This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing Letters From An American Farmer And Thoreau's Various Essays

1812 words - 7 pages

Comparing Crèvecoeur's Letters from an American Farmer and Thoreau's Various Essays  

St. Jean De Crèvecoeur's Letters from an American Farmer and Henry David Thoreau's various essays and journal entries present opposing views of what it means to be an American. To somewhat simplify, both writers agree that there are two kinds of Americans: those who are farmers and those who are not. Crèvecoeur views farmers as the true Americans, and those who are not farmers, such as frontier men, as lawless, idle, inebriated wretches (266). Sixty years later, Thoreau believes the opposite: farmers are doomed and bound to their land, and free men who own nothing posses the only true liberty (9). Both Crèvecoeur and Thoreau judge men and their professions on industry, use of nature, freedom, and lawfulness.

As America grew during these six decades, industrialization and higher education created more compact communities unable to economically provide the land needs of farmers. In Crèvecoeur's America, "some few towns excepted, we are all tillers of the earth"(263). In 1850, Thoreau's Concord was among the many towns allowing people to leave their farms for a more urban setting to house their law practices, shoe stores, or surveying businesses. The separation of farmers from the rest of society leads to intellectualizations of the profession by thinkers like Thoreau. Removed from the simple, hard labor of farming, it is easy for urbanized society to forget the farmer's purpose and importance in Western civilization.

Crèvecoeur states that "industry, which to me who am but a farmer, is the criterion of everything"(264). Indeed, a lack of industry in any vocation eventually leads to failure. Thoreau, however, sees little value in industry:

Dec. 22, 1853: Surveying the last three days. They have not yielded much that I am aware of. All I find is old boundmarks, and the slowness and dullness of farmers reconfirmed. They even complain that I walk too fast for them. Their legs have become stiff from toil. This coarse and hurried outdoor work compels me to live grossly or be inattentive to my diet. (14)

This journal excerpt implies that industry, in this case the work of surveying, is merely a bother, getting in the way of civilized living and a proper diet. Thoreau's disdain for work leads to criticism of the farmers who pay him. He portrays the farmer as a slave to his land, requiring him to work to the point of self-destruction (9). Surely the farmers that Thoreau describes did not attend Harvard and cannot earn money publishing books and lecturing. It seems naive of Thoreau, who never knew hard labor, to so freely criticize those who do. Thoreau's civility and affection for society (portrayed in his lifestyle rather than his writing) allow him to judge farmers' philosophy rather than their utility and importance in society.

Thoreau's age was the dawn of what is now called environmentalism. In the mid-nineteenth century, however, industry...

Find Another Essay On Comparing Letters from an American Farmer and Thoreau's Various Essays

Comparing Metaphors in Norman Maclean's, A River Runs Through It and Henry David Thoreau's, Walden

1477 words - 6 pages Comparing Metaphors in Norman Maclean's, A River Runs Through It and Henry David Thoreau's, Walden In Norman Maclean's A River Runs Through It, the author recounts the story of his early life growing up in Montana. The narrative revolves around his family and the art of fly fishing. Through the novel, Maclean begins to understand the wisdom of his father, the fierce independence and downfall of his brother, and the divinity and beauty of

Comparing and contrasting the various file systems used by Windows

2897 words - 12 pages option is the short and long term cost.For a company to convert from its current operating system, which is probably Microsoft Windows, the cost could be prohibitive. Here is a comparison between using a Linux OS and MS Windows OS.Linux:Many companies offer specific commercial versions of Linux for no cost or at a very minimum fee and can be installed on an unlimited amount of hardware but this cost saving in it self is only limited to the

Henry David Thoreau's Civil Disobedience and Martin Luther King's Letter from Birmingham Jail

816 words - 3 pages Henry David Thoreau's Civil Disobedience and Martin Luther King's Letter from Birmingham Jail Henry David Thoreau and Martin Luther King, in “Civil Disobedience” and “Letter from Birmingham Jail,” respectively, both conjure a definitive argument on the rights of insubordination during specified epochs of societal injustice. Thoreau, in his enduring contemplation of life and its purpose, insightfully analyzes the conflicting relationship

An essay comparing the issue of abortion from the religious views of Catholics, Jews, and Buddhists

1347 words - 5 pages Fate of the UnbornThroughout history, there has been a diversity of opinions regarding induced abortion from various religions and countries. To this day, there is no unified agreement within different religions and law authorities concerning the morality of abortion. Looking at abortion throughout time and around the globe provides an enlightening perspective on this important issue. Catholicism, Buddhism, and Judaism emphasize on the

Comparing Let Us Now Praise Famous Men and An American Exodus: A Record of Human Erosion

1383 words - 6 pages Comparing Let Us Now Praise Famous Men and An American Exodus: A Record of Human Erosion The Great Depression, which began with the stock market crash of 1929 and lasted for the next decade, was a time of desperation and disorientation in America. In an effort to bring the country back on its feet, President Roosevelt initiated the Farm Security Administration (FSA) project. Photographers were hired and sent across the United States to

Comparing Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave and Incidents in the Life

2262 words - 9 pages Comparing Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave and Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl What provokes a person to write about his or her life? What motivates us to read it? Moreover, do men and women tell their life story in the same way? The answers may vary depending on the person who answers the questions. However, one may suggest a reader elects to read an autobiography because there is an interest. This

Comparing the Teaching on the Resurrection in I Corinthians and the Thessalonian Letters

1974 words - 8 pages Comparing the Teaching on the Resurrection in I Corinthians and the Thessalonian Letters The purpose of this paper is to compare the teaching on the resurrection of Jesus Christ as it is noted in Paul's letter to the Corinthians and Thessalonian letters. The resurrection of Jesus Christ is one of the primary doctrines of study in the Bible because it reveals the victory that believers have over death, hell and the grave. However, the

Comparing and Contrasting American and Japanese Marketing

2209 words - 9 pages that “if a good, quality, lower-priced product is produced based on consumer information, people should buy it,” (Howard, 1999). The Japanese do not place marketing very high on their list of priorities. This is very different from their American counterparts. American companies value marketing highly. Japanese companies place more emphasis on production and manufacturing. Cultural differences between American and Japanese markets have a great

What We Learn from the Letters between John and Abigail Adams

785 words - 3 pages What We Learn from the Letters between John and Abigail Adams John Adams, a Harvard graduate and well-educated politician, married Abigail Smith in October of 1764. She was the daughter of a wealthy minister. Despite the lack of formal education because of illness, Abigail learned to read, write, and converse on level of great dignity. Ten years into their marriage, Mr. Adams was elected into Congress to represent Massachusetts. He

Letters from Birmingham Jail and Keynote Address at the First Woman's Rights Convention

1137 words - 5 pages "Letters from Birmingham Jail" by Martin Luther King and "Keynote Address at the First Woman's Rights Convention" by Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony It was Thomas Jefferson who uttered the words "That all men are created equal...." However, over one hundred years would pass before these words would mean anything. Equality

Comparing Amish and North American Society

934 words - 4 pages Comparing Amish and North American Society We can compare Amish society as seen in the movie Witness to North American society to decide which is more ideal. An ideal society is one where there is a strong sense of community among all the members. Education prepares children for life; therefore the type of education a child receives will change the society in the next generation. Although education is valued in both societies, its focus is

Similar Essays

Colonial And Contemporary American Identity (Crevecoeur, "Letters From An American Farmer" And John Steinbeck, "What's Happening To America?")

949 words - 4 pages most speechless about the disappearance of individual farms that made colonial America. In his "Letters From an American Farmer," he shows his high esteem and respect for the farmer, who was the prime example of stability and self-independence. It was that farmers who survived settlement in the late 1700's and while keeping a dependent population from starving during harsh winters. He describes most Americans as "tillers of the earth... a people of

Literary Comparison Between Henry Thoreau's "Civil Disobedience" And Martin Luther King's "Letters From Birmingham Jail."

978 words - 4 pages Martin King and Henry Thoreau both write persuasive expositions that oppose majority ideals and justify their own causes. While this similarity is clear, the two essays, "Letters from Birmingham Jail" by King and "Civil Disobedience" by Thoreau, do have their fair share of differences. Primarily in the causes themselves, as King persuades white, southern clergy men that segregation is an evil, unjust law that should be defeated through the

Comparing Thoreau's Civil Disobedience And Orwell's 1984

896 words - 4 pages Thoreau argues with his and suggests a variety of ways to cause reformation, he has the freedom of expression much unlike Winston. This is an essential point when trying to suggest any of Thoreau’s ideas to reform 1984 socialistic government. There is also no hope of rebellion from actual party members, this is one instance where Thoreau’s ideas falter. Even Winston admits early on in the novel that the government could never be brought down

Comparing Tolstoy And Chekov Essays

804 words - 3 pages The Case For Small , Short Words Ruth Ciani Brower English 101 Writing Assignment Did the Younger Brother and The Lawyer fulfill their expectations of the particular decision they made? In their respective essays, authors Tolstoy and Chekov, examine the experiences of two men who took a chance on the unknown. In Leo Tolstoy's "The Two Brothers" two men take different paths, and as a result two men had vastly