Comparing And Contrasting Hughes's Mother To Son And Wilbur's The Writer

1111 words - 4 pages

Comparing and Contrasting Hughes's Mother to Son and Wilbur's The Writer

Whether life is a steep climb up a shaky stairway or a challenging voyage over rough seas, a parent hopes a child will persevere to the end. In Langston Hughes's poem "Mother to Son" and in Richard Wilbur's poem "The Writer," the poets use the voice of a parent considering a child's future, and both use imagery of struggle and survival to suggest what lies ahead for the child. Although the point of view, context, and language of the two poems differ significantly, the message is the same: a parent wants a good life for his or her child, but knows that many obstacles can block the way.

While Hughes and Wilbur share a similar message in their poems, their points of view are very different. Hughes uses a first-person narrator, a mother speaking directly to her son. The title of the poem itself, "Mother to Son," states this point of view. The reader is listening in on a one-on-one conversation. The opening line introduces the mother's monologue: "Well, son, I'll tell you." The point of view stays consistent as the mother describes what life's stairway has been like for her: "Life for me ain't been no crystal stair" (2 and 20), and urges her son to do as she has done: "I'se still climbin'" (19). She addresses her son directly throughout the poem, calling him "son" (1), "boy" (14), and "honey" (18). The poem is entirely in the mother's speaking voice, with the informalities of someone speaking privately to a close relative and the grammatical errors of someone who is probably not well educated.

Richard Wilbur's poem is also written in the first person, but the narrator does not address his daughter directly until the final stanza (31-33). The first thirty lines of the poem are addressed to the reader, as the narrator describes two scenes that take place in the family's house. One scene is taking place now: "My daughter is writing a story" (3), and one scene took place in the past: "I remember..." (16) "two years ago" (17). Because the narrator is addressing the reader instead of his daughter herself, most of Wilbur's poem seems less immediate than Hughes's does. The title of Wilbur's poem, "The Writer," sets some distance between the narrator and his daughter. This is not "Father to Daughter." Writing about someone is at least one step removed from talking to someone. There are three levels to Wilbur's poem that reflect three writers: the daughter who is writing a poem, the father who is observing her, and Wilbur himself who is writing about the two of them. The narrator's voice is the formal voice of a writer, especially one who is well educated. The narrator uses a less familiar vocabulary, with nautical terms such as "prow" (1) and "gunwale" (6). The narrator also uses non-conversational sentence structure, for example, "Young as she is, the stuff of her life is a great cargo, and some of it heavy" (7-8). Only in the final stanza does the narrator address his...

Find Another Essay On Comparing and Contrasting Hughes's Mother to Son and Wilbur's The Writer

Poetry Analysis: Mother to Son and Those Winter Sundays

1407 words - 6 pages from their experience. Parents always make sacrifices to provide for their family. In the poem “Mother to Son” by Langston Huges and “Those Winter Sundays” by Robert Hayden, the poets talk about how the parents are always making sacrifices to make their children’s life a little bit easier. Both of these poems reveal the struggle the parents go through in order to provide for their family. Whenever someone mentions the word “mother”, one always

Perseverance in Mother to Son and The Negro Speaks of Rivers by Langston Hughes

975 words - 4 pages The founding fathers constructed the Constitution with the notion that “all men were created equal.” However, many minorities still struggle for the same rights and opportunities as others. “Mother to Son” and “The Negro Speaks of Rivers” are poems written by Langston Hughes that use symbolism to exemplify the struggles of African Americans as they attempt to persevere through adversity. Hughes utilizes the stairs in “Mother to Son” and the

Symbolic Imagery in Langston Hughes' Poems, The Negro Speaks of Rivers and Mother To Son

1787 words - 7 pages Symbolic Imagery in Langston Hughes' Poems, The Negro Speaks of Rivers and Mother To Son Langston Hughes uses symbolism throughout his poetry. In the poems 'The Negro Speaks of Rivers' and 'Mother To Son', Langston Hughes uses symbolism to convey his meaning of the poems to the readers. Readers may make many interpretations about the symbols used throughout these poems. Throughout the poem 'The Negro Speaks of Rivers' Hughes

Essay on Hardships Expressed in Hughes On the Road and Mother to Son

1521 words - 6 pages Hardships Expressed in Hughes On the Road and Mother to Son African-American citizens who live in the United States have experienced a tough life through personal experiences. They have struggled to obtain basic civil rights--a struggle that has spanned many centuries (Mabunda 311). Langston Hughes, author of the short story "On the Road" and the poem "Mother to Son," often illustrated in his writing the hardships experienced by the

Comparing and Contrasting Speeches

1444 words - 6 pages Gettysburg Address and the Iron Curtain are very comparable speeches, in content and delivery. Abraham Lincoln, US president, delivered his famous speech , The Gettysburg Address, on November 19, 1863 in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania. Only about 80 years later, Winston Churchill, British Prime Minister, gave his famous speech the Iron Curtain on March 5, 1946 in Fulton, Missouri. Both of these speeches were meant to rally the American people. Each of the

Contrasting and Comparing, "PS2/Xbox"

632 words - 3 pages Comparing and Contrasting PS2/Xbox They are both game consoles, are marked at the same price, and sold to millions of users around the world. Sony's Playstation 2 and Microsoft Xbox have many similarities, but there are also many differences between them. PS2 provides four unique controller modules: the Dual Shock Analog Controller that may be purchased in four different colors, the Dual Shock 2 Analog Controller that comes

Comparing and Contrasting Leadership Models

2167 words - 9 pages Comparing and Contrasting Four Leadership Models and TheoriesThe following paper outlines the comparison and contrast of four leadership models and theories. The purpose of this paper is to acquaint readers with the basic concepts underlying each model and theory. A review of the scholarly studies on leadership shows that there is a wide variety of different theoretical approaches to explain the complexities of the leadership process (e.g., Bass

Rationale for Commerce in the school curriculum - explaining to a mother and son why commerce studies is essential

969 words - 4 pages The Value of Commerce EducationRationalePoints to I would discuss with the mother and son:The Commerce subject falls under the Studies of Society and the Environment (SOSE) learning area of the Curriculum and Standards Framework (CSF). "SOSE is a study of human progress and how people have organized themselves into societies over time, and how they have interacted with their physical environments" (CSF). I believe the knowledge students gain

Everyday Use, comparing and contrasting the short story of Alice Walker, to the short movie.

1118 words - 4 pages Use," short film was more story oriented as it showed what Mama only described in the text: "Maggie will be nervous until after her sister goes: she will stand hopelessly in corners, homely and ashamed of the burn scars down her arms and legs, eying her sister with a mixture of envy and awe." (WALKER 120) Mama was explaining how Maggie would feel when Dee comes to visit. In the movie, viewers had to wait and see until Dee's arrival to see

Comparing and Contrasting "The Miller's Tale" and "The Reeve's Tale"

947 words - 4 pages "The Miller's Tale" and "The Reeve's Tale", two stories in Geoffrey Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales, are fabliaux, bawdy and comic tales that build to a ridiculous and complex climax usually hinging on some joke or trick. One parallel observed between the two stories is the unfaithfulness of the wife in marriage. Another similarity between the two stories is the theme of a husband who tries to keep control of his wife. In addition, the

"Thirteen Days": Comparing and Contrasting the Book and the Movie

760 words - 3 pages "Thirteen Days", written by Robert F. Kennedy, is an account of the Cuban Missile Crisis based on the view of Robert F. Kennedy. This book contains Kennedy's thoughts about the Cuban Missile Crisis and the actions that he and the rest of the United States cabinet took to prevent a nuclear disaster and World War III. There is also a movie based on the book starring Kevin Costner. Most movies that are based on books are often exceeding inaccurate

Similar Essays

Comparing And Contrasting The Poems, Carpenter’s Complaint And Coolie Mother

1143 words - 5 pages saving the money and working hard because her son Harilall had to go to school in Georgetown and had to wear clean starch pants or else they would laugh at him. He had to read book talk proper, take exam and go to England university, so that he didn’t turn out like his father who was a drunkard, and didn’t help out Jasmattie at all. The two poems ‘Carpenter’s Complaint’ by Edward Baugh and ‘Coolie Mother’ by David Dabydeen shared many

Cross Genre Mother To Son And The Bean Trees

659 words - 3 pages splinters, and boards torn up, and places with no carpet on the floor." She means that her life has been full of many different hardships, just like an old house can have many problems. In comparing this old house to her life, she utilizes the literary elements metaphor. Using a metaphor helps convey the feelings of the speaker, and therefore the author. The theme of this poem is the mother telling the son not to give up in his life, inspiring

Comparing And Contrasting Paganism To Christianity

2427 words - 10 pages approved way. “All Scripture is breathed out by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be competent, equipped for every good work.”(2 Timothy 3:16-17). The instructions given in The Bible teach its follows to deal with situations in their lives how God or his son Jesus would. That means being slow to judge and quick to forgive even when you have been done wrong to. The

Comparing And Contrasting Digging And The Follower

1914 words - 8 pages Comparing and Contrasting Digging and The Follower In this essay I will be giving quotes and explaining about two pieces of poetry, written by Seamus Heaney. The two poems I will be writing on will contrast and his memories on his rural childhood. The poems will be "the follower" which takes us back to Heaney as a child wanting to follow in his father's footsteps. I will also be writing on "digging", which takes us