Comparing Women In House On Mango Street And Woman Hollering Creek

1672 words - 7 pages

Ethnic Identity of Women in House on Mango Street and Woman Hollering Creek  

  The novels The House on Mango Street (Cisneros 1984) and Woman Hollering Creek (Cisneros 1992) relate the new American through the eyes of Cisneros. The women in both novels are caught in the middle of their ethnic identity and their American identity, thus creating the "New American." Cisneros moved between Mexico and the United States often while growing up, thus making her feel "homeless and displaced" (Jones and Jorgenson 109).

The House on Mango Street characterizes a community of girls and women restricted in their movements within the barrio. The roles of these girls and women are translated through the eyes of a child. When women in the barrio are confined, they can become a victim of abuse due to male domination. Women are confined to interior spaces in addition to their domestic roles as daughters, wives, and mothers. They live inside the barrio, but desire to escape and live outside the barrio. In addition, women can escape their restricted lifestyle by receiving an education. Esperanza, the child narrator is the only one who escapes this ethnic lifestyle (Mullen 6).

In The House on Mango Street, the vignette "My Name," Esperanza was named after her great grandmother, desires a life outside her interior walls of the barrio. Esperanza’s name means hope in English, while it means sadness and waiting in Spanish. Her great grandmother was wild as a young lady, but was tamed by her Mexican husband. Cisneros states, "She looked out her window her whole life, the way so many women sit with sadness on an elbow . . . I have inherited her name, but I don’t want to inherit her place by the window" (11). Esperanza is proud of her namesake, although she does not want to be a "kept" woman, that is, confined inside her home. She disagrees with the relationship between the name and the Mexican males’ suppression of women (Olivares 4).

Similar to Esperanza’s grandmother in The House on Mango Street, Rafaela in the vignette, "Rafaela Who Drinks Coconut and Papaya Juice on Tuesdays" desires freedom outside the barrio. While her husband is out playing dominoes, she is locked inside. Her husband believes she is too beautiful and is fearful that she will run away. Rafaela dreams of being at the dance hall down the street enjoying life with the other women (Cisneros 79-80).

Furthermore, the desire to explore their American identity for freedom outside the barrio is also expressed in various vignettes. In addition to Rafaela, Marin" is a vignette about a girl with the same name who is about to be sent back to Puerto Rico because of her beauty. She is not allowed outside until her aunt is home and then she is only allowed in the front yard. Marin loves makeup and dressing nicely. She would like to work where she could dress professionally, perhaps downtown. If she could work downtown, her possibilities are greater that she would meet someone, marry, and move...

Find Another Essay On Comparing Women in House on Mango Street and Woman Hollering Creek

House on Mango Street Essay

2157 words - 9 pages House on Mango Street I never had a choice. They decided it all for me and the next thing you know, we were moved. One night, I come home and my father gives me a big smile and says, we’re out of here. I give him a puzzled look, but after staring into his grinning face, I realize what he means. After thirty nine hard years, he has finally found the home he has always wanted. Since my father was young, he had always dreamed of the

Women Hollering Creek Essay

1010 words - 4 pages “Women Hollering Creek” is a story about a woman’s despair, anguishes, and pain of her life that she live. In the story, Cleofila the protagonist has an attraction to the legend of the Arroyo. The legend of the Arroyo is similar to the life of Cleofila, in that both the women in the legend and Cleofila expressed their despair of their life through similar examples. Both the woman in the Arroyo creek legend and Cleofila has experienced the same

Women hollering creek

1214 words - 5 pages The Hidden Story of a Battered Woman In describing "Women Hollering Creek," Sandra Cisneros uses hidden examples to show the pain, anguish, and despair a battered woman feels. The misleading images of the passions people have on the telenovas show us a glimpse of the life Cleofila wishes to lead. The constant fascination Cleofila has of the arroyo, which legend says is haunted by women who lived tragic lives. This fascination shows us the

The House on Mango Street

1518 words - 7 pages . Between her growing sexual maturities and the passing of two of her family members, her grandfather and her Aunt Lupe, she is forced to face adult problems and conflicts. Despite having a strong and intelligent mother Esperanza finds herself often observing the women in her neighborhood closely. This makes up majority of the second half of the novel. In the second half of The House on Mango Street it presents to the reader a collection of

The House on Mango Street

1632 words - 7 pages everything. For a time of Esperanza’s life, The House on Mango Street is not her dream house it is only a temporary house. Esperanza wants to find her own independence and freedom. She wants to get away from the Latino culture where women are pushed into homes and kept there to serve their husbands. She acknowledges that she is not like other women, who remain weak and in the control of dominating men, she believes that she is capable of escaping

House on Mango Street Essay

1246 words - 5 pages insight from these women, goes through mental and physical growth by witnessing positive behaviors and actions, and escapes the role of remaining an oppressed woman in her Latino society. Throughout House on Mango Street, the positive female role models Esperanza encounters, such as, Alicia, Mama, and Aunt Lupe, Wiederkehr 2 help her develop a sense of self accomplishment and perseverance which further reinforces the idea that the exposure of

The House on Mango Street

809 words - 4 pages school nun. “They always told us that one day we would move into a house, a real house that would be ours for always so we wouldn’t have to move each year. And our house would have running water and pipes that worked….” The image setup by Mama and Papa about the house on Mango Street made the author imagine living in the house with comfort and satisfaction. The image of the perfect house soon came to an end when Cisneros saw the house. “Its

"The House on Mango Street"

994 words - 4 pages Short, sometimes very short, essays, jumping from one topic to the next, comprise Sandra Cisnero’s novel, The House on Mango Street. The essays focus on topics from hair style and scent, to concepts of laughter, to neighbors, to various interactions between young women and young men. The book reads like a string of vignettes, which are “short, usually descriptive literary sketches,” rather than a novel. Indeed, the book has no

The House on Mango Street - 1256 words

1256 words - 5 pages live in through three of her short stories. The three short stories in which poverty seems to be an obstacle are The House on Mango Street, Our Good Day, and Chanclas. When the book begins the downgrading of Esperanza's esteem begins with it. In the first short story The House on Mango Street, Esperanza is outside her apartment building where she lives with her siblings and parents. They six were Mama, Papa, Carlos, Kiki, Nenny, and Esperanza

The House On MAngo Street

937 words - 4 pages Everyone has specific characteristics and qualities that make them the way they present themselves. Young, middle-aged, and old people are constantly forming the essentials that affect their self-awareness through their daily activities. Forming one’s identity is an ongoing process, because every person in the world can change people one way or another. In The House on Mango Street, the experiences young Esperanza faced day to day develop her

The House On Mango Street

1054 words - 4 pages for future opportunities. Been considered a poor person is lacking money or material things, but can be consider a great person for achieving their goals in life through many sacrifices. The perfect example is placed on two novels I read this summer, When I was Puerto Rican by Esmeralda Santiago and The House on Mango Street by Sandra Cisneros. This two novels talk about the life of two families living in very poor conditions. I founded

Similar Essays

Comparing Women In Raisin In The Sun, House On Mango Street, And Yellow Raft

1513 words - 6 pages the opposition many women face being viewed as the inferior sex as well as discrimination against their ethnicity. In this struggle Hansberry, Dorris and Cisneros depict women attempting to find confidence and security in the society around them. Comparing and contrasting the novels A Raisin In the Sun, The House On Mango Street, and A Yellow Raft In Blue Water, three principal images of women emerge: their strength, bondage and liberation. These

House On Mango Street Essay

629 words - 3 pages end. She really expresses her love-hate relationship with the red house on Mango Street and all she has been through there. Aunt Lupe tells her writing will keep her free because there is no limit and you can write about anything.Cisneros writing is some of the hardest things for me to relate to and she makes it easier by the way she uses analogies. Like the lady as thin as spider webs. The story seems a little backwards in the sense that at the

House On Mango Street Essay

749 words - 3 pages Esperanza is torn between deciding whether she wants to escape Mango Street. She is embarrassed by the superficial appearance of her identity, but appreciates her roots. Her house is a wreck and the neighborhood, probably not much better off. However, she has loving family and friends. Although marriage has caused the suffering of many of the women in her neighborhood, she realizes that she needs men to fulfill the new desires she attains as

House On Mango Street Essay

906 words - 4 pages Have you ever felt isolated, because of the way you look? The novel the House on Mango Street is about a young girl growing up in a Hispanic section of Chicago. Sandra Cisneros' book The House on Mango Street has numerous themes, but I chose to write about the one I felt was most eminent, feeling of alienation of people of different gender and culture. Many harms can arrive from feeling unwanted, as shown throughout the entire book. The book