Comparing American Slavery And The Holocaust

1050 words - 4 pages

The purpose of this essay is to compare and contrast the American Slavery and the Holocaust, in terms of which one was more malevolent than the other. Research indicates that “the “competition” between African-American and Jews has served to trivialize the malevolence which both has suffered” (Newton, 1999). According to L. Thomas “A separate issue that contributes to the tension between blacks and Jews refer to to the role that Jews played in the American Slave trade.”

History
Around 1600 (C.E), the United States began importing blacks from the continent of Africa for slave labor; and the Constitution later adopted by the colonies declared blacks 3/5 of a person (Martin, 1993). Laurence Thomas states that the Adolph Hitler’s purpose in 1938, was to exterminate the Jewish population of six million. I believe this is such a sad portrayal of what had occurred during this era, which is similar to what my ancestors faced during the Wounded Knee Massacre.
According to L. Thomas “American Slavery is the paradigm of African-American suffering for the African-American’s in the United States; and the Holocaust is the example of the Jewish people’s agonization” (Thomas, 2005). Tony Martin states that “the prerogatives of the first two sentences are based on facts.” Laurence Thomas emphasizes that the events referred to are in chronological order, and that nobody can dispute the order for which is happened (Thomas, 2005).
Slavery
Slavery is a sensitive topic that most would say evil and bad. Martin states that “some African-Americans claimed that Jews were the dominant figures in the trading of black slaves. (Martin 1993). Research by Mintz and McNeil support that “After making contact with the West Africans, the Portuguese established a trade relationship which would alter the Old World and the New World permanently.” Some viewed African American slave as if they were just property. For example, they were executed at given moment. Mintz claims that “they were at least valuable, and people paid a high price to purchase, house, and feed them (Mintz & McNeil, 2013) It seems this is where the African-American and Jewish people contrast.
The Holocaust
Ian Kershaw empathetically states that “The Holocaust was the systematic, extermination of six million Jews by the Nazi government and their allies during World War II.” He further add that it wasn’t until after Adolph Hitler “became Chancellor of the German government, he began targeting the Jews as racially inferior to the German people (Kershaw, 1985).
Accordingly, Hitler began eradicating all nationalities that he considered second-rate to Germans. Many believe that the depopulation technique was the “German viewpoint of the Nazi government, which wanted to create a "master race" of Aryan people. After January 1933, the Jews were placed in concentration camps which started the Holocaust” (Katz, 1994).
People were basically removed from their homes, barred from daily activities, and...

Find Another Essay On Comparing American Slavery and the Holocaust

Southern Slavery and the American Civil War

1801 words - 7 pages captivated by the exuberance that fills these protests. This same passion that continues to fill these protesters once filled every American. However, in this instance Americans had enthusiastic, but opposing viewpoints about slavery. The North believed everything about slavery was morally wrong and that having slaves went against the American ideal of freedom. Southerners believed in their guaranteed right of property protection, and believed that the

Holy Warriors: The Abolitionists and American Slavery

542 words - 2 pages politics. Most Americans suspected that immediate emancipation would suddenly create a large free population of inferior blacks. Jackson's Democratic Party was deliberately designed to support the planters' interests. Jacksonian ideology soon became related to racism and anti-abolition. The abolitionists faced great challenges. The ending of slavery peacefully of violently would require great changes in the American life. Modern approaches to

Comparing the French and American Revolutions

903 words - 4 pages While the French and the American revolutions share some similarities, they differ in most areas involving the revolution. Enlightenment ideas would help shape politics, economics, and religion in the revolutionary nations. Although both found the importance of individual rights, they took different paths in establishing and operating their respective governments. The economic standpoints of the French would be in contrary with the American

Comparing the American and French Revolutions

2978 words - 12 pages The American and the French revolutions had many similarities and differences. One similarity being is that they both wanted to escape the rule of their King. Second, they both started by an uprising of people against unfair taxation by the monarchy. The French peasants were not represented by the Parliament. It was mainly composed of middle and upper class people. Now, the American colonists were not represented in England because of their lack

Slavery and Freedom: The American Paradox by Edmund Morgan

2220 words - 9 pages order to grow crops and sell them to make a profit. Labor had become needed on the plantation system and in order to extract cheap labor slaves were brought to the south in order to work on the plantations. The shift from indentured servitude to slavery was an important time as well as the factors that contributed to that shift, this shift affected the future generations of African American descent. The history of colonial settlements involved

African and Native American Slavery

578 words - 2 pages African and Native American SlaveryThe 1500's, a time of discovery, was when theEuropeans came to dominate most of the New World. TheEuropeans traveled to Africa and captured Africans to helpdevelop their land and satisfy their need for power. I feelthat the treatment of the Indians and Africans by theEuropeans was completely unjustifiable. While the Indiansand Africans were less technologically advanced and theEuropeans were uneducated, in this

Slavery in the American Colonies

888 words - 4 pages 1. In the American colonies, Virginians switched from indentured servants to slaves for their labor needs for many reasons. A major reason was the shift in the relative supply of indentured servants and slaves. While the colonial demand for labor was increasing, a sharp decrease occurred in the number of English migrants arriving in America under indenture. Slaves were permanent property and female slaves passed their status on to their children

Slavery in the American South

1810 words - 7 pages Slavery in the South Slavery was a big part of life in the South. Many plantation owners relied on slaves and their work to help get the money and crops they needed. There were two types of slaves in the South at this time. There were house slaves and there were field slaves. House slaves consisted of servants, maids, and butlers. They were normally treated better than the field slaves (Biel 14). They got to be inside most of the time

Imagination and the Holocaust

2770 words - 11 pages for the methods used by slave traders to dehumanize African people in order to turn them into slaves (Council of African American Students' presentation). The packing of people into slave ships, torture, separation, and humiliation were all part of the process of "seasoning" because in order for humans to submit to slavery, or as in the case of the Holocaust, to being systematically murdered, they must first be persuaded they are inhuman. While we

Comparing and Contrasting the French and American Revolutions

767 words - 4 pages In comparing and contrasting the French and American Revolutions, are notable differences but there are similarities as well. Of course, each was fought for a different cause. The American Revolution was a break from the mother country, Great Britain. It was a matter of independence as an individual state, prompted in part by unfair taxation and religion. The Revolution involved a series of colonies, rising up against an oppressor, with the help

Women and the Holocaust

692 words - 3 pages Women and the Holocaust      The Jewish female is like the ovule of a flower, it spreads its seeds to create future generations. It is known that the true root of a Jewish person lies in the hands of his/her mother. As it was once said by Golda Meir, “To be successful, a woman has to be much better at her job than a man.â€? (Golda Meir Quotes par. 1). And in fact it is true, that women had to be better than man to

Similar Essays

Slavery And The American Revolution Essay

1493 words - 6 pages As the slave population in the United States of America grew to 500,000 in 1176, documenting slavery as part of the American Revolution became increasingly important. America was rooted in slavery; and it contributed to the economy and social structure. The revolution forced citizens of the new nation to be conscious of slavery and its potential dismissal from every day life. Two articles that prove slavery only succeeded because of the false

Slavery And The American Constitution Essay

632 words - 3 pages 700,000 slaves (18% of the population) in the United States of America. The idea of slavery in America was based on race and wealth. Patriots were talking about liberty and equality and it was one of the things the American Revolution of 1775 had set out to do as did the Constitution in granting American’s rights within the Preamble. However, African American slaves felt that they should be granted the same rights under the

Slavery And The American Revolution Essay

790 words - 3 pages The American Revolution caused changes in America other than the formation of an independent nation. Not only was there great change in political structure, aspects of social culture, especially slavery, were influenced by the revolution as well. The ideology of the revolution caused a positive step forward by emancipating slaves in both the North and the South. However, a technological breakthrough not only halted the social progression that

Comparing Slavery Of The South And North

1785 words - 8 pages ……………………………………………………………………………...6   Comparing Slavery of the South and North Introduction: The Americas (north and south) was referred to as the new world since they had recently been discovered by the Europeans. The Spanish, Portuguese and the Dutch resolutely instituted slavery in the Americas by the 1600s. Slavery refers to the practice of holding a person in bondage for labor. Nonetheless, slavery was not new to the Native Americans; it was a common practice