Comparing Pluralist And Marxist Accounts Of Power In The Uk And Us

2186 words - 9 pages

Comparing Pluralist and Marxist Accounts of Power in the UK and US

Pluralism and Marxism both offer comprehensive theories about the
location of power within the modern state. Both theories to some
extent were based on Western governments; with Marxism being developed
partly through Engels’ experiences in Manchester in the mid nineteenth
century and Pluralism being developed through the studies in America
in the mid twentieth century; but they both offer radically different
ideas about who holds power in the UK and the US. We should, however,
be wary about using terms such as ‘pluralism’ and ‘Marxism’ without
acknowledging that many different variations of the theories exist,
and that they have both developed over time. It must be seen,
therefore that my analysis of the accounts of power in either system
can hardly be holistic.

One of the basic premises of pluralism is that the more power is
dispersed between different groups within a society, no single group
will have a monopoly of power, and the problems of ruling elites or a
single ruling class will be altogether avoided. Pluralism is
descriptive, and asserts that modern states have developed mechanisms
over time which avoid state monism and encourage a diverse range of
methods and channels through which a citizen can control political
leaders and shape the development of public policies.[1] To this end,
therefore, pluralists invest key institutions such as the media,
pressure groups the state and elections with the importance of
diffusing power to individuals, which prevents a single group or
institution from controlling the state.

Marxism accounts for the location of power in a completely different
manner. It asserts that the only basis of power is economic power, and
that that is unequally distributed. Unlike pluralism it indicates the
existence of a ruling class which has a virtual monopoly of power, and
Marxism also disagrees that the existence of institutions such as the
church or courts of law help to disperse power from the state, as it
claims that they are merely part of the ‘Superstructure’ of society
which tries to justify the inequalities inherent in modern society.
The accounts of power and the significance of state institutions
differ greatly between pluralism and Marxism, therefore.

In pluralism, for example, the media is given a great deal of
responsibility, as its role is seen as one of disseminating
information to citizens in an unbiased, objective way; as it is
logical to say that the more accurate information citizens have about
the running of a country the better position they will be in to vote
at elections. Dunleavy and O’Leary say: “Accurate and full information
about politics is essential if [citizens] are to control politicians,”[2]
as if people know that a government is making decisions they...

Find Another Essay On Comparing Pluralist and Marxist Accounts of Power in the UK and US

In what ways and why are the constitutions of the UK and the US different?

1022 words - 4 pages One of the most significant differences, that is evident from the evaluation of the constitutions, is that one is codified and the other is not. The US constitution has a physical existence whereby it is written down and is accessible to virtually anybody in the US to refer to. Contrary to this, the UK constitution is regarded as being uncodified as it has not been formally established in a "bill of rights" format. However, these judgements of

The feminist and Marxist interpretations of Alice's Adventures in Wonderland

1024 words - 4 pages Marxist readers since it reflects upon the role of women and social hierarchy that was present in the Victorian era. In the view of a feminist, one may interpret Alice’s character as a rebel, or a slave. Alice is perceived to be rebellious against the stereotypical women during the Victorian era, when women lacked freedom and rights. Her curiosity breaks free of the common woman into an ideal model, boldly opening themselves to society. Alice

Compare and Contrast the Central-Local Relationship in the UK system and the US system.

994 words - 4 pages well as geographical. The different counties in the UK do have their own set of powers but they are nowhere as powerful as the states in the US. They are still following what ever their central government tells them to do. In the US the degree of separation is much greater. The states have their own power over matters that affect their own area. The State still holds power over the general area and matters concerning the economy. It is mainly

Essay Question: 'Pluralists and ruling elite theory provide fundamentally different accounts of the distribution of political power.' Discuss.

1267 words - 5 pages The Democracy by Faith Maria. This criteria is further illustrated on page 22 when the writer writes about the old soviet union politics and when he makes references to the present UK and US governments. Pluralist ideas oppose any form of tyranny, and the way they propose to avoid tyranny is for there to be social pluralism and 'the seven institutional features'. I will not go into detail about the seven institutional features, but they

The Differences Between the UK and US Constitutions

2332 words - 9 pages The Differences Between the UK and US Constitutions The question invites an analysis of how the differences between the UK and the US constitutions establish the political systems in both countries, and further whether there is distinction between the political systems. Initially I will define what a constitution and a political system are. Subsequently in the main body of the text I shall analyse the differences

Comparing Between Health Care System in UAE and UK

1077 words - 4 pages are 16 years or less, or 60 years old or above, It is Also free for pregnant women, and any women who had a child in the last 12 months, and for patients with low income. (The Commonwealth fund, 2010) Employees and Health Facilities: According to WHO statistics, the numbers of doctors in the UK is 27.7% per 10,000 people, but in UAE it is 19.3% per 10,000 people. However, for nurses and midwives in UAE its 40.9% per 10,000 populations, and in

Comparing The Grapes of Wrath and The Power of One

1777 words - 7 pages Comparing The Grapes of Wrath and The Power of One "Two heads are better than one," it's always been said. But is another person always valuable, or can extra baggage keep an individual from achieving his goals? Both sides can be argued effectively, and both may be true depending on the circumstances. Two historical novels, The Grapes of Wrath and The Power of One, show how two sets of characters took different routes to achieve their

A Comparison of UK and US Political Parties

1480 words - 6 pages A Comparison of UK and US Political Parties A party system as described by G.Sartori is "the system of interactions resulting from inter-party competition”. A one-party system cannot produce a political system, as we would identify it in Britain. One party cannot produce any other system other than

Differences in thinking betwen the USSR in the East and the US and UK in the West.

570 words - 2 pages believed in individual. These differences of their ideologies created much tension between the West and the USSR and it was one of the reasons why the Cold War happened. The West and the US and UK in particular saw themselves as the upholders of liberal democracy and freedom. People could choose what kind of government they wanted. On the other side in USSR, Communist party was the only one and there was no need for different ones as it represents

Comparing the Concepts of Seeming and Being in Relation to Political Power and Leadership in The Prince and The Republic

3114 words - 12 pages Comparing the Concepts of Seeming and Being in Relation to Political Power and Leadership in The Prince and The Republic 9. Machiavelli says the prince only has to seem good, not be good. Socrates insists that seeming is bad, being is good. Is it better to remain in the cave with Machiavelli, or see the light with Socrates? Write three pages for Machiavelli and against Socrates, write another three pages against Machiavelli and for

Accounts of Miracles and Their Support of Belief in God

841 words - 3 pages Accounts of Miracles and Their Support of Belief in God The definition of a miracle is a violation of the "laws of nature", it is an exception that is beyond all naturalistic explanations, meaning they must be explained supernaturally. So do accounts of miracles support the belief in God? Firstly, one must decided whether there is sufficient evidence to prove the existence of

Similar Essays

Comparing The Position And Powers Of The Us President And The Uk Prime Minister

2062 words - 8 pages Comparing the Position and Powers of the US President and the UK Prime Minister Political instinct alone seems to dictate to many that the American president - 'the world's most powerful man' - is the most powerful politician in any of the world's democratic nations. He is at the head of the world's most modern military force and the world's largest economy. What the president says is reported around the world and world

Critically Assess The Pluralist And Marxist Views Of The State

1753 words - 7 pages temporary history-making role for political leaders and state bureaucracies. (1987:210). Thus emphasising that even though power is essentially exercised by the ruling class, there is still a struggle on their part therefore, in a sense, unwittingly making the bourgeoisie and the proletariat more equal. When comparing the two views, the differences between the pluralist and Marxist views of the state are fairly evident. Apart from the fact that both

Which Legislature Has The Most Power In Holding The Executive To Account, The Uk Or The Us?

1286 words - 5 pages When considering the power held by the legislature in both the UK and the US, it is essential to acknowledge the constitutional powers allocated to it in order to hold the executive to account. In addition to this, the changing nature of both legislatures must be taken into consideration in order to examine the powers that each exercise today. However, from the evidence that is available, it is possible to infer that the US still maintains the

Comparing The Marxist And Functionalist Views On The Role Of Education In Industrial Society

1928 words - 8 pages Comparing the Marxist and Functionalist Views on the Role of Education in Industrial Society The functionalists and the Marxists both believe that the education system benefits everyone, but both have different views on society. The Marxist views of the education system are that there are conflicts because there is an inequality between the working class and the higher classes. They believe that there are two different