Comparing Daisy Buchanan Of The Great Gatsby And Brett Of The Sun Also Rises

2662 words - 11 pages

Daisy Buchanan of The Great Gatsby and Brett Ashley of The Sun Also Rises

     Written right after the publication of Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby, Hemingway’s The Sun Also Rises is apparently influenced in many ways.  The most obvious of Fitzgerald's influence is manifested in Hemingway's portrayal of his heroine, Brett Ashley. Numerous critics have noted and discussed the similarities between Brett and Daisy Buchanan, and rightly so; but the two women also have fundamental differences. Compared to Daisy, Brett is a more rounded, complex character, and Hemingway has treated her with more sympathy than Fitzgerald has with Daisy. Some similarities between Brett Ashley and Daisy Buchanan include their physical beauty, their extravagant/ flamboyant lifestyle, and their unhappy marriages. However, their most important similarity is the destructive influence they have on their suitors.

            Daisy attracts Jay Gatsby with her beauty--not only her physical appearance, but also the entire carefree, comfortable, luxurious lifestyle:

Gatsby was overwhelmingly aware of the youth and mystery that wealth imprisons and preserves, of the freshness of many clothes and of Daisy, gleaming like silver, safe and proud above the hot struggles of the poor (157).

To Gatsby the rich life is temptingly desirable because it was equaled to Daisy herself. Her life far detached from the sweaty hard struggling seems to hold as much enchanted beauty as she holds for Gatsby. He falls in love with that beauty, and Daisy has become his one and only goal and dream in life. With this, Fitzgerald is putting the blame for Gatsby's fall--his indulgence in the wrong dream, and his wrong choice of means to achieve his end--on Daisy.

But that dream is amplified by Gatsby's own imagination. It makes the dream more beautiful, more desirable, and more complete than it actually is, like the enchantment of the green light on the Buchanans' porch. Gatsby sinks into it, allowing his imagination to exaggerate until finally,

The colossal vitality of his illusion … had gone beyond her, beyond everything. He had thrown himself into it with a creative passion, adding to it all the time, decking it out with every bright feather that drifted his way. No amount of fire or freshness can challenge what a man will store up in his ghostly heart (101).

That dream is also empty because Daisy is empty. Fitzgerald depicts her as an empty, useless and dependent female who ultimately lacks definition. Whereas Gatsby works to pursue Daisy, Nick has a regular job, and even Jordan has her tournaments; Daisy does not have a purpose, a profession, or even a talent for anything. Her purposelessness is apparent in this scene with Jordan Baker:

"We ought to plan something," yawned Miss Baker, sitting down at the table as if she were getting into bed.

"All right," said Daisy. "What'll we plan?" She turned to me helplessly. "What do people plan?" (16)

More literally,...

Find Another Essay On Comparing Daisy Buchanan of The Great Gatsby and Brett of The Sun Also Rises

The Characterization of Brett in The Sun Also Rises by Hemingway

530 words - 2 pages The Characterization of Brett in The Sun Also Rises If taken at face value, The Sun Also Rises by Ernest Hemingway, seems simply to be a depressing story about a group of lost individuals, plagued with drunkenness who, as a result, float through life with little meaning at all; however, this naïve perception fails to account for the deeper meaning and thematic development that lies within the text. For many of the novel's characters

Jake and Brett in "The Sun Also Rises": Victims of there Own Environment or Tragically Bringing upon There Own Demise?

2046 words - 8 pages divorce from her ex-husband, to be unhappy. Brett has this ideal about being independent that she liked, but in the end she would have been happier with a commitment. If Jake and Brett laid off the alcohol, and realized how messed up they were pilling their lives to become, maybe they both could actually have prospered from life instead of making it worse. Works Cited • Bloom, Harold "Plot Summary of The Sun Also Rises." Bloom's Major

Relationship of Gatsby and Daisy Buchanan

1204 words - 5 pages The Relationship of Gatsby and Daisy in The Great Gatsby   At the heart of F. Scott Fitzgerald's novel, The Great Gatsby, there is a theme of desire, an unshakable quest by Jay Gatsby set in motion by the beauty of Daisy Buchanan.  Yet, when Jay and Daisy are together, considerable awkwardness is displayed between these two characters, and this awkward atmosphere is primarily the result of the actions of Jay Gatsby.&nbsp

Daisy Buchanan: the True Inhabitant of the Wasteland in "The Great Gatsby"

625 words - 3 pages name of Buchanan and having the old money that comes with that last name means more to Daisy then being happy with Gatsby even though he has “New money”. So Daisy is the true inhabitant of the wasteland because she essentially wastes her life away, Daisy has the opportunity to better her life but because her ego gets in the way she stays in the same situation she’s always been in and will always be in. Daisy even comments in chapter one how she

Comparing Tom Buchanan and Jay Gatsby of The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald

1449 words - 6 pages “Two sides of the same coin,” is a commonly heard English saying used to describe two items that seem very different from each other but in reality share a number of similarities. Scott Fitzgerald demonstrates this idea in his novel, The Great Gatsby, when he introduces the characters Tom Buchanan and Jay Gatsby. At first glance, both characters may seem like polar opposites. However, with a closer analysis, one can see that they are more alike

The Relationship between Brett and Jake in The Sun Also Rises

1019 words - 5 pages and get lost in something completely unimportant. The book can depict this very well. The book Jake Reinvented accurately portrays today’s high school teenager life, due to the levels of social ‘coolness’ the collection of diverse people, and the truth behind high school life. An ambitious teen analogue of The Great Gatsby, Gordon Korman’s new novel, Jake, Reinvented, makes explicit its literary antecedents: Jay and Daisy have been replaced

The Sun Also Rises

2557 words - 10 pages The Hemingway Hero Prevalent among many of Ernest Hemingway's novels is the concept popularly known as the Hemingway hero, an ideal character readily accepted by American readers as a man's man.In The Sun Also Rises, four different men are compared and contrasted as they engage in some form of relationship with Lady Brett Ashley, a near-nymphomaniac Englishwoman who indulges in her passion for sex and control. Brett plans to marry her fiancee

The Sun Also Rises

1952 words - 8 pages search of happiness but they also left their fellow countrymen to suffer from post war changes in the U.S. I think that many of the expatriates left because they could get away from the new amendment of Prohibition and to take advantage of the exchange rate in Europe. In my mind, this is immoral because they didn't show dedication to their country. Lady Brett shows the most immorality of any of the characters in The Sun Also Rises. She

The Sun Also Rises

1881 words - 8 pages “Fiesta: The Sun Also Rises” from the American Ernest Hemingway takes the reader in an after World War One Europe. More precisely this novel is based on men and women that experienced this war, with all its pains, changes and consequences. Hemingway's narrator , Jack Barnes, is an American journalist who suffers a war-wound that leads him to an emotional wound. Through the novel division in three books, the reader can see an evolution in Jake's

The Sun Also Rises

501 words - 2 pages The Sun Also Rises      In Ernest Hemingway’s The Sun Also Rises, Jake Barnes is a lost man who wastes his life on drinking. Towards the beginning of the book Robert Cohn asks Jake, “Don’t you ever get the feeling that all your life is going by and you’re not taking advantage of it? Do you realize that you’ve lived nearly half the time you have to live already?” Jake weakly answers, “Yes, every once in a while.” The

The Sun Also Rises

1457 words - 6 pages In The Sun Also Rises by Earnest Hemingway, setting has one of the most important roles in telling the story. The setting of a story is one of the most crucial things when you are reading and it allows you to imagine the environment in which characters are placed. It creates a tone and an attitude for the story which changes the way the reader feels as they continue to read. Normally setting is used only to describe where and when a story

Similar Essays

Comparing Barnes Of The Sun Also Rises And Caraway Of The Great Gatsby

1557 words - 6 pages Similarities Between Barnes of The Sun Also Rises and Caraway of The Great Gatsby     Supported by Ten Quotes from  Sun Also Rises, No quotes from Gatsby     Jacob Barnes shares a personality quirk with Nick Caraway; both want to give the impression of being decent, honest men forced to endure the corruption and pettiness of those around them. “What's not clear through most of The Sun Also Rises is whether or not Jake believes his own

The Different Lives Of Jake Barnes And Brett Ashley In The Sun Also Rises

747 words - 3 pages In the novel The Sun Also Rises we read about two characters that seem to depend on each other. Ernest Hemingway writes this story ingeniously to show how these two characters are intertwined with one another. One character can't get away from the other because of the friendship they share. We have to look at the lives of Jake Barnes and Brett Ashley from both points of view to understand how they are complicated. Brett Ashley was a

A Comparison Of Biographic Features In The Sun Also Rises And The Great Gatsby

2574 words - 10 pages based on actual events that happened to Hemingway and a group of his friends. This enhances the realism of The Sun Also Rises. Fitzgerald and The Great Gatsby In his novel, The Great Gatsby Francis Scott Fitzgerald includes many autobiographical features to enhance and illuminate the themes of the work. Certain main characters like Daisy Buchannon, Jay Gatsby, and the narrator Nick Carraway are representations of actual people from

The Great Gatsby And Comparation With The Sun Also Rises

1007 words - 5 pages characters of both works were in the word war but the ones from The Sun also Rises seems to be affected and destroyed much more than Jay from The Great Gatsby. The main reason for that, I think, is money. ___ you can make your life better with them and do not need alcohol as a means to forget about the war. The last thing I would like to mention is woman, as the main reason of complications. In The Sun Also Rises is one woman, Brett, everyone