Compare The Way In Which Tragic Heroism Is Developed In Jean Anouilh's "Antigone" And In Euripides' Medea?

1849 words - 7 pages

Aristotle has long ago delineated a renowned definition of a Tragic Hero as 'an honourable protagonist with a tragic flaw'. This definition had been conveyed through time; from Euripides in ancient Greece to Jean Anouilh in 1940's France. In order to assess the degree of tragic heroism in both Euripides' Medea and the 'modern' Anouilh's Antigone it is essential to reminisce upon this definition with its further details, as will be clarified later on. By discussing the moral flaw, the role of foreshadowing and of dramatic irony used by the authors in both plays, the pattern of developing tragedy could be easily recognized and evaluated. Even though both protagonists appear to be 'tragic' in the end, Medea murders her own children while Antigone commits suicide, it is important to note that their tragic heroism is diverse due to the significant distinction between the character traits of the heroines. While passion drives them both, Medea is experienced, wise and cunning, whereas Antigone is portrayed as young, naïve and desperate to make a difference.The best type of tragic hero, according to Aristotle, 'exists between these extremes . . . a person who is neither perfect in virtue and justice, nor one who falls into misfortune through vice and depravity, but rather, one who succumbs through some miscalculation'.¹ Consequently, the hero has a 'moral flaw'; for example in Medea Euripides depicts a woman driven to violence because of her intense suffering. It can be inferred that Medea's character's hamartia is uncontrolled passion and a manner of 'speaking without thinking'. Euripides' protagonist employs the art of 'rhetoric' and with the help of effective diction he accentuates her past nobility intertwined with her flaw, the extremist infatuation: 'Medea:...but when she is wronged in her marriage bed, no creature has a mind more murderous'" (l.265-66) This phrase, as well as being an emotional ending to her speech, one of the arts of rhetoric, Euripides' use of 'murderous mind' emphasizes the unrestrained passion and sharpness of language that Medea's character possesses. It connotes to violence, hatred and very 'unfeminine' characteristics. The word 'creature', too, insinuates inhuman passionate, wildness and is very unlike the ideal 'woman' of the time. Nonetheless, through use of the chorus, Euripides renders appeal for Medea: 'Chorus: Alas, alas, you pitiable woman, wretched in your sufferings'."http://larryavisbrown.homestead.com/Aristotle_Tragedy.html" 'Medea and other plays' by Euripides (Line 265-65)" 'Medea and other plays' by EuripidesThus, with the intervention of the chorus Euripides introduces his value judgments, reminds the audience that Medea's passion comes from heart-break and lost love. It is also worthwhile to note that the act of revenge is very common to humans even today and is arguably understandable and without doubt highlights the major theme of role of women and being another possibly motive and flaw in...

Find Another Essay On Compare the way in which Tragic Heroism is developed in Jean Anouilh's "Antigone" and in Euripides' Medea?

Medea: Euripides' Tragic Hero Essay

1511 words - 6 pages The rhetorical devices that Euripides uses throughout Medea allow Medea to become the poem's tragic hero. For Medea is not only a woman but also a foreigner, which makes her a member of two groups in Athenian society who had nearly no rights. Thus, the Athenian audience would have automatically aligned their sympathies with Jason instead Medea, and Medea would have been labeled the villain from the start. This would have negated Euripides

'Antigone' by Jean Anouilh - "Analyse Anouilh's use of variety dramatic devices in his presentation of Antigone in the scenes leading up to her arrest"

2735 words - 11 pages "Antigone", written in 1942 by the French playwright Anouilh, is based upon the original "Antigone" the third play in the trilogy of "The Theban Plays" written by Sophocles, of Ancient Greece, in around 450 BC. "Antigone" is based upon the age-old conflict between the requirements of human and divine law. Although Anouilh's version of "Antigone" is significantly similar to its original by Sophocles, there are substantial differences between the

Select two characters from the works Medea and Pygmalion and compare the means by which these characters are constructed and developed.

1531 words - 6 pages Euripides and Shaw employ a range of techniques to present the compelling personas of their female protagonists, Medea and Eliza. The intense emotional transformation of Medea and Eliza's striking physical change are formed by such methods as language, tone, stage direction and theme development. In addition, the course of action the characters take influences the way they are perceived, as does the way the other character's view them. Each

Compare the way in which these poets convey their attitudes to love

1070 words - 4 pages Compare the way in which these poets convey their attitudes to love and relationships. How is this affected by the era in which they lived? The two poems I am comparing are 'To His Coy Mistress' by Andrew Marvell. Coy can be translated into modern language as Shy. The whole poem is persuasive and is trying to get the lady to sleep with him, but because she is shy she wont. Marvell lived in the 17th century from 1621-1678. The poem in

Compare and Contrast the Way in Which Poets Present Ideas About Soldiers Leaving for War in Joining the Colours and The Send Off

1053 words - 4 pages what to expect. Owen uses personification to describe the surroundings 'Signals nodded, and a lamp winked to the guard', to demonstrate the lack of people who are there to see them off. This feeling is increased by the phrase 'like wrongs hushed up', which demonstrates how quiet and secretive the atmosphere is. Rhetorical questions such as 'Shall they return to beating of great bells in wild train-loads?', encourage the reader to reflect on the

The Wicked Character Medea in Euripides' Medea

726 words - 3 pages wisely...") Euripides p. 649. Medea is a smooth talker and knows, to live in the culture she was living in, she had to play by its rules. And she did, somewhat, get her way with Kreon. She was able to get one more day in Corinth, which was long enough to kill Creusa, Kreon and her two boys. Her goal was to punish Jason, the one that had actually wronged her. Warner says, "In murdering her children, the barbarous Medea seeks to destroy not only

The Characterization of Medea in Euripides and Ovid

1560 words - 6 pages The Medea by Euripides, Heroides XII: Medea to Jason by OvidBoth Fifth century B.C. playwright Euripides and Roman poet and dramatist Ovid tell the story of Jason ditching Medea for another woman; however, they do not always share a perspective on the female matron's traits, behavior, and purpose. Euripides portrays a woman who reacts to injustice by beginning a crusade to avenge all who harmed her which she is prepared to see through even if it

Feminism in Medea by Euripides

1029 words - 4 pages ). This reveals the most significant part of the play in which the audience, who instead of supporting Medea now are shocked and disgraced by her. The loss of sympathy for Medea because of her plans of infanticide is a tool showing that the matriarchal stereotype of women is a belief that is still firmly held by society. The ?motherhood? and ?nurturing? role are both characteristics concerning femininity that Medea out rightly disregards when she

Women in Euripides' Alcestis, Medea, Andromache, and Bacchae

2885 words - 12 pages . Euripides creates this final scene to demonstrate female liberation through Medea's cold total revenge over Jason. The frustration and the torment he causes her is relieved in the final scene of the play liberating Medea, which symbolizes liberation for all females. In Andromache two female characters are liberated. The characters of Andromache and Hermione are natural enemies from the start. Andromache is a slave brought in against her will so that

Topic: Is Medea a tragic heroine? This paper examines in details the main character Medea and proves that she is not a tragic hero based on the facts.

840 words - 3 pages children. Euripides describes this insight in Medea's two opening cries the first in (line 95-96) displays her suicidal helplessness an the second line (110-114) express a wish and curse that every trace of her love for Jason be cut off. In addition, Euripides demonstrates how cruel and evil Medea is. For instance, she decided to take revenge by killing her own children. This way, Medea would make Jason suffer as she did. Another evil thing that

Representation of Society in Euripides' Medea

525 words - 2 pages between culture and the individual. Euripides used his characters as a function to shape the ideas of the play (Arrowsmith 359). In Medea, there was not a "traditional" hero, but a fragmentation between the two paired major characters, which is characteristic of Euripides' work (Arrowsmith 356). Jason and Medea, the initial lovers of the play, were antagonists by the play's end. Euripides sought to take the wholeness of the old "hero" and represent

Similar Essays

Tragic Heroes In Euripides Medea, Shakespeare's Othello And Boccaccio's Decameron

2167 words - 9 pages ultimate revenge taken upon someone they love. Every misdeed carried out, like Othello's, is highly immoral and inexcusable in today's day and age, yet vengeance was seen as the right way to deal with another's infidelity. The most inexcusable of all the wrongdoing of these characters was that of Medea. This main character in Euripides great tragic play, "Medea", commits the most unspeakable crime that could ever be committed by a human being

The Most Tragic Character In Medea By Euripides

2199 words - 9 pages The Most Tragic Character in Medea by Euripides Medea is the story of an estranged woman who wishes to seek revenge on her husband (who has left her for another woman) by poisoning his new wife. This, however, is made more difficult when the King of the land, Creon, tells Medea to leave, mainly because he is scared of her. She appeals to him for one more day to sort things out, and uses persuasion by making him feel

Comparing Sophocles' Antigone And Jean Anouilh's Antigone

2293 words - 9 pages Both Sophocles and Jean Anouilh use the simple story-line of a girl defying her uncle and king in the face of death to reflect upon the events and attitudes of their days. Sophocles' Antigone models the classical pattern of tragedy by incorporating key elements such as a tragic hero with a fatal flaw and the Man-God-Society triangle. Creon is the tragic hero who disturbs the natural harmony of Thebes by denying Polyneices a funeral. Antigone is

Is Jean Anouilh's Antigone A Tragedy Or A Triumph? This Is An Assessment Of The Tragic And Trimphant Elements Within The Play 'antigone'

4517 words - 18 pages Is Antigone a tragedy or a triumphJean Anouilh's Antigone was first produced in Paris in 1942, it is based on Sophocles' version of the novel, which was written in 442 B.C.E and performed in Ancient Greece. It is a modernist play, which has the effect of highlighting the importance of the themes of the play and lets the audience focus more fully on the tragic and triumphant elements of the play. Antigone was performed under Nazi-occupied France