This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing Burgess And Draper's Theory Of Family Violence And The Film, The Burning Bed

2156 words - 9 pages

Comparing Burgess and Draper's Theory of Family Violence and the Film, The Burning Bed
 

I.  Introduction

     Burgess and Draper argue coercive patterns of family interaction represent the principal causal pathway that connects ecological instability to violence within families.  They maintain this raises the possibility that some of the common correlates of such violence are themselves reactions to sudden or chronic ecological instability.  For example, alcoholism, depression, and anxiety may be responses to ecological stresses in the family, such as loss of employment, excessive financial debt, or divorce.  Burgess and Draper suggest that violence towards one's mate or children may consequently be a direct result of ecological instability.  They argue that certain individual traits (e.g. problem drinking), which have previously been assumed to precipitate violent behavior, may actually be the result of the same factors that lead to family violence itself.

     The movie, The Burning Bed, is a made for TV movie centered on the issue of family violence.  The main characters were Francine and Mickey Hughes, a battered wife and abusive husband.  In the story, Francine struggled with Mickey's violence and intimidation for the better part of twenty years and finally ended up killing him in his sleep.  It is a vivid and realistic movie about domestic violence and the way society viewed such violence in the not so distant past.  By comparing the movie to Burgess and Draper's hypothesis, some agreements and some disagreements become apparent.  Do Burgess and Draper adequately explain and predict the Hughes's pattern of domestic violence?

 

II.  Ecological Instability

     Ecological instability describes when a person is in a situation, either perceived or actual, that is not the ideal.  It can describe a time of lacking or need and usually is not thought of as a good time.  These periods can be short lived or take years and years to run their course.  Causes of ecological instability may be the result of divorce, loss of employment, debilitating injury, excessive financial debt or something like a natural disaster.  Whatever the cause, the person in the situation feels like a victim and begins to think and behave as one.

 

     Burgess and Draper emphasis the importance of cultural norms and stability of the environment. (Ohlin, 71)  This stability is, supposedly, what every person in society is working to achieve.  As resources decline, stress builds proportionally.  Economic or psychosocial insecurities brought on by the loss of a job (as in Mickey Hughes' case) translate into sexual insecurity as well.  Social indicators of family violence should be regarded as "markers" of ecological instability when couple's stress exceeds their resources.  Therefor, families marked with unemployment or underemployment, have higher rates of family violence. (Ohlin, 87)

 

     Values in American society expect males to be...

Find Another Essay On Comparing Burgess and Draper's Theory of Family Violence and the Film, The Burning Bed

Bad Burning and Family Loyalty Essay

1530 words - 7 pages “Barn Burning” and Family Loyalty William Faulkner’s narrative “Barn Burning” highlights one of the most complex humanistic behaviors that has endured the test of time and is still relevant today. All cultures throughout history have placed an emphasis on familial loyalty to some degree or fashion and for the majority of people the bonds shared with those to whom one is directly related to are perhaps the most sacred and binding relationships

The Symbolic Interaction Theory and My Family

1460 words - 6 pages The Symbolic Interaction theory refers to ways in which a family or society attaches meaning to verbal communication, non-verbal communication, people, and objects. We are taught from a young age communication using verbal language and accepted ways to express our needs. The theory represents perception of objects or actions (Macionis, 2007, p.17). Members of a family learn what is acceptable within the family. We also can know through body

Comparing the Beginning of the Novel and the Film Of Mice and Men

1555 words - 6 pages Comparing the Beginning of the Novel and the Film Of Mice and Men Like any writer or director, John Steinbeck and Gary Sinise set out to grab the audience's attention. Although the novel and the film are based on the same story, John Steinbeck and Gary Sinise immediately involve the audience in different ways. When writing "Of Mice and Men" John Steinbeck draws the reader in by mainly describing the setting. In the

Comparing the Film and the Novel of Hemingway's Old Man and the Sea

2203 words - 9 pages Comparing the Film and the Novel of Hemingway's Old Man and the Sea After having read the Hemingway's "Old Man and the Sea" as a book in class, we also watched the film which was made afterwards because of the story's enormous popularity. As

Write an essay comparing the film and the novel versions of The Joke

1621 words - 6 pages so easily succumbs to. In the film, however, Jaroslav's internal conflict and struggle with the new times is not so clear because his family never enters the realm of the film.Jires does a good job contrasting the men in the ensemble with the rest of the village in the last scene. All the men playing the folk songs are illuminated, wearing all white and playing the forgotten melodies of their youth, while the rest of the people around them are

Comparing The Presentation Of Two Film Versions Of The Prologue To Romeo And Juliet

3017 words - 12 pages Comparing The Presentation Of Two Film Versions Of The Prologue To Romeo And Juliet I have been scrutinizing Baz Luhrmann and Franco Zeffirelli's unique styles of interpreting Shakespeare's, late 1590 's, play prologue: Romeo and Juliet. (To be truthful when I first found out I was going to be studying Romeo and Juliet, I thought I was about to pull my hair out! Image having to watch two Shakespeare play prologues, let

V for Vendetta: Comparing the Novel and the Film

977 words - 4 pages V for Vendetta is a graphic novel written by Allan Moore. It is a story full of comedy with V as the protagonist who is out to fight and destroy the government and affects innocent people. The novel was later adapted into a film and directed by James McTeigue and written by Wachowski Brothers. The graphic novel was set in 1990’s during the time where the world had suffered from a nuclear war and everything was left destroyed. The movie was in

Comparing the Film Black Orpheus and the Original Greek Myth

1352 words - 5 pages Comparing the Film Black Orpheus and the Original Greek Myth The story of Orpheus and Eurydice is one that has been retold countless times over the years. It started as a Greek myth, later being made into a movie titled Black Orpheus. After reading the myth and watching the movie, it is easy to see that there are far more differences in the two works than similarities. These differences are not only in the way the story is told, but also in

Domestic Violence and the Effect it has on Family

2063 words - 8 pages . Eventually this will end up in a divorce or even worse, death, depending on how far the violence goes. If there is violence in a family, then the ones who are affected by it may feel like they deserve it because of what the batterer is accusing them of doing. Battering occurs among people of all races, ages, socio-economic classes, religious affiliations, occupations, and educational backgrounds (Stewart & Croudep, 1998-2012). Domestic violence can affect

Domestic Violence and the effect it has on family

1901 words - 8 pages this will end up in a divorce or even worse, death, depending on how far the violence goes. If there is violence in a family, then the ones who are affected by it may feel like they deserve it or had it coming to them for what the batterer is accusing them of doing. Battering occurs among people of all races, ages, socio-economic classes, religious affiliations, occupations, and educational backgrounds (Stewart & Croudep, 1998-2012). Domestic

Comparing the Opening Sections of Kenneth Branagh's and Franco Zeffirelli's Film Versions of Hamlet

3846 words - 15 pages Comparing the Opening Sections of Kenneth Branagh's and Franco Zeffirelli's Film Versions of Hamlet So exactly why is it that Hamlet is still so popular with our modern day audiences when it was written for the naïve audiences of the 17th century? Personally I believe this is because Hamlet deals with many fresh issues including corruption, love and the supernatural, which still appeal to contemporary audiences. These

Similar Essays

Jane Eyre And The Burning Bed

2402 words - 10 pages and external turmoil she is conflicted with as she becomes entangled in the fiery torment that consumes Mr. Rochester: I became further aware of the strong sense of burning. I thought no more of Mrs. Fairfax; I thought no more of Grace Poole […]: in an instant, I was within the chamber. Tongues of flame darted round the bed: the curtains were on fire. In the midst of blaze and vapor, Mr. Rochester lay stretched motionless, in deep sleep. "Wake

The Terrorist Attacks And The Cherokee Theory Of Violence

894 words - 4 pages The Terrorist Attacks and the Cherokee Theory of Violence Like most Americans, I have spent many moments since the terrorist attacks of 9/11 trying to grasp both the acts themselves and the seemingly endless chain of depressing events following in their wake. Although many have rediscovered faith communities or a renewed social activism in their search for understanding, I have immersed myself in the lessons of Cherokee culture and history

Mystic River: Comparing The Book And Film

1419 words - 6 pages Mystic River is a crime novel went straight to the bestseller lists on 2001 written by Dennis Lehane. The reproducing film Mystic River by Clint Eastwood also won countless Awards. As Lehane points out in his interview with Linda Richards: “ 50 percent of the reviews has said this is not simply a crime novel.” Which obviously pleased him. The psyches and nature of human are the most fascinating parts in his novel. In the story Dave Boyle was

Unified Uncertainty And The Auteur Theory Of Film Criticism

1219 words - 5 pages Unified Uncertainty and the Auteur Theory There are no rules and regulations when it comes to creativity. The imagination of the artist and the creator determine what guidelines to follow, but that freedom consequently creates controversy when the piece needs to be evaluated for its true value. When French film director Francois Truffaut advocated the Auteur theory in 1954, it greatly influenced film criticism. The Auteur theory states that