This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing The Impact Of Stolypin And Rasputin On The Stability Of The Tsar's Government

1081 words - 4 pages

Comparing the Impact of Stolypin and Rasputin on the Stability of the Tsar's Government

Stolypin and Rasputin played a major role in maintaining Tsarism.
Whilst Stolypin brought in major reforms to improve Russia, Rasputin
did not have much impact, due to his lack of reforms.

Political stability was ensured by Stolypin, whilst Rasputin brought
instability.

Stolypin made Russiapolitically stable through the execution of the
Vyborg. This was when the Kadets and the Liberals tried to spark up a
revolution by encouraging people to refrain from paying their taxes
and avoid conscription. This therefore made Russiapolitically stable
because it allowed the government to retaliate and allowed Stolypin to
implement the Field Courts Martial Law which saw special courts being
set up to charge terrorists.

However, Rasputin brought instability due to his position as chief
advisor to the Tsar. This brought instability because he dismissed the
good ministers and replaced them with his friends, this is
substantiated by Rodzyanko, president of the Duma, when he stated,
''There is not one honest man," this shows that Rasputin was an
inadequate advisor and could not control state affairs well. His new
advisors were inefficient and lacked the skills required to stabilise
Russia, so this proves that Rasputin brought instability to Russia.

Stolypin was more successful in bringing political stability; yet,
Rasputin did bring a small amount of stability; this was because he
was associated with religion, so inevitably would be able to influence
some people.

The political stability and instability had a major impact on
preserving the Tsar's power because if it was stable, then the Tsar's
power would surely be preserved, but this was not entirely true.

Both Stolypin and Rasputin stabilised the Tsar's power.

The Tsar's power was preserved by Stolypin through the Field Courts
Martial. This was a court where terrorists could be dealt with without
investigation or delay. This stabilised the Tsarist regime because it
meant that any opposition or possible revolt against the Tsar would be
suppressed quickly and efficiently and it would discourage people from
speaking out amongst him.

Rasputin preserved the Tsar's power through religion. The Tsar used
Rasputin's simple faith and his religion to reach out to his people.
Religion was popular amongst the Russian people; therefore, Rasputin
used the Church as a means of control over them. This therefore meant
that the Tsar had power and would not be threatened by uprisings,
especially from the peasants because they were indoctrinated by the
Church to support the Tsar. This is evident through the quote, "God
commands us to love and obey..especially the Tsar."

Both were significant in preserving the Tsar's power, but Rasputin was
more important...

Find Another Essay On Comparing the Impact of Stolypin and Rasputin on the Stability of the Tsar's Government

The Evil Monk: Rasputin The life and times of Gregory Efimovich Rasputin

3786 words - 15 pages . Petersburg society. From rags to social prominence the life of Gregory Rasputin holds many of the events leading to the eventual overthrow of the Russian imperial system, the dethronement of the House of Romanov and the assassination of the Imperial Family.Gregory Efimovich Rasputin came from solid peasant stock. Gregory Efimovich was born on January 10, 1869, in Prokovskoe, a small village in Siberia on the banks of the Tura River. As a young

The Impact of Philosophy on Government

1445 words - 6 pages that surrounded him and watched how they acted under several circumstances while Hobbes gave a more scientific approach to the behavior of the human beings. Hobbes left very clear in his work that for a government to be powerful it had to have a strong central authority. His ideas had a great impact on the Federalists during the first steps of the creation of the US laws. Hobbes concept that men were weak and needed to be guided made

The Life and Death of Grigori Yefimovic Rasputin

2411 words - 10 pages . Pray.” The Life and death of Grigori Yefimovic Rasputin was nothing short of mysterious. Rasputin was a Russian shahman famed for the impact he is said to have hadd over Russian Tsar Nicholas II’s family. Actually, he is thought to have held a great deal of inspiration over the Tsar’s wife Alexandra, as well as on their son Alexei’s hemophilia treatment (a disease that the royal family did not want disclosed). His Influence was believed to be

Russia at the Time of Rasputin

1415 words - 6 pages During the life of Rasputin, Russia seemed to be in a constant upheaval. As a nation, it was struggling to modernize and make itself a formidable power of the western and eastern world. In terms of rulers, Tsar Alexander III had passed on, his reign of an iron fist on the people of Russia was given to his son Nicholas, who was not as restrictive as his father before him (Purishkevich 1985: 16). As Russia moved into the future, Rasputin would be

The Breakdown of Mental Health and Stability

1661 words - 7 pages and mentally? Could it be a key factor in this sudden uprising of mental ailments and the loss of many people's emotional and mental balance and stability? There are numerous studies linking stress with a multitude of health problems, many with a neurobiological connection. One of the biggest things stress takes it's toll upon is the immune system. The impact of stress on physical health is clearly evident, as it has been reported that

Richard III and the Stability of England

1253 words - 5 pages Richard III and the Stability of England Richard became King of England on July the sixth 1483 after the heir to the throne was proclaimed illegitimate. Whether this claim was true or not is questionable. During Richards reign, the stability of England has been debated. Was he the ruler England needed to end the 'Wars of the Roses' and bring stability back to the English people? Or did he cause England to be

Comparing Plato and Aristotle on government and the concept of good

1645 words - 7 pages good, I will show that they have contrasting political theories, and that Aristotle's political theory is more realistic and obtainable than Plato's political theory.Although Plato never says what the good actually is, he does state that only philosophers can know what the good is (). Plato offers two analogies as to why philosophers are capable of ruling, and why they should rule. The first is the analogy of a ship. On this ship, the captain is

The Effects of Pre-martial Cohabiation on Martial Quality and Stability

3085 words - 12 pages cohabitation has on relationships and the side effect's couples may have who do cohabitate, eventually committing to marriage. According to a study on these links Brown, Sanchex, Nock, and Wright (2006), found couples who do cohabite in order to test the stability of his or her relationship before committing to marriage experienced an unstable marriage and in the end divorced compared to couples who did not cohabite before marriage. The following paper

Effects of the 2005 budget on economic activity, price stability, economic growth, full Employment and inflation

943 words - 4 pages everyone because the lives of our citizen's matter, the decisions the Government may affect their mortgages, their businesses, and whether they can find a job.He said the Budget was brought down at a time when more Australians are in work than ever before. Our unemployment rate has fallen to a low unmatched for 28 years.The budget will have a number of effects on a number of different areas of the economy including the economic outlook, tax cuts

The Stability of Russia in 1914

761 words - 3 pages him there was a succession of futile ministers and they achieved nothing. Despite this Russia was doing well industrially. Government revenue exceeded expenses and this meant that they were making a profit and was therefore it was less dependant on other countries. The Tsar was key to the stability of Russia, he made all the decisions and any decisions that were made would have a dramatic impact. The people despised

The Importance of Social Stability and Economic Freedom to Conservatism

2100 words - 8 pages The Importance of Social Stability and Economic Freedom to Conservatism Traditionally Conservatism has generally focussed on both social stability and economic freedom, believing that the two are inherently intertwined. The central theme of Conservative thought, namely “the desire to conserve”, is closely linked to the emphasis placed on respect for tradition, established customs and institutions that have endured the

Similar Essays

The Impact Of Money On Family Stability

1346 words - 5 pages U.S.A.V. Conclusion The Impact of Money on Family Stability "The boat of love crashes on the ruins of the daily routine", an old saying reminds us. No doubt, love is a sublime sentiment that makes humans distinct from other living beings. Nevertheless, a great number of families affected by several "economic" factors fail. The main goal of my research is to find out what impact money and economic interest have on children and family stability

The Impact Of Money On Family Stability

1346 words - 5 pages U.S.A.V. Conclusion The Impact of Money on Family Stability "The boat of love crashes on the ruins of the daily routine", an old saying reminds us. No doubt, love is a sublime sentiment that makes humans distinct from other living beings. Nevertheless, a great number of families affected by several "economic" factors fail. The main goal of my research is to find out what impact money and economic interest have on children and family stability

The Murder Of Rasputin Essay

626 words - 3 pages Rasputin was an important figure in the Russian Revolution. His acclaimed magical powers helped lessen the symptoms of poor Alexei's hemophilia, an awful condition in which the blood doesn't clot. Because Alexei was the heir to the Romanof throne, Tsar Nicholas II and Alexandra were in a stressful situation. They gave Rasputin certain powers that people were jealous of. The aristocrats could not stand a peasant in such a high position

The Power Of Rasputin Essay

2579 words - 11 pages tsarina. Soon, he was living and working in close quarters with the royal family due to his gifts. I believe that because of this, Grigori Rasputin had a direct influence on Russia during the time he was alive. After Rasputin failed at being a monk, he began to wander. In 1906 he arrived in St. Petersburg and by this time many people had heard of his supernatural gifts. Years later, he met Czar Nicholas II and Alexandra Feodorovna. They were the