Comparing The Portrayals Of The Villains From Tell Tale Heart And The Speckled Band

1682 words - 7 pages

Comparing the Portrayals of the Villains from Tell-Tale Heart and The Speckled Band

The two villains in “Tell-Tail Heart” and “The Speckled Band” both
have similarities and differences in their portrayals of murder,
conveyed in the stories. They have disparities between motives and
methods of murder, although there is a resemblance in the masterminds
of murder.

The villain in “The Speckled Band”, Dr. Grimsby Roylott was married to
Mrs. Stoner in India who is prosperous with her wealth, but she had
died in a train crash and bequeathed the sum of £1000 to Dr. Roylott.
This money was enough to fulfil the family’s needs as they moved into
an old ancestral house in Stoke Moran. Roylott unfortunately in dismay
fears that the family will deteriorate into financial decline as his
step- daughters will be leading their lives through marriage. It was
an unmanageable situation for Dr. Roylott to elucidate this matter. He
was inconceivable to murder his step daughter, Julia Stoner with his
knowledge of deadly snakes in an ambitious attempt to stop her,
despite the fact that his motive was reason enough to keep him
focused. Dr. Roylott had planned to target his next victim, Helen
Stoner. It was only then that Sherlock Holmes intervened and impeded
his plan.

Edgar Allan Poe delineates a murderer’s mind thoroughly as it is the
murderer who relates the story to us. He commits a murder of an
innocent man, but does not take the blame that he is mad, as
throughout the story he attempts to deny it. His motive was to rid of
the innocent man’s “vulture eye” which was the concentration, because
he believes justification of society’s morals is his right. The
murderer finds contentment stalking the man for days and committing
the murder, but loses his diligence when revealing the corpse to the
officers he confronted.

Edgar Allan Poe creates a stereotypical villain in “Tell – Tale
Heart”, because the killer always stalks the man in the “dead of the
night”, especially when he is asleep. The realisation of this is that
the victim is left vulnerable; a perfect scenario for the villain to
assassinate. The killer is “patient” too, which would symbolise him
deadly because a stereotypical murderer assassinates and scrutinises
his victim without knowing his presence. The villain proves that he is
bloodthirsty as he “dismembers” the corpse, by cutting off the “head,
arms and legs”. This directly devises images of disgust as the corpse
is mutilated, which would portray the slaughterer’s villainy
temperament. He believes: “what you mistake for madness is but over –
acuteness of the senses?”. We are unsure of his sanity, because he
amazingly adjudicates his rights when we know his actions are
unreasonable in society.

Dr. Grimsby Roylott is an antagonistic person, who constantly finds
disgust of...

Find Another Essay On Comparing the Portrayals of the Villains from Tell-Tale Heart and The Speckled Band

The Tell-Tale Heart Essay

1228 words - 5 pages In the baffling tales of “The Tell-Tale Heart,” “A Rose for Emily,” and “My Last Duchess,” the narrators give in-depth descriptions about the characters and their surroundings. The central theme in these tales comes frightfully alive early on in the stories, but still manages to produce a dramatic ending in every tale. In each of these three first-person narratives, the narrator’s motivation to tell the tale influences the credibility of the

The Tell Tale Heart Essay

2346 words - 9 pages basically setting him up. Once Acton strangled Huxley he had started to clean the house of fingerprints. That was all fine and well but Acton didn't clean only the door knobs, glasses, cup and things like that which he touched he cleaned the whole house the walls, the couch absolutely everything which was a sign of big paranoia from Acton. The character in 'The Tell Tale Heart' had a lot of conversations throughout

the tell-tale heart

925 words - 4 pages   "Now this is the point. Your fancy me mad. Madmen know nothing. But you should have seen me"(42 Backpack Literature). Reading such words can create a wide imagination about what the character is truly like. The narrator in the story has an indirect personality where as you read you find out more and more about him.The narrator in Edger Allen Poe's "The Tell- Tale Heart" seems like he makes himself completely insane but as readers we are never

The Tell Tale Heart

648 words - 3 pages The Tell-Tale Heart In "The Tell-Tale Heart" by Edgar Allan Poe, the main character is completely insane. Think about it, he has no motivations for killing a man other than the man's eye, which drives him to murder. There is also the fact that he constantly says that he is not mad, do sane people go around saying that they are not crazy? I don't think so, he is clearly bonkers.There was only one reason and one reason only for the murder that

The Tell-Tale heart

822 words - 3 pages The behavior of the narrator in The Tell-Tale heart demonstrate characteristic that are associated with people with obsessive-compulsive disorder and paranoid schizophrenia . When Poe wrote this story in 1843 obsessive-compulsive disorder and paranoia had not been discovered. However in modern times the characteristics demonstrated by the narrator leads people to believe that he has a mental illness. Poe’s narrator demonstrates classic signs

Comparing Lamb to the Slaughter and The Speckled Band

3410 words - 14 pages , Holmes's accomplice and companion narrates "The Speckled Band" to the reader, this is third person. From this point events unfold quite slowly, the actual solving of the mystery doesn't begin until Holmes and Watson visit Stoke Moran. When they arrive at Stoke Moran, it is described in great detail, "grey…lichen blotched… windows were broken…a picture of ruin." A simile is used, "Like the claws of a crab." to describe the

Comparing Lamb to the Slaughter and The Speckled Band

3785 words - 15 pages Comparing Lamb to the Slaughter and The Speckled Band I am comparing two short stories "Lamb to the Slaughter" by Roald Dahl and "The Speckled Band" by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. " Lamb to the Slaughter" is a modern 20th Century novel as apposed to "The Speckled Band" which is pre-twentieth century. "The Speckled Band" is a typical murder mystery with everything you would expect it to have. First of all a victim and a

"The Tell-Tale Heart" Madness

548 words - 2 pages explores the idea of madness, in many of his stories, especially "The Tell-Tale Heart." The narrator of this story views his hyper-sensitivity as verification of his sanity, not an indication of mental illness. Nonetheless, what makes this narrator mad is that he unwillingly admits to a murder, which betrays the insanity he attempted to deny. ""Villains!" I shrieked, "dissemble no more! I admit the is the beating of his hideous heart!""In conclusion, "The Tell-Tale Heart" is a story in which the idea of madness is developed through the first-person narration, the symbol of the eye in relation to a person's identity and the actual theme of madness throughout the story.

Characters of The Tell-Tale Heart

1169 words - 5 pages The Tell-Tale Heart by Edgar Allen Poe is a short story that dives into the mind of an insane man. The story only features five characters. There is an old man with a blue eye, the crazed killer, and three police. The story is narrated by the nameless murderer. It is his attempt to justify his behavior and to prove to the reader that he is not crazy. As the story goes on you come to the realization that he is actually insane. The characters in

Comparing Lamb to the Slaughter to The Speckled Band

1465 words - 6 pages Comparing Lamb to the Slaughter to The Speckled Band 'Lamb to the Slaughter' and 'The Speckled Band' are both murder mysteries. Like most murder mysteries each of the stories have a murderer, a victim and characters acting in a suspicious or unusual way. 'Lamb to the Slaughter' is a 20th century story about a woman called Mary who kills her husband, Patrick Maloney, using a leg of lamb. This seems quite surprising at first as she

Analysis of the Narrator in The Tell Tale Heart

1475 words - 6 pages Edgar Allan Poe’s short story, “The Tell Tale Heart” depicts a narrator who observes a man and kills him. The narrator dismembers the old man after killing him and decides to hide it under the floorboards; he has no motive except for his pale blue eye. Police soon arrive and the narrator takes them on a tour of the house to prove that he is innocent. The narrator decides to take the policemen to where he kills the old man, in order to make it

Similar Essays

Comparing Villains And Victims From The Speckled Band, Twisted Lip And The Cardboard Box

1659 words - 7 pages Comparing Villains and Victims from The Speckled Band, Twisted Lip and The Cardboard Box The three villains which I am going to compare / contrast are Dr Roylott from The Speckled Band, Mr Neville St Claire from The Man With The Twisted Lip and Sarah Cushing from The Cardboard Box. The three victims I am going to compare / contrast are Helen Stoner from The Speckled Band, Mrs St Claire from The Man With The Twisted Lip and Susan

Edgar Allan Poe's Tell Tale Heart And Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's The Adventure Of The Speckled Band

2916 words - 12 pages .' Overall, comparing the structure of the two stories, 'Tell Tale Heart' and "The Adventure of the Speckled Band,' it could be seen that they both follow a formulaic plot, but the authors accentuate on different parts of the plot, such as the problem or development, in different proportions, either emphasizing more or less on it. For example, Poe emphasizes the self-obsessive actions and feelings of the protagonist in the development

Victims And Villains In The Speckled Band, The Cardboard Box, And The Red Headed League

2234 words - 9 pages Having read a range of detective stories by Conan Doyle, compare the presentations of victims and villains in The Speckled Band and two other stories. In this essay, I am going to look at how Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, has written the Sherlock Holmes stories, looking at the victims, villains, Holmes and his dear friend Watson. The Sherlock Holmes, stories are written in the detective genre, all of the stories that I have looked at to

Comparing Lamb To The Slaughter And The Speckled Band

1150 words - 5 pages Comparing Lamb to the Slaughter and The Speckled Band This essay is a comparison of two short stories 'Lamb to the Slaughter' and 'The Speckled Band' by highlighting the techniques that make it classic or not a classic crime novel. A typical murder mystery consists of a very intellectual person who pieces together parts of a jigsaw to unravel the murder mystery. 'The Speckled Band' is a typical crime novel because it