Comparing Amish And North American Society

934 words - 4 pages

Comparing Amish and North American Society

We can compare Amish society as seen in the movie Witness to North American society to decide which is more ideal. An ideal society is one where there is a strong sense of community among all the members. Education prepares children for life; therefore the type of education a child receives will change the society in the next generation. Although education is valued in both societies, its focus is much different. The Laws of a society reflect the values of a community, and it shows what they consider to be right and wrong. Each society has laws that reflect its values; however the way the laws are expressed is much different. Family life in a society is important, because families bring the community together. Though children are valued in both the societies, family life is different between the two when comparing the roles of the husband and the wife. The Amish lifestyle is more ideal because there is a better sense of community within the society.
Education in both societies is recognized as important. We see this in both societies because of the mandatory education laws. However, the focus of the education in each society is different. In North American society the focus of education is quite broad; to graduate highschool a person must have language, physical education, science, english and arts credits. Also, it is mandatory to attend school until grade 10. In Amish society however, school is only required up to grade 8. The education is much more focused on the practical side of things. For boys, it is important to learn how to work on the farm, not paint pictures. This is also why they are let out of school earlier; so that at the age that they are strong enough to work on the farm, they are free to do so. Thus Amish lifestyle is more ideal, because their education prepares the children for what they will do later in life.
The laws of each society show the values of that society. In North America the laws show that their society values equality, as there are many laws about the treatment of different cultures and races. In the Amish society, the law that doesn’t permit them to wear buttons reflects their value of not being vain, and the rule about not listening to music shows that they value not being worldly. Thus the values of both the societies are reflected in their laws. The difference in the laws of the two societies is the way they are kept and followed. In North America, the laws are all written down meticulously and are taken word for word. An example of this is, a few years ago, the supreme court let a man go who had...

Find Another Essay On Comparing Amish and North American Society

Comparing Slavery of the South and North

1785 words - 8 pages ……………………………………………………………………………...6   Comparing Slavery of the South and North Introduction: The Americas (north and south) was referred to as the new world since they had recently been discovered by the Europeans. The Spanish, Portuguese and the Dutch resolutely instituted slavery in the Americas by the 1600s. Slavery refers to the practice of holding a person in bondage for labor. Nonetheless, slavery was not new to the Native Americans; it was a common practice

Comparing Society in The Dharma Bums and The New American Poetry

1392 words - 6 pages Mass Society in The Dharma Bums and The New American Poetry       One of the best ways to fully understand an era is to study its literature. The printed word has the incredible capacity to both reflect and shape the hopes, fears, and ideologies of the time. This is very evident when reading literature from 1960's America, a turbulent period in the history of our country. While the authors' styles are very different, there are

Native North American Culture and Its Demise

654 words - 3 pages , in North America many Native ethnic groups’ cultures were destroyed by British, French and Dutch colonizers. The cruel results of European attempts to tear through Aboriginal society and extract all aspects of non-Christian culture and religion can still be felt today. Through establishments like reservations and internment schools and military action, the Euro-American/Canadian governments were able to destroy most of Native Canadians and

North and South American Yanomamo Culture

1259 words - 5 pages There are many differences between the South American Yanomamo culture and the North American culture that we have adapted to, but just at there is culture diversity between us, we have some similarities. The ethnography, which is chose, was “Yanomamo” written by Napoleon A. Chagnon, anthropologists. Chagnon tells us how to it was to live among the Yanomamo family, political and warfare system versus the American Culture. The

Terrorism and American Society

3338 words - 13 pages , the United States can adopt a foreign policy that supports military restrain especially in intrastate conflicts that do not affect its interests. Therefore, a change of foreign policy that limits American engagement in international situations will reduce the social, economic, and political impacts of terrorism on the American society. Methodology This research paper utilized secondary sources of data. This strategy ensured that maximum data

The Clash Between Amish Culture and Modern American Culture in the Film Witness

3390 words - 14 pages eat together. The women also work on the embroidery. All of the women's work is highly valued and the women are very well respected in an Amish community. All of the tasks, such as milking the cows, are done by hand which is very time consuming so they have to get up at a very early time in the morning to start. North America in this film is shown as a violent, corrupt, ruthless, aggressive society, even the police

Comparing the Inuits and the North-West People

1927 words - 8 pages Comparing the Inuits and the north-west people We have been studying the people of the North West and Inuits. In this essay I will describe their differences and explain why they are different. They have a large variety of differences which had a large effect on lifestyles. Housing The Inuits lives in snow houses known as Igloos. They houses were made out of snow as it was plentiful in the area they lived in. The snow was many metres thick so

Comparing and Contrasting American and Japanese Marketing

2209 words - 9 pages factories within the United States’ borders. Japan does not currently have such import quota laws to deal with in their own country, but its marketing is affected on an international scale. The United States also has the legal issues such as the North American Free Trade Agreement, which allows for open trade among the North American countries. This has allowed American companies to produce their products in Mexico at much cheaper labor and

Technological Advancements and American Society

1297 words - 5 pages Advances in technology and American Society Today Americans wake up in the morning to their automated coffee brewers, drive to work relying on their global positioning system (GPS), and arrive at work where they use e-mail, video conferencing, and numerous other technological devices all day. To say that technology has changed the way that Americans live their life today would be an understatement. Advances in technology affect many areas of

Body Image and American Society

809 words - 3 pages --and is making just as much money as previously (Tauber and Hannah 133). She explains that the average woman has curves and while she's not gigantic, she's not skinny either (133). The fact that most women are larger than what society tells her should sound an alarm. There is nothing more obvious than the fact that the American culture is telling women that they should be very, very thin. While perhaps some women can shrug off such images--like

North American Society Relected in John Updike's Short Story A & P

898 words - 4 pages North American Society Relected in John Updike's Short Story A & P At first glance, John Updike's short story A & P seems to be another coming of age piece. But with taking a deeper look, in many ways you see how the A & P grocery store could be viewed as microcosm of North American society in the 1960's - and it's not a very positive portrait. The general bleakness of the people, the accepted coldness of the store itself, and the theme of

Similar Essays

Comparing And Contrasting Amish And Muslim Americans

3819 words - 15 pages daily lives. Unfortunately, the way they are often perceived in modern American society is through stereotypes. Upon further research and reflection, we will gain a deeper understanding of 2 of these religiously influenced cultures, and discover why they aren't as different as they appear on the surface.No two cultures in Pennsylvania could seem more contrasting than the Amish and Arab-American Muslim communities. In all appearances they could not be

Comparing The North American Colonies Essay

1307 words - 5 pages /Jdn/writing/8teen.html>Elson, Henry William. Occupations and Customs. 20 September 2004.~Religion; Education; Medicine. 20 September 2004.< http://www.usahistory.info/colonial/education.html>Goldfield, David , Carl Abbott, Virginia Dejohn Anderson, Jo Ann E. Argersinger,Peter H. Argersinger, William L. Bareny, Robert M. Weir. The American Journey: A History of the United States. Brief Third Edition. Volume One. New Jersey. Pearson, 2002.Salisbury, Neal. Indian-White Relations in North America before 1776.Encyclopedia of North American Indians. 24 September 2004.

Cultural Change And Survival In Amish Society

5570 words - 22 pages . The Amish believe in voluntary baptism, which some consider odd. But voluntary baptism serves an important purpose. It allows Amish youth to experiment with the outside world and see if they wish join the Amish church and make the permanent commitment of living a godly life. Amish youth may own cars, listen to rock music, go to movies, and explore other aspects of American society during their late adolescents. It is striking that 80% of the

Comparing The North And South Essay

952 words - 4 pages . Rhode Island and Pennsylvania passed laws to keep African Americans from voting. Most communities did not allow African Americans to attend public school or other public services. African Americans were forced to attend poor quality schools and go to hospitals reserved only for them. Freedom’s Journal was the first African American newspaper. It was written by Samuel Cornish and John B. Russwurm. Most African Americans in the North lived in poverty