Comparing The Democratic Progress In Taiwan And Hong Kong

1794 words - 7 pages

Internal factors: The political system and the public involvement
Progress of development of the political system
The different progress of development of the democratic system in Taiwan and Hong Kong can be attributed to their internal and unique political structure and role of political parties.
First of all, it should be noted that there are fundamental differences in the design of government structures in Taiwan and Hong Kong. In Taiwan, as long as the boss of the party won the presidential election, he or she will be granted the legitimacy to rule the country, no matter the KMT, DPP or any party he or she comes from. Also, the president was elected by representatives of the National Assembly indirectly. He or she would be responsible for organizing the government. Thus, in the National Assembly, the power to rule the country rested on the political party who controls the majority seats. In contrast, the political system of Hong Kong was highly deviated from Taiwan. In Hong Kong, before 1997 it was the British who appointed the Governor to maneuver the administrative power, but after the handover the Chief Executive was elected by 400 people who are eligible to being in the Election Committee (Kwok, 2003). The British or the Chinese government had never intended to share the power to the local government which was made up by election. Even though direct elections had been introduced by the British government in 1991, administrative power was still strictly held in the hands of the Hong Kong government and the essence of the governance simply did not changed (Kwok, 2003). This can be reflected by the existence of opposition parties and the inability of them to get the ruling power despite they could reach a simple majority in the Legislative Council. Put it simply, the advancement of Hong Kong political party was not permitted and hindered by this kind of built-in limitation of the political system. All these parties or individual as a result could merely play a role of the opposition power and there is no room for them to participate in the making and implementation of the policy. It is quite clear that a line had been drawn by the Hong Kong government to avoid any political parties to undertake daily administration. This cause people’s frustration (especially for those who intended to contribute themselves to the political development) as in reality they can only become a civil servant or even to become close allies with the PRC government or the Chief Executive of Hong Kong.
Besides, the political parties in Hong Kong are in great variance with those in Taiwan. Although Taiwan has never proclaimed independence officially, it was a de facto political reality. In Taiwan, no matter which political power won the election, they are equal in the sense that all of them can have a chance in winning the full control of the administration of the country. This was applicable to both the KMT and the DPP party. Through the opening up of the political...

Find Another Essay On Comparing the Democratic Progress in Taiwan and Hong Kong

Toronto and Hong Kong. Essay

579 words - 2 pages , democratic governments run them both. Toronto is composed of six communities: Toronto, North York, Scarborough, Etobicoke, York, and East York. On the other hand, Hong Kong is composed of many different communities and towns. The population of Toronto consists of people from different ethnic backgrounds such as Italians, Chinese, English, Americans, Indians, Black Americans, etc while the 98% of the population in Hong Kong are Chinese and only 2% are

Prostitution in Hong Kong Essay

2547 words - 10 pages , 2008) , no concerns made. Situation in particular countries; and How if Hong Kong adopt policies from them For oversea countries, most of them adopt distinct policies when comparing with Hong Kong although some may adopt similar approach. For England, similar policies (Phoenix, 2009) is adopted since Hong Kong set the law based on hers in 1978. Some amendments had been made on Sexual Offences Act in 1985 and 2003 respectively, also some

Homosexuality in Hong Kong

1807 words - 7 pages Introduction In the last decade, the issue of homosexuality has been widely discussed and known in Hong Kong. People have more opportunities to approach the word `homosexuality' in their daily life through literatures, movies and occasional news revealing celebrities' homosexual behaviors. Simultaneously there has also been significant growth in commercial venues such as restaurants and bars, catering to gays and lesbians. In short, the

Hong Kong In 2051

1303 words - 5 pages transport as its network reaches every corner of Hong Kong. Apart from this, the monorail is fast and has a large carrying capacity, so there is not reason for not using it.Before I knew it, I am already heading towards the tree-planting site. This campaign has been going on for more than one year already, and we are now beginning to see the fruit of our hard work. I could never imagine Central becoming so ¡¥green¡¦ in the

Obesity in Hong Kong

706 words - 3 pages 1. Introduction: In Hong Kong, the problem of obesity is quite serious. According to the Population Health Survey 2003/2004 commissioned by The Department of Health, around 18% of the population aged 15 and above were overweight and around a quarter of the population were obese. [1] In spite of this, in order to tackle this problem effectively, the causes of the problem will be evaluated and the different preventative measures will be suggested

Civil culture in Hong Kong

1573 words - 6 pages towards democracy? To explore the issue I would first summarize the finding of the article "Political values" in "The ethos of the Hong Kong Chinese" and would focus the discussion on the political participation of Hong Kong Chinese.Political Values - The ethos of the Hong Kong ChineseMild Democratic AspirationsPublic satisfactory with the existing political system does not mean that Hong Kong people lack the desire for institutional changes

Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of online shopping for consumers in Hong Kong.

889 words - 4 pages In the past few years, a great deal of people created an online shop and exploit the online purchasing market in Hong Kong. Not only had some general residents do that, but also some large-scale chain stores, such as, IKEA and Sasa. These stores have also established their own online shopping system. In addition, the online shopping phenomenon has continuous increase. While some online shopping system’s users welcome this new technology that

Prosecutorial and Judicial Independence of the Superior Courts in Hong Kong

1445 words - 6 pages Basic Law provides for both prosecutorial and judicial independence, as both are vital under the Rule of Law in Hong Kong. This paper looks at issues in connection with prosecutorial independence and judicial independence of the superior courts. Indeed both are not functioning with total independency with the judiciary perceived to be more independent. As both are vital to the rule of law in Hong Kong, the prosecutorial independency and

business law in hong kong

826 words - 3 pages . There are numbers of immigration policies currently adopted by the immigration department of Hong Kong, Quality Migrant Admission Scheme (QMAS) and Capital Investment Entrant Scheme (CIES) are the most famous among all.To start with, Quality Migrant Admission Scheme refers to acquire of diverse talented or high technique person to stay and live in Hong Kong as a local citizen, in order to raise the international competitiveness of her. People

popular nomination in hong kong

1310 words - 5 pages essay demonstrates the difference and the comparison of views of two parties which are the 'against' and 'for'. By the explanation of the comparisons, it is believed that the popular nomination is a better way to choose the Chief Executive before the new method is proposed.POPULAR NOMINATION IN HONG KONG 1POPULAR NOMINATION IN HONG KONG 2First of all, the popular nomination does not violate the Basic Law. According to the article 45 in Basic Law

Air pollution in hong kong

628 words - 3 pages Class: 5D Name: Cheung Ching Him, Anson Number: (7) Air pollution in Hong Kong 'I durst not laugh for fear of opening my lips and receiving the bad air,' wrote William Shakespeare. Many people may feel the same the way when they are walking in Hong Kong streets. Air pollution in Hong Kong is often so bad that it is impossible to see across Victoria Harbour due to all the haze and smog. In this essay, I am writing to raise several concerns about

Similar Essays

Balancing Democracy And Reality In Hong Kong

3409 words - 14 pages rising demand from the public and to achieve any constructive progress in political development in Hong Kong. In the paper, explanations about the incompetence of the chief executives (CE) in Hong Kong will be focused under the umbrella of lacking legitimacy and institutional weakness that pose hurdles for the CE in his governance as well as providing suggestions to improve their performance. The executive is defined as the central policy-making

The Education System In Hong Kong

1092 words - 4 pages problems on the education system in Hong Kong. Then focus on the countermeasures of how to make the education system better and students not stressful.Firstly, it has been criticized that Hong Kong education system is being extremely tough. When comparing to other schools in different countries, schools in Hong Kong are much more exam-orientated. Specifically, students in Hong Kong have quizzes or tests on each subject weekly; and exams every

The Causes And Future Of Taiwan And Hong Kong's Fdi In Mainland China

1058 words - 5 pages From 1979-2000, China pursued a policy this promoted FDI related to export promotion, which contributed to Taiwan and Hong Kong investment, because it helped it helped protect China’s local businesses. Market driven FDI, which is primarily what the US, EU and Japan are interested in investing, was limited in China because it would potentially hurt Chinese firms due to intense competition from western firms (Naughton, 403). The “western” firms

Dim The Light: Light In Hong Kong

2068 words - 8 pages protruding from each of its districts. Ironically, this award had led to another one; being entitled as the worst light polluted city in the world. Light pollution had been a major phenomenon in the last few decades, particularly in urban areas. It was mainly caused by outdoor lights that scattered in the atmosphere and eventually reflected back to the ground. According to a survey conducted by physicists from University of Hong Kong, the light