Comparing Immorality In The Rise Of Silas Lapham And The Octopus

2662 words - 11 pages

Motivation of Immorality in The Rise of Silas Lapham and The Octopus

 
    In both William Dean Howells' The Rise of Silas Lapham and The Octopus by Frank Norris, a character is faced with the moral issues involved with operating his business. Howells' character, Silas Lapham (The Colonel) and Norris' Magnus Derrick are both desirous to have a prominent position in their respective societies, but are in the precarious situation of having to deploy immoral methods to achieve this coveted stature during the course of harder times. Each man has aspirations to be powerful, prestigious, famous, and/or wealthy. In combination with their lack of humility for their lofty position in society and their over ambitious definition of success, both are caused great distress on the path and during the fight to reach this egotistic plateau. The image created through their business venture became the primary tool to evaluate their own personal vision of success, and in doing so, the two men's morals and values became tainted, family relations were hurt and even devastated, in addition to creating social debacles that caused incredible harm to many others.

   Silas' background consisted of poverty, hardships, and hard work. He acquired his own wealth and that opened doors that were unknown to him or his family. The Colonel's background and attributes led him into an awkward situation of always attempting to appear in society as something that he is not. He is a common, vulgar man, doing his best to appear sophisticated, educated, and knowledgeable, when, in fact, it is only his wealth that connects him to the upper class. His incredible wealth places within him the motivation and false sense of obligation to conform to the tastes and preferences of high culture. His idea of success is to be recognized as someone who not only owns and runs a thriving business, but also is a refined man with knowledge of high culture. He desires acceptance as an equal to the socially distinguished Boston family, the Coreys. It is only through the money made from his mineral paint business that lends him the chance to associate with such families.

   Silas' rise from poverty was not fully morally sound though, notwithstanding the fact that the product he made his money with was one that was virtually handed to him and that sold itself. In spite of these facts, at an earlier stage in the business, Silas had taken up a partner, Mr. Rogers, to help him financially, and then forced him out before he could make any profit. This move appears to be the first immoral business choice in the career of Silas Lapham. It forces him to be dishonest not only to himself, but to his wife, by driving him to lie about and cover up his inner feelings about what he had done. Although he states that he has a clear conscience concerning the whole affair, he cannot so much as speak directly to the man during a chance meeting on the street. He shies away from the awkward situation entirely,...

Find Another Essay On Comparing Immorality in The Rise of Silas Lapham and The Octopus

The Response of the Community to Silas in Silas Marner

2634 words - 11 pages the summits of its social life'. Silas however was not a religious man, 'he invited no comer to step across his door-sill and he never strolled into the village'. From the way Silas had been betrayed in his old town, Lantern Yard, he tried to keep as far away from people as possible. As he had nothing to do with his days, his life slowly progressed into an obsession with work. Silas was a weaver and 'he worked far on into

The Immorality Of War Essay

1263 words - 5 pages The Immorality of War Wars are immoral. The distinction between the rights and wrongs of war is a significant concern to many people. It is difficult to determine whether a war is right or wrong. Many wars shared the idea that both sides believed they were right. It appears that President Truman was right to drop the atom bomb onto Hiroshima to end World War II. Truman claimed that the purpose of bombing was "to shorten the agony of war, in

The Immorality Of Plagerism

397 words - 2 pages The Immorality of Plagiarism In all of our history we as a nation have not seen the likes of an epidemic as systemic and potentially damaging as the current epidemic of plagiarism. We cannot ignore this blight upon our society any longer. We must take action as a collective society, for that is what we have become a collective society of immoral lazy cheats. We must stand up to the lazy hoard of college and high school students who do not

The Immorality of War

1169 words - 5 pages many different reasons: Landconflicts, Religious disagreements, and independence conflicts. Thisis a story about my grandfather's experience in World War II. It washorrifying and gruesome, but the story is not as bad as it was in reallife.In 1991, my grandfather, Mike Sabetai, was taken from his homeby the Nazis, with 17 members of his family. He was taken to a warcamp where he and other divide into groups. There were groups ofpeople who could use

The Octopus - Review

1006 words - 4 pages At the turn of the century, American readers were interested only in stories with happy endings, where goodness was praised and evil was punished. They did not particularly care if that was a false interpretation of the way life really was. When men such as Frank Norris, the author of The Octopus, wrote angrily of the injustices and poverty to be found in America, readers turned away. The Octopus made them change their minds. The course of the

The Immorality of the Soul

898 words - 4 pages evident that all living things have a soul; this includes animals and even plants. However, just like there are different grades of life, there are different grades of soul. Unlike animals and plants, human beings have a rational life; therefore, they have a rational soul. Immortality is a complex idea in society, even today. Immortality is the indefinite continuation of a person’s existence, even after death. (2) Immortality implies a never ending

Immorality of the Death Penalty

728 words - 3 pages supporting my claim that the death penalty is an immoral method of serving justice. D. Preview of the speech: I will discuss religious principles, particularly from the Bible that will hopefully persuade my audience that the death penalty is indeed immoral. Immorality and unethical-ism is not just limited to what it is in the Holy Bible, but it can also include fairness. III. Body Paragraph #1 A. Topic Sentence - When the state takes the life of

The Immorality of Child Labor

1305 words - 5 pages The Immorality of Child Labor Child labor is a serious moral issue. There have been many controversial debates over whether it should be legal or not. Two different viewpoints on the subject exist. Many argue that child labor is morally wrong and that the children should not work, no matter how poverty stricken their family might be. Advocates and major corporations that support child labor argue that it is good because it gives

The Use of Immorality in Order to Achieve Popular Rule

1469 words - 6 pages conventional standards of morality. His use of immoral tactics in leadership would appear to be unpopular; however the acts of immorality have limitations and are done solely to avoid displeasing the masses or creating disorder. Therefore it is acceptable to practice immorality if it is done only to a small number of constituents, if it is not repeated, and if it is performed to please and benefit the public. It is these limitations that prove

The Portrayal of Silas Marner

2241 words - 9 pages In this essay I aim to discuss the portrayal of Silas Marner in chapters 1, 2 and 14 in the novel. The story of Silas Marner is about how things can change in time. It also supplies a certain message. George Elliot wrote the story in 1860. George Elliot was a female and her real name was Marian Evans. She changed her name because it was difficult for a woman’s book to be published. Her story deals with themes of greed, jealousy and envy

Immorality of Euthenasia in The Giver by Lowis Lowery

842 words - 4 pages Do you love your grandparents? Do you want them to be euthanized for being old? IN The Giver by Lowis Lowry the old are euthanized for being old. The newborns that are not sleeping through the night are killed to. And people who can’t seem to get anything right are killed for just that. Lowry reveals the immorality of euthanasia in the scenes depicting the Euthanasia of the

Similar Essays

The Rise Of Silas Lapham Essay

1168 words - 5 pages In the Story “The Rise of Silas Lapham,” written by William Dean Howells, Silas’s desire to conform to the standards of society is the root of his company’s downfall but the rise of his understanding and morals. The society Silas is trying to feel accepted by is very judgmental and vain and do not care about others therefore making it very tough for the Laphams to be accepted or even feel somewhat normal where they are living. Persis is a

Character Manipulation In The Rise Of Silas Lapham

2081 words - 8 pages Character Manipulation in Howells' The Rise of Silas Lapham           Of all the characters who undergo change in The Rise of Silas Lapham, Lapham's change is the only one looked upon in a positive light by the narrator. William Dean Howells uses the corruption of other characters to promote Lapham's newfound morality and reinforce his ultimate triumph. Before Lapham's financial ruin, he is the only character with fault. Yet as his world

The Fall Of Silas Lapham Essay

1303 words - 6 pages In William Dean Howells’ novel, The Rise of Silas Lapham Silas is a very greedy selfish person who does not care about anything except climbing the social ladder. He has false social aspirations and his lust for power help his business to flourish as he rips people off and steels people’s money. As Silas begins to get higher and higher on the social ladder he begins to realize that his dreams are empty and have no real value as he achieves them

Comparing The Three Fathers In Silas Marner

4569 words - 18 pages Comparing The Three Fathers In Silas Marner Silas Marner, is a book of great depth, considering many types of situations that people still find themselves in today. It gives us an inner view on how people used cope with their troubles during the period of the industrial revolution, be they minor or major ones. George Eliot reveals human nature perceptively, humourously, and extremely intelligently. She is a brilliant