This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing Nothing's Changed And Half Caste Essay

1020 words - 4 pages

Comparing Nothing's Changed and Half-Caste

Half-Caste and Nothing's Changed are two poems that, despite having
different subjects, are full of similarities. Both Half-Caste and
Nothing's Changed express anger. Although, the object of their anger
is different. The anger in Half-Caste is directed at language, or more
specifically the use of one phrase while the anger in Nothing's
Changed is towards a culture. In Half-Caste Caribbean dialect is used.
Nothing's Changed is written in standard English. However, both
writers chose to use free verse meaning that neither poem follows
specific rules or patterns.

In Half-Caste the poem is written from the writer's viewpoint. Which
means the reader is able to see the writer's personal feelings about
the term half-caste. The opening line, "Excuse me" shows that the poem
is written from the writer's point of view as excuse me is a phrase
used by someone when they want to start a conversation. I feel that if
the poem was written from another person's viewpoint it would lose
some of it's effect. The emotion in the poem would come across less
strongly and seem less real, as it wouldn't be certain whether the
writer actually feels the anger expressed in the poem or just thinks
that people might feel that way. Half-Caste is written as a
conversation and therefore is in first person. You can see that the
poem is a conversation in lines such as line 33 where it says, "Ah
listening to yu..." and line 47, "...yu must come back tomorrow." Both
of these lines show that the poet is talking to another person. I
think this is good as it is original. I also think it makes the poem
more personal to you as you read it and so, perhaps, makes you think
more about what Agard is saying.

Nothing's Changed is written in first-person perspective, however it
is not an actual experience of the writer, but more of a story
describing an event which may have happened. Nothing's Changed does
show feelings though.

There is a lot of anger in the poem Half-Caste. That anger is directed
at the term half-caste but also at those people who use the term to
describe people of mixed race. This anger is emphasized by short lines
such as, "Explain yuself," which shows the poet just wants to get
straight to the point, as many people do when they are angry.
Repetition of the phrase, "yu mean" also shows his anger. The sarcasm
in the poem, e.g. "I'm sure you'll understand, Why I offer you
half-a-hand," is another way Agard accentuates the anger he feels.
Agard uses examples to justify his anger at being called half-caste.
One of these is comparing a symphony written by Tchaikovsky (using
black and white piano keys) to person of mixed race, "Is a half-caste
symphony?" as obviously it is a ridiculous thought that we would call
a symphony a "half-symphony" just because it mixes two different
coloured keys so, Agard is asking, why should a person of two
different races be called half-caste? Another point...

Find Another Essay On Comparing Nothing's Changed and Half-Caste

"An Old Woman" by Arun Kolatkar and "Nothing's Changed" by Tatamkhulu Afrika

1259 words - 5 pages Chose to or more other cultures poems you have studied. How do the poets present the theme of protest?'What else can an old woman do?''We know where we belong'These two quotes, the first from An Old Woman by Arun Kolatkar and the second from Nothing's Changed by Tatamkhulu Afrika, both seem to show a sense of abandoned protest and although the poems are from two very different cultures the theme of protest is clear in both.An Old Woman is about

Explore and Explain the Inequality of the two poems "Two Scavengers in a Truck" and "Nothing's Changed"

1233 words - 5 pages I have chosen to write about "Nothing's Changed" and "Two Scavengers in a Truck, Two Beautiful People in a Mercedes". In "Nothing's Changed" the inequality is based on black and white people, and "Two Scavengers..." is about the rich and poor division.As the name suggests, Two Scavengers in a truck, Two Beautiful People in a Mercedes is about two people in a garbage truck, and two people in a Mercedes waiting at a red light. Nothing's Changed is

Comparison between Half-Caste by John Agard and Presents From My Aunts In Pakistan by Moniza Alvi

1079 words - 4 pages Compare And Contrast Two Poems From Other Cultures And Traditions.I have chosen to compare Presents from my aunts in Pakistan by Moniza Alvi with Half-Caste by John Agard.The authors of these two poems were both born in another country and moved to England at an early age, where as John Agard was born and raised in Guyana and then moved to England during early adulthood. During this essay I will be comparing the imagery, tone, differences and

Comparative Essay for Poetry Unit: "Search for My Tongue" by Sujata Bhatt and "Half-Caste" by John Agard

1428 words - 6 pages Cultural conflict is when a new set of beliefs and habits overtakes and conceals the old set, deteriorating the sacred cultural connections established at birth. Sujata’s "Search for My Tongue" and John Agard’s "Half-Caste" are both excellent examples of cultural conflict. In the both cases, the authors are attempting to depict the hardships involved with a clash of culture. In “Search for My Tongue,” Sujata Bhatt finds

Poetry Is Often Used As A Form of Cultural Protest. How Do The Poets In "Nothing's Changed" And 'Charlotte O'neals Song' use their poems as a form of protest?

1951 words - 8 pages Changed'. He was angry about the Apartheid that was apparently gone but he still believed that "Nothing's Changed' The risk of writing this was so great in fact that he went by the name of Tatamkhulu Afrika Charlotte O'Neals song was however; written by Fiona Farrell and is about the way women where shipped around like cattle in the 19th Century. Charlotte was a passenger on a ship to New Zealand in 1871, where she hoped to start a new life and escape

How Poets Reveal their Ideas and Feelings about Other Cultures

989 words - 4 pages that he is proud to be half caste. This poem shows us how ridiculous it is to judge people on their culture by comparing himself to weather, music and art. John Agard says” when yu say half caste yu mean when the light an shadow mix in de sky is a half caste weather well in dat case England weather nearly always half caste” he expresses his feelings and his message is shouldn’t we neglect English weather because it has a mix of light and shadow


507 words - 3 pages How caste system can be used constructively and help the country? The caste system may promote stability in Indian society. The caste system can give the individual a fixed status in the society which can’t be changed in any circumstances, thus it provides a psychological and social security. Social status in caste system is hereditary. There will be no competition to improve status. People can utilize their energy for benefit of the society

The Caste System: History and Highlights

1690 words - 7 pages consists of five tiers, including one that is below its lower class, and differs from any other system; the caste system of India. In a caste system, the class that is received is hereditary and cannot be changed like in other societies. The civilization of India has an extensive history with this longstanding and controversial caste system that has evolved over time and is still in place today. The caste system of India originated from the

Moving Between Different Cultures in Poetry

850 words - 3 pages Moving Between Different Cultures in Poetry For my essay I will be looking at two poems which deal with the experience of moving between different cultures, these are Half-Caste and Search for My Tongue. These poems are written from experience. John Agard the author of Half-Caste was born in Gugana and moved to Britain in 1977. He is half-caste himself and his poem expresses his feelings about the term half-caste. Sujata Bhatt the

The History of Caste System in India

973 words - 4 pages The caste system in India originated about 2,000 years ago. “Caste”, is a representation of a large-scale kinship that is based on a stratified system of hierarchy. This system is mainly adapted among the Hindu society in India, which is divided into four “varnas”. Rita Jalali describes that the varnas are, “ranked categories characterized by differential access to spiritual and material privileges” (Jalali 249). Each social class has different

Caste versus Class

1652 words - 7 pages movement in a caste society such as India’s. Social fluctuations, such as shifting birth and death rates within castes, competition between castes, religious conversion, and discontentment with class repression has resulted in greater mobility (Gellner 1995: 395-396) When comparing the caste system of India to the class system of the United States, there is a great deal of resemblance. One such resemblance is the important role that caste plays

Similar Essays

Comparison Of Social Injustice And Protest In The Poems 'half Caste' And 'nothing's Changed'

1894 words - 8 pages "Social injustice is a concept relating to the perceived unfairness in the society" (Aguiar 9) which can be evidently seen in the two poems "Half-Caste" by John Agard and "Nothing's Changed" by Tatamkhulu Afrika. The two poems also show racism, protest and cultural conflict. "Half-Caste" is about the subject of ill-treatment against mixed raced people in Britain. "Nothing's Changed" is based on discrimination in South Africa, deliberating about

Comparing Half Caste And Search For My Tongue

2387 words - 10 pages Comparing Half Caste and Search for my Tongue Culture. It’s a very complicated term, with many different interpretations, but what does it actually mean? In this essay I will compare two poems from completely different cultures to see if we get any comparisons, the poems I have chosen to write about are Half-Caste by John Agard and Search for my Tongue by Sujata Bhatt, I have chosen these because I feel they raise some very significant

Comparison Of The Poems, Two Scavengers And Nothing's Changed

2463 words - 10 pages Comparison of the Poems, Two Scavengers and Nothing's Changed “Nothings Changed” was written by Tatamkhulu Afrika, a mixed race child with fair skin, who was later adopted by a white South African family who brought him up as though he was white, and he only found out about his origins as a teenager. Tatamkhulu lived in a multi-cultural area called District Six, which was destroyed by the white authorities. He feels strongly about this

Poetry Analysis Of Limbo, Blessing And Half Caste

1371 words - 5 pages Poetry Analysis of Limbo, Blessing and Half Caste I have chosen four different poems of which come from varying cultural backgrounds and have a moral. I will now explain how the writers present their ideas and give the readers an insight into different cultures. Limbo is a poem, which shows us the feelings of slaves on slave ships written by Edward Kamau. This poem tells the story of slavery in a rhyming