This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing Katharina, Of The Taming Of The Shrew And Beatrice Of Much Ado About Nothing

1340 words - 5 pages

Comparing Shakespeare’s Katharina, of The Taming of the Shrew and Beatrice, of Much Ado About Nothing

Shakespeare’s Katharina, of The Taming of the Shrew and Beatrice, of Much Ado About Nothing, are very similar characters.  Each is plagued with unrequited love, and depressed by their inability to woo the suitor of their choosing.  Neither will accept the passive female role expected by society. Yet, both women seem to accept their role as wife by the conclusion.  Upon further examination, one will find that Beatrice is a much more complex character.  One would have to agree with the critic who said, "Katharina is a character sketched in bold, rapid stokes, with none of Beatrice's sophistication, verbal brilliance, or emotional depth." 

In Taming of the Shrew, the first introduction to Katharina, by Gremio and Hortensio, tells that she is a shrew, (1.I .54-60) and that she will never find a groom.  When she first speaks we see her responding to these insults, but she was provoked so her words seem appropriate.  Yet as the play continues we see Katharina tying up Bianca, (2.I.29) and hitting her.  This can be rejected as sibling rivalry, but later Katharina slaps Petruchio when he is trying to woo her (2.I.214). Katharina seems to have a physically violent side that isn't present in Beatrice.  She also does not seem to have as strong as a character as Beatrice, especially when one considers that Petruchio was able to tame her in a very short time.

In the opening scene of Much Ado About Nothing,  Beatrice says some harsh things about Benedick (1.I.37-43).  She seems to be unprovoked but very rigid in her opinion of him.  In Leonato's house, the discussion of Beatrice and marriage leads her uncle to conclude that, "Thou will never get thee a husband if thou be so shrewd of thy tongue."(2.I.18-19)  Beatrice will participate in a verbal game of wit by exchanging words with Benedick but she is more sophisticated than to just slap him for no apparent reason.  Beatrice is also very sociable with other people and seems to be a shrew just when talking about Benedick and other males. Not unlike Katharina, who was told she would marry Petruchio (2.I.260-268),  Beatrice does not consent to marry Benedick directly.  Beatrice has to be entrapped with the love sonnets that Hero stole from her pocket (5.IV.88-90).  Even at the conclusion of the play, it seems as though Beatrice will not change her attitudes, just her status as an unmarried woman.

Both Beatrice and Katharina participate in stichomythia, a kind of verbal Ping-Pong match, with their suitors.  Katharina seems to go for the vulgar and obscene insults like, "No cock of mine.  You crow too like a craven." (2.I.222)  Most of Katharina's lines are short, two or three lines at a time, and she does not use very many complicated analogies.  Beatrice is not obscene in her exchange of words with Benedick, but she seems to have more to say and does more than just respond to insults. ...

Find Another Essay On Comparing Katharina, of The Taming of the Shrew and Beatrice of Much Ado About Nothing

Shakespeare's presentation of the gulling of Beatrice and Benedick in "Much Ado About Nothing"

1212 words - 5 pages declares that "it must be requited", his tone implies that this is just as much a favour to Beatrice as to himself, and is merely trying to save her from the way "she falls, weeps, sobs, beats her heart, tears her hair, prays, curses", as Claudio disclosed.The women's scene is contrasting, as it is written in blank verse, which is far more poetic, and suggests a richness and value which symbolises the femininity of the characters. The imagery is far

The Portrayal of Benedick and Beatrice in William Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing

1095 words - 4 pages The Portrayal of Benedick and Beatrice in William Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing At the beginning of William Shakespeare's play "Much Ado About Nothing" he portrays Beatrice and Benedick as two argumentative young people. However he also portrays them as being attracted to each other, this becomes clear because the first thing Beatrice says in the play is " I pray you, is Signor Mountanto return'd from the wars or

Beatrice of William Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing

1764 words - 7 pages Beatrice of William Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing One of the most intriguing characters from Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing must be Beatrice. An intelligent, well-spoken (and, perhaps more interesting, outspoken) young woman, she is an almost exact opposite of her cousin, Hero. What makes Beatrice so different than what one expects of a woman during Shakespeare’s time? Why did Shakespeare decide to make her such a strong female

The Liberation of Katharina in Shakespeare’s Taming of the Shrew

2257 words - 9 pages The Liberation of Katharina in Taming of the Shrew     In Shakespeare’s Taming of the Shrew, Katharina is presented ambiguously with much debate asking whether or not her character is tamed, liberated or whether or not in reality she was a good enough manipulator to make it appear that she becomes tame when in essence her character remains the same.  Within this essay I shall be concentrating on the aforementioned as well as discussing a

Much Ado About Nothing - Benedick and Beatrice

512 words - 2 pages H/W 27/09/14How are Beatrice and Benedick presented to the audience in 'Much Ado About Nothing'Benedick and Beatrice have close connections in the play, Benedick is portrayed to be a staunch bachelor, whereas Beatrice a combative character, also ironically, due to this being set in the Renaissance era, outspoken. Benedick is seen as very misogynistic.Benedick is portrayed as a misogynistic character to the audience; this is presented on multiple

Much Ado About Nothing Beatrice And Benedick

618 words - 2 pages In the comedy Much Ado about Nothing, Shakespeare illustrates Beatrice and Benedick's change of character lead them to love. To pick which couple's relationship was the most successful would be quite simple. I felt that both were doomed at the beginning. Whether its because the relationship is based on appearance and impressions rather than a true love and friendship or based upon extreme openness and stubborn mindedness which you see neither is

Shakespeare's Presentation of Hero and Beatrice in Much Ado About Nothing

2313 words - 9 pages Shakespeare's Presentation of Hero and Beatrice in Much Ado About Nothing Hero and Beatrice are the two main female characters in Shakespeare's "Much Ado About Nothing" and they tell us a lot about how Shakespeare saw women in the context of the sixteenth century upper classes. In looking at the presentation of the characters it is important to examine their entrance into the play and what first impressions the

Comparing the Play versus the Film of William Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing

884 words - 4 pages Comparing the Play versus the Film of William Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing ?Much Ado About Nothing'' is a postwar love story. Its principal subject is that of romance that may settle over the land after soldiers come home. I noticed that Much Ado is actually two love stories. One concerns sweetly innocent lovers who are driven apart by the plotting of enemies. The other involves very sarcastic lovers who are swept into each

Much Ado About Nothing Essay: Effective Use of the Foil

1044 words - 4 pages themselves and their thoughts more clearly.  For, as Blake asserts, without attraction, one cannot understand repulsion, and without imagination, one cannot understand reason.  In Much Ado About Nothing (MAAN), William Shakespeare uses this idea of the power of opposites to show the differences in two types of love.  Using the relationship, language, and actions of Hero and Claudio as a foil against those of Beatrice and Benedick, Shakespeare has

The Transformation of Benedict in Much Ado About Nothing

1596 words - 6 pages The Transformation of Benedict in Much Ado About Nothing In "Much Ado About Nothing" Shakespeare manages to transform Benedict from a bachelor to being in love with Beatrice. Shakespeare does extremely well to make this change of character seem believable as it such a big one. Shakespeare does this by using key scenes to gradually reveal the true relationship between the two. This transformation is

Much Ado About Nothing - The Importance Of Noting

1138 words - 5 pages Discuss The Importance Of Noting In Much Ado About Nothing Noting, or observing, is central to many of the ideas in Much Ado About Nothing. The word nothing was pronounced as noting in Elizabethan times, and it seems reasonable to presume that the pun was intended by Shakespeare to signal the importance of observation, spying and eavesdropping in the play. As a plot device, these occurrences propel the action and create humour and tension. The

Similar Essays

Women In Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing And Taming Of The Shrew

1954 words - 8 pages “orange,” but also as something that “taken back” demonstrates his perception of his potential wife as something that he ought to be able to sexually “consume,” and, ultimately, take control of. In conclusion, The Taming of the Shrew as well as Much Ado About Nothing employ the use of one’s property and objects to describe women. In doing so, the roles appropriated to women at the time are clearly depicted to be one’s similar to that of

The Merchant Of Venice, Much Ado About Nothing, The Taming Of The Shrew

2909 words - 12 pages the Shrewwhen Lucentio and Hortensio plot to win Bianca. Thetwo disguise themselves as teachers to gain access toBianca, without the trouble of the shrew or Bianca'sfather.Disguise occurs in Much Ado About Nothing, but toa somewhat lesser extent. In this work, most of thecast is dressed up for a costume ball that is heldearly in the play. In this instance, Beatrice ispaired with a disguised Benedick for the evening.Beatrice, however, sees through

The Character Of Beatrice In Much Ado About Nothing

2480 words - 10 pages The Character of Beatrice in Much Ado About Nothing Many would believe this to be a understated summary of the way Shakespeare presents her character in Much Ado About Nothing because Beatrice is not just a humorous character but a strong role model for both ShakespeareÂ’s time and for a modern audience defying social expectations and being equal to her male counter parts, she is the heroin of the play and even though

The Presentation Of The Relationship Between Beatrice And Benedick In Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing

2971 words - 12 pages The Presentation of the Relationship Between Beatrice and Benedick in Shakespeare’s Much Ado about Nothing Beatrice is the niece of Leonato, a wealthy governor of Messina. She is feisty, cynical, sharp and witty. Benedick has recently returned from fighting in the wars. He is also witty, and like Beatrice is always making jokes and puns. They both continue a ‘merry war’ against each other, in which Beatrice often wins the