Comparing The Documentary Hearts And Minds By Peter Davis With The Book, Dispatches By Michael Herr.

755 words - 3 pages

To far too many people, Vietnam and the conflict there remains a mystery. To some, it was the only war America has ever lost. To others, a senseless venture into a land we did not know, politics we did not understand, and an enemy far better able to fight in jungle terrain than American soldiers. Vietnam is history- and not very pleasant or comforting history. Hearts and Minds- the title comes from a Lyndon Johnson speech, depicts not merely the cruelty and callousness of both Americans and Viet Cong- but is far more politically against our involvement. Dispatches is an objective, but just as frightening series of reports from Esquire's war correspondent, Michael Herr.It is interesting to compare the documentary Hearts and Minds with the book, Dispatches. It is one thing to read about events by a correspondent, and quite something else to actually witness the horrors of war, and the comments both by politicians from Eisenhower to Nixon defending involvement in Vietnam, and then interviews with some who opposed Vietnam. The documentary even showed some veterans who felt some sort of regrets. And yet, one scene that stands out is a navy officer lecturing a classroom of children, and when one girl asked what Vietnam was like the answer was: "It's a beautiful country, if it weren't for the people". Hearts and Minds shows us brutality. And here one has to blame some of the Americans- not merely, as in one scene, shooting a young Viet while the camera continues to focus, but also GIs soliciting prostitutes. We see many scenes of crying children, citizens with missing limbs, burial of the dead, wounded moaning soldiers who had no idea really why they were even in this land of jungles thousands of miles from home. This is not Matt Damon, movie star, with grimy make-pup, as Private Ryan, or John Wayne storming beaches in the South Pacific. This is not make-believe. This is real. But, the movie, it is easy to establish right from the outside, takes sides. As a war correspondent, Herr is just an eyewitness. He defined his job when a helicopter group commander walked by: "'Don't you men salute officers?' 'We're not men.... we're...

Find Another Essay On Comparing the documentary Hearts and Minds by Peter Davis with the book, Dispatches by Michael Herr.

Book Review: The Practice of Management by Peter F. Drucker

1860 words - 7 pages The Practice of Management by Peter F. Drucker. Harper & Row, 1954This book is divided into 6 main parts: Managing A Business; Managing Managers; The Structure Of Management; Management Of Workers And The Worker; What It Means To Be A Manager; and a conclusion.In Managing a Business, Drucker stresses the importance of the customer , not economic or market forces, in defining a business. He suggests that it is the customer, not forces, that

Paper on the book "Timeline" by Michael Crichton

739 words - 3 pages The thrilling and truly fascinating book "Timeline", by Michael Crichton, is an action packed and intellectually intriguing read that will not only enrich the reader's knowledge of the 1300's, but also have the reader totally immersed in the mesmerizing plot accentuated with a mind-blowing amount of suspense that lingers throughout the duration of the book. Timeline adequately addresses both the history and the english requirements that are made

"The Andromeda Strain" by Michael Crichton, a science fiction book

1071 words - 4 pages The Andromeda Strain by Michael Crichton is a science fiction book aboutthe fictional 'first crisis' in the biological field. The book starts out bypointing out that technology is growing so rapidly, there is bound to becrises, like Three Mile Island and Chernobyl, and how the biological field ofscience has never had a major crisis. He also points out that biology is theyoungest of all the fields, and a crisis has been long overdue.It begins

Book Review: The Lesser Evil by Michael Ignatieff

2356 words - 9 pages that no violations of rights can ever be justified and a purely pragmatic position that judges antiterrorist measures solely by their effectiveness." (Ignatieff viii). Clearly, this book is a response to the apparent threat terrorism holds over the United States, and the belief that this threat is likely to only increase with time. Consequently, Ignatieff aims to offer a comprehensive argument detailing the ethics, justifications, successes

"The Maestro", by Peter Goldsworthy.

808 words - 3 pages The Maestro, by Peter GoldsworthyThe novel Maestro, by Peter Goldsworthy is a beautifully crafted novel dealing with the tragic gulf between talent and genius, between the real and the spurious. Good literature, however, is often judged not only by what is written, but also the way it is written. Reflecting this criteria, Maestro is well written, perfectly contrasted and thus an excellent example of a good piece of literature. Goldsworthy has

"How was Hitler able to successfully capture the hearts and minds of the German people and achieve such great power?"

1046 words - 4 pages them big promises of the birth of a new era for Germany. The Germans, desperate to cling onto any hope they had left, allowed themselves to be consumed with Hitler's policies and actions- consequently letting Hitler capture their hearts and minds, and attain great power.Hitler, with the help of Joseph Goebbels, was able to win the Germans over and consequently attain great authority by utilizing propaganda tactics. With the amount of followers that

The Investigation By Peter Weiss

528 words - 2 pages After reading The Investigation by Peter Weiss I feel completely discombobulated. I use this word with care and consideration. This, in my opinion was one of the most powerful books in the sense that it was accordingly written genuinely. The book being an actual play was at first a little confusing to figure out who was talking, the names were not given unless one of the "witness'" addressed them in their dialect. The descriptions of the

The Nutcracker by Peter Tchaikovsky

1603 words - 6 pages musical study and graduated with a silver medal from the St. Petersburg Conservatory(1). He published his first orchestral works, a symphony and an opera, by 1869 (1). Inspired by E. T. A. Hoffmann’s libretto, Tchaikovsky wrote his best-recognized ballet, The Nutcracker (“Peter Ilych Tchaikovsky” 2).The Nutcracker lends an ironic understatement to Tchaikovsky because of the ballet’s cheerfulness and Tchaikovsky’s various forms of mental stress he

Comparing the Stories of Mark and Peter

1597 words - 6 pages and empty accusations. (Mark 15.2) By saying this, Jesus never admits anything. While he does go along with what they are doing to him; he makes no comment on whether their accusations or rumors about him are true. A position that lets us know Jesus is taking the high road. However, in the Gospel of Peter we do not have the luxury of starting with such a conception, in fact we do not even get to see Jesus until they begin his tortures and

"The hours" by Michael Cunningham.

888 words - 4 pages the screen, as inspired by Michael Cunningham's 1998 novel, The Hours, which was in turn inspired by Virginia Woolf's Mrs. Dalloway.The film opens with Virginia Woolf's 1941 suicide. She places stones in her pockets and wades calmly into the river, letting the rushing water engulf her fragile body and battered soul. Eighteen years earlier, she is already struggling with her sanity. She hears voices. She succumbs to "moods." And she writes

Comparing and Contrasting Aunt Ida with Christing in A Yellow Raft in Blue Water by Michael Dorris

753 words - 3 pages Compare and ContrastIn A Yellow Raft in Blue Water By Michael Dorris the differences and similarities between Aunt Ida and Christine added to the overall effectiveness of this work and the imagery of a braid. In order to achieve this effect, Michael Dorris uses three different points of view; Christine's, Aunt Ida's, and Rayona's. Michael Dorris also uses diction to portray characterization differences as well as similarities.Aunt Ida's

Similar Essays

An Analysis/Review Of The Book Dispatches, By Michal Herr

1004 words - 4 pages Dispatches PaperAs I read Dispatches by Michael Herr, there is an overwhelming sense of fear and horror. His dispatches are populated by soldiers called 'grunts', whose enemy was everywhere and nowhere. Their maps were blank; their names for the enemy, 'Charlie' or 'VC', told them nothing. How do you recognize them? They all wear black pajamas; they are all alien to us. They are everywhere. That's where the paranoia began. Herr's dispatches are

Comparing The Ways Michael Herr In Dispatches And Pat Barker In Regeneration Show The Effects Of War

4183 words - 17 pages Comparing the Ways Michael Herr in Dispatches and Pat Barker in Regeneration Show the Effects of War When comparing Michael Herr's 'Dispatches' and 'Regeneration' by Pat Barker the differences in format, style and setting are clear from the outset. However both books explore the horrifying effect of war on those directly and indirectly involved. The two authors attempt to take the reader away from objective, statistical

Compairing The Two Books, "Dispatches" By Herr And "Batman: The Dark Knight Returns By" Miller. Focuses On An Indepth Look At The Main Characters And How They Are Seen In The Eye's Of The Reader.

1348 words - 5 pages other derogatory terms classing them through race. "I don't give a fuck, that's a fucking gook!"(Herr, 161) The view of the opposing enemy was commonly seen as worthless; many American soldiers mutilated the dead Viet Cong taking souvenirs such as ears for a necklace. One would never consider doing that to one of there own, so why is it accepted when done to another human? Total disregard and disrespect was shown by many Marines to the corpses of

Comparing The Old Nurses Story By Elizabeth Gaskell And Lost Hearts By M.R. James

1912 words - 8 pages Comparing The Old Nurses Story by Elizabeth Gaskell and Lost Hearts by M.R. James 'The Old Nurses Story' by Elizabeth Gaskell and 'Lost Hearts' by M.R. James are both 19th century mystery stories, so naturally they have similarities due to them both having the same genre but there are some ways in which the stories differ. 'Lost Hearts' is about a young girl called Rosamond aged about 4 or 5 who is orphaned and so has