This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing Plato's Republic, More's Utopia, And Gurney's Dinotopia

1513 words - 6 pages

Plato's Republic, More's Utopia, and Gurney's Dinotopia

Throughout history, mankind has struggled to lead better lives and improve their society for future generations. What do we continuously attempt to improve? What kind of changes are we trying to institute? In other words, what is an ideal society? Many people have very diversified views about a perfect civilization. In Plato's Republic, Sir Thomas More's Utopia, and James Gurney's Dinotopia, three imaginary societies are described, each with its own peculiarities and highlights. Various aspects of the nations described in these three novels, including their respective economies, governments, and social structures, will be compared and contrasted.

A crucial aspect of any society would be its economy. In Utopia, business was conducted chiefly to import iron, and in many cases they traded on credit. The Utopians have no currency, though they trade their goods for gold in order to pay mercenaries in times of war. If one is in need of something, one merely has to inform the head of one's household and he will get it. Their society is arranged so that they reject many material things that our society would consider valuable, such as silver and diamonds. "The Utopians fail to understand why anyone should be so fascinated by the dull gleam of a tiny bit of stone, when he has all the stars in the sky to look at - or how anyone can be silly enough to think himself better than other people, because his clothes are made of finer woolen thread than theirs" (More 89). To minimize the importance of these materials, Utopians make everyday objects out of them, like chamber pots. In Dinotopia, people are given what they require, much like Utopia, although they do not ask for much: as indicated in the Code of Dinotopia, "Rule # 4: Give more, take less." The Republic still utilizes currency as a medium for trade, due to the fact that nearby nations would presumably use money as well. It also applies the use of funds within the country, similar to many other nations in the world today.

Now, we will proceed to the most important part of any human institution - the government. In Utopia, the political hierarchy is based on the household: every city has 6000 households, each containing ten to sixteen adults. For every thirty households, one Styward, or District Counselor, is elected. One Bencheater, or Senior District Counselor, is elected for every ten Stywards. Every town has one mayor, who is elected by secret ballot by the Stywards. Every three days the Bencheaters have a meeting with the mayor to discuss public affairs and, rarely, to settle disputes. There are rules concerning the debate of propositions. For example, "no resolution can be debated on the day that it's first proposed... Otherwise someone's liable to say the first thing that comes into his head, and then start thinking up arguments to justify what he has said, instead of trying to decide...

Find Another Essay On Comparing Plato's Republic, More's Utopia, and Gurney's Dinotopia

Comparing Contemporary Politics to Plato's "The Republic"

1197 words - 5 pages Contemporary politics seems to more closely reflect Thraysmachus’ view of justice more so than Plato’s. Contemporary is defined as belonging to the present time adding on to it, politics, which are decisions and actions between parties with power. In “The Republic”, Socrates asks Thraysmachus to give him the answer to his question of what justice is. Thraysmachus was a sophist, who charged people for wisdom. The battle of seeking the true

Utopia and more's age Essay

1839 words - 7 pages fooled by their husbands,also the right to work and make money.In conclusion,More's Utopia has a perfect structure of ruling without a place for kings.There is tolerance,the right of education and respect for knowledge in the country.The most important of all is that every one contributes equally to the national budget.Whereas,in More's time,there is religious tension and political instability,there is a large amount of poor people deprived of

Thomas More's Utopia and His Context

3527 words - 14 pages More describes the society and culture of an imaginary island on which all social ills have been cured. As in Plato's Republic, a work from which More drew while writing Utopia, More's work In Book 1 presents his ideas through a dialogue between two characters, Raphael Hythloday and More himself. Hythloday is a fictional character who describes his recent voyage in Book 2 to the paradise of Utopia. Throughout the work, Hythloday describes the

Glaucon's Challenge and Plato's Theory of Justice in Plato's Republic

1939 words - 8 pages Plato’s Republic focuses on one particular question: is it better to be just or unjust? Thrasymachus introduces this question in book I by suggesting that justice is established as an advantage to the stronger, who may act unjustly, so that the weak will “act justly” by serving in their interests. Therefore, he claims that justice is “stronger, freer, and more masterly than justice” (Plato, Republic 344c). Plato begins to argue that

The Forms in Plato's Republic and Meno

1638 words - 7 pages Forms specifically refers to Plato's belief that the natural world as perceived by us is not truly real, but only a shadow of the real world. The forms themselves are abstract representations of the many types and properties of the things that exist in the universe. Plato delineated his ideas regarding forms in his Republic and Meno, and these were used in devising his explanation to the concept of universals. It was this attempt to rationally

Plato's The Republic and The Old Testament

2333 words - 9 pages Plato's The Republic and The Old Testament A Buddhist teaching suggests that practicing Buddhism is like taking a raft over a great river. One riverbank represents the realm of ‘samsara,’ the cycle of suffering that we are all spinning around in. On the other side is ‘wakefulness,’ or ‘nirvana,’ an enlightened state of awareness characterized by an infinite sense of unity and bliss. The raft symbolizes Buddhism; its purpose being to help

Justice in Plato's Republic and Hobbes' Leviathan

2841 words - 11 pages One of the main concepts in both Plato's Republic and Hobbes' Leviathan is justice. For Plato, the goal of his Republic is to discover what justice is and to demonstrate that it is better than injustice. Plato does this by explaining justice in two different ways: through a city or polis and through an individual human beings soul. He uses justice in a city to reveal justice in an individual. For Hobbes, the term justice is used to explain

Thomas More's Utopia and its impact on English society during the Renaissance

1447 words - 6 pages nobility throughout Europe exercised their power to place friends and relatives in positions of power to further their own desires. In Utopia, citizens must be elected, voluntarily, by the people without a campaign. The Utopian government is run as a republic, where households choose a manager or Philarch who in turn reports to a senior Philarch. The senior Philarchs meet in a commission run by the chief executive. Unlike Europe in More's time, no one

Plato - "The Republic" - Explain and Evaluate Plato's theory of knowledge

1148 words - 5 pages Plato's triangular theory of knowledge expounded in "The Republic" has acted as one of the most important contributions in philosophical history - particularly to the field of epistemology. Plato uses three powerful metaphors to explain what knowledge and goodness are: The simile of the sun, the image of the divided line, and the most famous of all, the allegory of the cave. The study of epistemology is primarily concerned with what knowledge is

Researching Socratic Pedagogy and Education in Plato's Republic

4911 words - 20 pages Researching Socratic Pedagogy and Education in Plato's Republic ABSTRACT: Though Plato never wrote a dialogue that explicitly asks, "What is education?", few argue that he is uninterested in the subject; after all, Plato, like Socrates, was a teacher. In his magnum opus, the Republic, Plato deals with education repeatedly. The eduction of the guardian class and the allegory of the cave present two landmark pedagogical passages. Yet to catch

Plato's Republic, the Search for Justice and Goodness

2076 words - 8 pages Plato's Republic – The Search for Justice and Goodness Plato's Republic is often read as a political work, as a statement of some sort on government, society, and law. This is certainly not a rash reading of the dialogue; it is called the Republic, and over half of it is devoted to the construction of a city through speech, a city complete with a government structure, a military, an economic system, and laws. However, I believe that to read

Similar Essays

Comparing Sir Thomas More's Utopia And Virgil's Aeneid

2376 words - 10 pages Identity and Power in Sir Thomas More's Utopia and Virgil's Aeneid In Utopia and the Aeneid, Sir Thomas More and Virgil describe the construction and perpetuation of a national identity. In the former, the Utopian state operates on the “inside” by enforcing, through methods of surveillance, a normalized identity on its citizens under the guise of bettering their lives. In the latter, the depleted national identity of the future Romans in

Comparing More's Utopia, Machiavelli's The Discourses, And Hobbes' The Leviathan

2627 words - 11 pages Relationship Between the Sovereign and the Subjects in More's Utopia, Machiavelli's The Discourses, and Hobbes' The Leviathan         Thomas More, Niccolo Machiavelli, and Thomas Hobbes offer models for the relationship between the sovereign and the people in their works Utopia, The Discourses, and The Leviathan. Each argues that ensuring the common good of the people should be the primary goal of the sovereign. However, they differ in

Comparing Plato's Republic And Gulliver's Travels

867 words - 3 pages Plato's Republic and Gulliver's Travels       In The Republic, Plato attempts to define the ideal state as it relates to the tripartite division of the soul. In this division, wisdom, the rational characteristic of the soul, is the most valuable and important. In the ideal state the ruling class would be the guardians, those who maintain rationality and will operate according to wisdom. Each individual "should be put to use for which

Comparing Machiavelli's The Prince And Plato's The Republic

1796 words - 7 pages Comparing Machiavelli's The Prince and Plato's The Republic       Many people in history have written about ideal rulers and states and how to maintain them.  Perhaps the most talked about and compared are Machiavelli's, The Prince and Plato's, The Republic.  Machiavelli lived at a time when Italy was suffering from its political destruction.  The Prince, was written to describe the ways by which a leader may gain and maintain power. In