Comparing The Book And Movie Version Of The Secret Garden

674 words - 3 pages

The Secret Garden: Book vs. Movie

The Secret Garden is a film based on Frances Hodgson Burnett's classic children's book bearing the same title. This movie is about a young girl who is literally shipped off to her uncle's English castle after her parents are killed in an earthquake. The main character, Mary, is played by Kate Maberly. She is tossed into a world where sunlight and cheerful discourse seem as rare as the attention she receives from the sour-pussed housekeeper Medlock, played by Maggie Smith. She helps her crippled cousin to see past his hypochondria and into the wonders of a long forgotten garden hidden beyond the confines of Misselthwaite Manor. While one critic dislikes the slight deviations from the book, another is content to relish in the imagery and scenery of The Secret Garden.

Megan Rosenfeld, a Washington Post staff writer, is obviously distressed at the modifications made by director Agnieszka Holland to the original story. Ms. Rosenfeld asserts, "If it ain't broke, don't rewrite it." She refers to some specific changes, including the use of an earthquake as a means to kill off Mary's parents, instead of the cholera outbreak employed by the book's author. Throughout her review of The Secret Garden, Ms. Rosenfeld hammers away at the movie's deviations from the book, though she acknowledges, "Some changes admittedly are useful. . . ." She also feels that screenwriter Caroline Thompson's effort was "annoying." This critic, with a few exceptions, gives the crew high marks for the props and scenery that support the story. Though charming, The Secret Garden is no more than a hatchet job on a classic story, according to Megan Rosenfeld (D1-2).

Desson Howe of The Washington Post saw The Secret Garden in a positive light, regarding the slight changes from the book as "quiet charms." Howe finds this picture to be an especially agreeable one, considering some of the less cerebrally challenging movies that are aimed at youngsters. This is mostly a serious movie, even...

Find Another Essay On Comparing the Book and Movie Version of The Secret Garden

"Thirteen Days": Comparing and Contrasting the Book and the Movie

760 words - 3 pages "Thirteen Days", written by Robert F. Kennedy, is an account of the Cuban Missile Crisis based on the view of Robert F. Kennedy. This book contains Kennedy's thoughts about the Cuban Missile Crisis and the actions that he and the rest of the United States cabinet took to prevent a nuclear disaster and World War III. There is also a movie based on the book starring Kevin Costner. Most movies that are based on books are often exceeding inaccurate,...

Comparing and Contrasting Society in the Book, The Lathe of Heaven and the Movie, Matrix

825 words - 3 pages Comparing and Contrasting Society in the Book, The Lathe of Heaven and the Movie, Matrix In the book The Lathe of Heaven, by Ursula K. Le Guin, there are many similarities and some differences in society in comparison to the movie Matrix. The two stories settings take place in different locations. Although, throughout both stories many huge changes are made, the people in the societies remain unaware of the changes. Then, similarly,...

This essays compares the The book version of the Salem Witch Trials "The Crucible" to the movie version of The Salem Witch Trials

595 words - 2 pages The Crucible is a story of the Salem Witch Trials, which took place in 1692. Arthur Miller has portrayed this story in many different forums. The book for example, requires the reader to think, picture and visualize emotions and scenes by thought of imagination. The movie, however, adds all emotions and allow the viewers to connect with the characters, from seeing the emotions and body language being expressed. This leaves many with the question,...

Comparing and Contrasting the Movie "Troy" and the Book "The Iliad"

732 words - 3 pages Between the novel "The Iliad" by Homer and the movie "Troy" directed by Wolfgang Peterson, there were mostly great similarities, yet there were also some strong differences. Although most of the movie was on point according to the storyline and dialogues of the characters, there were still some major differences among the two. If I was ever to make my own version of the Iliad into a movie, this would be what I would change; I would make the movie...

Into the Wild: Comparing the Book to the Movie

1398 words - 6 pages Into The Wild Everybody expects to see the best parts of the book when going to see a movie that is based on a book, but most of the time “The book is better than the movie” and that is what happened in Into the Wild. The movie’s theme is somehow same but the way it is presented quite different than the book. The book Into The Wild, is a travel essay written by Jon Krakauer. It is about a young suburban man from a well to do family who hitched...

Comparing the movie "Awakenings" with the book "Charlie"

878 words - 4 pages The movie "Awakenings" Is about a boy who slowly slows down until his brain is oblivious to his surroundings. The book "Charlie" Is about a mentally challenged man who undergoes a surgery to make his intelligence increase to the norm, except it increases to the point of brilliancy. Both Charlie and Leonard learned to appreciate the smaller things in life as a result of what they went threw. The intelligence that Charlie obtained and Leonard's...

Comparing and Contrasting the Movie and Natalie Babbitt's Book Entitled Tuck Everlasting

904 words - 4 pages Do you know a book called Tuck Everlasting which is written by Natalie Babbitt existed in this world? It is a very interesting novel with a very sad ending. It’s a story about a girl, who discovered a very dangerous secret about a particular spring water. When you drink the water, it makes you immortal. A movie on this book was produced later on. Things change when you have to audition something that is written. And so, the movie Tuck Everlasting...

Can we Trust? comparing minority report the movie to the book. theme of trust

1593 words - 6 pages Can We Trust?In some point of life, everybody has been faced with the question whether to trust or not to trust. What is trust? Trust is defined by Webster as a firm reliance on integrity, ability, or character in someone or something. Throughout the book, by Philip Dick, and the movie, "Minority Report", trust is a key element that plays a major role. In comparing the book to the movie, trust in technology, trust in people, and trust in fate are...

Analytical Exposition - Comparing the book 'Tomorrow when the war began' to the movie 'Lord of the Flies' By Emily Bridget

980 words - 4 pages Analytical ExpositionEmerald BeamishTheir lives will never be the same again after what has happened to all of them.Tomorrow, when the war began has a sense of hope, whereas Lord of the Flies promotes despair. When two girls, from Tomorrow, When the War Began, decide to spend their Christmas holidays in a bush with a group of friends, they don't expect a war to erupt in their small town of Wirrawee. Luckily, they see light at the end of the...

Comparing and Contrasting Joy Luck Club Movie and Book

848 words - 3 pages The novel, The Joy Luck Club, by Amy Tan, tells of four Chinese women came together in San Francisco to play Mah-jong and they tell stories of the past while they were in China. These four women and their families all lived in Chinatown and suffered bad childhood while they were in China. They came to America with the belief that their daughters can change their fate. This is how the Woo's, the Hsu's, the Jong's and the St Clair's met in 1949. ...

The Secret Garden

1170 words - 5 pages The physiological and psychological impact of the gothic elements in Frances Hodgson Burnett's, "The Secret Garden", become linked with an appreciation of the joys of extreme emotion, the thrill of fearfulness, the awe inherent in the sublime, and a quest for atmosphere. Both Mary Lennox, a sour and spoiled child native to India, and Colin Craven, a sickly and baleful boy native to England, embark on a majestic transformation from the sublime...

Similar Essays

Comparing The Book And Movie Version Of The Grapes Of Wrath

2088 words - 8 pages The Grapes of Wrath: Comparing Book and Movie       Ford attempted to establish a sense of historical context by inserting two paragraphs of prose on the screen immediately following the opening credits: ' In the central part of the United States of America lies a limited area called 'the Dust Bowl', because of its lack of rains. Here drought and poverty combined to deprive many farmers from their land. This is the story of one...

James M. Cain's Novel Mildred Pierce: Comparing The Book And Movie Version

919 words - 4 pages James M. Cain's Novel Mildred Pierce: Comparing the Book and Movie Version Mildred Pierce is one of the greatest novels written by James M. Cain. After the success of the novel, the Hollywood film came out, produced by Jerry Wald. The novel and the movie are very different from each other. “James M. Cain sent several letters of complaint to producer Jerry Wald, objecting to the changes Wald wanted to make, especially the dramatic idea of...

Movie Essays Comparing The Novel And Film Version Of Joy Luck Club

1844 words - 7 pages Comparing the Novel and Film Version of Joy Luck Club    Wayne Wang's adaptation of Amy Tan's Joy Luck Club combines literary and cinematic devices by adopting the novel's narrative techniques and strengthening them through image and sound. The adaptation exemplifies not a destruction or abuse of Amy Tan's novel, but the emergence of a new work of art, not hindered but enhanced by the strengths of its literary precursor.            ...

Comparing And Contrasting The Book And Play Version Of Shelley's Frankenstein

1624 words - 6 pages Do not judge a book by its cover. Those are the words of a famous American proverb that says a person’s character cannot be judged based on their appearance. This proverb is very fitting in regards to the monster from Frankenstein. On the outside, he has a terrible appearance, and as a result is victimized and made to suffer by those who cannot see past his looks. Yet he has a kind soul and is simply looking for happiness and a little compassion...