This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing Life Without Meaning In Eliot’s The Waste Land And Welles’ Citizen Kane

2173 words - 9 pages

Life Without Meaning in T. S. Eliot’s The Waste Land and Orson Welles’ Citizen Kane

It is the foundation of modern civilization that knowledge is better than ignorance, understanding more valuable than confusion, and wisdom more desirable than foolishness. Consequently, people feel that they should be able to understand the meaning of life and, in doing so, know that their lives are not in vain. They want life to be a coherent whole infused with meaning, so that they can know and understand what life is and where they fit in, thereby attaining wisdom. Life, then, is in essence a struggle to find a meaningful framework for the experiences and feelings we have collected. Since art reflects the human state, and we have grown more conscious of this struggle, our art has come to reflect this problem of making a coherent, meaningful whole out of the assorted fragments of life we have collected.

Though this theme of collecting is visible in all media of modern art, it is especially noticeable in literary and film art, in particular in T. S. Eliot’s The Waste Land and Orson Welles’s Citizen Kane. These two pieces analyze collecting on two levels: first because they focus on collecting and second because they are collections. However, the division between these levels is somewhat superficial, as both Eliot and Welles blur the lines between the two parallels, making the audience more acutely aware that this art is a picture of all human life. On both levels the artists draw parallels between the works and the audiences’ lives by examining the content, style, and meaning of the collection; that is, what is collected, how it is collected, and what it says, concluding that life is not a coherent whole, but rather “a heap of broken images” (line 22).1

It is apparent from the outset of Citizen Kane that a parallel is being drawn between the viewers and the main character, Charles Foster Kane, a fact visible in the title. The word “citizen” implies equality, both under law and through the ballot. The effect would have been quite different if the title had been “Tycoon Kane” or “Comrade Kane.” By using a word with which we all associate, Welles sets up a parallel that draws the viewers into the plot. This parallel is magnified by the opening scene where young Kane is sledding happily down the hill, reminding the viewers of their childhood pastimes and happiness, and therefore drawing a strong link between the viewers and Kane. This significant effect continues throughout the movie, thereby creating a real and personal experience for the viewers.

We also find another parallel between the viewers and the reporters making the newsreel of Kane’s life. Both attempt to make sense of his life by collecting pieces of it. We see through Kane that we cannot solve the enigma of life from the first-person perspective, and through the reporters that we cannot solve it from the perspective of the detached observer. The implicit reason is that perhaps no inherent...

Find Another Essay On Comparing Life Without Meaning in Eliot’s The Waste Land and Welles’ Citizen Kane

Speaks of Okonkwo of "Things fall apart" by Chinua Achebe, and Charles Foster Kane of Orson Welles' "Citizen Kane"

1500 words - 6 pages Okonkwo, the main character of Things fall apart, by Chinua Achebe. And Charles Foster Kane of Orson Welles Citizen Kane, both have value systems that are incongruous with their cultures. Thus allowing them to be defeated by society. These are two men with a great need for recognition. Their need for something that was extinguished long ago. Okonkwos struggle to prove his greatness in the face of those who knew his father. Charles Foster Kane's

Visual Effects and Symbolism in "Citizen Kane"

1318 words - 5 pages some films. Using the nonlinear approach in "Citizen Kane" gives it a more unique story line and portrays Kane's life in a way that makes it easier to understand his struggles and emotions. I do not believe it makes it more difficult for an audience to follow as long as they are focusing on the movie. The problem with this type of storytelling approach is that if one doesn't pay close attention to the movie, one can miss out on a lot of important

Mind Control || The satire in "Citizen Kane"

534 words - 2 pages The famous classic Citizen Kane, by Orson Welles, lashes out at the way we are affected by the mass media. The film paints a stingingly clear picture of the malleability of the public opinion, and the power that the media possesses over it. The film outlines the life a newspaper tycoon by the name of Charles Foster Kane, showing the significant influence his newspaper had on politics, war, and the personal lives of several people. It is a harsh

Naturalism in Citizen Kane

667 words - 3 pages , directed by Orson Welles, truly elaborates on the hopeless things in life. Kane's marriages always prove to be failures because of the love for himself and the dictation of his wives' lives. He first married the niece of the president of the United States. His marriage was never close because it was permeated with his campaigning for governor. The only time he ever saw his wife was at breakfast where he would talk mainly of himself. Kane tells Mrs

Rosebud in Citizen Kane

1694 words - 7 pages of the ability to love and how to love. The film Citizen Kane has a lot of direction meaning that every shot means something in its own way, there is a hidden message in every movement of the camera. There was a close up on the "NO TRESPASSING" sign emphasising the fact that the person (Kane) was isolating him and didn't want anyone to disturb him. The camera slowly pans up the fence, showing how tall the fence is

Lost in the Waste Land

1086 words - 5 pages essential allusion to modern day London after World War I. In part two of The Waste Land, entitled "A Game of Chess", Eliot reveals two exceedingly different worlds in regards to the levels in society. The first depicts a high-born lady and "The chair she sat in, like a burnished throne" (line_). She is completely isolated and alienated from the rest of society. She is empty and lacks meaning in her life. She fills the void of meaningless with material

Waste Land Essay: Superficiality in The Waste Land

1653 words - 7 pages Superficiality in The Waste Land   The Waste Land is concerned with the 'disillusionment of a generation'. The poem was written in the early 1920's, a time of abject poverty, heightening unemployment and much devastation unresolved from the end of WW1 in 1918. Despite this, or because of it, people made a conscientious effort to enjoy themselves. In doing so they lost their direction, their beliefs and their individuality. They were

The Crucible, Citizen Kane, Newspaper

978 words - 4 pages The film Citizen Kane directed by Orson Welles shows us a multifaceted view of Charles Fost Kane. He uses a variety of innovative film techniques to show Kane who struggle with love, power, truth and so on .Through Thompson, we go through five close people relate with Kane and know the different"faces"of Kane. But none of them knows the meaning of Kane' dying word "Rosrbud". The Charles Foster Kane that Orson Welles presents just like Thopson

Film Noir and German Expressionism in: "Batman" and "Citizen Kane"

987 words - 4 pages In the films, "Batman" (1989), directed by Tim Burton, and "Citizen Kane" (1941), directed by Orson Welles, there are many Codes and Structures of German Expressionism and Film Noir. The films show these through the institution of the American family, masculinity, history of colonialism and colonization, and Film Noir and German Expressionism.In the film Batman, the institution on the American family is similar. This is because Alfred (actor

Mise-en-scene in Citizen Kane and Persona

619 words - 2 pages Mise-en-scene in Citizen Kane and Persona Mise-en-scene is the principle by which a piece of film will derive its meaning wholly from what happens in the single shot and not from the relationship between two shots. For example the director might include shots with various composition, angle, depth, movement, and lighting. Citizen Kane has many good examples to show Mise-on-scene usage. The scene that I believe is the most significant and

a life without meaning

554 words - 2 pages Without religion human life would be meaninglessBy Marte DahlA life without religion is for someone a life without value. Why should everyone on earth have a religion they should follow? Do we just need belief in something that is better than us, and can "forgive" us when things are not right? We might even be able to choose our own partners no matter the sex and would earth be better without religion? Thinking back on history, how many wars

Similar Essays

T.S. Eliot’s Powerful Use Of Fragmentation In The Waste Land

2694 words - 11 pages a new whole. While T.S. Eliot’s stylistic fragmentation in The Waste Land reflects on a world he may have perceived as shattered and devoid of meaning, these fragments also assume a more active role in the poem. They wreak havoc with the reader’s literary and cultural sensibilities, turning him into an alien fragment in his own right. Most importantly of all, this fragmentation presents the reader with a personal quest. It is a challenge

T.S. Eliot’s The Waste Land The Most Influential Work In Modern Literature

1235 words - 5 pages T.S. Eliot’s "The Waste Land" - The Most Influential Work in Modern Literature T.S. Eliot’s "The Waste Land" is considered by many to be the most influential work in modern literature. First published in 1922, it captures the feelings and sentiments of modern culture after World War I. Line thirty of "The Waste Land," "I will show you fear in a handful of dust," is often viewed as a symbol of mankind’s fear of death and resulting love of life

A Critical Analysis Of Orson Welles' Masterpeice, "Citizen Kane."

972 words - 4 pages A Fledgling's MasterpeiceCitizen Kane is widely hailed as the "great American film" and with good reason. From its complex narrative structure to pioneering photography to its incredibly rich use of sound, Welles' 1941 picture remains one of the most innovative movies ever to come out of a Hollywood studio. Even Today Citizen Kane stands out as one of the great films of all time.Unfolding almost entirely in flashback, Welles's masterpiece

Death Without Rebirth In T. S. Eliot's The Waste Land

562 words - 2 pages desert waste, as the lives Eliot describes are missing something, somehow empty. Journeying through the desolate land in search of water, in search of life, is similar to journeying through life seeking answers and meaning. This search for meaning is a kind of spiritual unrest. The meaning of life the author seeks is perhaps a renewal of life. Parts of the poem deal with death without rebirth. Death is a final end, but an unsatisfactory one