This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing The Film And The Novel Of Hemingway's Old Man And The Sea

2203 words - 9 pages

Comparing the Film and the Novel of Hemingway's Old Man and the Sea After having read the Hemingway's "Old Man and the Sea" as a book in
class, we also watched the film which was made afterwards because of
the story's enormous popularity. As always, there are some ways in
which the book differs from the film as well as the fact that they
have several things in common.
Taking into consideration that this novel was Hemingway's last
desperate attempt at breaking through after all his previous
narratives flopped I thought that the film might be different from the
movie indeed because he might've wanted to bring the story into
perfection in this way. Also I assumed it to be very boring to spend a
whole film showing how one single man overcomes his mental and
physical problems and eventually manages to catch a huge marlin and
take it home; thus that there were other, new events involved for more
variety and that things which were pushed into the background in the
book now were more striking fore extra depth. For example, a new role,
flashbacks and different storylines would make the film more
interesting.
From these suggested improvements you can conclude that I consider the
book to be a bit longwinded because there are actually very few events
taking place: the long fight against the marlin before it dies and
then the numerous shark attacks to the fish which the old man can't
avert. Anyhow, at mental point there's a lot to enjoy: every time when
Santiago faces a new problem to cope with he thinks of lions on the
beach (which represent him when he is young and strong and could
overcome any challenge), the great softball player Di-Maggio in whom
he has faith (he wants to be just as strong as him) or about the young
boy (Manolin) in his home-village (he wants him to be with him so he
can help). All those memories of his youth, idol and helper make the
story more interesting because in this way you get an idea of his
norms and values and what his life now and in the past looked like.
This corresponds to Hemingway's life, so he represents Santiago. His
norms and values are compared to the sea: in a struggle, nature will
always win. Thus the message "don't give up" is characterised by faith
and bravery. Those trains of thought, though not essential for the
story, make it gripping.
So what do we expect from the film?

· More depth in the story and events through an extra role, flashbacks
or different storylines.

· Making the story less longwinded by bringing in more physical
interaction.

· The general storyline with Santiago's thoughts, norms, values and
struggles and how he overcomes them to be a...

Find Another Essay On Comparing the Film and the Novel of Hemingway's Old Man and the Sea

Ernest Hemingway's The Old Man and the Sea

1521 words - 7 pages illustration of human strength, physically and mentally, at its finest. These qualities about him, along with the decisions he makes throughout the novel, give him similarities to Christ, while other elements of Hemingway’s prose can arguably serve as Christian symbolism as well. The Old Man and the Sea tells the story of Santiago, a very old fisherman, and his quest to catch a fish after eighty four days of failing to catch any fish at all. When his

The Effective Use of Imagery in Hemingway's The Old Man and the Sea

3023 words - 12 pages most insightful commentary has gravitated invariably toward biblical, natural, and classical imagery in the novel. These images turn an otherwise simple fishing tale into a sublime narrative of human endurance. A reading that examines these images will serve to clarify the hidden significance in Hemingway's novel. Biblical imagery literally abounds in The Old Man and the Sea. The name "Santiago" itself is a biblical allusion. Donald

Hemingway's Use of Code Hero in The Old Man and the Sea. By Nicole Robichaud

676 words - 3 pages an oar and his knife) and uses all of the energy he has left in him to protect the fish.Through the novels Hemingway has written, like The Old Man and the Sea, his famous code hero can be seen with detailing evidence. Santiago is the symbol of Hemingway's code, and it can be proven by the ways he lives his life, from his honor, to his endurance and courage. "Life is filled with misfortunes, and a code hero is know by how he endures those

Old Man and the Sea

1846 words - 7 pages to the ones that make them most productive. In Hemingway's novel, The Old Man and The Sea, the main character Santiago needs this rite of passage to define and seal his destiny, and to truly understand and believe in himself. It is through this journey that he establishes limits and boundaries on the illusions he holds onto ritualistically, and yet opens himself up to the larger possibilities of life at the same time. He goes through very obvious

Old Man And The Sea

636 words - 3 pages Old Man And The Sea Out of every single book that is in the ninth grade curriculum there is only one that is worth keeping. This one novel is The Old Man and the Sea. Other books students have read throughout the course of the year include; Death Be Not Proud, To Kill A Mocking Bird, Romeo and Juliet, and finally The Odyssey. These books were extremely tedious, hard to follow, and most of the time something students see as a "chore." Reading

Old Man and the Sea

842 words - 3 pages The Old Man and the Sea, by Ernest Hemingway, is a great work of literature. I found this book to be a good reading for a course such as "The Common Course"; it is an excellent example of humanity. Hemingway uses this novel as a symbol of the human condition: the struggle to survive and maintain one's dignity in a cruel and heartless world. While reading this novel, I felt sorry for Santiago, yet at the same time, admiration for his will not to

Old man and the sea

1462 words - 6 pages Ernest Hemmingway’s Old Man and the Sea shines as example of the bravery that is required to chance at conquering the ultimate struggle. Santiago embodies a man full of whole-hearted character whose love and resolve enable him to push beyond the limits of even a great man- a man one can only dream of becoming. Santiago’s unique personality offers a variety of insights on the way that life should be approached. Not many possess the ability to

Old Man And The Sea

536 words - 3 pages Hemingway, Ernest. The Old Man and the Sea. New York: Collier Books, 1952 The book, The Old Man and the Sea, an elderly man named Santiago and a boy named Manolin live in a small village off the Gulf Stream. The two of the men enjoy the sport of fishing more than anything, so much that they stay on the sea for eighty days without catching a single fish. One day Santiago casts his line in the water and hooks a monstrous eighteen-foot long marlin

Old Man and the Sea

1228 words - 5 pages Ernest Hemingway wrote The Old Man and the Sea to show how you can push through the hardest of times and still not be defeated. The story shows how an old fisherman overcame an unlucky slump with the support from a young boy that loved and helped Santiago named Manolin. Santiago fought through the discrimination of the other old fisherman and refused to give up. Through Santiago’s struggles when trying to catch the great marlin, he kept

Old Man And The Sea

1943 words - 8 pages That salt seawater stench grazes your nose, "gawk gawk" as the seagulls make their infamous noise. The smell of elderly fishers and their cigars. Does this give you any pictures or images? Well this is the scenery and background of the book "The Old Man and the Sea". This proved to be one of Earnest Hemmingway's greatest achievements. This critically acclaimed book is credited for giving Hemmingway his noble prize. It also won

Santiago as a Hemmingway Code Hero in Hemingway's "The Old Man and The Sea"

819 words - 3 pages relationships allows the Hero to stay focused. In The Old Man And The Sea, Santiago is considered the Hemingway Code Hero for many reasons.Santiago lived an extremely simple life, the life of a fisherman. Although sometimes he wished for some of the modern conveniences others had, he was able to do without them. Other fishermen had radios to pass the time while all Santiago had were his thoughts and sometimes the boy. The old man asked for the help

Similar Essays

Hemingway's "The Old Man And The Sea"

617 words - 3 pages In Hemingway's novel "The Old Man and the Sea" there is a common relationship between Santiago and the fish that dealt with respect but the desire to conquer. Within this relationship Hemingway describes Santiago's feelings and attitudes toward the fish and how these feelings change. At first, Santiago was glad he hooked the fish, then he felt sorry for the fish, and finally he felt guilty for going out so far. He describes Santiago's views by

Hemingway's The Old Man And The Sea

1784 words - 8 pages Calcutta, 2013. N. pag. Facts on File. Web. 13 May 2014. Burhans Jr., Clinton S. “THE OLD MAN AND THE SEA: Hemingway's Tragic Vision Of Man.” American Literature 31.4 (1960): 446. Academic Search Premier. Web. 13 May 2014. Gale, Robert L. “The Old Man and the Sea.” Masterplots II: Juvenile & Young Adult Literature Series, Supplement (1997): 1-3. Literary Reference Center. Web. 13 May 2014. Hemingway, Ernest. The Old Man and the Sea. 1952

Earnest Hemingway's "The Old Man And The Sea"

669 words - 3 pages the old man and the sea. it gives me pleasure to let readers read this. this is about santiago the old man who wanted to be lucky again and wanted to win the fight of his life. he represents courage and hope in the story. back in the topic,this paper analyzes Earnest Hemingway's "The Old Man and the Sea" about the troubles and the travails that the old man is willing to face to restore his lost pride. It shows how with only a very few characters

Hemingway's Organic Symbolism In "The Old Man And The Sea"

1109 words - 4 pages Ernest Hemingway's novella "The Old Man and the Sea" is considered to be his last, and often his greatest, literary work. The short novel, which is comprised of less than one hundred pages, recounts the trials of an elderly Cuban fisherman who is thrust into an exhausting life-or-death struggle of wills when he hooks an unmatchable marlin. When questioned about the presence of symbols in the novel, Hemingway maintained that any symbolism present