This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Compare And Contrast: Two Film Adaptations Of Macbeth

1548 words - 6 pages

April, 2 2014 Perspectives

As far as we’re aware, Shakespeare wrote Macbeth in 1606, making it roughly 400 years old and in desperate need of a revival. While setting an adaptation of the play in modern day Melbourne in the midst of a gangland war may have seemed comical a decade ago, with corpses piled high from St Kilda to Sunshine in the real gang war of the Victorian city, it now seems 100% plausible. The difficulty of course, is finding a way to accurately transform noble lords of Scotland into underworld gangsters and still maintain Shakespeare’s true intentions. It’s quite simple really, you can’t.
Despite Geoffrey Wright’s efforts in producing the twenty-first century adaptation of Shakespeare’s Macbeth in 2006, and his attempt to depict the concept of stereotypical gender roles and relations in a modern context, he has served only to make a mockery of this powerful tragedy. On the contrary, Roman Polanski’s The Tragedy of Macbeth, produced in 1971, is now considered to be one of the most influential filmic illustrations of the Shakespearean play, while closely following the themes and threads of the original text.
Polanski’s Macbeth was produced in accordance with the socio-political background of the 1970s. Thus, prior to embarking on an analysis of the film it is imperative to first gain an understanding of the era within which is was released. The turn of the 1960s established a period of immense change and development within society; the age of The Man on the Moon, Communism and Women’s Liberation.
Roman Polanski intertwined several of these pressing concepts into his production and more specifically, opted to highlight the stereotypical role of women and the appropriate way of conduct, through characterisation of both the Witches and Lady Macbeth as such prominent and powerful figures. His interesting interpretation of the final scene of the original text also reflects upon the period in which it was directed. The reappearance of the witches in the concluding scene of the film indicates the constant and cyclic status of unrest within the world, more commonly expressed as “The Wheel of Fortune”. Through the inclusion of such pertinent themes, Polanski draws attention from a more contemporary and cultured audience.
The initial scenes of the film generate a strong connection with viewers in relation to establishing the characters, plot and the context in which the film was intended. With the introduction of the three witches, who together constitute a very important part in the sequence of unfolding events, the viewer immediately becomes aware of the particularly dark and unsettling tone of the play. Assembled together on a rugged coast alongside a backdrop of an angry storm, the witches possessively chant, introducing the supernatural element of the play.
Furthermore, a strong sense of reality is engendered as the camera focuses in on each of the witches’ unnatural and unappealing physical attributes: the...

Find Another Essay On Compare and Contrast: Two Film Adaptations of Macbeth

A Comparison of Two Film Adaptations of Hamlet

1021 words - 4 pages " engraved in stone, which adds to the foreboding feel the music has already given the film. The first scene gives a little comic relief when the guards become confused after seeing the ghost. When the camera enters the looming castle a celebration is being had and is abruptly interrupted by the mysterious Hamlet. The real life of the play starts to be seen upon Hamlet's entrance; Hamlet's costume and character are very bold and start to add to the

Compare and contrast two approaches Essay

1404 words - 6 pages contrast these two very different approaches. Not only will I compare the methods of research used but also will note any similarities or differences they may have and indeed the strengths and weaknesses of each approach. My chosen approaches to evaluate are Behaviourist V Psychoanalytic.In 1913 John Watson published ' Psychology as the behaviourist view it', in it he outlined his new ideas. These ideas were considered 'new' because Watson disagreed

compare and contrast two countries

2643 words - 11 pages Population Policy Essay in GeographyComparison of two Population PoliciesIntroductionPopulation policy determines the principles, objectives and policies adopted by the State as regards population issues for the purpose of influencing the population status, including variables in population growth and its main elements (fertility, births, deaths, geographical distribution, immigration, population composition such as population youthfulness or

Compare and contrast the two characters of Celie and Jeanette

1738 words - 7 pages Compare and contrast the two characters of Celie and Jeanette. Consider the influence of religion on the two main protagonists. Despite the fact that Celie and Jeanette are characters who appear to be lost in completely different worlds they do in fact have quite a lot in common. The influence of religion on the two girls is significant and can be seen throughout the two novels. Jeanette is trapped at home with an extremely strict

Compare and contrast the way men are portrayed in two different film genres

1084 words - 4 pages Movies that are being discussed are "Billy Elliot" and "Remember the Titans" for a genre of drama, and on the other hand, Armageddon and Fight Club are being discussed in regards of an action genre. After viewing the four films, it is noticed that there are wide differences portrayed in men from the two genres present. It is clear that men within drama genres are portrayed as being ambitious and more feminine. It shows that they fight for their

Compare and Contrast Two Theories of Gender Role Development

1505 words - 6 pages Compare and contrast two theories of gender role development A dominant debate in current psychological research is one on gender development. Psychologists try to understand relative importance of social and cognitive factors. Various theories are brought up in this field and in this essay two of the most standard theory in this field are going to be explained. The theories covered in this essay relate to aspects of children’s thinking that

Compare and Contrast Two Views of Gay Marriage

892 words - 4 pages William Bennett, editor of The Book of Virtues and co-director of Empower America, responded to an article that Andrew Sullivan had written supporting gay marriage in America. Bennett started out by first issuing two key points as to what divides the proponents and opponents of same-sex marriages. The two articles are derived from Sibylle Gruber’s Constructing Others: Constructing Ourselves edition. Bennett notions that

Compare/contrast of two communistic countries: North Korea and Cuba

1059 words - 4 pages North Korea and CubaNorth Korea and Cuba are two of the five current communist ruling states, also known as the Ruling parties of Socialist states. North Korea is under the rule of Kim Jung Il, a strong communist leader since 1994. He succeeded his father, Kim Il- Sung, when he died in 1994 after his rule for 50 years of communism. Cuba is ruled by Fidel Castro, who overthrew Fulgencio Batista in 1959 during the Cuban revolution. Castro has been

Compare and Contrast Religion in Two Works

1933 words - 8 pages religious. Jesus was able to say so few of words and have people become devoutly religious. It is not impossible for someone to do this, but many people today would not believe in something just because someone told them to. Elmer Gantry also had charisma which influenced people to be religious or temporarily religious even if they had not been previously. In the opening scene of the film, Elmer is sitting in a bar when two women walk in asking

Compare and Contrast two ethical theories

2167 words - 9 pages In this essay I have chosen to compare two opposing theories, Immanuel Kant's absolutist deontological ethics and Joseph Fletchers relativist situation ethics. The deontological ethics focuses on actions made according to duty and the categorical imperative - which shows how acts are intrinsically good or bad. The situation ethics state that no act is intrinsically good or bad, and that actions should b made according to love. From this

Compare and Contrast the Two Families

941 words - 4 pages . Furthermore, as for Benjamin, the better family for him is the Komoetie family because of the fact they give him love, a different view of life, and in the end he searches for his own self identity. Fiela’s Child is set in the nineteenth-century rural area of South Africa. There are two different families, one being the Van Rooyens, a white family who lives in the dense Forest near the southern coast, and the Komoetie family, a black family who lives in

Similar Essays

Compare And Contrast Of Two Film Versions Of Romeo And Juliet Analysis

1107 words - 4 pages William Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet is the classic story of two families, the Montague’s and Capulet’s who have an age old feud. Two children of the families, Juliet Capulet and Romeo Montague, meet and fall in love. The feud of their families encourages them to keep their relationship secret. They get married without telling anyone, but their family feud gets in the way. Juliet’s cousin, Tybalt, and Romeo’s friend, Mercutio, get into a sword

Compare And Contrast Two Works Of Art

1376 words - 6 pages compare and contrast. I will also discuss how these inspirational sources have contributed to my final project outcome with regard to composition and technique.Baboon and young and The little fourteen year old dancer are free-standing sculptures depicting life through different animals. These artworks are of different sizes, The little fourteen year old dancer is 104.5 cm while The baboon and young is 21cm respectively. They are both made the same

Compare And Contrast Of Two Dramas

1387 words - 6 pages Untitled Jackie Magnuson Professor Adkins English 1B 11 May 2011 Compare and Contrast Fences By August Wilson and Death of a Salesman By Arthur Miller August Wilson's Fences and Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman warrant comparison. Wilson and Miller both execute dramatically different styles to articulate their independent perspectives of the struggles in maintaining respectful, trustworthy

Compare And Contrast Two Developmental Theories Of

2321 words - 9 pages Compare and contrast two developmental theories of intelligence Intelligence is a complex psychological construct and promotes fierce debate amongst academics. Many experts maintain that intelligence is the most important aspect of individual differences, whereas other doubt its value as a concept. At one extreme many claim that individual differences in intelligence depend upon genetic factors, and at the other many argue that environmental