Comparing And Contrasting &Quot;My Papa's Waltz&Quot; And &Quot;Piano&Quot;

923 words - 4 pages

In comparing and contrasting the poems, "My Papa's Waltz" by Theodore Roethke and "Piano" by D. H. Lawrence, the reader could also compare and contrast the childhood lives of the poets themselves. Roethke's father, Otto Roethke, was a drunk and a figure of terror to his son (Seager 26). His mother was an angry woman and Theodore was a desperate child consistently in the middle of his parent's opposition (Seager 28). D.H. Lawrence's father was a drunk, almost illiterate miner (Squires and Talbot 34). His mother; however, was educated, refined, and pious, ruling the lives of her sons (Squires and Talbot 42). Reviewing the form, tone, and imagery of both poems, the attitude of the boy towards his father in Roethke's "My Papa's Waltz" allows the reader to observe the poet's ironic tone contrasting with the attitude of the boy towards his childhood in Lawrence's "Piano", allowing us to sense a more melancholy tone.

The poems are similar in form. Roethke uses closed form in "My Papa's Waltz" (Seager 165). The work has a distinct structure and rhyme scheme. There are four stanzas within the poem and each stanza consists of four lines (435). The lines of the poem are either six or seven syllables and create a concise meter for the work. The quatrains of "My Papa's Waltz" are an alternating rhyme pattern of a b a b. For example:

We romped until the pans

Slid from the kitchen shelf;

My mother's countenance

Could not unfrown itself. (5-8)

Lawrence also uses closed form in "Piano" (Squires and Talbot 329) with a distinct structure and rhyme scheme. There are three stanzas within this poem and each stanza consists of four lines (520) creating a concise meter for the work. The quatrains of "Piano" have line rhymes as couplets: a a b b. For example:

Softly in the dusk, a woman is singing to me;

Taking me back down the vistas of years, til I see

A child sitting under the piano, in the boom of the tingling strings

And pressing the small, poised feet of a mother who smiles as she sings. (1-4)

The reflection of each poet's childhood is displayed within these lines helping to build a tone for the memories of each narrator.

The tone of "My Papa's Waltz" differs from the tone in "Piano." The ironic tone of the first poem is one of a young man looking back in fear of his father. "But I hung on like death.../The hand that held my wrist.../You beat time on my head..." (3-13). The reader senses a painful scene, which the father appears to hurt and demean his son. On the other hand, the tone of "Piano" is more melancholy. "In spite of myself.../Betrays me back.../To the old Sunday evenings at home..." (5-7). The reader can feel the lyrical and longing tone in the narrator's description of a man who wishes he could go back in time to his childhood...

Find Another Essay On Comparing and Contrasting "My Papa's Waltz" and "Piano"

Tennessee Williams: His Life in "Suddenly Last Summer" and "The Glass Menagerie"

3627 words - 15 pages is the country of my heart as well as my birth" (1: Holditch/ Leavitt, "Tennesse Williams and the South", pp 88), reflecting his deep love for the South. This change in Williams's life meant the end of the Southern idyll and the beginning of a new but unhappy time which would be marked by the isolation and internal conflicts. Later, his father withdrew him from the University and pushed him onto the warehouse of a shoe company where he felt

A Close Ananlysis of "Daddy" and "Zonnebeke Road"

1885 words - 8 pages Sylvia Plath's case. Although she resented and hated her father for what he stood for in her past, she still loved him and was devastated when he died. "Bit my pretty red heart in two. I was ten when they buried you." There is a definite structure to the poem but the images created are still mixed up throughout the stanzas. This emulates Sylvia's state of mind at the time of writing this poem; she has mixed emotions towards her father that

"Bag Lady" A Critique and Analysis

1803 words - 7 pages will hide their true feelings with their good looking hairdos, nice clothing, and phony smiles. In the end, the person that they got involved with will notice their true colors and take off running because they do not want to deal with what ever issue that woman has. The fourth verse ties into the proceeding verse when she says "One day he gon' say you crowding my space" (Badu) and the verse is repeated three times, with the last line in this

Descartes and His "Crazy Thought Experiment"

1476 words - 6 pages they make my original cause, the more likely it is that I am so imperfect as to be deceived all the time - because deceptions and error to be imperfections" ). This is where the idea of an `evil demon' comes into play. He wonders if the God he has always believed in might actually be a malevolent Demon using his power to deceive us even about our own thoughts and, ultimately, existence. To shame this demon, Descartes believes, he must avoid

"El Corazon Lowrider"

676 words - 3 pages The bright colors caught my eye and the image reminded me a little of my hometown. Where I come from there's a large range of ethnicity and when I saw this lithograph it brought back old memories. Of when, I guess you can call them thugs, would drive up and down the streets of Dumas in there decked out lowriders thinking they were the coolest thing since sliced bread. In my opinion I always thought low riders were absurd and that they were

"A Doll's House"

1003 words - 4 pages is seemingly what leads her down the path to her own independence. It is through the disillusionment that Nora undeniably felt towards her husband Torvald and the world that she finally comprehends her unmitigated state of repression. Nora clearly represents the doll of the house and Torvald's dehumanization of her is flagrant throughout the story. He relentlessly refers to his wife through the use of pet names such as "my little skylark

The "Patriot Act"

1269 words - 5 pages Nixon's executive power to conduct warrantless wiretaps and now it is been done. The Bryant letter declares that "As commander-in-Chief, the President must be able to use whatever means necessary to prevent attacks upon the United States."* In my opinion this Act is reasonable if used under self defense. "If the government's heightened interest in self-defense justifies the use of deadly force, then it certainly would also justify warrantless

"A Domestic Dilemma"

1956 words - 8 pages nightgown and go to sleep. My children turned away from me. Andy looked at his mother and turned away. She was caught in the rhythmic sorrow of alcohol"(77). The physical effects can be just as bad as the psychological effects. Once a person becomes addicted, the most immediate effect is withdrawal. Addiction often includes physical dependence on the substance. When the presence of the substance suddenly decreases, the person's body

Cognitions on Craft and Culture in "My Last Duchess"

1515 words - 6 pages ). Scanning Robert Browning's poem "My Last Duchess," one immediately notices that Browning has rigorously adhered to a pattern of ten syllables per line.  The casual scholar will be tempted to follow the leading tradition of English versification and immediately label the meter of the poem "iambic pentameter."  However, examination of the word and rhetorical accents within each line casts significant doubt upon the accuracy of such a

James Joyce's "The Dead"

1339 words - 5 pages ritual is Mary Jane playing the piano, something she does every year. Gabriel "doubted whether it had any melody for the other listeners" (Joyce 861). Despite this apparent lack of talent, Mary Jane continues to play every year and nobody informs her that her piano playing is not very good. These are both examples of something common to all the characters. They are all emotionally unavailable and simply observe each other unwilling to really know

Freedom in "Hedda Gabler"

800 words - 3 pages hoping to inspire George as she did Eilert. After all remaining limited power Hedda had disappears; Hedda acknowledges Thea's victory. She plays one last song on the piano and admits defeat, "Not free. Still not free!...From now on I'll be quiet." Hedda's overall problem is she denied her own freedom in order to have the self-esteem that comes with personal achievement. Her attempts to retain her independence within a society that won't let her and

Similar Essays

Comparing And Contrasting &Quot;The Ring&Quot; And &Quot;Ringu&Quot;

1332 words - 5 pages their last seven days of life. It keeps the movie on track and gives you an idea of just how close someone was to dying. My favorite line in the movie is, "before you die, you see the ring." This makes a direct correlation between the video and the video watcher's experiences. While watching Ringu, I found myself to be lost at times, wondering where exactly the movie was going, and what the images in the video even meant. Without the

&Quot;My Faith&Quot; Essay

957 words - 4 pages According to Hill, faith is a human act of will and a gift from God, involving deep emotions and trust in ourselves and others, and requiring us to be involved with other groups and communities. As it stands today, I believe that I can place myself in the middle range of Stage 4 of faith development. However, I wasn't always this confident in my relationship with God. Until recent changes in my life, there is no doubt in my mind that my faith

Reflections And Interpretations On &Quot;Digging&Quot; Essay

1015 words - 4 pages man. / My grandfather cut more turf in a day / Than any other man on Toner's bog." ("Digging" 15-18). In this setting the main character makes it clear that his father and grandfather were very hard workingmen and also took pride in their work. But, you will soon see that the main character uses the descriptions of his father and grandfather to help describe himself as a person. Some of the imagery that you can get from the

Sonnetts; &Quot;The Long Love&Quot; And &Quot;Love That Doth Reign&Quot;

821 words - 3 pages understand then Wyatt's difficult language for instance the expression for love reflecting on face is expressed by Surrey as "Oft in my face he doth his banner rest" and Wyatt expressed it as "Into my face presseth with bold pretence." Comparing both it is easy to grasp Surrey's language then Wyatt's; his language and structure is complex. Wyatt's language has strong and forceful impression its more business like. Surrey's is more of a complimentary and