Comparing The Position And Powers Of The Us President And The Uk Prime Minister

2062 words - 8 pages

Comparing the Position and Powers of the US President and the UK Prime Minister

Political instinct alone seems to dictate to many that the American
president - 'the world's most powerful man' - is the most powerful
politician in any of the world's democratic nations. He is at the head
of the world's most modern military force and the world's largest
economy. What the president says is reported around the world and
world share markets can fall or rise on any public statement by him.
But is he the western world's most powerful politician?

In America, the president is the best known of many politicians. This
alone gives him a great deal of authority as many people within their
own states cannot name their own representatives in the House, Senate
or governor. The simple fact, that the president has the title of
president gives him enormous authority and power in that he is the
main figurehead within the whole of the massive American political
structure. To take on the president is seen as almost taking on
America and all that the nation stands for. When Clinton moved towards
the impeachment process during the Lewinsky scandal, he was paying the
price for what he had done as a person not as a politician who
happened to be president. Even so, the fact that the Senate failed to
go all the way down the road to impeachment was probably because they
did not want to see the title of president sullied in such a manner.
The same is probably true of Nixon during the Watergate crisis. Here
was a man who was allowed to resign rather than face the ignominy of
impeachment and possibly a full trial in the full glare of the public
at both domestic and international level. Protecting the name of the
president and all he stands for does give the post-holder a great deal
of authority and, in this sense, power.

The British Prime Minister does have the same international standing
as the president. In the crisis involving Iraq, the driving force
behind any move against the leadership in Baghdad has been the
American president, G W Bush, while Tony Blair, the British Prime
Minister, has been referred to as clinging onto the coat tails of
Bush. Britain simply does not have the international standing to
overtly influence policies - her military is weak compared to America
and though a member of G7, our economic standing in the world is
dwarfed by America's. Such a position does not allow the Prime
Minister to drive an international agenda whereas the US president
can. In this sense, the power of the US president abroad is far
greater than that of the British Prime Minister.

In domestic politics that same power is more open to question. The
president can select his own cabinet with which he can work, but it
has to be ratified by the Senate. Whilst this is usually a formality -
as the Senate would...

Find Another Essay On Comparing the Position and Powers of the US President and the UK Prime Minister

Power of the British Prime Minister

946 words - 4 pages Crossman was able to develop his original theory that the PM dominated the decision making process. The PMs powers have grown over the last 100 years for a variety of reasons: the growth of the franchise has placed the elected government in a position of greater authority; the development of national party organisations after 1870 has tended to exalt the position of party leaders as leaders of mass parties and

The Affects of Prime Minister Sir. Robert Menzies and the turn around of Austraila's economy during his stint as prime minister

1543 words - 6 pages because of the fear of inflation, nonetheless the removed the rationing law, and inflation did increase but not as badly as expected. However it did pose a problem for the government beginning in 1951, luckily the threat of communism provided a convenient smokescreen for the government to hide behind until they figured out a solution to the problem.Sir Robert Menzies served as the Australian Prime Minister for 16 years (1950-1966) he was the only

The Separation and Balance of Powers in the UK Constitution

1742 words - 7 pages The Separation and Balance of Powers in the UK Constitution “By the latter part of the 20th century the independence of the judges had come under increasing threat from interference by the executive. Recent reforms have, however, served to redress this position and ensure that a proper division of personnel and functions between these two arms of the state is restored. Discuss this statement in the context of the

Finance Overview of US and the UK

1321 words - 6 pages , under all circumstances are reasonably adduced as per the accepted code of conduct in accounting principles ( For proper comparison of government spending between the US and the UK governments, this research paper will pick 2011-2012 financial years for both countries as the basis of comparison. Government spending (United Kingdom) Public sector expenditure, also known as government spending, is AuthorLastName4 the

The Powers of the United States President

1055 words - 4 pages States for at least 14 years” ( Presidents). The powers of the U.S, President are outlined in Article II of the Constitution. This states that executive power shall be vested in a President of the United States making the President the head of the Executive Branch of the Federal Government. Presidential powers include: authority to appoint judges and ambassadors as well as other high ranking officials, foreign policy powers

The President of the United States of America - Powers and Priveleges

1874 words - 7 pages Despite the intentions of the framers of the Constitution and the subsequent roles laid out for the president therein, the President of the United States of America has assumed roles and powers that somewhat challenge these intentions. Since the forming of the Union there has been a continuing struggle over the powers of the president and whether he should take a reserved legalist position or a more activist role. The legalist and activist

No Separation of Powers in the UK

1698 words - 7 pages . However, it is important to realize that in the absence of a codified constitution, there is no formal separation of powers. The functions of legislature and executive are inter-related and ministers are members of both. Overlaps do occur, which can question its effectiveness in protecting the rule of law. Unlike US, in the UK, the PM is always the leader of the leading party, which makes scrutiny much harder and makes the likelihood of exploitation

Questions and predicted answers for the australian prime minister and minister for foreign affairs to stimulate thought about australian foreign policy

669 words - 3 pages Questions for the Hon. Prime Minister John Howard1. Mr Prime Minister, how do you feel about Australia's early Foreign Policy, for example the White Australia Policy and propaganda about the 'yellow peril' in the first half of last century?-early Foreign Policy was mostly dictated by Britain-White Australia Policy was a lamentable mistake, but might be considered essential in the development of Australia's modern Foreign Policy.-all turned out

Board of Directors' role in the US and UK

1637 words - 7 pages the UK, which only rose by 5.9%. (Eisinger) Eisinger believes the reason the UK have been able to control excessive compensation is because in Britain shareholder have a vote on the compensation package that the board’s compensation committee has come up with. If the shareholders believe it is too excessive they can vote it down. In the US in July of 2010, President Barak Obama signed into law the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer

This essay is on Robert Muldoon, the former New Zealand Prime Minister and his role in the 1981 Springbok tour

509 words - 3 pages accepting apartheid.Muldoon and his national party won the New Zealand election in 1975, keeping his promise of not interfering with sports, unlike Norman Kirk the last prime minister, Muldoon did not stop the All Blacks going to South Africa in 1976 despite tens of thousands of protesters. To show their displeasure at his action, 21 nations mostly African, walked out of the Montreal Olympic Games.To talk about the damages between African counties

Biography of Mackenzie King, The Longest Serving Prime Minister of Canada

1175 words - 5 pages Mackenzie King was the longest serving Prime Minister of Canada (Neatby, 2005). For many King was a great and effective Prime Minister. But for others, he was ineffective due to his “5 cent speech”, racist behavior and lastly for his strong spiritual beliefs. Therefore this makes William Lyon Mackenzie King to be an ineffective Prime Minister of Canada from the years 1921-1929. King’s biggest act that clearly shows him to be an unfit and

Similar Essays

Comparing Pluralist And Marxist Accounts Of Power In The Uk And Us

2186 words - 9 pages Comparing Pluralist and Marxist Accounts of Power in the UK and US Pluralism and Marxism both offer comprehensive theories about the location of power within the modern state. Both theories to some extent were based on Western governments; with Marxism being developed partly through Engels’ experiences in Manchester in the mid nineteenth century and Pluralism being developed through the studies in America in the mid

United States President Vs Canadian Prime Minister

1262 words - 5 pages The US president wields a lot of power both domestically and in the international scene. These powers are granted by a number of statutes, amendments, the Constitution, congressional acts, and numerous influences and soft power by virtue of his position as the leader. On the other hand, Canada does not have a president and is instead led by a prime minister. Although the two countries are almost equal in size, their leaders exhibit vast

Kgb To Prime Minister To President

1290 words - 6 pages politician, Anatoly Sobchak, for mayor of Leningrad. When Sobchak became mayor Putin became his first deputy mayor. After that he steadily rose in Russian politics to become President, then Prime Minister, and then to become President again. After earning his third term in office Putin moved his troops into the Crimean peninsula amongst criticism from many other countries. The day after his troops entered the Crimean peninsula his nomination for

Limits Of The Prime Minister Essay

1237 words - 5 pages Limits of the Prime Minister The formal constitutional powers listed in the previous answer 'The powers of the Prime Minister' are subject to a number of restraints in practice, which means that the British PM is not as powerful as often assumed, or as commonly alleged by critics. The large number of main constraints are as follows: Constraints on the power of patronage