Comparing Othello's Two Speeches: Act I, Scene Iii, (126 169) & Act V, Scene Ii, (1 23) In Relation To His Feelings Towards His Wife, Desdemona.

2392 words - 10 pages

OthelloTextual analysis - Take home* * *I n Shakespeare's Othello, the protagonist, Othello, changes his attitude towards his wife, and indeed all women, through the course of the play, initially viewing her as the nurturing figure to later perceiving her to have taken on the completely opposite role of 'the temptress'. Two speeches, in particular, Act I, scene iii, (126-169) & Act V, scene ii, (1-23), spoken by Othello, not only reflect the prevalent themes of the play but enable the audience to recognise the transition of feelings he undergoes in regards to his wife, Desdemona. This change is revealed through the use of language and imagery which also serve to introduce us to the major concerns of the play and the prevailing attitude, of Othello, towards this wife and to women in general.Throughout history women have been marginalised on the basis of their sex with traditional female gender roles having two extremes, neither being very positive. Women, traditionally, either take on the passive or the active role, and neither role, not even the active role, contains much power. The nurturer is covert, emotional, caring and passive holding no real power. The temptress is more overt, less emotional, self-centred and active, holding only slightly more power than the nurturer which is solely sexual. The traditional male role the provider and protector, possessing great power over women as they 'need' a male to survive. It is what women must give in return for their 'being looked after' that has created the two traditional roles; the male will provide the female with shelter, food and security and in return he needs just two things from them: to be cared about and sexual fulfilment.Some central themes or concerns of Othello, presented overtly throughout the play, are that of love, jealousy and appearance versus reality. This is an interesting trio of themes and when linked together form a thick and perplexing plot: when love flourishes, so can jealousy; but if the other common theme, in the play, is to do with things not beings what they seem, then feelings of lust and pity can be mistaken for love, and jealousy can be brought on by a lie. In the two speeches by Othello, all of this is expressed. In both speeches love is conveyed but in each speech it is seen and acted upon quite differently, and in the second speech jealousy is very distinct whereas the first speech jealousy is not an issue. Othello's first speech is full of love, both love towards a companion and love towards a wife (their love too new and fresh to be concerned with a negative emotion such as jealousy).Othello mentions the mutual love for Desdemona's father, Brabantio as a long-time friend: "Her father loved me, oft invited me"?(1sp,126). This does not just show fond feelings for his father-in-law but also reveals his gender values. He mentions Brabantio, a male, before Desdemona, a female, even though she is his wife. Othello establishes Brabantio first as Desdemona is...

Find Another Essay On Comparing Othello's two speeches: Act I, scene iii, (126-169) & Act V, scene ii, (1-23) in relation to his feelings towards his wife, Desdemona.

Drama in Act III, Scene I of Romeo and Juliet

1746 words - 7 pages Many Critics consider Act 3 Scene 1 As the turning Point of the Play. How does Shakespeare Make This Scene Dramatic for His Audience? “Romeo and Juliet” was originally a poem by Author Brooks, in 1562, it was called “Romeus and Juliet“. William Shakespeare later rewrote the tragic poem in to a play in 1595 and renamed it “Romeo and Juliet”. The scene that I am studying is Act 3 scene 1, it contains, hate, revenge and violence. The themes

How the Character of Macbeth Changes Between Act I Scene iii, and Act III Scene I

779 words - 3 pages How the Character of Macbeth Changes Between Act I Scene iii, and Act III Scene I Shakespeare uses many different methods to show that Macbeth changes greatly between Act I Scene iii and Act III Scene i, these include his use of language in speeches and directional action. Banquo's reaction in Act I Scene iii shows that Macbeth is initially afraid of the prophecy. Macbeth's own speech indicates that he is unsure of the

Additional Scene to Shakespeare's Macbeth. I wrote Act VI, Scene 1, after Shakespeare concludes the play in Act 5.

1293 words - 5 pages Characters:Donalbain: Malcolm's brother who early in the play fled to Ireland after his father's (Duncan)death. He is not seen the remainder of the play, until now.Witches: The 3 troublesome sisters who plagued MacBeth and contributed to his downfall for their own pleasure.Macbeth: Act VI, Scene 1Setting: Desolate rocky plain near Malcom's Castle in Scotland. Donalbain meets the witches.[Enter alone on horseback with sword and supplies]Donalbain

Comparing differences in Romeo and Juliet, Act 1 Scene 5.

870 words - 3 pages Romeo and Juliet essayI have been comparing differences in Romeo and Juliet, Act 1 Scene 5. In the scene I am studding there is a lager social variety, there is a large range of importance, it's a sort of hierarchy, this occurs in both families. The kitchen servants are at the bottom running around getting everything sorted, slightly higher up is the nurse who ahs earnt respect from the family by caring for Juliet most of her life, she is

Play and Film-"The death of Desdemona" (Act V Scene ii): Oliver Parker's "Othello" and "Othello" by William Shakespeare.

1607 words - 6 pages This comparative essay focuses on the murder of Desdemona (Act V, Scene ii) of William Shakespeare's 'Othello', in both the Folger version of the play, and Oliver Parker's film adaptation of the play. Through omissions to the script, use of lighting, and added scenes, Oliver Parker alleviates Othello of guilt, and preserves his honour in his adaptation. This paper will examine the original play as performed in the Globe Theatre in the

Comparative Essay on the use of media two directors make of Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, with paricular reference to Act I Scene I: The fight Scene and Act II Scene II: The Balcony scene

1993 words - 8 pages Compare and contrast the distinctive use of media two directors make of Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet with particular reference to Act I Scene I: The Fight Scene and Act II Scene II: The Balcony SceneIn this piece of coursework I will be looking at the different interpretations of two directors on Romeo and Juliet. The interpretations of Franco Zeffirelli and Baz Lurhamn are very different and contrasting. Nearly 30 years apart we can see that

Titus Andronicus - Act III, Scene ii, Lines 53-80

2007 words - 8 pages The Behavior Of Titus Andronicus In Act III, Scene ii, Lines 53-80     In this part of the play, we encounter the intense inner struggle of Titus Andronicus and the extent to which his hardship and anguish have affected his perception and behavior. The need for revenge has reached an extreme level, very close to madness, expressed by his ever-changing mood and inadequate way of reasoning. Shakespeare further develops the character of

Hamlet Act 1 Scene 1

639 words - 3 pages Hamlet, written by William Shakespeare opens with the conversation of two sentinels outside the gun platform of Elsinore Castle. Right in the beginning of a play, the confusion starts and there is strong foreshadowing of the violence that is to come. The first line of the play is Barnardo asking "Who's there?". This foreshadows the many questions that are yet to be asked later in the play- such as 'Is Hamlet faking his insanity or is he actually

Act III, scene iii of Shakespeare's Othello

1959 words - 8 pages 403-5). Naturally, Othello, already in doubt of his wife's honour, falls into this rhetorical trap; Iago is now free to condemn Desdemona through suspicion, with only the smallest bit of "ocular" evidence.This act represents the beginning of Othello's giving up language; until this point in the play, Othello has spoken with beautiful images, convincing speechifying, and used his language to express the eloquence and beauty in his soul. From this

Act V-Scene 2 in Hamlet

1103 words - 4 pages Act V-Scene 2: The ClimaxIn Act V-Scene 2, as the play begins with Hamlet fill in the detail of what happened to him since he left Denmark, Hamlet concedes that there was a kind of fighting in his heart. But clearly his inner struggle has been manifested from the time of his first appearance in this play. Now it is to hear no more expression of self-approach or doubts that he will act positively against Claudius. What is impressive is his

An Interpretation of Titus Andronicus, Act III, Scene 1.

3422 words - 14 pages crying, even mourning intensely? I believe two emotional conditions caused Titus' deep mourning and tears. First, he has not been able to cry until now. As pointed out in act 1, a commander does not have time to mourn the loss of his sons or soldiers; he must relentlessly pursue the objectives of his campaign. He must repress his emotions. Second, Titus feels betrayed, one of the strongest emotions a man can feel. In a figure of speech, Titus

Similar Essays

Essay On Hamlet's Evolution Of Thought Through Act Iii Scene I, Act V Scene I, Act V Scene Ii.

1375 words - 6 pages In Shakespeare's play "Hamlet", the character of Hamlet is seen in many situations with changing evolutions of thought. The conscience plays a very important part in Shakespeare's Hamlet and gives insight to actions and thought that take place within Act III scene I, which includes perhaps the most famous of all of Shakespeare's soliloquies, Act V scene I, regarding Yorick and the grave yard, and lastly Act V scene II, which involves Claudius's

Drama In Act I, Scene V

1192 words - 5 pages . Just before Act 1 scene 5, Shakespeare has placed this piece of text, which Romeo says ‘I fear to early’. This makes us think why Shakespeare has put this here and what feelings is he trying to create. The possible feeling he is feeling at the moment is fear that is referred in the quote. This creates a lot of tension in the air and brings the audience in feeling very desirous wondering why he is feeling fear? What is it that is making him feel

Romeo And Juliet: Act Iii, Scene V

863 words - 3 pages their fate. Upon his exit, in a foreshadowing tone, Juliet thinks she sees his body not on the ground, but 'as one dead in the bottom of a tomb.' (III, v, 56) In prior scenes Juliet was mesmerized and infatuated and would not have been able to make Romeo leave. In this scene Juliet is transformed from that of a little girl, to that of a rational, independent and self-sufficient adult.Another transformation in Juliet is that in earlier scenes she

Comparing Romeo's Speeches In Act One Scene One And Act One Scene Five

3141 words - 13 pages Comparing Romeo's Speeches in Act One Scene One and Act One Scene Five What changes in Romeo’s language, feelings and opinion of love can be noted and what conclusions can be reached about the nature of his love for the two women? Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare was written around the 16th century. Shakespeare’s “Romeo and Juliet” is a love-tragedy about two people who fall in love from two feuding families