Comparing Shakespeare's Romeo And Juliet Versus Arthur Laurents West Side Story

1324 words - 5 pages

Comparing Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet versus Arthur Laurents West Side Story

In approximately 1594, William Shakespeare began to write one of the most well known tragedies in history, Romeo and Juliet. Arguably, no author to date has matched Shakespeare's skill and beauty in the creation of this work. However, authors have regurgitated and will continue to regurgitate the theme, "star-crossed lovers", for centuries. Martha Duffy remarks in "West Side Glory", "Slang may change and violence escalate, but the theme of star-crossed city kids has never dated, nor has its appeal diminished" (p. 1). The only viable attempt is the work of modern dramatist Arthur Laurents. However, Laurents' West Side Story originally written as an attempt to modernize Romeo and Juliet, actually became a work of skill and beauty in its own right. The emphasis is now removed from simply "modernizing" Romeo and Juliet; the emphasis is the creation of art through a similar theme, yet very differing styles and influences. The similarities abound within Romeo and Juliet and West Side Story; consequently, there are many deviations found in the plots, characters, and authors' influences.
While certain aspects of the two works remain parallel, many deviations are found within the plot. In West Side Story, the first obvious difference, excluding time periods, is the "exile" situation. In Romeo and Juliet, Romeo is exiled due to public knowledge of his deed. West Side Story's Romeo, Tony, becomes a fugitive because the public is searching for a criminal. In "Introduction, Romeo and Juliet and West Side Story: An Appreciation" Norris Houghton writes, "As a result of this altered circumstance the plot of West Side Story begins at this point to deviate from Shakespeare's drama" (p. 10). Another deviation in plot is the role of the Friar Laurence character, Doc, in West Side Story. Mr. Houghton also comments, "Doc, who is obviously intended as a counterpart of Friar Laurence, takes no comparably active role in the plotting" (p.10). Houghton also agrees, "More significantly, the false report that the boy receives of the girl's death is carried by Anita through the gang as a willful act, not as an unfortuitous happenstance, such as befell Romeo because of the erroneous information Balthasar conveyed and the prevention of Friar John's delivery of the secret of Juliet's feigned death" (p.10)
The greatest alterations in the plot of West Side Story occur in the final scene. In Romeo and Juliet, the final moment is as expected from a Shakespearean tragedy, almost all of the main characters die. However, Houghton explains that Laurents totally abandons Shakespeare's ideals in his final scene. "Laurents eschews Shakespeare's scheme of the fake death of Juliet induced... to allow time for a reunion with Romeo" according to Houghton. Due to this abandonment, Laurents must create his own quasi-tragic ending. Laurents does create the desired ending, and with this creation he removes the...

Find Another Essay On Comparing Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet versus Arthur Laurents West Side Story

Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet vs. West Side Story

722 words - 3 pages Romeo & Juliet vs. West Side Story Shakespeare's is one of the most read writers ever and his writing was so successful that not just one group of people liked it. He did this by relating to his audience using universal truths. . Human emotions are not something that change over time and they are also known as universal truths; love, hate, revenge, and envy are all examples of universal truths. This play was so successful that many other

This essay is comparing shakespears "Romeo and Juliet" with the movie, "West Side Story".

775 words - 3 pages "West Side Story" is a modernized musical based on Shakespeare's play, "The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet", which takes place in Elizabethan times. Both of these stories have many similarities, but there are a lot of major differences as well. Both of these stories are about forbidden love shared between two characters of opposite sides. The tragic endings of these stories cause the two opposing sides to finally get along."The Tragedy of Romeo and

Romeo and Juliet, west side story, compare and contrast

514 words - 2 pages times afterwards. It is also a love story which also ends with somebody's death. Both Shakespeare and Arthur Laurents had done their best when they wrote these stories."Romeo and Juliet" and "West Side Story" have similar, if not exactly the same theme. Both stories display the power of love and the destruction caused by hatred. In "Romeo and Juliet" two people from rival families fall in love. The families' hatred destroys the two lovers, and the

Contrast Of Romeo And Juliet and West Side Story

1653 words - 7 pages , plot sequence, and theme of hatred in West Side Story and Romeo and Juliet intertwine resulting in two parallel yet slightly differing representations of the most famous love story of all time. Shakespeare presents an entertaining, witty and sometimes sexually provocative portrayal of Arthur Brooke’s tale. Robbins’ presentation of the celebrated classic paints the awful truths of racism and irrational violence through dance, song, and music. Romeo and Juliet’s blind love is the force that unites two enemies, just as the eternal human spirit brings all people of the Earth united as one.

"Romeo and Juliet" and "West Side Story": A comparison

2973 words - 12 pages IntroductionIn the mid 1590's, a masterpiece was written and performed as a play. It was a tragic story, but it was a beautiful story. I'm obviously talking about Shakespeare's The Most Excellent and Lamentable "Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet" or for short, "Romeo and Juliet". Over 300 years later, a man named Arthur Laurents, took that same masterpiece, changed the setting, the dialogue and the characters, and got a story called West Side Story as

Romeo and Juliet / West Side Story - A Comparison / Contrast

995 words - 4 pages      Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet and West Side Story both have a lot in common as well as major differences that set them apart. Although West Side Story is a direct rendition of Shakespeare's original play, many of the themes and symbols are altered to fit the modern perspective. The characters have a direct correlation to each other, yet racial issues give them a new light. Many of the events also reflect each

West Side Story as a Modern Romeo and Juliet

1952 words - 8 pages their circumstances of arranged marriage. In fact, for almost every character in Romeo and Juliet, West Side Story has a counterpart:•Nurse – Anita•Tybalt – Bernardo•Friar Lawrence – Doc•Paris – Chino•Mercutio – RiffThe obvious main story change comes from the era in which it was adapted into: the gang era of the 1950’s. This has come under much scrutiny and criticism for it’s portrayal

Romeo And Julite Vs. West Side Story

557 words - 2 pages Switching Roles (R&J v. WSS) Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet and Ernest Lehman's West Side Story are similar in many ways; however, in those comparisons there are some minor differences. Aside from the similarities between Romeo and Tony or Juliet and Maria, there are many other likenesses such as the balcony scene in Romeo and Juliet and the fire escape scene in West Side Story. In Romeo and Juliet the scene starts off with Romeo listening

Title: The Tragedies of "Romeo and Juliet" and "West Side Story"

665 words - 3 pages Juliet care so much foreach other that they are discussing marriage only mere hours after theirmeeting.Romeo and Juliet are both timeless dramas that will live on forever, butRomeo and Juliet is a classic that has a much more powerful and tragic impacton the reader than West Side Story. There are many differences and similaritiesin West Side Story and Romeo and Juliet, and they are not, as many peoplepresume them to be, identical. If Arthur Laurents

Contrast of the Portrayal of Characters within The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet and West Side Story

1486 words - 6 pages different ways. In The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet, Juliet’s character develops strength through her love for Romeo, while in West Side Story Maria, the equivalent of Juliet, is strong from the very beginning. When questioned about marriage, Juliet first says, “I’ll look to like, if looking liking move. But no more deep will I end art mine eye than your consent gives strength to make fly.” (Shakespeare Ⅰ,ⅳ,103-104), but later after she has met Romeo

Relationship between Romeo and Juliet by Shakespeare and its appropriation West Side Story and how the respective contexts demonstrate values that have been maintained or changed

1178 words - 5 pages In comparing the play "Romeo and Juliet" by William Shakespeare (1596), with its' film appropriation "West Side Story" directed by Robert Wise (1961), it is evident that the portrayed values have been maintained or changed as a consequence of the time the texts were created in. The vastly different contextual eras predominantly generate altered values towards social and cultural issues such as patriarchy, marriage and family, whilst other

Similar Essays

Comparison Of Romeo And Juliet By William Shakespeare To West Side Story By Arthur Laurents.

783 words - 3 pages The play Romeo and Juliet written by William Shakespeare is about two teenagers from rival families, Romeo, a Montague, and Juliet, a Capulet, that fall in love. They must go behind their parents back to be together, but their relationship only ends in the death of both of them, plus others close to them. The book West Side Story written by Arthur Laurents was based on the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet, but set in the 1960's with a modern setting

An Ultimate Parallelism: Romeo And Juliet Versus West Side Story

3896 words - 16 pages The story of Romeo and Juliet is a classic. It is preformed in many forms and fashions. Themes changed, twisted, and unfolded accordingly. Although the play may have consisted of a tragic ending, other directors tended to put their own twists on the theme to give a happier ending. For West Side Story, on the other hand, this unforgettable play followed in the footsteps of the Shakespearean classic. With so many performances and awards, West Side

Comparing Romeo And Juliet And West Side Story

1079 words - 4 pages Comparing Romeo and Juliet and West Side Story In this piece of coursework I will be analysing the technical aspects of the opening scenes in Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet and West Side Story. I will be talking about the body language, costumes, colour schemes, the sounds, music and camera angles used in each of the films. Both these films are about two lovers who fall in love despite being in rival gangs or families

Shakespeare's Romeo And Juliet Vs. West Side Story

1839 words - 7 pages lovers of Shakespeare's work), that the major difference between the two works becomes apparent.      Granted, instead of tension between feuding families, West Side Story offers prejudice between races, as illustrated between street gangs, the Jets and Sharks. Some of the characters in West Side Story are carbon copies of those in Romeo and Juliet: Maria (Juliet), Tony (Romeo), Bernardo (Tybalt), Lt. Schrank (Prince