Comparing And Contrasting Four Leadership Models And Theories

2156 words - 9 pages

The following paper outlines the comparison and contrast of four leadership models and theories. The purpose of this paper is to acquaint readers with the basic concepts underlying each model and theory. A review of the scholarly studies on leadership shows that there is a wide variety of different theoretical approaches to explain the complexities of the leadership process (e.g., Bass, 1990; Bryman, 1992; Gardner, 1990; Hickman 1998; Rost, 1991). Some researchers conceptualize as a trait, or as behavior, while others view leadership from a political perspective, or from a humanistic viewpoint.The paper begins with a description of leadership trait theory, a theory that concerns itself solely with leader characteristics. Following this, two theories are reviewed. They are: transactional leadership and contingency approach to leadership. The paper concludes with a look at transformational leadership. Although these leadership theories or models could be considered contingency models, they are addressed separately because of the emphasis that they place on morality and follower development.Trait TheoryIn the early 1900s, leadership traits were studied to determine what made certain people great leaders. The theories that were developed were called, "great man" theories because they focused on identifying the innate qualities and characteristics possessed by great social, political, and military leaders (e.g. Thomas Jefferson, Abraham Lincoln, and Mohandas Gandhi). It was believed that people were born with these traits and only "great" people possessed them. During this time research concentrated on determining the specific traits that clearly differentiated leaders from followers (Bass, 1990; Jago, 1982). Although different researchers identified a variety of leadership traits and characteristics, it is generally thought that there are five major leadership traits: intelligence, self-confidence, determination, integrity, and sociability.In the mid-1900s, the trait approach was challenged by research that questioned the universality of leadership traits. In a major review in 1948, Stogdill suggested that no consistent sets of traits differentiated leaders from non-leaders across a variety of situations. An individual with leadership traits who was a leader in one situation cannot be a leader in another situation. Rather than being in quantity that individual possessed, leadership was reconceptualized as a relationship between people in social situation (Stogdill, 1948).Because the trait approach focus on the leader, however, and not on the followers or the situation, researchers failed to discover any traits that would guarantee leadership success. Early trait theorists assumed that leadership was innate. They failed to acknowledge that being in a leadership role might facilitate the development of leadership traits. Also the theory neglected to account for why some individuals might be effective leaders in certain circumstances yet not in...

Find Another Essay On Comparing and Contrasting Four Leadership Models and Theories

Contrasting and Comparing, "PS2/Xbox" Essay

632 words - 3 pages Comparing and Contrasting PS2/Xbox They are both game consoles, are marked at the same price, and sold to millions of users around the world. Sony's Playstation 2 and Microsoft Xbox have many similarities, but there are also many differences between them. PS2 provides four unique controller modules: the Dual Shock Analog Controller that may be purchased in four different colors, the Dual Shock 2 Analog Controller that comes

Comparing and Contrasting The Outsiders Essay

802 words - 4 pages group of friends, you will find that he is a gold-hearted person. Although the movie and the book, both entitled The Outsiders, contain several similarities, they have many differences as well. To begin with, when comparing the book and the movie, you will find they both tell the story of fourteen-year-old Ponyboy Curtis who is the youngest brother in the Curtis family. He earns good grades, loves sunsets, and grows up in Tulsa, Oklahoma, in a

Comparing and Contrasting Labor Unions

805 words - 4 pages During the Victorian age, and up until about the 20s, labor unions were new developments. They had existed before, but on a much smaller scale. The labor unions that did exist were all vastly different. Some were conservative, while others were extremely radical. The Industrial Workers of the World are an example of a more radical group, while the American Federation of Labor is more conservative. The two unions had contrasting opinions to the

Comparing and Contrasting Structuralism and Behaviorism

582 words - 3 pages In this paper I will be comparing and contrasting to very different theories in psychology, structuralism and behaviorism. Under the theory of structuralism psychologists mainly used introspection to describe mental life. Whereas, in behaviorism psychologist try to observe the behavior of living things in the universe. Throughout this paper I will be looking into the validity and acceptance of both theories. In structuralism, psychologists use

Comparing and Contrasting Scientific realism and Phenomenology

1008 words - 5 pages test the limits and validity of the knowledge that are created from research. The objective of this paper to is to explore two differing epistemologies by comparing and contrasting how they arrive at the “truth” of science and the production of knowledge. A historical perspective will be given in order to provide a framework for understanding how these differing epistemologies emerged. Scientific realism and phenomenology provide an interesting

Comparing and contrasting HP and DELL

3429 words - 14 pages Comparing and Contrasting HP and DELL Scope and OutlineThe scope of the report is to compare the practices followed in two companies, "Hewlett-Packard" and "Dell Computers", and the reasons for their success. The comparison is done on the basis of structure, technology, culture, fit with the environment.The outline of the report is as follows:Brief introductionOrganization structureTechnology and systemsCultureFit with environmentFuture

Comparing And Contrasting Jesus And Mohammad

1644 words - 7 pages Comparing and contrasting Jesus and Mohammed Jesus & Mohammed Jesus and Muhammad are two very different individuals that have kind of a similar history and at the same time a very different history. They both break off from an established religion and started their own. They had been banished by the other religions and the cities they lived in. Most religions are thought to be separate and different than any other religions. As

Comparing and Contrasting Military and Civilian Jobs

605 words - 2 pages I have worked many types of jobs. I have worked in the civilian world and the military world. There are so many people in the world that don't see or understand what kind of similarities or differences there are between the two. I have enjoyed working both types of jobs and I like them both so much that currently I am working in the military and civilian world. When comparing and contrasting a civilian job versus a military job you will find

Comparing and contrasting homeschool and public school

995 words - 4 pages well as I can because it is important to consider all of the facts when comparing and contrasting anything. It is especially important when covering a subject as widely debated as forms of education for youth. Even though similarities are few in number, they are still there, and they are important. Firstly, all children are taught through textbooks, teachers, worksheets, or online material regardless of whether they are studying it at their

Comparing and Contrasting Revelation and Hebrews

1389 words - 6 pages Comparing and contrasting different written works is a key aspect to discovering truths about the Christian Bible. When we compare and contrast canonical books, we can learn many things about the theology and context in which these books were written. Today, we will be comparing two books from the New Testament: Hebrews and Revelation. While Hebrews is often referred to as an epistle, it is actually more similar to a sermon. Revelation is a book

Comparing and Contrasting Mirandolla and Machiavelli

636 words - 3 pages This compare and contrast essay will focus on the views of leadership between Mirandolla and Machiavelli. Mirandolla believes that leadership should not be false and that it should follow the rule of reason. He believes that leaders should strive for the heavens and beyond. On the other hand, Machiavelli believed that leadership comes to those who are crafty and forceful. He believed that leaders do not need to be merciful, humane, faithful or

Similar Essays

Comparing And Contrasting Leadership Models Essay

2167 words - 9 pages Comparing and Contrasting Four Leadership Models and TheoriesThe following paper outlines the comparison and contrast of four leadership models and theories. The purpose of this paper is to acquaint readers with the basic concepts underlying each model and theory. A review of the scholarly studies on leadership shows that there is a wide variety of different theoretical approaches to explain the complexities of the leadership process (e.g., Bass

Comparing And Contrasting Two Of The Four Models Of Stress

1430 words - 6 pages This essay aims to compare and contrast two of the four models of stress; Hans Selye’s (1907-1982) general adaptation syndrome (GAS) and Mowrer (1939) avoidance model. Firstly, the author will give published definitions of the term stress; the author will then briefly discuss the term stress. This essay will look at the Selye (1956) general adaptation syndrome and Mowrer (1939) avoidance model of stress and then compare and contrast both models

The Relevant Concepts, Theories, And Models About Leadership

3434 words - 14 pages Assignment aim and structure: The aim of this assignment is to analyze the relevant concepts, theories and models about leadership and describe one person who could be identified as leader and analyze how effective this person’s leadership is and why it is effective. Defining what is leadership comes first, second will provide an overview about my organization and the importance of leadership. Moving forward will address the different type of

Leadership Models And Communication Essay

1117 words - 4 pages these leaders can therefore be termed as ineffective leaders. Therefore, leadership is not limited to a role, rather leadership skills comes from within.Transformational leaders set challenging expectations and enable others to achieve higher levels of performance. Bass (1985) depicted transformational leadership as comprising of four distinct factors: charisma, inspiration, individual consideration and intellectual stimulation (p. 178).A basic