This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing The French Lieutenant's Woman And Jewel In The Crown

1021 words - 4 pages

Similarities between French Lieutenant's Woman and Jewel in the Crown

 
    John Fowles's French Lieutenant's Woman and Paul Scott's Jewel in the Crown are two literary works that illustrate continuity in British literature over time.  While French Lieutenant's Woman [is set in]...the Victorian era and Jewel in the Crown [depicts events in]... the twentieth century . . ., the two exhibit similar thematic content.  Both works emphasize the importance of social stature, both portray society's view of what's acceptable in the intimate relationships of women, and both are stories in which two lovers are together regardless of whether or not society approves.

 

The portrayal of social statures in French Lieutenant's Woman is rather simple.  Other than Sarah Woodruff, the characters are of the wealthy upper class.  Sarah is described as a "poor but educated woman who has lost her reputation."  Other characters include Charles Smithson, a wealthy gentleman who becomes Sarah's lover; Ernistina Freeman, Charles' fiance and daughter of a wealthy businessman; Mr. Freeman, Ernestina's father, a successful businessman who aspires to the upper class by marrying his daughter into [a higher class]...; and Ms. Poultney, a wealthy widow who takes in Sarah Woodruff to belittle and humiliate.

 

Social statures portrayed in Jewel in the Crown are more complicated; race also plays into the social status of its characters.  The main character of the story is Daphne Manners, who starts off as upper class but is later demoted to "that Manners girl" due to an inter-racial relationship with Hari Kumar.  Hari is born in India, but grew up well to do in England.  Upon his return to India he has lost his social status.  he aspires to the English as that's what's familiar to him, but in India the English see him as one of the Indians who are socially segregated from the English.  Lily Chatterjee is friend of the family, whom Daphne goes to live with and refers to as Aunt Lily.  Lily is an upper class Indian, a Rajput Princess.  Even as royalty, Lily is not allowed in the social circles of the British, because of her skin color.  Sister Ludmila is another important character, a curious woman who cares for the sick and dying in her sanctuary.  She is a saint who is probably not concerned with her social status, so I won't be either.  We meet Ronald Merrick in her sanctuary.  Merrick was born to a poor, working class family in England so when he comes to India he has the opportunity to claim superiority, due to the virtue of white skin.  Merrick proposes to Daphne, but she declines his offer.  Merrick, who already has a grudge against Hari, becomes jealous because he has Daphne's attention.

 

French Lieutenant's Woman parallels this relationship between people from different social statures when Sarah Woodruff gets Charles Smithson's attention.  When their eyes meet [in the film] it is love at first sight; unfortunately, Charles is with his fiance...

Find Another Essay On Comparing the French Lieutenant's Woman and Jewel in the Crown

Some Notes: "French Lieutenant's Woman" by John Fowles

2863 words - 11 pages ". She can be seen as fantastically manipulative, seducing Charles with her vulnerable, 'fallen woman' image, or a victim of social position, in which case (in Darwinian terms) she adapts into the stereotype of "poor tragedy" to survive. Her contradictions and enigma makes her 'real' - not just a puppet of the author. The narrator sometimes delves into her psyche to give us some doubtful insight into her motives, but then resigns that neither he

Prejudice and Racism in The Jewel in the Crown and Heart of Darkness

1402 words - 6 pages Racism in The Jewel in the Crown and Heart of Darkness      The effects of British colonialism are reflected in literature from both early modernism and post colonialism. Racial discrimination tainted both eras portrayed in the British morale of white supremacy over non-European counties unfolded. Heart of Darkness exemplifies early modernism in the British explorers viewed African natives of the Congo as incapable of human equality due to

Historical Context of The Jewel in the Crown

801 words - 3 pages Historical Context of The Jewel in the Crown   The historical context of Paul Scott's novel - The Jewel in the Crown - serves to explain and interpret a tragic love story between two characters; Daphne Manners and Hari Kumar. The love story serves to clarify and interpret the social/racial and historical significance of the time period in which it is set - 1942.  Their love - a product as well as a victim of the time and events

Characteristics of Modernism in Jewel in the Crown and Heart of Darkness

1835 words - 7 pages Characteristics of Modernism in Jewel in the Crown and Heart of Darkness         A Modern novel, Jewel in the Crown, by Paul Scott, depicts the latter stages of imperialism's erosion and explores it through the lives of individuals and their relationships as symbolic of larger societal conflicts and political events.  Jewel was written well into the 20th Century and employs thematic concepts and literary forms characteristic of Modernism

The Death of Indian Culture Exposed in The Jewel In the Crown

1342 words - 5 pages The Death of Indian Culture Exposed in The Jewel In the Crown      The Jewel in the Crown, by Paul Scott, is a postcolonial novel about the realism of the interracial love affair between Daphne Manners and Hari Kumar, the subsequent rape of Daphne Manners, and the after effects on British and Indian relations. At a time when British and Indian affairs were strained, at best, the rape of Miss Manners is significantly metaphoric of the

Comparing Love in Shakespeare's Midsummer Night's Dream and Soyinka's Lion and the Jewel

973 words - 4 pages “Love is a familiar. Love is a devil. There is no evil angel but Love. (Love’s Labours Lost.1.2.)” This Shakespearean quote relays on the fact that love can lead to many misfortunes, presented as one of the aspects of love in both William Shakespeare’s “A Midsummer Night’s Dream”, and Wole Soyinka’s “The Lion and the Jewel”. One aspect of love demonstrates its brilliant sides, and with it, brings affection, faith, and intimacy. However, it is

Importance of the Weaknesses of the French Crown in Explaining the Outbreak of the French Wars of Religion in 1562

2006 words - 8 pages Importance of the Weaknesses of the French Crown in Explaining the Outbreak of the French Wars of Religion in 1562 Previously France had been ruled by Henry II, a strong experienced ruler. It was, however, an unfortunate jousting accident lead to the swift decline of the French monarchy. Henry’s successor, Francis II, was only fifteen years old on his accession to the throne in 1559. He was inexperienced and easily

Comparing Femininity in The Woman Warrior and King Lear

2645 words - 11 pages Femininity in The Woman Warrior and King Lear         What is femininity? What role should women play in society? These are questions that humanity has faced ever since the first hunter-gatherer tribes developed. Gender roles, at least in the popular imagination, were clear; the men hunted for big game, the women picked nuts and berries. There were clear reasons for this - hunting required the brute muscular strength of the male, while

Comparing the French and American Revolutions

903 words - 4 pages While the French and the American revolutions share some similarities, they differ in most areas involving the revolution. Enlightenment ideas would help shape politics, economics, and religion in the revolutionary nations. Although both found the importance of individual rights, they took different paths in establishing and operating their respective governments. The economic standpoints of the French would be in contrary with the American

Comparing the American and French Revolutions

2978 words - 12 pages The American and the French revolutions had many similarities and differences. One similarity being is that they both wanted to escape the rule of their King. Second, they both started by an uprising of people against unfair taxation by the monarchy. The French peasants were not represented by the Parliament. It was mainly composed of middle and upper class people. Now, the American colonists were not represented in England because of their lack

Sex and Marriage Dictated by Class Restrictions in John Fowles, The French Lieutenant’s Woman

1636 words - 7 pages There have always been class divisions in England’s social groups, but it was not until the nineteenth century that they were labeled. The lower class was often uneducated and overlooked and mostly servants and prostitutes, the middle class generally had steady jobs and members of the higher classes were born to old money and did not have to work. The French Lieutenant’s Woman written by John Fowles is a complex “Victorian novel filled with

Similar Essays

Legal Aspects Of "The French Lieutenant's Woman"

786 words - 3 pages The French Lieutenant's Woman is a novel which takes place in England in the Mid-Victorian period (1867). This story is about Charles Smithson, a discontented bachelor who had an affair with a prostitute named Sarah Woodruff (a lady's companion and former governess). As a result of his affair with Sarah, Charles breaks his engagement to Ernestina Freeman. After breaking his engagement he learns of the disappearance of Sarah and hires

The Ways In Which Narrative Perspectives Vary In The French Lieutenant's Woman And Hawksmoor

6000 words - 24 pages The Ways in Which Narrative Perspectives Vary in The French Lieutenant's Woman and Hawksmoor Although there are many different perspectives taken in the two novels that shape the overall theme of each plot, comparisons can be drawn between them to show that they share a few fundamental similarities in the way that the authors present their narrative. By looking at the this presentation, it is possible to extract that the

The French Lieutenant's Woman As Victorian Realistic Novel

1822 words - 7 pages The French Lieutenant's Woman as Victorian Realistic Novel      Although The French Lieutenant's Woman was written and cinematized in the 20th century and is based on a modern film production of a piece of 19th century fiction, the stories and plots themselves have contextual elements of a Victorian Realistic Novel. Despite the inability to accurately and directly compare it with that of true Victorian literature, many of the same elements

Role Of The Victorian Society In The French Lieutenant's Woman By John Fowles

757 words - 3 pages their husbands and children. A Victorian woman was expected to accept the patriarchal normunhesitatingly. Her duty was to her husband and children. Only if she toed this social line would she be deemeda proper young Victorian lady. The institution of marriage was often a contract agreement. Money oftenmarried into a titled family as in Charles and Ernestina's case, thereby reinforcing the dominant society's power.Money and nobility were often the