This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing The Efficacy Of Cognitive Therapy And Antidepressant Medication In The Treatment Of Depression

1746 words - 7 pages

Major depressive disorder affects nearly 15 million of American adults in a given year. (Kessler, Chiu, Demler & Walters, 2005). With the impact it has on the society as well as the well-being of the individual, it must be in the interest of the healthcare to be able to provide patients with the most effective treatment method. Extensive research has been conducted on the efficacy of antidepressant medication and cognitive therapy, the two main treatment methods used for depression today. The discussion has, however, been characterized by conflicting claims, resulting in a debate over what should be used rather than us having definite conclusion of how patients are best helped.
The extensive research of Elkin et al (1989) concluded that cognitive therapy was not an effective treatment method for severely depressed outpatients. This had a major impact on the treatment guidelines of The Agency for Health Care Policy and Research, resulting in medications becoming generally favored at the time. These results, the quality of the therapy provided as well as the conclusions drawn have, however, been questioned by contradicting research which instead argue that cognitive therapy is just as effective in the treatment of depression. Hollon et al (1992) conducted a randomized trial which displayed both treatment methods as effective, with a non-significant difference of efficacy. Murphy, Carney, Knesevich, Wetzel and Whitworth (1995) also designed a trial which displayed similar results between the treatment methods while the research conducted by Blackburn & Moore (1997) indicated that cognitive therapy was superior to medications in the maintenance phase of treatment.
A high number of studies as well as the current treatment guidelines seem to conclude that the efficacy of cognitive therapy is just as high as for antidepressant medication. There is, however, discrepancy between the results, and in this review a closer look will be taken at more recent research and what the results suggest.

Five randomized trials conducted from the year 2000 and onwards were selected. The primary database used for searching was PsycINFO. Keywords used include “cognitive therapy”, “psychotherapy”, “antidepressants”, “medication”, “psychopharmaca”, “depression treatment” and “depressive disorder”.
In research conducted by Hollon et al (2005), it was stated that while there was evidence for the enduring effects of cognitive therapy, there was a lack of extensive research comparing the effects to the use of antidepressant medication after terminating the treatment.
In the study, 180 patients meeting the criterias for severe and major depression were assigned to either one of the treatment methods. Of these, 104 met the response criteria and were included in a 12 month continuation phase and constitute the main focus of the study. Patients who had responded to the therapy were withdrawn and followed up during a 12-month period. Those who had...

Find Another Essay On Comparing the efficacy of Cognitive Therapy and Antidepressant Medication in the Treatment of Depression

How Medication and Therapy Combats Depression

1692 words - 7 pages medication and psychotherapy. Depression is a highly treatable disorder and as with most illnesses, the earlier treatment begins the more effective it is and the greater the likelihood of recurrence can be prevented. The brain of a person who is suffering from depression has been altered and treatment time needs to be long enough for it to effect. Without extended treatment, relapse becomes very likely. In fact, more than fifty percent of people

How Medication and Therapy Combats Depression

1912 words - 8 pages , protection, and initiation of treatment. In combined treatments, medications are used to treat the symptoms of depression, while psychotherapy is used to help alleviate the problems depression causes in daily living. Psychotherapy is particularly important to undertake for anyone experiencing suicidal thoughts or profound psychological impairment. The most successful types of therapy that have shown to be the most effective, includes, cognitive

Cognitive Behavioral Therapy: Depression

1933 words - 8 pages , often trying to identify particular problematic thoughts or behavior. Once these problems are broken down it is then suggested a straightforward plan in which the patient and therapist can intervene to promote recovery. Cognitive behavioral therapy earliest inventors were behaviorist, such as Skinner, Watson, and Pavlov. They’re the ones who led to the advancement for behavioral treatment of mental disorders. Behavioral modification is a

Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy: Treatment of Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder

1527 words - 7 pages IV: Moodiness, loss of brother Axis V: 61-70, mild difficulty in social, occupational, or school functioning. BUT, the person is generally functioning pretty well and has some meaningful interpersonal relationships. Goals of Treatment Although the patient displays symptoms of Axis I disorders (depression and anxiety), she is likely to benefit from cognitive behavior therapy with a focus on restructuring her maladaptive cognitions concerning self

Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy: Treatment of Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder

2056 words - 9 pages ” and help the family. Since the gradual approach to the patient’s needs may result in strong feelings of guilt and aggression during initial therapy, it seems beneficial to focus on the treatment of cognitive schemas first. The therapist will strive to bring Thea to “soften” her current values and assumptions to remove the exaggerated, obsessive and dysfunctional parts. Beck emphasize the emotional and behavioral components of cognitive


2327 words - 9 pages that impacts the mind, body and interpersonal relationships of those with this disorder. Family therapy is helpful with patients suffering from anorexia nervosa in that parents and close family members take the active role in restoring positivity toward body image and dealing with eating issues. Family-based and cognitive behavior are found to be promising treatment build on the understanding of the client and changing the outcome of the

Comparing Adlerian Therapy, Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, and Solution Focused Brief Therapy

3634 words - 15 pages use to guide me daily as a school counselor. Modern day counseling is equipped with a wide variety of therapies, techniques and approaches. The purpose of this essay is to compare and contrast three approaches of therapy. Also in this essay the views of the person and the Therapeutic process will be discussed. The three models that are going to be compared are Adlerian, Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), and Solution Focused Brief therapy (SFBT

Comparing Various Treatment Options for Sexual Offenders and Their Efficacy Rates

2063 words - 8 pages offenders could be rehabilitated, as a result, the medical aspect of providing treatment minimized while appropriate therapy methods were developed that focused on the offender effects on their cognitive process of sexual deviant behavior increased. This evolution of treatment methods continued with clinicians, in the 1990's, pushed for a more structured therapy process that extended past the confines of a prison institution and into the

The Integration of Cognitive and Behavior Therapy

1644 words - 7 pages develops and changes (Kramer 293). The term “cognitive-behavioral therapy” or CBT is a term for therapies with many similarities. CBT is not used as a cure and often times used to help with anxiety or depression the most, and may be single or in group settings. There are several approaches to this form of therapy which include, Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy, Rational Behavior Therapy, Rational Living Therapy, Cognitive Therapy, and Dialectic

Using Music Therapy in the Treatment of Stress and Anxiety

2260 words - 9 pages the Journal of Music Therapy, “anxiety is generally regarded a negative emotional response to situations that are appraised to be threatening” (Elliot, Polman and McGregor 2011, p. 264) (as cited in Spielberger, 1989, p. 3-17). At the cognitive level, anxiety can produce feelings of apprehension, uneasiness, preoccupation, and worry (Elliot et al. 2011) (as cited in Bourne, 2000). There are many techniques used to treat those suffering with

The Symptoms and the Treatment of Depression

1663 words - 7 pages The Symptoms and the Treatment of Depression Depression has been a part of our lives for as long as humans have been on the earth. Everyone has had days when nothing was going right. But it all depends with an individual how to handled this adversity and how depressed that person becomes. Depression is considered to be the "common cold of psychological disorders." This is because depression

Similar Essays

Cognitive Behavioral Therapy In The Treatment Of Depression

2447 words - 10 pages Cognitive Behavioral Therapy in the Treatment of Depression Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) is a method of correcting invalid thought patterns to a more positive view of the person and their place in their world. Some people do not believe that Cognitive Behavioral Therapy is a real treatment for depression, claiming it is a form of positive thinking ("The Daily Mail," 2009). On the opposite end of the spectrum, others argue that Cognitive

Comparing Therapy And Medication Essay

1927 words - 8 pages is just as effective as keeping the patients on medication. The perhaps most highlighted study in recent years is the one of DeRubeis et al (2005), a straightforward placebo controlled trial comparing the efficacy of antidepressant medication and cognitive therapy in the treatment of moderate to severe depression. The background of the study consisted in a lack of research evaluating the effects of cognitive therapy in this specitic group. In the

Acceptance And Commitment Therapy Versus Cognitive Therapy For The Treatment Of Comorbid Eating Pathology

579 words - 3 pages disorders, substance abuse disorders, sleep disorders and psychotic disorders. Studies have shown that CBT actually changes brain activity in people with mental illnesses who receive this treatment, suggesting that the brain is actually improving its functionality as a result of engaging in this form of therapy. Thesis Statement CBT has been shown to be as beneficial as antidepressant medications for some individuals with eating disorders and may be

The Effectiveness Of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy On Treating Depression

2023 words - 8 pages In this assignment I will introduce my research project and examine some of the issues surrounding my topic, take an initial look at the research papers I have chosen for my literature review and consider the wider context that the research took place in. I have chosen to look into the effectiveness of Cognitive Behavioural Therapy(CBT) on treating depression in primary care. I am interested in this particular area of counselling as my