Comparing The Beloved In Shakespeare's Sonnet 20 And Sonnet 130

1392 words - 6 pages

Comparing the Beloved in Shakespeare's Sonnet 20 and Sonnet 130   

In the hands of a master such as Shakespeare, the conventions of the sonnet form are manipulated and transformed into something unique and originally emphasized. Both sonnets in one way or another subvert the conventions of the base Petrarchan sonnet; though they are about love, the traditional topic of sonnets, whilst in Sonnet 20 the object of desire is unattainable and there is no evidence of the level of affection being requited, the target is male, and the target of the poet's affections in Sonnet 130 is the poetic voice's current mistress. It also seems important to note that love in neither of these cases is of the generic youthful female Aryan stereotype, and in the latter case we are left in little doubt this is most definitely calculatedly to be so. Shakespeare's sonnet collection runs the gamut of a host of playful tweaks of the usual, routine sonnet; each break from convention serves not only to emphasise his particular point of the moment, but enrich the reading experience for those familiar with genre as it stood before Shakespeare's diversification.

Sonnet 130 belongs to the 'dark mistress' group of the Sonnets, and is well-known and often selected for anthologies. This may possibly be because it conveys two opinions particularly beloved of Shakespeare — the purpose of this sonnet (indeed a number of the pieces of Shakespeare's sonnet arc cover this issue) is to challenge the conventional image of beauty of the era, which held pale skin and golden, wiry tresses to be the desirable zenith of female beauty. It is also, perhaps more importantly, seeking to challenge the almost wilfully insincere flattery demonstrated in the largely derivative sonnets in circulation in the author's time; Shakespeare replaces this with a genuine regard and affection as strong as any poet ever claimed in exaggeration.

The poetic voice's mistress is of nature; no supernal gifts are hers. It is even strongly indicated that she is beneath the highest forms of beauty nature has to offer (her eyes are "nothing like the sun", "coral is far more red" than her lips, no "roses see I in her cheeks".) But this is to stray beyond the confines of the original subject, the rest of the verse argues, because the love the voice has for its lover is "as rare" as any other; beauty does not have to draw such clichéd parallels with nature to be thought of in the mind of a lover as surpassing everything around it. In reference to this repeated theme, in the introduction to the Penguin Classics printing of the Sonnets (though in reference specifically to sonnet 84), editor John Kerrigan concludes:

'"Which hyperbolic poet", Shakespeare asks, "which most-sayer, can exceed this sublime truism, that 'you alone are you'. For you comprise the only things which, in honesty, you can be compared with"'.

This sonnet serves to invoke a strong sense of realism in love, arguing that as strong an...

Find Another Essay On Comparing the Beloved in Shakespeare's Sonnet 20 and Sonnet 130

A Critical Comparison of Shakespeare's "Sonnet 130" and Elizabeth Barrett-Browning's "Sonnet 14"

1312 words - 5 pages Petrarchan sonnets are like all the other typical sonnets in the early sixteenth which consist of 14 verses in the poem and 10 syllables per line. In comparison, they all instigate the traditional theme of love where women were admired and sometimes worshipped in order to express deep love that emissaries her beauty. However, Petrarchan sonnet could not said be too congruent to sixteenth style of writing sonnets. Nevertheless, they share

Comment on the relationship between form and meaning in Shakespeare's 'Sonnet 20', and state briefly its context in relation to the rest of the sonnets.

1028 words - 4 pages In Elizabethan England, sonnets were extremely fashionable amongst poets, and it was common for poets to write customary love poems concentrating solely on the subject's positive aspects. Shakespeare broke away from the Renaissance tradition by forming his own methods, and by writing about a range of highly diverse concepts and themes. Sonnet 20, for example, is connected with anti-female ideas and homosexual love, which is in extreme contrast

Egotism and Love in Shakespeare's Sonnet 42

1364 words - 5 pages Egotism and Love in Shakespeare's Sonnet 42      William Shakespeare's sonnets deal with two very distinct individuals: the blond young man and the mysterious dark-haired woman. The young man is the focus of the earlier numbered sonnets while the latter ones deal primarily with the dark-haired woman. The character of the young man and a seductive mistress are brought together under passionate circumstances in Shakespeare's "Sonnet 42

Love in Shakespeare's Sonnet 128 and Gibran's The Prophet

1877 words - 8 pages Love in Shakespeare's Sonnet 128 and Gibran's The Prophet        William Shakespeare's "Sonnet 128" suggests a rather playful and sensual approach to love, while an excerpt on love and marriage from Kahlil Gibran's The Prophet has a didactic and intellectual tone. Shakespeare revels in lustful possession of his lover, but Gibran advises leaving space between partners in their relationship.   Well-endowed with imagery

The Tension between Beauty and Virtue in Shakespeare's Sonnet 95

1229 words - 5 pages The Tension between Beauty and Virtue in Shakespeare's Sonnet 95      "Sonnet 95" of Shakespeare's "blond young man" sonnets depicts a tension-filled variation on the classic blazon. The poet seems torn between the "shame" (1) that taints his subject and the "sweets" (4) of the subject 's beauty. The initial imagery of a "canker" (2) within a "rose" (2) serves to set up the sexual overtones that dominate the poem, as well as to

“Trout” and “Sonnet 130”: A Comparison of Two Poems

553 words - 2 pages “Trout” and “Sonnet 130”: A Comparison of Two Poems In “Trout” by David Marlatt and “Sonnet 130” by William Shakespeare, both describe their loves in unusual, more complex ways then what is usually written in poetry. “Trout” describes a day where the speaker swims next to his love, and explains to her that she is as beautiful as a trout. Throughout the poem, however, there seems to be a tone of admiration, and the audience cannot hellp

Warnings in Shakespeare's Sonnet 95

1474 words - 6 pages Warnings in Shakespeare's Sonnet 95        William Shakespeare is the master of subtle humor and sexual puns.  In his "Sonnet 95," a poem to a blond young man, both are seen while pointing out a couple of realities about sexual sin.  He speaks directly to a young man whose physical beauty compensates for his lack of sexual morality.     Shakespeare would like for this young man to realize that his handsomeness is the

Close Reading of Shakespeare´s Sonnet 130

795 words - 3 pages Sonnet 130 is Shakespeare’s harsh yet realistic tribute to his quite ordinary mistress. Conventional love poetry of his time would employ Petrarchan imagery and entertain notions of courtly love. Francis Petrarch, often noted for his perfection of the sonnet form, developed a number of techniques for describing love’s pleasures and torments as well as the beauty of the beloved. While Shakespeare adheres to this form, he undermines it as well

Life Struggling Against Death in Shakespeare's Sixtieth Sonnet (Sonnet 60)

982 words - 4 pages Life Struggling Against Death in Shakespeare's Sixtieth Sonnet (Sonnet 60) Shakespeare's sixtieth sonnet is probably addressed to the same young, male friend to whom most or all of the earlier sonnets are said to be addressed. The sonnet does not specify this, however, so it could be to anyone or everyone. The theme is certainly universal; time steals human life away, but poetry is immortal. The poet uses diction and imagery to paint a

Physicality and Emotional Attachment in Shakespeare's Sonnet 46

1203 words - 5 pages Physicality and Emotional Attachment in Shakespeare's Sonnet 46      In "Sonnet 46" of his works about the blond young man, William Shakespeare presents a unique view on the classic debate about physical lust versus emotional love. The poet struggles to decide if his feelings are based upon superficial desire and infatuation, represented by the "eye" (1), or true love independent of the physical world, symbolized by the "heart" (1

William Shakespeare's Sonnet

944 words - 4 pages their lover and give it to her. In this work I will compare William Shakespeare's written sonnet "Shall I compare thee to a summer's day?" in the 16th century and Howard Moss's offered interpretation of this sonnet.The Shakespeare's sonnet is about the power of love to immortalize the poetry. From the first lines of the sonnet we can see the idealized image of Shakespeare's friend:"Shall I compare thee to a summer's day?Thou art more lovely and

Similar Essays

Comparing And Contrasting Shakespeare's Sonnet 130 And Clause Mc Kay's The Harlem Dancer

769 words - 3 pages “Beauty is not in the face; beauty is a light in the heart.”- Kahlil Gibran. I am going to compare, contrast and analysis between “Sonnet 130”, by William Shakespeare and “The Harlem Dancer”, by Claude McKay. Both poems and sonnets are English and have fourteen lines or stanzas, and the rhyme scheme of ABABCDCDEFEFGG, which points out beauty in women. A sonnet is a fixed patterned poem that expresses a single, complete thought or idea. Sonnet

Shakespeare's Sonnet 130 And Unconventional Love

942 words - 4 pages to glorify her because his love is strong despite her imperfections. She does not float above him like any divine form, and this shows that she is Shakespeare's equal. The idea that they walk on the same ground reinforces the authenticity of Shakespeare's love because he loves her not in spite of her humanity, but because of it.Shakespeare's Sonnet 130 is a bold statement on unconventional, natural love. It displays the author's frustration with

Sonnet 130 Vs. The Passionate Essay

808 words - 3 pages showing her that he will give her all these opulent treasures if she would just fulfill his one wish. However, in Shakespeare's poem, the poet expresses the same kind of love but instead uses characteristics and physical attributes of his love rather than tangible materialistic things like the poet in Marlowe's poem did. The persona in Sonnet 130 uses attributes of his beloved to tell her that she is "rare" and at the same time he loves her. After

An Explination Of Shakespeare's Sonnet 130

649 words - 3 pages the Petrarchan tradition. Instead of being love sick and idolizing his lady, Shakespeare demeans his lady by comparing her to unattractive subjects by using similes and metaphors. While the quatrain mocks his lady, the couplet unveils a whole different side of his “love story.” Shakespeare’s sonnet explores the idea that his love is incomparable and rare even though his lady is not the most desirable through mocking the idealized love object