Comparing The Act Of Creation In Grendel And Frankenstein

1325 words - 5 pages

The Act of Creation in Grendel and Frankenstein

   Man has always been driven to create. We constantly shape the world around us by inventing stories of heroes and monsters, by crafting complex but passionate ideals about good and evil. Some relish in the power that this manipulation of reality wields; others are more innocent in that they are simply yielding to a universal longing for something in which to believe.


In both John Gardner's Grendel and Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, creation is a central theme. Victor Frankenstein is inexplicably driven to make a creature like himself, though he doesn't have any external reason for doing so. The monster himself enacts a kind of creation; he seeks to understand the truth of human nature by reading man's works, but also indulges in his own stories and fantasies of a life lived among friends. Shelley explores to some extent the morality of such creation (at least on the part of Victor Frankenstein), but Gardner is more interested in what the act of creation reveals about the nature of existence.


In Grendel, nearly all of the characters are driven to shape the world to their ideas. Hrothgar spends his life crafting a government. Grendel's mother is described as loving her son "not for myself, my holy specialness, but for my son-ness, my displacement of air as visible proof of her power (138)." Both Grendel and the Shaper constantly seek the ability to reshape reality with words. While they have differing motives, all of these acts of creation give power and significance to the creator. As Baby Grendel desperately convinces himself, it is the act of observing and commenting on what is outside that makes one real: "I understood that, finally and absolutely, I alone exist. All the rest, I saw, is merely what pushes me, or what I push against. (16)"


Throughout the story, Grendel makes constant references to his whispering as a means of protection against falling into the void of total meaninglessness. As long as he can continue to shape the world around him, even if only he can hear, he knows that he is really there. Grendel recognizes that reality is subject to interpretation; for this reason, the safe world he has built around his own importance is gravely threatened by the song of the Shaper (the poet of Hereot, and also representative of the author of the original story to which the characters of Grendel are bound). Grendel knows that the lofty stories of a great, wise Scyld are not true, that Hrothgar's empire is one of hypocrisy and greed. At the same time, the Shaper causes to exist another version of the truth. This contradiction terrifies Grendel and he seeks first to make true the Shaper's reality, by joining the humans as a friend and repenting his alleged sins. When he realizes that this is obviously impossible his only option is to destroy any trace of the majesty described by the Shaper in order to affirm the dragon's...

Find Another Essay On Comparing the Act of Creation in Grendel and Frankenstein

Comparing The Sandman and Frankenstein Essay

1545 words - 6 pages . According to him, this image of the father has an intimate connection to Nathaniel's anxiety about his eyes. It separates Nathaniel from Clara and from his best friend--her brother; it destroys Olympia--the second object of his love, and drives him into suicide when he has returned to the happiness of normal life with Clara. In Shelley's Frankenstein we see the same symptoms in the character of Frankenstein. His unfortunate creation

Comparing and contrasting elements of horror in Dracula and Frankenstein

736 words - 3 pages of disbelief for this novel to even make you raise an eyebrow. “Frankenstein” is a very fictous novel and only has slightly accelerated elements of fear because some monster was abandoned and disowned by its creator. Otherwise, if Victor had of stayed with his creation and nurtured it in its time of need this book might not have even been seen as a gothic novel because there would have been no bloodshed. Note that most of the murders that took

Comparing the Duty of the Physician in Dracula, Frankenstein, and Awakenings

3715 words - 15 pages . Although humans have the tendency to set idealistic goals to better future generations, often the results can prove disastrous, even fatal. Frankenstein was not doomed to failure from his initial desire to overstep the natural bounds of human knowledge. Rather, it was his poor parenting of his progeny that lead to his creation's thirst for the vindication of his unjust life. In his idealism, Victor is blinded, and so the creation accuses

Comparing the Nature of Terror in the Gothic Novels, Bram Stoker's Dracula and Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

702 words - 3 pages The two Gothic novels, Dracula and Frankenstein, introduced two of the most terrifying characters throughout all of literature. Bram Stoker, the author of Dracula, and Mary Shelley, the author of Frankenstein, both present elements of terror and create a tense mood and a gruesome picture. In both of these novels the other characters are not able to see these evil creatures actions. Although both of these novels depict truly evil minds, Dracula

Comparing Frankenstein, Origin of the Species and Decent of Man

1408 words - 6 pages Comparing Frankenstein, Origin of the Species and Decent of Man   I will demonstrate in this paper how Mary Shelley's Frankenstein confirms, and at the same time contradicts Darwin's ideas presented in "The Origin of the Species" and "The Decent of Man." Mary Shelley's Frankenstein is at once, confirming, and contradictory of Charles Darwin's scientific discoveries and views on science, nature and the relation of the individual to

The Characters' Personalities in "Grendel" and "Beowulf"

1057 words - 4 pages of Grendel entails that Grendel is a depressed and misunderstood monster, restrained to the confinements of his own underwater cave. He is a lot like the monster in the book Frankenstein. Both Grendel and Frankenstein are born with no real purpose to life, going off of what they hear other people say and taking it as the truth. Both monsters, knowing that everyone detests them for being unattractive and different, retaliate by way of murder and

Point Of View In Grendel And Beowulf

1145 words - 5 pages Contrasting points of view in Grendel and Beowulf significantly alter the reader’s perception of religion, good and evil, and the character Grendel. John Gardner’s book, Grendel, is written in first person. The book translated by Burton Raffel, Beowulf, is written in third person. Good and evil is one of the main conflicts in the poem Beowulf. How is Grendel affected by the concepts of good and evil? Grendel is an alienated individual who just

Analysis of the Creation Scene from Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein and Kenneth Branagh’s 1994 Film Version

1346 words - 5 pages Analysis of the Creation Scene from Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein and Kenneth Branagh’s 1994 Film Version One of the key themes in Mary Shelley’s ‘Frankenstein’ is human arrogance. Frankenstein’s curiosity leads him to play the role of God. In a way Frankenstein is responsible for the monster and has ultimately become a father figure to the monster. Frankenstein abandoning the monster leads up to it turning evil and looking

Creation of Life in Frankenstein by Mary Shelley

1389 words - 6 pages Many people may think that if someone were to create life as complex as humans it would beneficial to humans. In the story Frankenstein, Victor creates an intelligent new species of life. This “monster” is rejected by society and seeks revenge on humans and Victor. Throughout Frankenstein, Mary Shelley uses the theme of the creation and destruction of life to illustrate how the creation of life can be a threat to many other lives. The book

The “Other” Creation: Post-Colonialism in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein

1288 words - 5 pages . Throughout the novel, the Creature is ostracized not only by Frankenstein but by society as a whole. Initially a kind and gentle being, the Creature becomes violent and eventually seeks revenge for his creator’s betrayal. Rather than to merely focus on the exclusion of the Creature from society, Shelley depicts the progression of Dr. Frankenstein’s seclusion from other humans as well, until he and the Creature ultimately become equals – alone in the

Frankenstein - Ideologies of Fire as Knowledge and Creation

1299 words - 5 pages Frankenstein's and both are cruelly punished for their challenge to the role of the gods. Shelley, in describing the dream from which her most famous Gothic novel grew, said about the creation `Frightful must it be, for supremely frightful would be the effect of any human endeavour to mock the stupendous mechanism of the Creator of the world.' Whilst Prometheus is disciplined for his blasphemous act as I have already mentioned, Frankenstein's

Similar Essays

Comparing The Creation Scene In James Whale's 1931 Frankenstein And Kenneth Brannagh's 1994 Frankenstein

5257 words - 21 pages Comparing the Creation Scene in James Whale's 1931 Frankenstein and Kenneth Brannagh's 1994 Frankenstein James Whale’s 1931 portrayal of Frankenstein when compared to Kenneth Brannagh’s alternate account from 1994 reveals some similarities but also many differences in the way they try to evoke emotions such as horror, fear and expectation from the audience and keep the plot moving. To do this, the directors have used a

Comparing The Theogony And Creation In Genesis

1524 words - 7 pages Throughout the world there are various cultures with varying religions and creation stories to explain the creation of the Earth and it’s inhabitants. Of these creation stories two with similar and also different characteristics is the Creation story in the book of Genesis which is a part of the 1st Testament in the Hebrew Bible and explains the creation of Earth and humans, and the Theogony which is the greek creation story that describes

Comparing Creation Myths Of Ancient Egypt And The Christian Bible

1207 words - 5 pages Comparing Creation Myths of Ancient Egypt and The Christian Bible Creation in Ancient Egyptian religion can be much different than the creation account taken from The Bible. Genesis has a set description of “The Beginning” while there are several different versions and variations in Egyptian mythology. The versions range from a “one god” myth (Ptah; see picture) to the more common creator out of Nun, which in itself has several derivations

A Comparison Of Grendel In Beowulf And John Gardner's Grendel

740 words - 3 pages character in Beowulf except Grendel? The only outright thing we know about him is that he is the spawn of Cain. It is almost as if the Anglo-Saxon's didn't want you to know how Grendel became the way he did. If you don't want people like that in your colony, why would you teach them about one; unless the story was dead-set on comitatus and heroism against this creature? They hammer this vision of Asgard and what you will get if you die in an act of