This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing Dignity In A Lesson Before Dying, Jane Pittman, And Of Love And Dust

2738 words - 11 pages

Dignity in Southern Society in A Lesson Before Dying, Autobiography of Jane Pittman, and Of Love and Dust

    The ante-bellum Southern social system put blacks in a low economic and social class and limited their pursuit of happiness.  The aristocracy firmly held blacks in emotional and spiritual slavery. Cajuns, Creoles and poor whites maintained a low status in society, which frustrated them because they felt they should be superior to blacks and equal to whites. Racism was a base of southern society and a hope to improve life and gain respect.


        Ernest J. Gaines grew up in Southern Louisiana and his aunt Augusteen Jefferson taught him "the art of living with dignity" (Current 201).  In The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman, the main character, Jane, narrates her life that spans from the Civil War to the 1960's.  She portrays the lives of black people fighting against the stigma of social inferiority in order to live out their dreams.  Of Love and Dust depicts rebellious radical characters striving for new standards of equality in the reformation of a small traditional community.  A Lesson Before Dying shows Grant Wiggins's and Jefferson's personal battles toward reforming themselves, and their community's battle to earn self-respect.  Living in subordination compromises freedoms of socio-economic mobility.  Gaines's characters rebel by fighting against suppression to achieve deserved rights and privileges. They achieve dignity through the struggle to hold onto the honor won from  society. . Ernest J. Gaines describes people surviving within the social system at the same time as they overcome it to find dignity and freedom from prejudices.


Living in subordination compromises freedoms of socio-economic mobility.


        In The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman characters challenge a system that places them in subordination in order to help them find an identity and better their lives. At the end of the Civil War, Ticey (Jane), an eleven year-old slave, is introduced to personal identity by Corporal Brown, a Yankee soldier who passes through her plantation:  "Ticey is a slave name..." he says to her and temporarily renames her Miss Jane Brown (Pittman 8).   Critic Valerie Babb concludes that "the soldier's altering a label of slavery reveals a new world of control to her...for the first time in her life Jane has the option of deciding whether or not she will retain it" (82).  Jane quickly learns that her newly found identity threatens the master and mistress, and she is beaten for demanding to be called "Miss," a title of respect.  She shows them she is an individual with dignity, rather than an inferior being and takes the control that they assumed over her.  The soldier directs Jane's strong character and convictions which results in her insubordination toward white authority.  She continues through her life looking for "the One," a black leader to free her people from the bondage to whites.


Find Another Essay On Comparing Dignity in A Lesson Before Dying, Jane Pittman, and Of Love and Dust

a lesson before dying Essay

651 words - 3 pages Lesson Before Dying The Right to Be Free In the novel A Lesson Before Dying, although Grant is an educated black man in the era of a racist society he has struggles greater than most men of his decent. I feel sorry for him because of his limitations, even though I view him as a coward. He cannot break free of his background and family. The three main female characters in the novel, Tante Lou, Miss Emma, and Vivian, restrict and limit Grant's

A Lesson Before Dying Essay

1100 words - 5 pages A dynamic character is one who grows and changes during the corse of a novel. Jefferson, in Ernest Gaines’ novel A Lesson Before Dying, is an example of a dynamic character. Throughout the novel, Jefferson grows and matures from a life where he considers himself a hog to a life where he realizes he can defy what is expected from him. At the beginning of the novel Jefferson is introduced during his own trial for a murder he did not commit. At

A Lesson Before Dying

849 words - 3 pages A Lesson Before Dying In the novel A Lesson Before Dying, Grant and Jefferson are black men in the era of a racist society; but they have struggles with a greater dilemma, obligation and commitment. They have obligations to their families and to the town they are part of. They lived in a town were everybody knew everybody else and took care of each other. "Living and teaching on a plantation, you got to know the occupants of every house, and

A Lesson Before Dying

908 words - 4 pages of someone, you can never react to that person until you get to know who they really are and come to par with that truth. Both men learn that they have come to settle their differences with one another and begin to accept each other for who they really are. And that leads to the true meaning of a lesson before dying.Looking at the movie and reading the novel is a great deal different. In the novel there aren't as many characters and you actually

A Lesson before Dying

898 words - 4 pages attempts to teach Jefferson about dignity, Jefferson insists that dignity is for "you mans," not hogs. He eats and snuffles like a hog and tries to anger Grant, but Grant maintains his patience. Each hour long visit ends in failure, but Grant continues to try to reach Jefferson. On his fourth visit, Grant starts a conversation with Jefferson about his final meal. Jefferson admits that he wants a gallon of vanilla ice cream because, although he loves

A Lesson Before Dying

1292 words - 6 pages down. Kumalo agrees, and the two sit in the church, dodging the leaks in the roof the majority of the time. The following day, after his daily lesson with "inkosana," Jarvis drives up, and drops off a young man. As he approaches Kumalo, he identifies himself as Napoleon Letsitsi, and was sent by the white man. He informs Kumalo that he is the new agriculture demonstrator, and he is going to help the people farm the land in the most

A Lesson Before Dying - 681 words

681 words - 3 pages few donations from other people- this clearly shows how far Wiggins come on his path towards finding meaning in his life. This is the man that yelled at his students for wasting precious chalk that came out of his own pocket. In my eyes, this puts Grant on the path to redemption. This seemingly simple gesture is a monumental step. It is the first major step on the road to emotional bonding for both Jefferson and Wiggins. At the beginning, this

A Lesson Before Dying, Song of Solomon, and athe Piano Lesson

2008 words - 8 pages The books of A Lesson Before Dying, Song of Solomon, and The Piano Lesson are all classic tales of African American Literature. While written in assorted periods and by different authors, the lessons found in between the pages transcend time. They recount stories of injustice, perseverance, and success. Memory and the past play a critical role in understanding each character’s mindset. A Lesson Before Dying portrays the past as both a hindrance

Racism in A Lesson Before Dying

1765 words - 7 pages A Lesson Before Dying is set in rural Louisiana in the 1940’s. The setting is ripe for the racism displayed in the novel. Ernest J. Gaines weaves an intricate web of human connections, using the character growth of Grant Wiggins and Jefferson to subtly expose the effect people have on one another (Poston A1). Each and every character along the way shows some inkling of being a racist. However, Paul is an exception. He treats everyone as if

Analysis of A Lesson Before Dying

1289 words - 5 pages significance is a definite symbol in A Lesson Before Dying. The characters in the book use food to show their affection for one another. Grant is expected to eat Tante Lou’s food as soon as he gets home, and when he does not, she is both hurt and upset. In the same way, when Jefferson refuses to eat Miss Emma’s food, she becomes sad as well. Grant tells him to eat her food to show her that he loves her, and eventually he does. Grant brings Jefferson ice

The Literary Merit of A Lesson Before Dying

1126 words - 5 pages took creative writing courses. His first book, Catherine Carmier, was published in 1964. He finished his most famous novel, The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman, in 1971. The success of The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman prompted Gaines to write more about the black communities of southern Louisiana. The most successful book dealing with the colored people of southern Louisiana, A Lesson Before Dying, was penned in 1993 (“About Ernest Gaines

Similar Essays

Reverend Ambrose And Grant Wiggins In A Lesson Before Dying

1121 words - 4 pages .  In Ernest Gaines' A Lesson Before Dying, we are introduced to Jefferson, an uneducated, average black man who has been wrongly accused of a murder.  Convinced that he is an animal, Jefferson is going to be taught by Reverend Ambrose and Grant Wiggins, the plantation schoolteacher, that he is actually a man.  Because Reverend Ambrose, and Grant Wiggins have such different teaching beliefs and personalities, they approach teaching Jefferson with

A Lesson Before Dying Essay

1059 words - 4 pages instead the false-hope that he finds when people, always hoping, never get anywhere. This is a complex that Grant is starting to shine light on and through his work with Jefferson it is clear a connection is made. This connection is seen at the end of the novel where Grant, after hearing the news of the completion of the execution, begins to shed tears of sadness. In conclusion, the novel A Lesson Before Dying, written by Ernest J. Gaines

A Lesson Before Dying Essay 589 Words

589 words - 2 pages In Ernest J. Gaines novel A Lesson Before Dying, a young African-American, Jefferson, is caught in the middle of a liquor shootout, and as the only survivor is convicted of murder and sentenced to death. During Jefferson’s trial, his attorney calls him a hog in an effort to persuade the jury that he could not have possibly planned a crime like this. Having heard this, Jefferson’s godmother, Miss Emma, calls on the local school teacher, Grant

A Lesson Before Dying Essay 1628 Words

1628 words - 7 pages society would be better off without them. However, how can one allow such people to decide the life of another when they have already been judged by pre-conceived notions, which remain unquestioned by the residents in that society. Overall, the predominant cause still remains, that these characters have racist views, and are unwilling to change their standpoint. Nonetheless, Grant ("A Lesson Before Dying") has taken it upon himself to try and give