firsthand knowledge from being hospitalized for depression, Foucault’s discourse on madness changed, he found that the modern medical treatments for the mad were suspicious and that they were a way of controlling the insane. He also believed that instead of these treatments being objective they were in fact a means of control by those in society of high social ranking. In Foucault’s view, the previous and current views of the mad were both inaccurate.
Within “Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison” (Foucault, 1979) he speaks on the shift from sovereign to disciplinary power; where force or punishment was no longer necessary. This power was not only displayed in prisons but mental hospitals as well and focused more on the use of surveillance to control individuals so they would behave as expected or normal based on self-discipline.
Foucault agreed with Bentham’s Panopticon theory as it supported and reflected his view on surveillance. The Panopticon was the idea of a design like a prison with inmates separated from each other and always visible to a monitor. This monitor would be placed in the central tower and even though it was incapable of seeing all activity from the inmates, the goal of this, was to make...

Find Another Essay On Compare Foucault’s Treatment of the Insane with that of Goffman’s on Asylums

COMPARE AND CONTRAST BOURDIEU'S APPROACH TO THE AGENCY/STRUCTURE DICHOTOMY WITH THAT OF GIDDENS

2876 words - 12 pages COMPARE AND CONTRAST BOURDIEU'S APPROACHTO THE AGENCY/STRUCTURE DICHOTOMYWITH THAT OF GIDDENSIn recent years, several authors have attempted to deal with the problem of the relationship between agency and social structure. This has manifested itself in the theory of structuration. Anthony Giddens' structuration theory is one of the best-known and most articulated efforts to integrate agency and structure. His theory proposes a duality of

On The Construction, Organization And General Arrangements Of Hospitals For The Insane (1854)

1186 words - 5 pages controlled mental hospitals. Dr. Thomas Kirkbride was the one that lead this transformation in the United States. In 1954, after 14 years of serving as the superintendent of Pennsylvania Hospital for the Insane, he published On the Construction, Organization and General Arrangements of Hospitals for the Insane. This book extensively explained his theories for treatment of the mentally ill. The first several chapters Kirkbride explains what insanity is

A Treatment of Three Things that Went Wrong on the Island

975 words - 4 pages , this is due to levels of high testosterone. No females are on the island with them to the chemical males produce seems to spread like wild fire ironically all over the island triggering a side of the boys that has never been seen before to happen. Once they kill one pig and human they become blood thirsty and the rest of the novel is based on the violence and revealing the darkness of the human condition. Above all, there was not a strong enough

Insane, or not Insane? That is the Question

958 words - 4 pages Megan CollinsCordel BrowneENG 4U1October 19, 2007Insane, or not Insane? That is the QuestionThe definition of mad is as follows: a deranged state of the mind or lack of understanding. Throughout Shakespeare's play, Hamlet, the main character, young Hamlet, is brought on to find out who killed his father. He decides to put on a façade of madness as part of his plan to gain the opportunity to kill his Uncle, and new father, Claudius

Compare the condition of white indentured servant with that of the slave in the seventeen- century Caribbean

1871 words - 7 pages scale to Europe but did not produce the desired economic results that came later with the cultivation of sugar cane. The mortality rates of indentured servants were very high as, like the planters, they were unaccustomed to the heat and environmental difficulties that life presented on the islands. Planters who used indentured servants treated them extremely badly, and often put them to work as soon as they arrived from an undoubtedly horrible

The Impact of Spirituality on Cancer Treatment

1010 words - 4 pages ? Even though the number of case studies or research conducted in dealing with this aspect has been limited, there is phenomenal similarity that demonstrates a positive co relation between religiosity and cancer treatment. It has been shown in these studies that the individuals that strictly adhere to the doctrines of their faith and conviction are capable of handling such situations in a much better way and in a more positive manner. (King 2006

The Role of Environment on ADHD Treatment

2950 words - 12 pages same knowledge as the normal students or even deeper knowledge, about something they’re interested in, than normal kids. Without realizing, students will know how to learn to pay attention, which is the purpose of the treatment itself. Class management can also be used to deal with ADHD students. Many studied have found that classroom-based involvements have a positive effect on ADHD behavior and less extent of their academic progress. Family

Acupuncture's Effectiveness on the Treatment of Migraines

1649 words - 7 pages , biofeedback, chiropractic care and acupuncture (About Migraine, n.d.). I will be looking at how effective acupuncture is in the treatment of migraines. Acupuncture is one of the ancient Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) methods and is estimated to have began 2000-3000 years ago (Introduction to TCM, n.d.). TCM believes that all life sources, also called Qi, must flow freely through channels that travel throughout our bodies on twelve

Treatment of PTSD with MDMA

1054 words - 5 pages symptoms of PTSD. A complete pilot study of the use of MDMA to assist in the treatment of PTSD with the use of psychotherapy was conducted in Charleston, South Carolina, in the United States. The study was completed in September 2008 and published in the Journal of Psychopharmacology on July 19, 2010. In the study subjects were recruited through letters to psychotherapists and advertisements. With the use of a scripted telephone call possible

The Character Analysis of the Insane Lady Mcbeth

1094 words - 5 pages Kelly Kerrigan Ryan Strunz English IV 14 May 2014 The Character Analysis of the Insane Lady Macbeth Throughout the play Macbeth by William Shakespeare, observers see Macbeth as a merciless, cold blooded killer. After reading and watching Shakespeare's play people could make the argument that Macbeth is the most ruthless and evil character in the play. Macbeth is not the most ruthless or evil in the play. In reality Macbeth's wife, Lady

Compare the treatment of the subject between "Bavarian Gentians" and "Ship of Death"

1521 words - 6 pages death cosily domestic. This is evident when he says ' oh build your ship, your little arc, and furnish it with food.... down oblivion' as well as when he says ' the ark of faith with its store of food...clothes'. The material world gives Lawrence comfort. Lawrence speaks in terms of the need to clutch onto something familiar and that the soul needs nourishment on its journey which is material and not religious. This poem expresses such a positive

Similar Essays

History And Overview Of Insane Asylums

2182 words - 9 pages bring them back to their senses. This method of treatment proved ineffective because patients would go into a deep state of depression and inflicted self-harm; being inside an asylum as a patient was nothing but torture, and humiliation. Public entry to either family members or press inside American insane asylums was almost always denied. The reason being was said to be that attendants and doctors did not want anyone interfering with their

A History Of Insane Asylums And Mental Illness

2418 words - 10 pages mental illness into positions in life that are harder to live in. The social stigma tends to be harder to escape because it is all around. People with mental illness find that they are stigmatized in the hospitals that they go to to receive treatment. Once you are committed to a hospital, you are labeled, and are subject to this label for the rest of your life. The staff in “Being Sane in Insane Places” all had a similar attitude towards the

American Insane Asylums In The Mid 1900s

1063 words - 5 pages Asylums of the 20th century were deplorable places created for insane people because of the ignorance of the medical community about helping or treating the mentally ill, the way the asylums were use to get the insane out of the way, and the sheer fact that the hospitals felt the need to withhold the information about what was going on inside the institutions from the public. Some Americans today may believe that in the last few decades we had

The History Of Dorthea Dix's Creation Of Mental Asylums

1090 words - 4 pages board of the state at first did not listen so Dix began handing out pamphlets to society on what was happening in hospitals to the insane. Almost from the day Dix’s pamphlet appeared, “it came to be seen as one of those rare utterances that shock the collective conscience into a new way of seeing the world, in this case promoting a revolution in the perception and treatment of insanity.” (Gollaher4) With the public on her side the government began